Is pet insurance REALLY worth it?

Pet Insurance
2 followers
16 Video Views·Oct 8, 2026
Our pets are like family but is pet insurance worth the money? A big dilemma when you adopt a pet is if pet insurance is a yes or a no? Vet bills can cost a fortune but so can paying for insurance that might not cover what your cat or dog needs anyway.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker discusses the financial responsibilities of pet ownership, specifically focusing on the costs of veterinary care and the pros and cons of pet insurance. By comparing insurance premiums against alternative financial strategies, such as mortgage overpayments or dedicated savings, the video emphasizes the importance of having a financial plan for pet emergencies.
Did you buy anything weird during COVID? Do you want to see what I bought? I think you can't see
him. He's yawning. This is Teddy and we welcomed Teddy into our family last year like so many
other Australians. We bought a pet. We weren't able to have a dog before that because we work
full-time and now thanks to flexible work, thanks to COVID, we're able to have Teddy in our house
and Ted has been amazing. He's brought so much fun even though he's yawning and joy to us. I
wouldn't regret it for a second. Not gonna lie, our little guy did cost a little bit more than
we're expecting to pay and that's because there has been a bit of a supply and demand issue with
so many people wanting pets. We also looked at getting a rescue dog and found it incredibly
difficult, which is great news for rescues, to find one. There aren't many rescue dogs around
and for our family, we have a child who has some neurodiversity, needs a calm dog. We actually had
to come to the decision that a Cavoodle was the right kind of dog for us. Beyond the actual
purchase price, what's been interesting is thinking about the kind of costs you have
day-to-day or year-to-year if you own a pet. I've never really crunched it before. I've owned pets
for most of my life and we had a cat who lived to the grand old age of 20 last year but I'd never
crunched the numbers. RSPCA has though and it costs on average about $15,000 to own a dog over
its lifetime and $12,000 if you have a cat. Now that's on average. That's if your pet doesn't have
any special needs or gets into any accidents and while there's the cost of things like food
and grooming and ridiculous squeaky chickens that my kids keep buying for Teddy, the big killer is
vet bills. If your dog or cat has an accident or gets a serious illness, you can be looking at
tens of thousands of dollars for your pet. Now pets in Australia don't come with Medicare like
humans so if you want treatment for your animal, you are going to have to pay. So what do you do?
We have pet insurance in Australia and something that I get asked all the time and is on my list
today is does my pet need pet insurance? Is pet insurance worth it? So how does pet insurance work?
In a nutshell, you basically pay what's called a premium or a fee each month or for the year that
gives your pet a level of cover. Then if your pet is unwell or needs a checkup, you can go to any
registered vet, you pay for the bill up front and then you can claim that back on your insurance and
you can usually claim back about 85% and roughly $20,000 a year. That sounds like a lot but if
your dog or cat gets in an accident or your dog does something crazy and dogs do like eat a sock
and get really unwell, you'd be surprised how quickly those vet bills can ratchet up. So having
insurance can be a real lifesaver but we'll need to look at the different types of cover that are
available and the kind of costs around that in a sec. There are basically three different kinds of
cover. There's accident only cover which only covers injuries caused by an accident. That's
like broken bones from a car accident, scratches from fighting or even snake bites but this kind of
policy doesn't pay out for all kinds of accidents. There's accident and illness cover which will
protect your pet from accidents as well as sickness or disease. So your furry friend will be covered
from conditions such as cancer or infectious diseases or even skin conditions. The gold
standard is comprehensive cover and that protects your four-legged friend against accidents and
illnesses to a much higher limit and some policies also cover routine care which can even
cover things like training, prescription diets, deworming and de-sexing. So the million dollar
question is how much is it going to cost to pay for your pet insurance? The answer depends on
whether you have a cat or a dog and in the dog's case what breed it is. On average for a dog you're
looking at about $300 a year for really bare bones basic cover right up to $800 for comprehensive
cover but if you have a breed like a Frenchie or a Great Jane or any of those kind of dogs
are going to stop everyone dead at the dog park because they're so unusual you're probably going
to be looking at paying more usually because these breeds do come with more existing health
conditions and are more prone to getting unwell. Good news if you're a cat lady, cats are all the
same cost no matter what breed they are and again you're looking at between $300 to $600 for a cat
and of course if you insure earlier the better. If you've read anything much about pet insurance
it's probably no surprise to hear that there is a bit of criticism leveled at the industry
and the product itself and some of that is true. Pet insurance can be very confusing,
it can have a lot of loopholes, complicated Ts and Cs and a lot of exclusions so it's
understandable if you are feeling nervous about taking it on. I'm going to go through a couple
things to look out for and I'm also going to look at some alternatives to pet insurance
depending on your situation so either way you're not going to be in the situation where you have
to look at having your pet put down because you can't afford the bills. So looking at the pros
and cons of pet insurance there's a couple of things to think about. On the pro side insurance
helps cover unexpected or ongoing vet bills which we know can be extremely expensive.
It'll give you peace of mind, you'll know that you're not going to be forced to think about
costs when it comes to your pet's health when you're standing there in the vet surgery and
something has gone wrong. Your pet can get covered for congenital conditions so the sooner you insure
them the better and the Australian Veterinary Association strongly recommends pet insurance.
On the downside though your pet could have really expensive health issues in the short run anyway.
