LIVE: IMF Hosts Discussion on 'Integrated Markets in a Fragmenting World'

Live News Network
1.4K followers
26 Video Views·Apr 17, 2026
The International Monetary Fund hosts a discussion titled “The Power of Integrated Markets in a Fragmenting World” at 2 p.m. ET on April 17.
I would like to welcome everyone here today as we talk about an issue that has come up
repeatedly throughout the week, and it's the increasingly fragmented world, how it comes
together at a time of supply chain resilience being put first and foremost on so many different
nations' agendas.
We have an incredible panel for us, so I just want to start it off.
We have, sitting to my left, His Excellency Mehmet Simsek of Turkey.
He is the Minister of Treasury and Finance for Turkey.
Next up, First Deputy Managing Director at the IMF, Dan Katz.
And then His Excellency Amir Hamza Azizan, the Minister of Finance of Malaysia.
Dan, I want to start with you.
The world has changed in the past six years pretty dramatically when it comes to supply
chain resilience.
Can you give a sense from your vantage point of just how significant the transformation
really has been?
Sure.
So, thank you, Lisa.
So, really, it has been an incredibly rapid evolution in the nature of international economic
integration over not just the last six years, but I would say the last decade generally.
And the primary way I think this evolution has expressed itself is not necessarily in
the degree of international economic integration, but largely in terms of the patterns of international
economic integration.
In the context of some of the shocks we've seen, for example, COVID, where the brittleness
of many supply chains was exposed.
In the context of natural disasters, like, for example, the 2011 earthquake and tsunami
in Japan, which is probably actually really the first time when I became aware of the
macro-criticality of supply chain impacts.
And also in the context of geopolitical fragmentation, increasing trade tensions, and also just general
geopolitical tensions that have caused countries to resort to economic choke points, for example,
to achieve non-economic objectives.
The sum of all of this has actually been a pretty significant change in the bilateral
patterns of trade that countries have engaged in.
For example, in the United States, trade with China has come down 30% over the last year.
But if we look across the entire system, while the patterns are changing on a bilateral basis,
the degree of interdependency in the international system is still fairly high and remains steady.
And so I think really the next step that we're likely to see is the system has been adapting
to these shocks, building more resilience into the system, but we see now over the last
six weeks or so that the international system is still very, very subject to disruption
from, for example, the current war in the Middle East.
And so I think the next phase of international economic integration is really going to be
continuing to examine the degree of resilience in the system.
That may include further changes in the patterns of bilateral trade, or it could just include
building additional redundancy into the system, which might actually lessen the overall degree
of economic integration, but I would say probably less so from a reduction in existing relationships
and more a redoubled focus on investment and resiliency in domestic production.
Minister Aziz, from your perspective, given that you're in an open economy, very reliant on all
of the supply chain dependency on the global supply chain, how much has changed from Malaysia?
I mean, has it been a really transformative period, frankly, since before the pandemic,
but the pandemic really kind of keying off?
I think, well, from a Malaysian perspective, we have an aspiration that we want to evolve
the economy to become a high-income nation, yeah?
So clarity in terms of what we are needing to actually do that means that we have to attract
higher complexity industries into Malaysia, but in order to make sure that this is resilient enough,
then you've got to look at the whole ecosystem as a chain that has done that.
So as part of Malaysia's journey of doing that, I think we anchor based on what we're good at.
So we've always been a material player in E&E, semiconductors, so that space we want,
so we're attracting more and more in, but we want to make sure that
local supply chains actually are much more resilient.
So creating local suppliers, attracting foreign suppliers that actually fit into that chain
makes it easier to ensure if there are disruptions, the core supply chain is less disrupted.
The second thing that, from a strategic point of view,
while we do that in a lot of other segments of industry,
is also making sure that your economy is resilient.
So in economy resilience, we look at diversification of industry,
we look at diversification of markets, so if anything were to shift,
then that resilience comes in because we are able to shift along the way.
