10 Steps Campaign Community Call: Litigating for Democracy

Stacey Abrams
1 follower
2 Video Views·Sep 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis discussion examines the \"10 Steps\" campaign and the transition of the U.S. toward \"competitive authoritarianism.\" It advocates for strategic litigation and state-level civic engagement as essential tools to hold the executive branch accountable, protect civil rights, and reclaim democratic power from a small circle of loyalists.
Thank you to the panelists, truly an all-star lineup.
I want to remind everyone that tonight's call
and the organization itself, 10 Steps, is nonpartisan.
But as a lawyer, I want to be clear.
Nonpartisan does not mean we don't have opinions.
Nonpartisan means that we don't engage in electioneering
and that we are clear about our orthodoxy.
But you're going to hear things that may make you think,
well, I thought they were nonpartisan.
We are, but we also have sense.
So I just want to keep that front and center
for today's conversation.
And that's really the genesis of the 10 Steps campaign.
For a long time in this country, we have believed
that we were all headed in the same direction
towards a more perfect union.
And that attempt was really guided by this notion
that we may disagree about how we get there,
but we all have the same destination in mind.
I would say, if we're going to use political jargon
or those on the left were using Apple Maps
and those on the right were using Google Maps,
those who consider themselves sort of independent,
they were using Waze,
and sometimes they crashed into people's houses,
but we were all heading in the same direction.
The challenge that we are facing today
is that we are no longer as a nation
headed in the same direction.
What happened over the last 60 years became manifest,
and worse yet, it became actualized in January 2025
with the election inauguration
and overthrow of our traditional democracy.
We are now a competitive authoritarian nation.
And it's important that we hold that as true
because everything that follows
begins with understanding what this is.
Competitive authoritarianism
is not the same as totalitarianism.
It's not the same as regular authoritarianism.
It's this interstitial place
that the US and a few other nation states currently occupy.
And that's where you have democratic institutions.
It still looks like democracy.
It looks like the day before,
but those institutions are now being used
for authoritarian ends.
So they're taking your toys, but using them to hurt you.
And how do we think about what authoritarianism means?
I've studied political science
as did I'm sure all of my friends on this call,
or on this panel, we're all lawyers, but let's be clear.
Authoritarianism is basically three things.
It is seizing power from the people
because you've decided they don't deserve it.
It is hoarding that power among a few of your cronies.
We can call them oligarchs, we can call them loyalists,
but you basically take the power you've seized
from the people and you hoard it
among a select group of people
that you think can do it better,
that you think should have it.
And you are doing your best
to make certain no one else gets it.
And then third, and most importantly,
in an authoritarian regime,
especially competitive authoritarianism,
you wanna make certain that the power
you have seized and hoarded is never accountable to anyone.
And that is why the judiciary matters.
That is why elections matter.
Because in a democracy,
those are the mechanisms we use for accountability
and so authoritarians despise them.
So if that's what authoritarianism is, what is democracy?
Democracy is the antidote.
Democracy is the predicate act that we take
to make certain that first and foremost,
that power that we're talking about,
that power that everyone's fighting over,
democracy says that power should be shared.
We may not like everyone we have to share it with,
we may not wanna invite them to come eat dinner with us,
but we agree that we are going to share that power.
Number two, we agree to leverage that power
for the benefit of others.
Where authoritarians hoard that power for their own benefit,
democracy says we're going to leverage that power
for the benefit of others.
We may not all agree on what that benefit should look like,
but we agree that it should be used in that way.
And then ultimately at its foundation,
democracy demands accountability for the use of that power.
That's why we have elections.
That's why we have a court system.
That's why we have freedom of speech and lawyers.
We have those things
because that's how we hold power accountable.
And in the United States right now,
we are in a death fight about whether democracy will survive
or whether authoritarianism will rise.
And those of us gathered on this call believe in democracy.
And so I started by talking about partisanship
because I want us to be clear.
This is no longer a question of Democrat versus Republican.
This is about patriotism versus authoritarianism.
And if you believe in patriotism,
you have to believe that we can get this done.
And therefore there are 10 steps,
10 steps that we have watched them take
to create this competitive authoritarian nation.
And if you go to our website,
and since you're here, you probably have been,
we walk you through those steps
and what it looks like in real practical terms.
But if there are 10 steps to authoritarianism and autocracy,
there are 10 steps to freedom and power.
And number five in those 10 steps is litigate.
We have to argue the case
and we can argue it among the people,
we can argue it on social media,
but where we are the most effective
is when we litigate in the courts.
And that is why I am just delighted to be on this call,
in this panel with four extraordinary people
who all understand why this matters.
And to lead us in our conversation
is the inimitable Dahlia Lithwick.
If you do not follow her on Slate,
you are making terrible life choices.
You should follow her on Slate.
You should read what she writes.
She has an amazing series right now,
looking at what the future of the Supreme Court
and the court should look like.
And I'm gonna borrow many of the things she says
and pretend I came up with them myself.
But until that happens, I want to turn this over to Dahlia.
Thank you so, so much.
And thank you to the 10 steps campaign
for not just inviting me to moderate,
but I cannot underscore,
like if you had to hatch in an underground lab,
the dream team of people to talk about litigation
in a moment of crisis, this is it.
And so it is just like a thrill and an honor
to introduce the panelists to you today.
And then we're gonna do a moderated discussion with them
and leave room at the end for your questions.
So please pop them in the Q&A as you go,
and we'll try to get to as many of them as we can.
