Are insurance companies taking advantage of pet owners by raising rates?

Pet Insurance
2 followers
4 Video Views·Apr 23, 2026
Many pet owners have turned to pet insurance to help pay for rising medical care costs for their beloved animals, but some insurance companies are taking advantage of them by raising rates. Toni Yates has the story.
Many pet owners have turned to pet insurance to help pay for rising costs of medical care
for their beloved animals. But a congressman from New Jersey says as a result some insurance
companies are taking advantage of pet owners by raising their rates along the way. New Jersey
reporter Tony Yates with more from Glenrock. We met Georgia and Lily, Cody and Callie out at the
Glenrock dog park. Their owners all having opinions or experiences with the world of pet insurance.
Eileen Hillock lost two dogs to severe illnesses, major vet bills, before she adopted Cody and
Callie. We got insurance on them because of what we learned with the others, but again so much
isn't covered and so many people cannot afford it. Congressman Josh Gottheimer brought his dog
Rosie out to the park. The congressman concerned that pet insurance companies are looking to raise
their rates significantly. Many families across North Jersey, including mine, recently received
a letter that our pet insurance rates were set to increase 44 percent this year alone. The
congressman says the three major pet insurance companies in New Jersey are asking for hikes of
33, 44 and 56 percent, while he says veterinarian bills are up only about 10 percent on average.
There's a line between reasonable and unreasonable, and these rate increases in one year
crosses that line. Jordan Babin, Georgia's owner, opted not to buy pet insurance. Instead I opted
for a wellness plan which covers like the things that we know we're going to need each year. While
John Kang, Lilly's owner, says he will pay the premium regardless of how high it goes. 100 percent
because it's peace of mind. I spend $81 to cover cell phones. The average cost of premiums right
now can run about 50 to nearly $100 a month depending on coverage, with plans that offer
from $5,000 to unlimited coverage. Double that? Another rate hike this this high could mean owners
not being able to afford their animals and having to give them up. Gottheimer is asking the state's
department of banking and insurance to reject the company's applications for the increases.