I think nothing plays it out more than what's happened over the last year,
and it's actually what's happening this year.
Last year, with the trade disruptions and so on, Malaysia bucked the trend.
We were pushing out to get GDP growth between 4.5% to 5%.
We closed the year at 5.2%, despite the challenges,
and we had a fourth quarter at 6.3% GDP growth.
We've contained inflationary elements, we're operating at about 1.4% at this point of time,
unemployment is at 2.9%.
So when all the engines are working well, when there's clarity of public policy,
when there's good execution along the way,
it's easier for you to actually anchor investors to come in,
and it builds your resilience of what you need.
Minister Simsek, from Turkey's point of view, how have you seen the transformation,
given your location also with Europe and the Middle East,
and kind of as one of the key points for a lot of infrastructure,
as well as energy transport?
Well, as I think Dan framed it pretty well,
look, the old model relied on stable geopolitics.
That's no longer the case.
So I think there are significant risks,
and the way we need to address them,
before actually it turns into a crisis,
which is the one we are experiencing right now,
I think we should design it.
The first thing that comes to my mind within this context is energy dependency.
I think by design today,
we have very little exposure to Strait of Hormuz.
There is quite a bit of diversification in terms of energy supply security.
So this is key.
We've invested in LNG capacity.
We have plenty of pipelines going through Anatolia.
There's a fair bit of pipeline corridors.
The way we see it going forward is that I think
the need for additional trade corridors is quite clear.
We think that the middle corridor is going to be one of the most efficient ones,
and I can tell you this week at the World Bank,
we signed a major loan, $8.1 billion in total,
but 83% of which from IFIs we're going to build.
We're going to connect Anatolia, I mean Asia,
to Europe via railway over Bosphorus.
But it's not just that.
We've been in talks with Iraq to connect Basra,
you know, the Persian essentially Gulf, the GCC countries,
again to the Turkish infrastructure.
So the only way to deal with it by design,
rather than wait for something to hit you,
I think is to invest in new corridors,
to invest in additional supply chains.
Now, Turkey has a major, you know,
we've invested very heavily in infrastructure.
Over the past 20, 25 years,
we've invested about $400 billion in physical infrastructure.
And we are anchored to Europe, to the West in general,
but we continue to engage with the rest of the world.
So that provides actually Turkey as a platform to reduce the risk,
to de-risk and for diversification for our part of the world.
So we think there are opportunities for us.
Yes, right now there's a major issue,
but we look beyond short term
and we believe that there will be a lot of opportunities.
I want to ask the first Deputy Managing Director,
why do you think there have been so many supply shocks?
I mean, what has been the driver of it?
Is it, you know, they're all different, right?
They've got COVID, which is a natural health disaster.
Then you have a question around trade relationships
and the United States
with some of what has transpired with tariffs, et cetera.
Now you have the crisis in the Gulf.
Why are these happening so much more frequently?
Sure, so I think you have to look at it from both directions,
both in terms of the frequency
with which the things that cause the disruption are happening
and then also the ability of the system to absorb those shocks
and translate them into economic disruption.
On the former, you know,
I think the key driver that we clearly can identify
is in fact the geopolitical tensions
and the shifting nature of international relations.
Those actually do interplay a fair amount though
with some of the more exogenous type of shocks,
like for example, COVID,
which of course was a health disaster.
But many of the geoeconomic fragmentations
that were revealed in the context of COVID,
like for example,
interdependence between different economies,
I would say that actually international relations
probably interacted with that disruption
in the form of, you know,
certain countries wanting to take measures
to hoard certain products.
And by the way,
once countries began to develop these tools
around controlling the export or import of products
in their economy,
I think they've also figured out
that those tools can be adapted to other uses,
like for example,
use to achieve non-economic goals.
So I think there is a general trend
of the shocks coming more frequently
and I think we probably are headed
for a continuation of that trend, if anything.