All right, your extraordinary panelists are Ashley Upkins,
who is the immediate, by like days,
past president of the National Bar Association, the NBA,
the nation's oldest and largest network
of predominantly black lawyers, judges, and law students,
founded in 1925.
A Nashville native, Ashley leads complex litigation
and dispute resolution at Silicon Ranch,
one of the country's largest independent
solar power producers, fresh from the NBA,
and literally stepping out
of their 101st annual convention.
Welcome, Ashley.
We're also joined today by Skye Paraman.
She is president and CEO of Democracy Forward,
a national legal organization
that challenges unlawful federal executive action
through litigation, regulatory engagement,
and public education.
Skye is also the author of The Forthcoming,
again, minutes away, days away, book,
Ordinary People, Extraordinary Times,
How to Reclaim Your Power, Fight for Freedom,
and Reimagine Democracy, a guide for all of us,
which focuses on building civic and social trust,
assisting people in finding their agency
to engage civically and work across differences.
It's gonna be on the shelves August 25th,
and to the extent that you just heard
that Stacey Abrams is going to borrow heavily
from our popcorn series,
our popular constitutional series,
I will borrow heavily from Skye's new book going forward
because this is, in fact, the work, I think,
of the moment of our lifetimes.
Last but not at all least, Tracy Fightlove,
founder and executive director
of Lawyers for Good Government, L4GG,
which she started as a Facebook group
for lawyers looking to volunteer their skills
after the 2016 election.
L4GG has grown into a national nonprofit
mobilizing more than 125,000 attorneys
that has delivered over $165 million
in pro bono legal services,
including helping safeguard nearly $5 billion
in federal climate funding,
running two daily updated legal resource hubs
on reproductive health and transgender rights laws
in all 50 states,
and supporting more than 10,000 asylum seekers.
In 2025, Tracy spearheaded L4GG's pro bono litigation corps
mobilizing hundreds of independent litigators
outside of big law to take on high impact cases.
She now co-chairs the Nation of Laws Coalition.
So welcome to you, Tracy.
And I think I wanna start by just asking each of you,
and we can do this briefly,
to set the table and explain to the folks
who are tuning in here what we even are talking about
when we talk about strategic litigation.
What does that phrase mean to each of you?
And what does it actually look like in practice
in your lives?
Because you all come at it from really different places.
Is this defense?
Is this offense?
Does that even matter?
Is this about class actions?
Is this about individual habeas corpus petitions?
What, in your view,
is the work that we are trying to focus on today?
And maybe we can start with you, Ashley.
Well, thank you so much, Dahlia, Leader Abrams.
Thank you.
It's wonderful to be here.
And as you highlighted,
if I look like I've been run over by a train,
I have because I am fresh,
days away from the convention
in my hometown of Nashville, Tennessee.
But to address the question that you've asked us,
I think strategic litigation,
it has to be both defensive and affirmative.
So we must defend people and institution
from unlawful government action.
A successful case can't just stop at unlawful policy.
So yes, that looks like in time class actions.
That looks like individual cases.
It also looks like understanding
that every valuable case will not produce
a sweeping Supreme Court decision or some dramatic case.
Many times the most strategic litigation
is a temporary restraining order
that may keep a person free
or may allow enough time for a community
to gather together to create their response.
It requires us to have the right plaintiff,
understand whether the community
is prepared for public attention.
It also means that we need to be cautious
of what unfavorable decisions
that certain decisions could make, right?
So what precedent could an unfavorable decision create?
And so strategy means understanding the cases
in front of us while also being mindful
of the cases that will come after.
But it does not always look like,
I would love this group to take away that
it doesn't always look like the win, the W.
It also means us taking strategic steps
to better organize, right?
Or better come together.
And sometimes that may mean,
even like for our organization,
it may be better to support another organization
in what they're doing than creating your own litigation
or your own case.
And that's been my message this year.
Tracy, what are you thinking about
when you in your head define strategic litigation?
Well, I have to first agree with everything
that Ashley just said.
What I can add is that this administration
has chosen to go after some of the most vulnerable
and under-resourced communities
and individuals in our country.
And from our perspective,
our job is to make sure that every time
one of those communities is attacked,
every time a federal grantee has their grant terminated,
every time a federal employee is unlawfully terminated,
that there is a lawyer, a law firm,
an organization ready to step up
and represent those communities in court.
And that also means not just waiting for the lawsuit,
but proactively putting programs in place,
which is something we do,
that you might consider pre-litigation
so that when the time comes, we have potential plaintiffs,
we have potential causes of action.
But what this government, this executive branch fears
most of all, as Leader Abrams said, is accountability.
Litigation is designed to force that accountability
and ensure that the needs and the rights
of the most vulnerable are protected.
Leader Abrams?
So I heartily agree with everyone.
And I frame it slightly differently.
The work that I've been doing for the last few years
before 10 Steps, I was working on DEI.
So part of our job there was making certain
that people understood the difference
between what sounded like law and what was actually legal.
You had a lot of lawsuits filed
by those who were antithetical to communities of color,
disabled communities, communities of oppression,
having access to resources.
And so part of our responsibility was lifting up
what the law actually says.
For so many people, and I think Tracy was alluding to this,
for so many people,
they understand the law from the headlines.
And Ashley said it as well, it's not just about the W.
Sometimes it's about knowing what is law
versus what is wishful thinking done through a lawyer.
And part of our responsibility in strategic litigation
is making sure people understand
how to parse those things out.
