🎯 Support Into the Impossible on Patreon — get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
God forbid, if these AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, we have our non-carbon-based
humans. We're going to have to think about their rights.
She is a philosopher who trained in physics and she just told me that AI might deserve
human rights. Here is her argument.
The other obsession with this verb, matter, is that we are creatures of matter who long to
matter. You can only say that in English, but I'm so glad you could say that in English because it's
incredibly poignant. We're creatures of matter who are subject to the laws of physics,
the second law of thermodynamic, but we long to matter. So much of the book is trying to
explain that, how that transformation from within, within us, within our species,
happens. That's a normative transformation, an ethical transformation, and it's really what
distinguishes us. That we, in some sense, want to justify the fact that we matter so much to
ourselves, that we pay so much attention to ourselves, and that we actually can pinpoint
the place in human history where this emerged during the period when all the religions emerged
that are still extant, which is so interesting, and also Western philosophy emerged during the
period of history that's called the Axial Age. I do think things have changed for the better,
you know, as... Me too, yeah.
Parental, you know, paternity leave, I've taken advantage of that, but...
Yeah. I guess, you know,
the ultimate expression, and I don't think there's anything wrong with it, I mean, I think that
women sacrifice a lot more. I think that also we have a crisis with men and boys and so forth,
and now you have grandsons and you can appreciate it, and you probably appreciate it.
Absolutely. I mean...
I always appreciated this before I had daughters, but the book is full of these things, ranging
from, as you said, from Aristotle to the Chinese one-child policy that you talk about at the end
of the book. It's hard, Rebecca, but I guess, you know, as we come, you know, kind of landing the
hovercraft, the, you know, kind of fear that a lot of people have nowadays is about artificial
intelligence, kind of replacing, you know, what we do that we have a sense of mattering from,
what we derive our matter, you know, and you quote Freud in the book. Freud said, you know,
all of life is work and love, and if AI can replace the work of knowledge workers, like you
and me, and it can replace the love because of things like character AI and all these artificial
relationships that, you know, don't require me to go out and ask a woman on a date or, you know,
nowadays for men. So, I want to ask you the question, can AI have a mattering instinct? Or
is it encoded in this wet supercomputer that we carry on our shoulders? Is it possible, you're
right, that AI is making everyone feel that redundancy is threatening to us, but will the AI
rob ourselves of our matter? Yeah, so there are two different questions there. One, which is really,
I think, you know, going to be upon us, maybe already is, you know, that some of the most
creative ways of appeasing our mattering instinct will be superseded by what AI can do, you know,
that prove math theorems faster, make discoveries in science, write novels, write music, paint
pictures, some of the most creative things and that have led to flourishing and led to great
achievements that we can all take pride in. I take great pride in our species producing
Bach and Shakespeare and Michael Jordan. I'm a big basketball fan. I mean,
we mere mortals and look what we can do, but they'll be able to do it better. I think this
is going to be a real problem. Here's one thing I would say, you know, heroic strivers, what I
call heroic strivers, it's really going to threaten them, you know. I think the socializers are going
to look to, I mean, to some extent maybe for romantic partners, but mothers are not going
to have little babies, AI agents that are acting like they're babies. I don't think this is going
to happen, but I think heroic strivers, what I call heroic strivers, are going to be severely
threatened. Well, one thing I can say is that one of the ways to be a heroic striver is ethically,
and that will still remain to us, you know, to do these ethical projects of trying to minister
to others, to other creatures, to the planet itself, all of these. AI will not be able to
do that. They could write our novels or our poetry or our music or improve our math theorems,
but they're not going to be able to do that for us. And so wouldn't that be a wonderful, you know,
a wonderful turn of events if somehow there was a change, an incredible ethical change, and that's
how we got our status, you know, from how much good we're actually doing in the world, how much
counter-entropic good we're doing in the world. You know, this is a big thing that's upon us,
is all I can say. I can't think of anything else, not the Industrial Revolution, not the
Enlightenment, nothing that has the possibility of so changing what we are and, you know, and what
we see our lives as being about as AI. Even the very name of our species, you know, homo habilis
meant, you know, toolmaker or handyman. Yeah. And homo sapien means man who knows, right? Exactly,
exactly. We're not the only things that know. And your other question, God forbid, if these
AI agents begin to have a longing to matter, want to justify their own, you know, it would take
self-reflection, you know, of the sort that we have to be able to step outside themselves and
say, oh my God, I pay so much attention to myself. Am I worth it? Do I deserve this? If they do this,
then what we have are non-carbon based humans. These will be humans. And that means we're going
to have to think about their rights and we're going to have a whole new, yeah, we're going to
have a whole different way of having to think about effects because we will have created,
and we've always been creating humans, but we will have created humans in a new way.
And so this is, this is big. This is so big. I think I'll tell you something. I think
this is, you know, philosophers have been at it for over 2000 years since the ancient Greeks.
This is the moment for philosophers because these are philosophical problems. So show us what you've
got philosophers. Yes. You've been thinking about this for 2000 years. Show us what you've got.
It's amazing. You take some matter and you elect, you shoot some electrons through it and it starts
you know, is it okay to turn it off? You know, can I turn off my, you know, my chat companion?
Can I, is it okay to have it, you know, answer questions on ethics for my children,
all these things. But Rebecca, this has been such a wonderful conversation. This book is
incredible. It reminds me, you know, of a famous quote by John Archibald Wheeler. Wheeler said,
maybe you heard him say it. Maybe not. He said, matter tells space-time how to curve and space-time
tells matter how to move. And this book, The Mattering Instinct,
was one of the most moving books to me.