But the other side,
I think is the other critical transmission mechanism
we have to look at,
which is the fragility of the system.
And I think, you know,
COVID was a big wake-up call for many
who didn't understand just the complexity
and the very, very narrow margin for error
in many of these supply chains,
which create, you know,
highly, highly convex risks, right?
Because the difference between, you know,
factory running at normal production levels
and a factory shutting down
for weeks or months at an end
can be an incredibly, incredibly small component
that you have an incredibly,
incredibly small inventory of.
And I think during COVID,
we began to realize just how vulnerable the system was.
But the truth is, you know,
the economy is so complex
and has been so heavily engineered
over many, many, many decades
that it is just going to take an enormous amount of time
to rebuild a greater degree of resilience in the system.
And I think that,
I think many countries realize the importance of that work
and are working actively to achieve that.
But given the scale of the challenge,
I think it's going to be some time
before we can all say that we feel reassured
about the system's ability to absorb these shocks.
So it's imperative that we work at it.
But I think in, you know,
in the intervening period,
we could find ourselves subject
to yet more and more disruptions.
Minister Aziz, and you're nodding along.
Is this something that you see from your vantage point,
this sort of question around
particularly geopolitical tensions?
How do you deal with that,
given the fact that you rely
on international relationships for your economy?
I think just taking on from what Dan's point was, right?
And if you look at how the world has progressed
over decades and decades,
it relied on stability or geopolitics, yeah?
When the stability of geopolitics
and everything is quite predictable of what you do,
then businesses started to look at
how do I increase efficiency
in order to increase profitability along the line?
But once the game starts to maneuver a little bit more,
people are competing with the nations
to position themselves in different form,
then that efficiency to the nth degree
is no longer on the table.
So I think we've moved from an era of just-in-time
to a just-in-case sort of mechanism.
So the roles of countries are actually
making sure that you map within your own area.
So what's your core strength?
What's the capacity that you have?
And how do you anchor your core capacity
so that you are building in resilience?
And I think COVID taught us
quite a bit of lessons along that way, right?
Everybody got shocked during COVID.
You couldn't get vaccines.
You couldn't get basic breathing equipment.
You couldn't get medical support along the way.
So instinctively,
I think most governments have now taken a stance
where you are building buffers, yeah?
The second thing that you're trying to do
is also build new relationships that you have
so that you don't put everything in one basket, yeah?
And in that, opening up better trade lanes,
better partnerships, and so on,
gives you comfort that when things hit,
you can shift, and so on.
But underpinning of what made the world successful
in the past was clarity, stability,
rules of engagement still need to anchor
even if you move towards a much more bilateral life.
It's more painful to do more bilaterals,
but you need the undercurrents.
And I think countries who can adopt to that,
can build relationships, build on trust,
build some frameworks that can work,
will probably end up much more resilient.
Minister Simsek, I'm curious, from your perspective,
how you prioritize certain relationships
and which countries you decide to get closer to,
how that calculus works?
Well, fragmentation doesn't mean...
Well, the response to fragmentation
shouldn't be isolation.
I think global fragmentation is there.
It's a reality.
So the antidote to that is probably regional integration.
At least one way of addressing it
would be enhancing regional integration.
I think these investments in new corridors
is a soft, is part of soft strategic power.
So where do you engage?
Ideally, we would like to continue
to enhance Turkey's, to increase Turkey's
full economic integration into EU.
Domestic politics in Europe, unfortunately,
so far got in the way.
We have a full customs union.
We've been member of Council of Europe
from the very beginning.
We are one of the founding members.
We've been member of Western, again,
security system, NATO, since 1952.
An association agreement with European Union since 1963.
So for us, European Union is natural habitat.
50%, 49% to be exact, goes to Europe.
Our exports goes to Europe.
Our trade volume with Europe is $230 billion.