There have been dozens of executive orders issued recently
on DEI since the, in fact,
the very first day of this administration.
Most of them are unlawful.
The ones that have been litigated,
they've lost every single case.
And so part of our approach to strategic litigation
is understanding that just because someone says it,
doesn't make it so.
Even if the person saying it is the president
or a member of Congress, or even sometimes a judge,
because there are steps to making those decisions.
As someone who spent a lot of time
fighting against voter suppression,
I also want us to think about strategic litigation
as not just about offense or defense.
Sometimes it's about dreaming.
So sometimes you file the suit
because you want people to imagine what could be,
not because it is, not because it has been,
but because if you do not have the court engaged,
people don't think it's even worth talking about.
And so I think part of the strategy of litigation
has to be using the court system
much in the way the other side has effectively leveraged it.
They demonize an idea,
they litigate to try to take away what they don't like,
and then they legislate to make sure
whatever they've defeated can never come back.
We have to do the opposite.
We have to imagine what we want,
litigate to test the theory,
and then legislate to make it so.
And so I see strategic litigation in this moment
as a way for us to build the democracy we deserve.
I love that answer,
because it absolutely puts meat on the bones
whenever another executive order would come out
and folks would reflexively say,
well, this is the law now.
I would say, no, this is like,
has the legal force of a letter to Santa.
Like it actually,
and just because it has a big signature at the bottom,
it's still a letter to Santa.
And it's so important, I think,
because the law is so mystified,
to be really clear that we have, as lawyers,
this educative function,
which is to both say, no, this is law, this is not law,
but also to say law can be aspirational
and creative and imaginative too,
and that actually those things are not intention.
Skye, what about you?
Democracy Forward has just filed this massive
trench of huge lawsuits
that challenge federal executive overreach.
I wonder if you can tell us how you are thinking
about this question of what strategic litigation means
in this moment.
First of all, thank you, everyone.
And thank you, Leader Abrams,
for having me and our team at Democracy Forward.
And it's amazing to get to be in this community
with so many change makers.
I agree with what, and not surprisingly,
with what everyone has said,
and with just my gloss on it is,
I do think strategic litigation
is about reclaiming the power of people.
And so in some instances,
that is using litigation as the tool that people have
in the moment to stop what is happening,
to raise awareness and expose what is happening.
Just as folks mentioned,
sometimes a temporary restraining order
or just a order that you get
is what the community needs
to stop something that's happening in its tracks
and allow people to build a response.
Sometimes it's what Leader Abrams is referring to,
which is that if your lawmakers
or people that are elected aren't doing their job
and can't dream for the people,
sometimes the litigation provides that dream
and that path forward as well.
But in all of it,
the strategy behind it is about how we reclaim
the power of people and assert the power of people.
And that's what we've seen in our hundreds of cases
over the past year.
In a nonpartisan fashion,
I will mention that right now,
the Senate is going to be looking
at Todd Blanche's nomination.
And he is claiming one thing
and what the court documents say,
say a completely other thing.
And it is that litigation that's been filed
that is undisputed,
what has sort of happened that is equipping people
to be able to say, wait a second, wait a second,
what you just said doesn't match up
with what you're actually doing.
And that's an incredible power in so many different forums,
but we even see that power have the ability,
even in a legislative forum,
which is not even a courtroom,
to influence the way people can claim their power.
Tracy, can you talk for a minute
about when you use the phrase good government litigation,
what that means?
And maybe you can tell us,
because I think all of you have versions
of the same question,
which is how do you decide which cases to take,
which cases to leave to others?
How do you think through
what good government legislation means
and also your lane in that?
So the first thing I think is important to share here
is that Lawyers for Good Government
has been around for 10 years,
but our litigation work and our litigation team
has only been around for one year.
Before then, we exclusively relied on the strategies
of direct legal services,
providing one-on-one assistance to individual clients
and advocacy and education.
We started the Pro Bono Litigation Corps to fill gaps,
and that is still what we are working to achieve.
In other words, we know that there are organizations
like Democracy Forward that focus solely on impact litigation
and are fully staffed up to do exactly that.
So we look for areas where the resources are thinner,
where the other organizations focusing on impact litigation
are not already stepping forward.
And then we look for ways to fill those gaps
with pro bono help supervised
by our in-house, very experienced litigators.
So in terms of what we think of
as good government litigation,
I think the best way to explain this
is honestly to provide just a couple short examples.
One of them is our work
with the Underground Railroad Education Center.
The administration eliminated 98%
of federal humanities grants
tied to black history and culture.
The center itself lost a $250,000 NEH grant,
which also put in jeopardy about $4 million
of additional financing as a result.
So we brought essentially a Fifth Amendment
equal protection claim asking,
is the government allowed
to selectively defund institutions
because a particular administration
disagrees with the message
or the history that is being preserved?
So that litigation is a direct test
of whether funding can be weaponized
to punish disfavored speech,
or in some cases,
disfavored entire groups and communities of people.
That's one example.
Another is our work on trans youth medical records.
This was back in January of this year.
We worked to quash a federal subpoena
where the administration was seeking access
to the personal medical records
of more than 3,000 trans youth at Children's Hospital LA.
This was lawful medical care
endorsed by every major medical association.
It should never have been the basis
for a federal investigation.
So that work was about,
is this administration,
is the executive branch allowed
to use their investigative power
to surveil and intimidate a targeted population?
