How the Iran War is Hurting Republicans

Stacey Abrams
1 follower
Apr 23, 2026
One of the shifts that we're seeing is happening
around the issue of the Iran war.
And before that, just America's involvement
in foreign wars and foreign enterprise.
And we're seeing it animate voters
across the political spectrum.
What do you see as the implications
for political realignment, either in 26 or 28,
or is there really a realignment happening?
I think there is.
I think there's a lot of shifts that are taking place,
but Iran's a good example because the biggest driver
of people's cynicism is still individual economic concerns.
So it's Iran tied to gas prices.
It's tariffs tied to rising inflation.
And I think some of those are,
we shouldn't see these issues as inherently disconnected,
but somewhat connected.
But Donald Trump, and I think this might sound ridiculous
to people who obviously never believed him,
but Donald Trump has won AV on some fundamental promises
that have mattered, you know, no forever wars
or focusing on egg prices.
All of those things are things that he, I think,
diagnosed people's legitimate concern
about America's place in the world under Biden too.
But he has not provided solutions.
And I think, frankly, was never really providing solutions
that was based in what people wanted.
And so I think that gap has become super clear.
I mean, to answer the question directly though,
on the Republican side,
I do think that your Tucker Carlson's
and Megyn Kelly's are leading indicators
or of a shift among a base that does feel
like he did not follow through on Epstein,
that he, that, you know,
things like no forever wars were things they meant
and that, you know,
and we're seeing some friction on that front.
And I think the question of America's changing thought
about Israel and our relationship to Israel
is roiling both parties.
And so I think that those things
are going to be things that are most clearly fought
in 2027 in a presidential primary.
But I do think we're seeing some of those seeds right now
in the congressional races,
because I think there will be,
I think Democrats will have,
or I think both sides kind of will let candidates exist
on their own in relationship to their own races this year
because of the need for, you know, winning Congress,
winning the Senate and the rest.
It comes next summer.
And I think in those open primaries
where some of those fundamental questions
will have to be answered.
If I'm JD Vance, for example,
this is question number one, right?
I think that's the reason you see him trying to make clear,
oh, I maybe didn't like this action here.
I maybe didn't like that action here and such,
because he understands that there is a legitimate conflict
between Trump's words and Trump's actions.
So as we think about going beyond
the Trump-centric Republican Party,
as you think about who joins JD Vance
and Marco Rubio in the scrum,
I know there's a lot of attention being focused
on the Democratic side, but I think to your point,
there is an evolution happening with the GOP
that is under-reported or certainly under-commented upon.
Who are some dark horses that you're seeing
in this conversation?
Either, you mentioned Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly,
who are the political actors or potential political actors,
maybe non-systems candidates
who might enter this conversation?
Yeah, I mean, I think from both sides of the coin,
I would start thinking about 2028
from non-system candidates.
I think there's a desire from both parties
from someone who feels a little untainted
of the last five, 10 years or so.
But to that point, I would not,
I think Tucker Carlson is an important question
about where he wants to live in the political system.
He is increasingly sounding-
I think he's gonna run for president.
I don't think that's out of the question.
He said it, he was on today's Explainer box
and he said he was ruling it out,
but he sounds like someone
who is making an important distinction
or at least positioning himself as kingmaker
for that next nomination.
I think someone like Marjorie Taylor Greene,
I think people who are making the argument
that America first was betrayed
have a lane in the Republican Party.
And so I don't think that comes
from the more Liz Cheney, anti-Trump, personally band.
And there's not really a desire
for more of that, I would say, principled disagreement.
It's a critique from the right
that is having some salience.
And so I guess those two people,
Marjorie Taylor Greene and Tucker Carlson come to mind.
I think whether the Vance Rubio bromance last
is a key question.
I would even throw in somebody to the non-system point,
like RFK Jr., who has,
which I think has hurt himself in other ways.
But I think that's what I'm saying
about the brand of independence.
I remember him really capitalizing
on people's dislike for both parties
at a key time in 2024.
And so I think people who speak in that language
will find some support.
And the other thing is you don't have to rely
on those traditional gatekeepers as much anymore.
From a media way, from a donor way,
there are ways to make yourself viable
outside the kind of party anointing.
And nobody knows that more than Donald Trump.
And so he's implicitly actually showed a roadmap for people
on how you can go around the party
and reshape it in your image.
Now, does that require his name recognition?
Does that require his personality?
Certainly those things made it easier.
But I think some other people are gonna try that.
We've talked about the underrepresented.
We've talked about the shifting dynamics.
But another place where you have really been
on the leading edge are the religious dynamics
of our politics.
And as you've pointed out,
there's an evangelical dimension
that I think cuts across race and geography
that often gets segmented or sometimes just overlooked.
And I think there's a lot to unpack
when we think about the religious dynamics of this moment,
including some of the jaw-dropping imagery
that this administration has been sharing recently
on their social platforms.
And as someone who has reported
on white evangelical voters,
someone who knows how black evangelicals
think about politics,
how do you see this sort of authoritarian God complex
affecting the Republican standing with that demographic?
And then how do you see other voters
who cite faith as a reason to vote?
How are they responding
and aligning themselves in this moment?
Yeah, I think that's an important question.
I remember us talking to a lot
of that evangelical community in 2022.
And I remember being,
the way that they would contort themselves
to make kind of excuses for Donald Trump's open disdain
for religion, I mean, I would say open,
like just total ignorance, right?
Like if you look through the principles
of what evangelicals said they wanted
from the Republican Party or from their leader,
Donald Trump's flagrantly violated most of those, right?
And so we were going to most,
I mean, just openly.
And so we were going to a lot of them saying like,
okay, what gives?
And I actually appreciated their clarity
because a lot of Al Mohler,
like Kentucky theologian who we had on the show
made really clear to me,
I have made a peace with the fact that I would prefer,
at that time we're talking about Doug Mastriano
or people who were at the Capitol
or I guess were anti-democracy candidates
versus someone who I think is against
what I find to be an existential cultural war
particular about LGBTQ stuff.
And so they made a choice about Donald Trump
that was a understanding deal with devil
that they are now arriving to some of that impacts with.
But I think that there are increasing questions
about evangelical place overall in Republican Party.
Obviously the rise of Catholicism
and I think JD Vance kind of pushing a wing
of conservative Catholicism,
particularly among younger voters,
becomes an interesting piece of where Republicans go next.
But, or even the question of the changing sentiment
around Israel, the most supportive groups
you have around Israel right now are evangelicals.
And so how does the party,
if a lot of other people are moving in different directions,
how does that parties capture,
how does that groups capture on the Republican Party live?
I think it's an important thing.
But I'm glad you mentioned kind of black evangelicals
and others too, because I think sometimes
when people talk about religious voters or faith voters,
we only think white, of course.
When you think like religious Latinos
are hugely important demographic,
like when we think of,
if I could think about communities to focus on
to actually answer the question of who will be post-Trump,
the same way I say like first-generation Americans
or groups we're typically thinking at,
I would probably put faith-based voters in that too.
Because I think that particularly
as our demographics are changing,
our assumptions about the way that moves ideologically
are gonna be broken down.
Because it doesn't look the same for all these groups.
And there are a lot of different types
of I think faith-based voters
increasingly inserting themselves in the spectrum.