So naturally, we hope that one day
we can overcome domestic political considerations
in European circles
and upgrade Turkey's customs union with EU
to include services, agriculture, public procurement,
which could easily double the current trade volume
within a decade or two.
Now, having seen limited progress there,
we are now focused on also our immediate neighborhood.
Even though it is not as promising markets
as European Union, meaning in terms of maturity,
still they are emerging and growing markets.
So Central Asia, Middle East, North Africa.
This is, again, our natural habitat,
meaning it's immediate neighborhood.
There's a lot of scope for French shoring.
And near shoring.
So I guess, how do we prioritize this?
I mean, Africa for us, again, is one place
where we see demographics supporting huge investments
in infrastructure, broadly speaking,
and other provisions of services and goods.
So we think we have plenty of choice here.
But as I said, in the short run,
I think our immediate focus will be
to see if we could persuade Turkmenistan
to connect to our natural gas corridor,
to persuade our southern neighbors,
who are currently suffering from the closure of Hermuz,
to think about northward corridors.
And that would be enablers.
Again, we have 54 free trade agreements,
including, of course, 27 EU member states.
And that's huge.
So I think we don't have to choose.
We would like to stay anchored to EU
and the West in general,
while continue to enhance our engagement
with the East and Africa.
You said something that I would love to pick up on.
And Dan, I'd love your thought on this.
This idea of regional integration.
And this moment that we're at kind of highlights it perfectly,
given the fact that the energy shock
is causing true shortages in Asia
and potentially even soon in Europe.
And in the US, equity markets just hit another all-time high,
and people are all very excited about tech stocks, right?
I mean, it seems like a complete divergence
in terms of sentiment.
Dan, from your perspective,
how much does the energy shock
expedite sort of the regional dependencies
and the interdependencies that are more local
in a new kind of way?
Well, more generally, I would observe that,
you know, regional integration is certainly a trend
that we have been observing in the context of recent years.
And, you know, this is generally, I would say, a welcome,
certainly a welcome development.
If there are opportunities to shrink supply chains
and, you know, French oars, as Mehmet said,
I think those should be considered absolutely a positive.
But at the same time, actually, as we see in the context
of the current war in the Middle East,
you know, the relationship between Iran
and some of its Gulf neighbors
is not exactly in a healthy place
from an economic perspective.
And so regional integration generally
is not necessarily a panacea.
Not all of your neighbors,
you're going to have the proper conditions in place
to have a healthy and well-integrated
economic relationship.
And so I think we really should be thinking about this
through the lens of regional integration,
but also diversification more generally.
You know, you can have very healthy trading relationships
with a country on the other side of the world,
given the relative lack of friction in seaborne trade,
subject to a few particular choke points, of course.
And so I think diversification really is the thing to focus on.
More generally, on this particular supply shock,
which is, you know, at its core,
obviously, an energy supply shock,
I think it just reinforces the need for energy security.
And that has got to be at the absolute top
of many countries' agenda.
There will be regional solutions to that, certainly.
You might think about regional pooling of investment
and new, you know, extractive technologies
or new refining capacities.
But it also, I think, has a diversification element.
And, you know, other suppliers, for example,
in the Western Hemisphere,
who may not be subject to the same choke points
like the Strait of Hormuz,
whether they're in South America,
big South American producers like Brazil, Argentina,
or producers in North America
like the United States and Canada,
I think many consumers of energy products
will be looking towards the Western Hemisphere
to diversify their energy security
and insulate themselves from another shock
like this in the future.
Minister Azizan, how do you handle it,
given the fact that you are really reliant
on imports of energy?
How do you plan to diversify?
Solar panels?
I think Malaysia has been somewhat lucky in these things.
And God was kind to us
when they endowed us with energy resources in the country.
So from a gas point of view, we're self-reliant, yeah?
So from an electricity point of view in the country,
generation and what we can do,
we can assure stability of supply inside it.
But from a liquid point of view,
we do depend on importation, how we manage through.