So these are examples of the work
that we are doing every day
to try to ensure that the government
is being held accountable
and that this question of what is legal or illegal
actually has meaning.
This was the last thing I'll say,
but this is one of the questions
that people ask so often
every time they see a news story.
Is that legal?
Are they allowed to do that?
And the reality is what is legal or illegal on paper
means nothing from a practical perspective.
Those actions have to be challenged in court
in order to ensure that illegal government behavior stops.
So I'll stop there.
I love that framing, Tracy,
because it is such a good embracing and timely reminder
that whether something is legal or not
is only half the question,
that whether they can get away with it
is where the burden shifts to us
to hold them accountable,
which was, I think, where Ashley started.
Ashley, I want to talk for one little minute with you
about history because, of course,
the NBA was founded back in 1925
by 12 black lawyers who were excluded
from the American Bar Association.
And so the NBA members went on to work
through the NAACP toward wins
and huge, huge consequential cases like Brown v. Board.
And so here you are,
you're a year out from the centennial of the NBA,
and you're walking out of this year's convention
in Nashville.
And I would love for you to maybe take a step back
and tell us what this history teaches
about how this moment that feels new to a lot of us
is not new at all,
and that we have a long, long history in this country
of knowing how to do this work.
Absolutely, thank you for that question.
I have the benefit, honor, and privilege
of still being able to reach back
and to talk to leaders of that time,
such as Fred Gray, who is still alive and with us today,
who was the lawyer for Martin Luther King,
Rosa Parks, and many others.
I'm blessed in that way.
And what past President Gray said to me plainly was,
in some ways you have it worse
because at least at times you could depend
on the Supreme Court, which is not the case right now.
But I looked right back at him and said,
well, you all didn't have a blueprint and you created one.
And so what I would say looking back is
that our 12 founders, only one of whom was a woman,
did not respond to exclusion
by waiting for an invitation, right?
They didn't wait for an institution, they built one.
And I believe that that remains true today.
When institutions that are responsible
for protecting democracy,
like what we've seen with this administration,
fail to do so, fail to include us, we need to organize.
We develop legal talent.
So the Deprecrate Scholars,
we are an organization pouring back
into creating and training civil rights attorneys.
We build our own infrastructure.
We prepare cases that will eventually
obviously reach the courthouse,
but it's also about mobilizing your group, right?
We have a lot of lawyers.
Yes, we're already doing pro bono work,
but certainly when the TPS decision came down,
what did we do?
We started before that happened,
training non-immigration lawyers
in areas that would be ripe,
given what we assumed would be the outcome.
And so we trained family lawyers,
we were training our real property trusts
and estates lawyers on how they can help with this issue
that most would think of as an immigration issue only,
immigration law issue.
And so our lawyers are working side-by-side
other civil rights organizations.
And what I would also remind us is,
build a record that the country cannot ignore.
So what made sense at that time,
and I think it goes back to what Leader Abrams says,
is sometimes what we file in these cases,
it may feel aspirational,
but it's also building a record
of what our country chose to do
in times and moments like this.
And so usually transformative litigation is not one case,
it's not one brilliant lawyer.
Like I said earlier, it's not one dramatic moment,
but it's preparation over time,
it's community over time.
And I believe that litigation and community
are not necessarily always lockstep,
but what happens is community gives strategic litigation
its direction and its legitimacy.
So many times we look at litigation being the driving force
when that's not many times the case,
it's the community and their demands
on what is right and wrong,
or righting a wrong that drives the litigation.
And so for us, we have a blueprint.
Now we, so we're more fortunate
than our foremothers and forefathers,
it's just a matter of us executing
and not feeling disillusioned or defeated right now
because of all the, what I would say,
chaos that's going on.
We're non-partisan, but we also believe
in speaking the truth about what's going on.
Yeah, and I think chaos is chaos.
That's a non-partisan issue as much as democracy is.
Leader Abrams, that's such a nice segue
into another cut at this historical question,
which I know you think about more than a lot of us,
who are lawyers, who are just like doing the next thing.
And Ashley makes this really good point that we tend to,
because we learn law in case books,
we learn about the big win,
we learn about Brown and we learn about Roe v. Wade
and we learn about Obergefell.
And it seems as though that's the whole story.
But of course, behind every one of those landmarks,
Supreme Court, and again, you've all made this point,
the Supreme Court is not the only game in town,
but behind each of these cases,
there are years of strategic,
tactical coalition building, public education.
There's an enormous under the surface churning,
churning of how we build a case and what a win looks like.
And I just love, again,
for you to pan back both historically
and also in terms of a sort of a vertical look
at everything that goes into a landmark lawsuit
to just give us a sense of how every person
who is on this call, even non-lawyers,
is in fact involved in building those wins.
Thank you, Valya.
So the conversation we had
when we were creating the 10 steps to freedom and power,
I was very aggressive and insistent
on litigation being one of those steps.
And there was some legitimate pushback
because the intention of the 10 steps
was to create 10 things that everyone could do.
You could pick what you want to sort of,
choose your own adventure to save democracy,
but litigation was one of the steps.
And a number of people said, well, I'm not a lawyer.
Litigation is not simply about going to court.
At its core, litigation is about arguing the case.
It's about arguing the point.
And the way we make arguments include filing briefs
and what we learn about in case law,
but it's also taking the actions necessary
to create the record that has to be argued.
It is changing the cultural narrative
so that people start to believe
that they have the right to argue.
I think about Frederick Douglass and Sojourner Truth
and those who had been enslaved
who created a narrative in this country
that said that the accepted notion of enslavement was wrong.