Some conditions have sublimits so you're not going to be covered for them things like paralysis
ticks. You may not get covered for pre-existing conditions. Now pre-existing conditions could be
a trademark of that particular breed so you're going to get stung there too and of course even
though you're going to be paying for insurance you're still going to have some out-of-pocket
expenses. So for me and my family I'm not completely convinced whether pet insurance is
the way to go. In our family we do have a home loan and we're a little ahead on our mortgage so
something I was thinking about is whether we could put the money that we'd spend on pet insurance
onto our mortgage and whether that would work out better. For people that don't have a mortgage and
may not want to take out pet insurance another alternative is setting up a savings account but
spoiler warning this is going to take a lot of discipline. You're going to have to make sure you
put money away each month or each week and you're going to want to do it from when your pet is a
baby so you're going to build up a supply of money and it will get you over some of those
shorter term illnesses and accidents but know that it may not cover you for the big ones but
it's another thing to consider. Finally with pet insurance if you are going to do it do it sooner
than later. So our guy is still under a year old so we've still got some time to get him insured
but the earlier you do it the less you're going to pay. So I've just been having a look at Finder
and basically it's saying that a Cavoodle which is what Ted is which is a pretty healthy breed
doesn't have too many pre-existing conditions you're looking at about six to seven hundred
dollars a year to insure him. So is there an alternative? I'm going to talk to Sarah Megenson
who's our Homelands Editor just to see if I do have an alternative. What would happen if I use
the money that's six to seven hundred dollars a year over 15 years? What would happen if I put
that on my Homeland instead? Would I get more bang for my buck? Is it another option? Okay I've
magically changed locations also I'm not filming from home I'm very excited I've got Alex on the
camera behind me. The reason I'm here is because Sarah Megenson is here she's Finder's Homelands
Editor and I wanted to pick Sarah's brain about my pet insurance dilemma. Sarah tell me I have a
I'm trying to pay it down pretty hard would there be any value using that money for pet insurance if
I was disciplined for example and putting it on my mortgage what do you think? Yeah absolutely I mean
seven hundred dollars a year is the kind of average premium and that's such a lot of money
and the thing about insurance is it's an expense that you're kind of hoping you'll never have to
claim on you know you it's something you pay for that you don't ever want to have to use
but it's there in case of emergencies and with that kind of money if you're talking about seven
hundred dollars a year if you're able to add that to your mortgage every year over say 15 years
that's going to be almost eleven thousand dollars. Oh my god that's actually it doesn't seven hundred
sounds like a bit but eleven thousand is a lot. It's a lot right yeah and so if you've got that
in your mortgage if you're popping in a redraw facility or even an offset account either way
if you've got that accessible yeah it means that if something happened to your dog say you're
putting away your seven hundred dollars a year and something happens after three years you'll
be able to access that money and pull it out but in the interim it's working to pay your mortgage
off sooner and we know from doing calculations that any little extra bit you put into your
mortgage it actually it doesn't just reduce the amount of interest you pay but it means you pay
off your home loan sooner so I'm not sure of the exact calculation with this but if you're looking
at around 15 years and seven hundred dollars a year you could say own your home at 12 months
sooner that's 12 months where you're not paying a mortgage repayment so you know that adds up to
actually you know could be twenty thousand dollars worth of mortgage savings. Yeah hopefully he won't
eat too many more socks because he's already tried that this I think it's so useful too Sarah because
when we think about finances sometimes we don't always think about we only tend to look at the
thing at hand we don't look at like the helicopter view so I'm thinking for someone else who may not
have any savings or you know a mortgage like insurance is a good option then but you know if
you look holistically it's not always the only option and I guess in our situation that's really
worth looking into. Absolutely and I think that's a really good point with insurance it's something
that if you found that if something happened to your dog or your cat that you would have no way
to pay it then insurance is a really good you know backup there but if you've got a bit of savings
and you can you know dip into that if you need to then putting the money into your mortgage can just
have such a big impact and the main reason why is because mortgages are for such a long time
it's the compounding effect a really small kind of commitment to saving it can have a really big
impact down the track so it's kind of just it's really worth always looking at what the long-term
impact is going to be. Yeah that's so cool so I think I think you know less treats for Teddy
less budget on the treats sorry Teddy maybe less squeaky toys we'd all probably be happy
about that except for him put that money aside Sarah thanks so much. Oh you're welcome. So there
you have it the verdict for my personal situation is if we put the money that we were going to spend
on pet insurance on our mortgage we'll actually get a little bit more bang for our buck so it'll
bring our interest down and it'll mean when Ted does need you know veterinary assistance or some
kind of operational treatment we've got a choice about how we pay for that and how it all rolls
out however that's worked for us it may not work for you either way what I've learned is if you
have a pet you need a plan whether it's pet insurance a savings account or what I've done
with my mortgage you need to have a backup in case your pet gets sick or gets into an accident
our pets are like family members these days and no one wants to end up having to make a really
tough decision because they can't afford to you know make the payment for the treatment that their
pet needs so I would really strongly suggest if you're one of the people that's got a pet like
me in the last year or so check out pet insurance we've got details online in the description below
for details on my situation and how I crunch the numbers there's details on that in the
description below don't forget to like and subscribe to finder too if you'd like to see
more videos like this I am taking pet insurance off my list this week pretty happy about that
I'll see you next time for another big thing until then take care