So one of the key lessons that we've learned
as a developing economy and so on
is to make sure that you have the right signalings
that are actually going into the market, right?
So historically, we've always been
very heavily utilising subsidisation
in order to keep the population at the low-cost structures.
But it was very expensive.
It caused my fiscal deficits to balloon up.
And when markets like this happen,
then the strain for the government was very, very big.
So what we needed to do was to reform.
We had to reform the structure
so that the balance was fairer.
So key groups that needed to be supported, we support
in terms of assistance to the lower-income people,
key inflation-leading things,
we can provide some assistance
for everybody else's base market, yeah?
And when we got that discipline,
the market will also sort out
in terms of supply and demand.
And efficiency measures become much better to be done.
And I think you must keep an eye on the long term
because the long term reminds us
that if you're not efficient in that process,
you will damage your long-term competitiveness in the country.
So from a Malaysian perspective, we've done that.
But going forward, we do have to address
what's the longer-term balance that we need.
So Malaysia commits to net zero by 2050.
We are clear that we have to transition
even the grid into injecting more renewables inside it.
But the answer doesn't necessarily only belong
from a Malaysian perspective.
And again, I think the theme of regional integration
has part of the answer.
So one of the key projects that we're pushing along the way
is the Asian power grid.
So if we can have that redistribution in a better form,
everybody is induced to make sure the system is stable.
You get the regional integrated power grids well,
everybody gains because you reduce redundancies in the system.
At the same time, you also bind the regions
to be more co-dependent on each other.
So in essence, it leads to more and more things
that will build better trust as you move forward.
And I think that's important.
So here, from a Malaysian perspective, we will shift.
We will get a lot more things in terms of renewables and so on.
But we want to make sure that is a sustained base
that will anchor stability for the country going forward.
You know, Minister Azizan raises a really interesting point.
And Minister Simsek, I'd love your thoughts on this.
The idea that when you have these shocks, they're expensive.
And you have to use money that otherwise would be spent
on longer term plans to meet the crisis.
So how do you plan for long term resiliency
if you're playing whack-a-mole with different crises
and trying to make sure that certain populations
aren't disproportionately hit?
I think the best way is not to waste a crisis.
Milton Friedman, I think, once said,
you know, only a crisis, whether it is real or perceived,
leads to real change.
So I think we have to really not waste the current shock.
And how do we handle that?
I mean, speaking of energy, for example,
surely we should speed up green transition.
You know, to the extent that is possible long term,
clearly we could invest in nuclear.
That's what happened post-1970s.
You know, there was a boom in investment in nuclear power.
So that would be an option, but that's a long shot.
But in terms of solar, wind, geothermal,
and other forms of renewable energy,
clearly should be deployed, should be accelerated.
That's one way.
Secondly, yesterday we had great presentations about the AI.
I can tell you, again, we cannot miss this opportunity
and not to invest in digital transformation.
And that's why, for example,
we are really investing very heavily in fiber, in 5G+.
You know, again, we need power to support it,
in human capital aspect of it.
So I think reforms, but to build buffers,
in normal times, you have to really have fiscal discipline.
For example, you know, at the beginning of the crisis,
I think conditions matter.
Today, if we are able to reduce the shock from crude to inflation,
through sliding scale, you know, pricing system for diesel, gasoline,
it's because last year we had our fiscal deficit to GDP at less than 3%,
and that to GDP ratio at less than 24%.
Meaning we have the luxury to defy IMF,
I'm just joking, to deploy the fiscal space.
But then again, we've rebuilt foreign exchange reserves.
You know, unfortunately, when there's a big shock,
risk appetite disappears.
So what I'm trying to say,
there is no substitute to good policies,
hopefully good politics, and structural reforms.
Reforms are difficult to deliver, but I think they're doable.
And even if it is in piecemeal fashion,
I think we should continue to focus and insist on doing regardless of the pace of it.