Litigation helped make it true,
but it was the argument of the case that made it so.
Another example I think about is Ida B. Wells.
Ida B. Wells is a journalist
who was writing in the early 20th century, 1900s,
writing about lynchings.
And she had this very contested argument with Jane Addams.
Jane Addams, who's this amazing social justice leader
who created Addams House,
was really one of the leaders of the progressive movement
who tried to excuse lynchings
as just this overwrought reaction of white Southerners
to black men being overly likely to assault white women.
And in her argument, she published it in a Chicago paper.
Jane Addams, with all good intention, decried lynching,
but made the argument that,
well, perhaps there was a reason
because the law had failed them.
They thought they had to take lynching
as the answer.
And Ida B. Wells, in a very famous response,
said, no, this is the kind of excuse
that people use to justify privileging their behavior
above someone else's humanity,
and we have to argue the case.
We have to tell the truth about what it is.
Litigation is what does that.
And so sometimes the litigation
comes from a lawyer going to court.
Sometimes it comes from a reporter,
in her case, arguing the case.
Sometimes it comes from a plaintiff calling up Ashley
or sending a note to Tracy on Facebook saying,
this thing happened to me.
Can you help me solve it?
And sometimes it's those of us who are not at all involved
hearing or seeing something
and telling our neighbors on social media,
did you know this is true?
Did you know this happened?
We as Americans start to accept things
because they seem so.
Litigation is a disruptor
because it argues that maybe it should not be so.
And what organizers and litigators have done in tandem
for the entire history of this country
is shape the narrative of who we are
based on what we're willing to fight about.
And because we are a civilized community,
we fight in the courts,
but organizers, we fight in the streets, non-violently,
but our engagement in the streets,
our engagement in community,
our engagement on social media is about setting the stage
for what should the law say is permissible?
What should society accept?
But it's also about pushing us to be more exacting
in how we describe it.
And I think that's where the combination of litigator
and organizer becomes so perfected
because it's when we take things that are wrong
and argue for it to be made right,
or where we see things that people have accepted as true
and say, maybe this is not enough
and we should do something else.
That's such a nice frame also on this question,
I think of what history remembers and who history remembers
because we forget who gets written out
of a particularly right constitutional and legal history.
And as you mentioned,
we've been doing this series on popular constitutionalism
and the story that blew my mind
was the story of Inri Turner,
which is this seminal case that's brought
when an emancipated girl who was enslaved
was immediately re-enslaved under state apprenticeship laws.
And you know who brought the habeas petition?
Her mom also, a just released slave.
And her mom is the one who literally marched
across the country and said, I'm filing, I'm not a lawyer.
I don't know exactly what I'm doing,
but I do know that under the state constitution,
this is wrong and prevails, right?
And so I just want to lift up what you just said,
which is this constitutional muscle
that we can all do this
and that history tends to bury the stories
of the ordinary people who have done this,
not just after the civil war,
but again, in the civil rights movement,
history buries those stories and lifts out,
the one great man who changed the world.
There are so many people who are not lawyers
who do that too.
And that maybe leads me to you Skye,
because you've said to me, and I quote you constantly,
and I think Ashley just made this point,
but it's so important.
When folks say to you,
oh, we don't have the Supreme court,
don't litigate this case,
we're gonna lose in the courts of appeals,
what are you doing?
And you keep telling me that there's two reasons
you go on doing this.
Ashley made the point.
You are creating a record,
you're creating a historical record,
and you are telling a story to the public to engage them.
And I just love for you to amplify that for a minute,
because again, I think there is this tendency,
you all made this point,
to think in terms of wins and losses.
And this is not about wins and losses,
there are values that are much, much more important.
And I do really think of you as someone
who thinks about wins in really different terms.
Yeah, well, thank you.
I mean, first I'll amplify what everyone has said,
but then to just put a fine point on a few of them.
I mean, one is sometimes the best you can hope for
is the courts serve as a mirror.
And they serve as a mirror of what the society
is willing to tolerate at that time.
So when you look at something like the Calais decision,
that we are all still having to process,
live with and understand that what the court did,
as we saw in that mirror just days after,
is to set voting rights back,
to set the representation of black and brown communities
in the South, particularly back a generation.
That is a mirror of where we are and what we are up against.
And sometimes it is that clarity
that people and communities need
in order to mobilize and organize
and take the 10 steps to freedom,
one of which is litigating the other steps as well.
And so it's not about creating a record
so we can go back and say, gosh, things are bad,
then can you believe the court did it?
Sometimes it's about creating a record for ourselves today.
So that is one place,
but the storytelling is so important.
And that's not just about telling a story
of someone who is harmed,
it's also about telling a story
of the people who are willing in that moment
to step up and fight back.
We represent a range of librarians who just this week,
after having blocked a law in Arkansas
that Sarah Huckabee Sanders signed into law
that would criminalize librarians,
that would literally seek criminal penalties
against librarians, we blocked it for over two years
as a violation of the First Amendment,
we got a negative decision on appeal.
And we have some strategies about what we are going to do
in light of that, and it's not over yet,
and I'll always say it's not over yet.
But what we did in that matter
was show kids and young people and families
that are living in Arkansas, all over Arkansas,
including in rural Arkansas,
that there were people,
including their librarians and their booksellers
that were willing to step up and say,
in this moment, we care about your ability to read,
about your ability to thrive,
about your ability to access ideas
that should be available to everyone,
and we are going to step forward.
That's the same thing that our clients
who have so far prevailed in our litigation against ICE,
houses of worship, houses of worship across the country
going to court, that's not something you normally think
about a church or a house of worship doing,
going to court against the president to say,
you're not going to conduct these indiscriminate operations
in our houses of worship,
and so part of that narrative
is not just about telling the stories
of people that are negatively affected,
that's important, and that record is important,
and that mirror is important,
but it's also about lifting up
the people that are willing in the moment
to step up and to stand up,
because what we know is that courage is, in fact, contagious
and data shows that the presence of one,
in many instances,
the presence of just one dissenting voice in a room
can give others the strength and the courage to join in,
and when we're talking about steps to authoritarianism
and steps to autocracy,
we are talking about steps in a glide path
that only runs on silence and compliance,
and so I believe that litigation
as one of the steps to freedom
is a major step in helping people engage in the other steps
and find their voice and find their community
and find their courage.
Tracy, we've been talking about big, big lawyerly
and constitutional ideas,
but I would love to ask you this,
just brass tacks question, which is L4GG,
the whole model has been about mobilizing
a network of volunteer lawyers
who, I remember when you started,
just want to do a thing,
and they want someone to say,
here's a thing to do.
Can you talk in the most concrete terms
about pathways for lawyers to get involved?
Absolutely, thank you so much.
So the first thing I'll share is that if you are a lawyer,
you must subscribe to our impact docket,
and I can put a link in the chat in a little bit,
but basically this impact docket
is the answer to the question that, as Dahlia said,
we at L4GG have been trying to answer since 2016,
which is, what can I do?
And the impact docket comes out every week
and lists anywhere from five to 15 different opportunities
for lawyers to make a difference that week.
It could be something as simple as sending in
an advocacy letter to your member of Congress,
but it also could be signing up to participate
in the pro bono litigation corps.
I'll talk about a few big opportunities,
but it's important to note that we have at L4GG
dozens of different programs and ways for lawyers
with all levels of experience,
all different practice areas to get involved.
The first one is pro bono litigation corps.
If you are a litigator, regardless of years of experience,
but if you are a litigator,
this is a great opportunity for you.
We can provide you with things like legal research access,
supervision, malpractice insurance,
all of the things that you need
to actually be able to bring a case,
but we will also match you with co-counsel, a matter,
make sure you have the support that you need along the way.
We have another program called detention bridge.
This is a great option for lawyers
who want direct hands-on service work,
and you don't need an immigration law background,
even though the work is to conduct intakes,
know your rights and document conditions
for asylum seekers and other migrants
who are currently detained in frankly horrific conditions.
Again, you don't need to be an immigration lawyer.
We've designed this program to be accessible to any lawyer
who's willing to do the work.
And lastly, I'll highlight our COFSE clinic.
This is for the Court of Federal Claims.
So this would be a great fit for lawyers with contracts,
claims or litigation support experience
who want really structured, well-defined work.
Volunteers will help grantees
whose federal funding was terminated
to build and pursue breach of contract claims,
reviewing grant terms, building the administrative record
and preparing filings.
So there are so many different opportunities.
I don't want to bore anyone,
but the best way to stay up to date on all of those
is through the Impact Docket.
And it looks like the link has been posted, so thank you.
And I assure you, nobody is bored.
This is really essential work.
I want to do one very quick speed round
with all the panelists,
and then we'll turn to the audience Q&A.
And please pop your questions there
if you have something that hasn't been addressed.
But this panel, as we've now said
in many, many different ways,
is not just about litigation.
And I wonder if you can each talk about
what the work in your world
outside of direct litigation looks like,
and again, how folks on this call can get involved
even if they're not attorneys.
Can we start with you, Ashley?
Sure.
So like you've highlighted,
you do not need a law degree
to contribute to strategic litigation, excuse me,
or this work in general.
So like I highlighted earlier,
first things first, we need documentation.
We need evidence.
So stating that notice, informing,
keeping that email, reporting that date,
learning what organizations are in your community,
and making sure that you partner
with those individuals or those organizations.
But also aside from all that is,
and I'm sure this may come up, is engaging young people.
Now, my son just is starting college in a couple of weeks.
He's 18 years old.
And so many times they're not there.
We say, oh, they're not engaged,
but we're not engaging them.
And so even 16 and up,
they're aware many times what's going on,
and they understand technology and digital communication
in a way that many of us my age don't.
And so they're helpful in making sure
to stop efforts to spread disinformation,
to intimidate community, to conceal information.
We're not engaging them in that way.
We're talking about things like Vote 16 initiatives
and things that have gone around.
We think about the removal of civics in school,
but we're not making sure
that we're getting those young folks involved.
And what that looks like is community organizing.
It looks like spreading the word
and partnering with folks that have large platforms online.
Those are easy ways that non-lawyers can be engaged.
And again, we always need support.
When the 300,000 black women were just put,
now over 600,000 black women
have been displaced from the workforce.
It was non-lawyers who helped us connect
some of those women with jobs.
You just had to have a source, a referral source.
And so we've worked with numerous organizations this year.
And so not standing by on the sidelines,
that's the one option that you don't have,
is standing on the sidelines.
Same question for you, Leader Abrams.
Well, I would say make certain
that you are part of the 10 Steps campaign.
The entirety of the 10 Steps campaign
is exactly this question.
No matter who you are, you can do something.
And the thing to understand
is that we don't all have to do the same thing,
but we all have to do something.