Well, then I guess this really brings up a question for you, Dan.
I feel like I should call you the first Deputy Managing Director.
I think I'm going to do that.
I much prefer Dan.
Okay, all right, Dan.
I feel like there's a real question right now.
Does the consecutive shocks make the world more fragile
and create a friction and inefficiency in the global economy
that creates more times of need?
Or does it make greater resiliency?
Because there have been so many tests
that a lot of countries have already built in systems
that they can rely on and playbooks that are more familiar.
Well, look, I think the truth is we don't know yet.
But generally, you know, I don't think it's worth spending a whole lot of time
worrying about whether the consecutive shocks or the more frequent shocks
are making the system more fragile.
Because the truth is, I think those consecutive shocks
or those more frequent shocks are coming no matter what.
So it's absolutely imperative to work on trying to build additional resilience into the system.
But I will say I am generally inclined to take the view that
you come out of challenges stronger.
And I completely agree with Mehmet's point that we should use these opportunities
to double down on many of the same institutional reforms
that have made the system so resilient.
I mean, let's just keep in mind over the last year,
you know, we've seen a number of successive shocks
that many people thought were going to very severely hamper global growth.
Until this most recent shock, actually,
the fund had upgraded its global growth projections
in most of the recent forecasting cycles.
And just six weeks ago, we were also poised to upgrade global growth again
until, of course, we were hit by this shock.
And I think a big reason for that level of resilience that we've seen in the system
has been all of the institutional reforms that countries have put in place in recent decades.
And in particular, I would highlight the emerging markets
as the group of countries that had probably the greatest outperformance over the last year.
And I think that's largely a function of the hard work that policymakers have done,
including during quiet times,
to double down on reforms and make themselves more resilient.
The fund, of course, has been a part of that as well.
But really, it's been countries demonstrating the political will
and very, very wise and long-term planning
to undertake what are sometimes difficult reforms.
And so I think it would be a shame if we didn't continue that reform momentum,
especially given that we're confronted with very, very real consequences
of not having a sufficiently resilient system in place as a result of this shock.
Minister Azizan, you were talking about how you had built up that buffer
and that you were trying to reduce the deficit.
That's been something that you've been really working on.
So going forward, what are those priorities right now
that you think would lead to continued resilience in Malaysia?
I think from a Malaysian perspective, right,
fundamentally, we have to restructure the economy.
The economy must be a lot more nimble to be able to address changes that's happening.
The economy must be much more hooked on to the developments in the world
so that we keep pace with what's happening
and maybe even take leaps of change along the way.
And more importantly, in going forward,
we must understand that you have to maintain balance.
You can drive the economy forward.
You can make everything happen.
But if you do not address the societal impact of what changes are you going to do,
you're not going to have an internally stable system.
So as part and parcel of the Malaysian journey, we are trying to do both.
Attract, bring in the high complex industries inside it,
build better jobs and so on,
but make sure we also do the reforms that protect pits of society
that may be a bit more disadvantaged.
Improve social protection in the country.
Improve wage levels in the country.
Allow better policies to be built so that we focus about predicting
what's happening in the future and skill up the economy
so it becomes much more robust.
So if you can balance the two things,
then you can chart a path better along the way.
So when shocks hit the system,
the ability of the government to cushion blows is important.
And they may have countries that will slip a little bit,
but you cannot at that time decide to change directionality
because your directionality has already been wired
into what you're trying to do along the way.
So if you have to go through a reform stage,
double down and continue that path
because it's shown you that when you've done it,
you have the buffers and the buffers continue to help.
So don't give it up when it's happening.
So for example today,
we're telling what's happening in the economy at this point in time,
this is a supply crunch.
In the supply crunch, we don't stimulate.
Stimulating the economy in the supply crunch is a wrong tool
at this junction because it leads to inflationary elements along the way.
However, providing lifelines and providing assistance
to allow people to ride it out
is probably the best intervention at this point in time.