There are 10 steps,
which means you can pick the thing that makes the most sense.
You're on this call tonight.
When you finish, make certain you send out
to 10 of your friends an email saying,
I was on this call, and this is what I heard,
and here's who was on it, and this is what I learned.
That's all you gotta do, send it to 10 people.
And in the spirit of being someone who is over 45,
it's a chain mail.
So tell them to send it to 10 more people.
Tell people, because step two in the 10 Steps is share.
Step five is litigate.
And so everything that these litigators tell you to do,
do it.
But I think the most important one to me
is that when you're done, you're not finished.
So we might be done today,
but every day there's something else we can do.
And if we find one thing to do every day
that helps push back against the idea
that we have agreed to allow them to seize our power,
it changes the outcome.
Skye said it perfectly.
Silence and compliance is what they demand.
That means we have to be loud and disruptive.
And for those who are introverted like me,
disruption doesn't mean you have to be out in the streets,
but you can be on social media every day.
You can say something or follow someone.
They have created an echo chamber of evil.
We have to create an ecosystem of good.
And that ecosystem is sometimes nothing more complex
than finding each day five folks
that you follow on social media,
dropping a like, subscribing to their channels,
making sure that you're on Tracy's docket,
that you're getting what Skye puts out,
that you're on the 10 Steps docket,
that you're supporting NBA,
but make sure you're doing something
because what they have done effectively
is convince us that they're everywhere.
They're not.
They're not even half the country,
but they occupy an outsized portion of our minds
because they have a singular focus
on convincing us we've already lost.
The 10 Steps campaign is about proving to ourselves
that we can still not only win,
but we can demand the democracy we deserve.
And so find one thing you can do every day,
reach out to 10 people that you can tonight
and tell them what you heard
and follow five people every week
and make sure they know
that you care about what they're saying
so more people can find them and we can win.
Tracy, same question.
I know you gave us a laundry list of how to get involved,
but what's a way to put an oar in right now?
So I'll share a couple of opportunities that we have
that in the language,
you'll see if you go to the websites,
it does talk about being a lawyer,
but these opportunities
actually don't require a law license.
The first one is we offer something
called the State Legislative Advocacy Academy,
and this is designed to train lawyers
and others how to organize for policy change
in their own state capitals.
This is absolutely critical work
because so many of the key fights of the modern day
are happening at the state level
while most of us are focused
at what's happening at the federal level.
So this is specifically about learning
how to use your skills and your voice in your own state.
Another one is combating election disinformation.
So with the midterms ahead,
we are mobilizing volunteer lawyers
and others to monitor emerging false narratives,
to help flag harmful disinformation
and to support rapid response
and platform reporting before falsehoods spread.
This maps directly onto, I believe,
the disrupt step of the 10-step program,
refusing to let bad actors control the narrative
and pushing back on false information before it takes hold.
It's a way to get involved
without any litigation experience.
And the last thing I'll say is I think we hear it so much,
we may overlook it,
but there is not any such thing
as communicating too often with your members of Congress.
So much of what is taking place
in the executive branch right now is happening
because the legislative branch, our own representatives,
are allowing it to happen.
So please make sure that when that is taking place,
that you are contacting your members of Congress,
you are telling them what is
and is not acceptable to you as a constituent.
I think it was President Obama who emphasized in a speech
that the highest office in the land
is not president or senator, it is citizen.
We all have an obligation as citizens to play our part.
And I know all of you will.
I just wanna say a quick hi to so many names I recognize
on the attendee list.
Thank you for joining.
Skye, can you land this plane before we turn to Q&A?
I'm trying to imagine anything you could add,
but if anyone could.
Well, all I'll just say,
certainly do all the things that are listed,
follow all the organizations, sign up for the actions.
And I'll just highlight at Democracy Forward,
we launched a 100 Days of Action campaign
on the day that was the 100th day
before the midterm elections.
And every week we release seven actions,
one for each day that people can do.
And so follow our social media channels
at Democracy Forward, go to our website,
you will find the 100 Days of Action.
I was just talking with someone today
that had an application open to start filling out a form
to get information about being a poll worker
because there was information about how to do that
through our 100 Days of Action campaign.
But it's really about how we can take these small steps
that are not small steps
when all of us take them together
in order to strengthen our democracy in this time.
So I'll lift that up.
And then Dahlia, you were so kind to focus
that my book is coming out,
which has a bunch of actions to take,
but you guys are already doing it
because one of the main actions I suggest
is to join and engage with 10 Steps, what you're doing.
And we'll have some opportunities
to highlight actions through that as well.
And I wanna turn it over to Kezia Clark,
who's going to ask some of the questions.
Leader Abrams.
Dahlia, you should answer your own question, please.
I don't wanna step on other people's questions.
You're not.
This is what I would say.
I would say very, very, very, very much
that we have come to a moment in this country
where we have a little bit of learned helplessness
around the court and you get a 6-3 decision
and it is like Calais, utterly catastrophic.
And the impulse is to say,
oh, well, the final arbiter has spoken.
And I just really wanna make the point
that what Sky just said is true.
And what Tracy just said about we are the final arbiters.
We make law, we know how to do this.
And it's not a wait till the midterms thing.
It's like today and every day,
probably for the rest of our lives.
But I just think we cannot be in a situation now
where kind of passivity dictates outcomes
because every time we are passive,
the other side banks on it.
So I really, again, every single person has said this.
You don't have to do everything,
but you absolutely have to understand
that you are a brilliant constitutional lawyer
in your own right and the document was written
so you can do that work.
Now, I'm really gonna, thank you for asking me to talk.
I'm really gonna turn it over to Kezia
to read some of the questions from the Q&A.
Thank you so much.
And that was actually a perfect segue
to one question from Martin Wolf, who said,
when the Supreme Court makes an erroneous decision,
must litigants wait until the court is reconstituted
before challenging the case
or are there other mechanisms available?
I'm happy to.
There are other mechanisms available,
but we do have to insist on a court
and a constitution that holds all of us.
And so part of it is to harness that anger and outrage
and make sure that we are making the demands
that our constitution enables us to make
to say that if this is a court
that's not gonna protect the rights of all people
and it's not going to lead us
on a path of unrestricted democracy,
it has to be a court that is reformed.
So hold on to that, but there are many ways to make change.
The first thing I would just point to
is tremendous litigation that is happening
in states across the country
under state constitutions across the country.
We have seen states, including states
that might not be seen as the most progressive,
the most sort of progressive states,
be able to establish,
people be able to establish through litigating rights
that are even more expansive than our constitutional rights
under state constitutions.
And so that is a really important pathway.
It can often operate on the same path
as strategic litigation at the federal level.
And one great example of that, of course,
is since the Dobbs decision,
we have seen, sure, we've seen ballot initiatives
and we've seen legislative initiatives,
but there have also been a number of litigation initiatives
that are resurrecting the passages in those constitutions
that, of course, as our own constitution does,
even if our Supreme Court doesn't acknowledge it right now,
encompass a full scope of personal autonomy.
So that's one strategy.
Another strategy is what I would call cases are just cases.
They're fundamentally about specific facts.
And so you can read the headlines
that are gonna want you to say,
well, this whole thing is dead letter,
but actually get dirty and get in there
and look at the facts,
because good lawyers can often find ways
to distinguish cases that the Supreme Court heard
with cases and situations that are happening on the ground
in order to try to develop out those exceptions.
And just remember that of all the cases
that are filed in the country,
of all those cases,
the Supreme Court only takes about 60 to 80 cases
on its full merits docket.
They take more on their shadow docket,
their emergency docket,
which we believe is improper how they're using it,
but they don't take that many more.
And so there's a lot of work that can be done
in those lower courts to protect people's rights too.
Thank you.
Okay, another question is,
can there be litigation against HHS
for the dismantling of Head Start?
That litigation is ongoing.
There we go.
And some of it's successful and some of it's pending.
Okay.
And another one is from Allie Brockhoff,
who is actually from one of our partner organizations,
Right to Be.
What is the roadmap ahead with strategic litigation
in regards to voter suppression like the SAVE Act
or redirecting voter maps due to racism
or on partisan grounds?
So I'll start,
but then certainly invite Ashley and Skye
and Tracy to jump in.
Our first responsibility is to vote for state legislators.
As much as we are focusing on midterm elections
as a referendum on Congress,
all of these maps,
Calais basically said the federal government
is not coming to help,
which means all of the work to defend democracy
in this fashion relies on what the states permit.
And what they did when they vitiated
the second section two of the Voting Rights Act
would say that they no longer believe
that we have a federated right to vote,
that we have restored the Jim Crow South
that said that it is every state deciding
the quality of your citizenship based on your access to vote.
And so we have to vote for state legislators.
What Calais also permits is the ability
for all of the states in the U.S.
to redraw their districts.
There are 190 seats that can be redrawn.
And if those seats get redrawn
through midterm redistricting,
that interferes with every right that we've talked about.
And so I'm gonna list a few states
that have really competitive races this year.
If you're in Minnesota,
if you're in Michigan,
if you're in Pennsylvania,
if you're in Nevada,
if you're in New Hampshire,
if you're in Wisconsin,
you have the ability in Arizona,
you can flip,
we can actually take seats
and move towards if not trifectas,
then at least a much more responsive
and contested set of decisions about voting rights.
And before people say,
well, those are blue states.
These are a lot of competitive states
where a lot of voter suppression
in the last 20 years has come from.
Wisconsin at one point
had some of the most egregious anti-voter laws
in the country.
And it was not that long ago.
It was 2014, 2016.
In 2016, a black woman was denied the right to vote
because she was born without a birth certificate
because she was born in the Jim Crow South
and Wisconsin's voter ID laws made it illegal
for her to stay on the rolls.
So this is not ancient history.
This is last week.
So we've got to participate in those elections.
In Georgia, we have a chance
to flip one of our chambers.
We've got to participate here.
In North Carolina,
they need a handful of votes
in the House and the Senate
to break a super majority
so the governor of North Carolina
can actually govern North Carolina.
And so state legislative races matter.
They matter in November
because in January,
that's when you're going to see
the rush of litigation,
but it's going to be coupled
with a rush of legislation
to ferment what they want,
to start to bubble up to the top,
this notion that democracy shouldn't really work.
And so we've got to be engaged
at the state level now.
Calais is not just a terrible decision.
It is a call to action
because if you live in a state
that you think is perfectly safe,
hold my beer.
Things change very quickly.
And the reality is until we have state laws
that actually cement in the Constitution
the right to vote,
until we have voting rights laws
across the country at the state level,
then what they are trying to do
through the courts and through the Congress
will continue to work.
States can push back,
states can win,
and it's not just blue states,
it's blue states,
it's purple states,
but it's also red states
because in red states...