So part of it is making sure society understands that.
Society appreciates that reaction is a form,
so you've got them behind the approach that you're trying to do.
And I think in the reforms that we've done,
even difficult reforms when we did reforms on energy and so on,
which had tremendous effect to society overall,
if you plan it well, you condition it well,
and you do great change management, acceptance can happen.
Most human beings are quite practical.
They understand.
They may not like it, but they understand it.
And it's allowing them to get to that level
and managing the phasing that eases out change.
Minister Simsek, from your standpoint, a similar kind of approach?
Yes, I think a targeted policy is key.
I mean, I'm also not a big fan of generalized subsidies,
and that's wrong usually.
It does happen, so I'm not saying it doesn't,
but I think clearly we have to address dislocations.
If we had managed this before,
maybe we could have saved globalization,
because globalization did lead to dislocations in certain pockets.
And sadly, that wasn't the case, and now here we are.
We're living in a relatively more protectionist world,
so trade, which used to be the engine of growth, is sputtering.
So I think that applies to how we think about fiscal,
vis-a-vis parts of society that are clearly negatively affected.
So we cannot be, in that sense, purely textbook.
I think we should look at parts, segments of society
that are negatively affected and support them.
And that is the case when it is structural, like AI.
Countries may have to come up with some form of
universal basic income schemes for families
if AI is going to destroy, as predicted by the IMF,
40% of the current workforce.
Hold on one second.
Are you saying that in Turkey,
you're actually considering universal basic income?
I didn't say that.
Just making sure.
I just want to clarify.
I think, look, I think we should definitely support the bottom 10-20%,
and we should do it, because that's fair,
and that's key to social cohesion,
and that's also essential for ownership of any reform program
or stabilization programs.
So the answer is yes.
We need to consider this,
but you have to obviously, again,
have the buffers and the fiscal discipline to deploy those resources.
Dan?
Well, let me just first express my appreciation for you
citing the work of the Fund.
But I do just want to correct the record.
We haven't said that 40% of the jobs are going to disappear due to AI.
What we have said is that up to 40% of the global workforce
could be exposed to AI.
And in responding to any kind of shock,
I think it's very important to think about incentives.
The reason why the global supply chain became so highly tuned,
so efficient,
and therefore also so subject to shocks,
was the various incentives that were in place,
including, for example,
because we were in a period of geopolitical stability,
and so it was unimaginable
that some of the shocks that we've seen in recent decades
were going to come to fruition.
So it was rational for companies to engage in the behavior they did
that led to a system that was in a very, very fragile equilibrium,
it turned out.
And I think we need to also think about the incentives.
So it is incentives that shape behavior.
We need to think about the incentives change now, by the way.
And I think the market and the economic system
will generally change in response to that
in terms of the degree of integration.
In response to the AI shock, since it just came up,
I also think we need to be very, very careful
about thinking about the incentives that we put into place.
Protecting vulnerable populations
can certainly be important for social cohesion,
but I think in designing the form of protection,
it's very critical to keep in mind the incentives
that whatever policy response creates for the population generally
and for the workforce across all of society.
And the key, I think, is going to be setting up the right incentives
for, for example, in the context of AI,
workers to actually go out and try to innovate in their job,
to go get a new job, for companies to innovate,
to create new products and services
in order to fulfill the increased demand
that should come from rising real incomes
as a result of the productivity enhancements associated with AI.
And sometimes when we overdo it in terms of provision of support,
it can often interfere with the incentives
that the market would otherwise have.
And when I speak to our membership
about how to think about responding to the shocks
from the war in the Middle East
and successive supply chain shocks,
or a potential shock to the labor market from AI,
it's really the structural incentives
that permeate through the economy
and how those incentives affect behavior
that I think we all need to focus on the most.
Minister Azizan,
do you think that there is a place for universal basic income?
I think the challenge,
it depends on the development level of a country.
When you have the physical space,
you have these sort of areas,
I think it's a lot easier to be doing it.
In the practical consideration,
when countries are constrained,
the bare minimum is actually to protect
the most exposed part of society.
So in this instance,
I agree with Mehmet,
that you really have to look at
fiscal capacity of the country.
We really have to look for making sure
that we carry society along with the changes
and challenges that's happening on
so that we maintain social cohesion.
If nothing else,
when you look at the periods
of where the world has done well,
it's done well when there are stability,
there are predictability,
there are frameworks,
everything can run.
So in the changing world today,
you can still have that,
but you make the bubble become smaller
and more stable.
So you have to anchor good governance.
You have to have clarity
in terms of where you're going inside it
so people can partner
when they know what you're doing.
You must be able to trust
that you're doing it
and you must be able to ensure
that the stability is anchored
throughout society.
So when you've got those principles right,
then I think countries are very resilient,
countries can move ahead and manage through.
I want to finish up,
and Dan, I love your thoughts on this.
There's a real question of how to balance
the idea of independence and interdependence.
And I don't have real clarity right now,
maybe you can answer this
about what it's going to look like,
say in five years, 10 years time,
in terms of regional dynamics
or whether it's some sort of fragile dance
to try to have bilateral relations.
What's your sense of how to have interdependence
while also having independence?
I'm sorry for me.
So look, I don't have a crystal ball
in terms of where we're headed.
Pretend.
You know, five or 10 years from now.
But I would just generally observe,
I think that a more diversified
set of relationships
with relatively larger buffers built in
to deal with some of these shocks
is likely to be where we are headed.
And I think 10 years from now,
if we look back
and we find ourselves still buffeted by these shocks
and we haven't gotten better at adjusting them,
I think we will all have missed a real opportunity
and we may be shaking heads at ourselves 10 years on.
So I think it's critical
to try to seize this moment right now
and put in place the right set of incentives
that can help guide the system
to a more stable equilibrium.
Minister Simsek, what's your sense
of what it's going to be in five years?
You've got a crystal ball.
I think still,
I think more than two thirds of global trade,
maybe three quarters of global trade
is still rule-based
despite all this talk of,
obviously, fragmentation, protectionism.
So I guess interdependency will continue.
We cannot be completely,
we cannot live in isolation.
We cannot be completely independent
of our neighborhood or global supply chains.
But I think Dan was spot on in the sense
that we have to de-risk,
we have to invest in diversification.
We have no choice because we are in real world,
we are faced with shocks
and we have to learn from these shocks.
And Dan, thank you for correcting me
about the exposure versus job loss.
Thank you.
Minister Aziz, final word.
What's your sense?
I think the world gyrates with models.
Sometimes you're in this model
because the conditions
encourage you to go this way.
So now we're into a world
that's a lot more fragmented,
but the world still looks at ways
that it wants to find a stable ground.
So if bilateralism creates a stable ground,
if regionalization creates a stable ground,
that's what the world will do
as partial mitigant to be able to do that.
I'm hopeful that like-minded people alone
will actually find that way
so that we can isolate the impacts
that are going through.
But then again, it doesn't change the core.
The core still remains that
in order to progress,
the world needs clarity.
In order to progress, it needs predictability.
In order to progress,
it needs to build systems
that people can trust on the way.
So while the bubbles may change in size,
but when you anchor it with these sort of things,
you sustain it better.
And I think every time we go through a crisis,
we will learn new things.
So this time, we've reinforced the learning
that we got from COVID,
which is buffers are important.
At this time, we've learned the lesson
that diversification is important.
At this time, we've learned the lessons
that ability for us to be nimble,
the ability for us to deploy as necessary
is fundamental.
So move on, build that,
but still continue to promote a better future.
I love that phrasing.
We're just learning a lot.
That's how we could describe this period of time.
I just want to thank our incredible panelists
for a wonderful conversation.
Really appreciate the time.
