Many parents see the Montessori method as the gold standard of early education.But after researching the method and learning more about the life and ideas of Maria Montessori, I realized something surprising. In this video, I explain why I personally would never send my child to a Montessori school or kindergarten. This is not a hate video. Montessori education has many strengths — and I’ll talk about those too. But there are also important downsides that parents rarely hear about. In this episode we discuss: • what the Montessori method actually is• the main advantages of Montessori education• the real story behind Maria Montessori’s life and ideas• three important limitations of the method parents should consider Kids by Science — where proven wellness for kids meets real life.
Montessori is everywhere, but almost nobody talks about the controversial parts of this matter.
Montessori schools, Montessori kindergartens, Montessori toys.
Even I, with the attrition, fell in it when I became a mom.
At one point I even seriously considered sending my son to a Montessori kindergarten.
It looked very appealing. Lots of developmental toys,
thoughtfully designed environments, teachers trained in psychology.
So I shared the idea with my family, and my mother-in-law, who is a practicing
child psychologist with many years of experience, asked me three simple questions.
Have you ever read Maria Montessori's biography?
Have you looked at the strengths and weaknesses of the matter itself?
Or have you only heard about the toys?
Those questions stopped me, because I suddenly remembered something very important.
I'm not only a mom, I'm also a scientist.
So I started digging into the research, and what I found surprised me.
Some parts honestly shocked me.
After looking deeper into the history of the matter,
the evidence behind it, and some of the Montessori's own ideas,
I realized something very clearly.
I would never send my child to a Montessori school of kindergarten.
Now, don't rush to disagree with me or close this video.
This is not a hate video.
Today, I simply want to share what I discovered while researching this topic,
and my personal perspective on it.
You may agree, you may disagree, but I think we can at least talk about it.
Support the channel, like, subscribe, turn on the bell, and let's go.
I know many of you have heard about the Montessori matter.
But most parents, just like I was before,
actually have a very surface-level understanding of what it really is.
So before we go any further,
let's quickly break down the core idea behind the method created by Maria Montessori.
The Montessori method is an educational approach focused on independence and
natural child development within a carefully prepared environment.
It's built around a simple idea.
Help me do it myself.
In this system, the adult is not a traditional teacher
who constantly instructs and directs the child.
Instead, the adult acts more like a guide and an observer,
stepping in only when necessary.
The entire system rests on several key principles
that make Montessori very different from traditional education.
Let's look at five main pillars of this method.
Prepared environment
The classroom or playroom of the whole house is carefully designed
so children can reach and use everything independently.
Materials are placed on lower open shelves, organized in a logical order.
The idea is simple.
The environment itself should invite the child to explore and learn.
Freedom of choice
Children choose what they want to work on.
Reading, math, writing, or even practical activities like washing clothes.
They decide what to do, how long to do it,
and whether to work alone or with others.
Self-correcting learning materials
Many Montessori materials are designed so
that the child can notice mistakes independently
without the teacher pointing them out.
For example, a piece simply won't fit into the wrong opening.
This encourages children to experiment,
adjust, and find solutions on their own.
Next-age classrooms
Children of different ages learn together,
usually in three-year groups.
For example, 0-3, 3-6, or 6-9.
This creates a natural social environment
where younger children learn from older ones
and older children develop leadership and responsibility.
The teacher is an observer
In Montessori classrooms,
teachers don't usually stand at the front giving lectures.
Instead, they observe quietly and step in only when needed.
For example, to demonstrate how to use a new material.
Or when a child's behavior begins to affect others.
At first glance, the method looks very appealing.
And to be fair, the method does have the real strength.
And that's exactly why it has become so popular
with parents around the world.
So, before we talk about the consorts I discovered later,
let's first look at the main advantages
that attract so many parents to Montessori education.
Independence
Children choose their own activities,
manage their time,
and learn everyday self-care skills.
Putting toys back on the shelf,
setting the table,
cleaning up after themselves.
These small routines help children feel capable and responsible.
Although, to be honest,
I don't personally know many adults
who never learned basic self-care
in a traditional system education either.
But still, Montessori materials
that encourage children to figure things out on their own
are actually some of my favorite early learning tools.
Many of these toys work almost like puzzles.
The child tries,
makes mistakes,
adjusts,
and eventually finds the solution independently.
And that kind of learning can be incredibly powerful.
Individual pace
Montessori classrooms usually don't follow
rigid lesson plans or traditional grading systems.
Children can move through activities at their own pace.
Faster in areas they enjoy,
slower in areas that take more time.
Some children may spend 20 minutes working with numbers,
and that flexibility can reduce stress and pressure.
After all, children really are different,
and giving them space to develop at their own rhythm
can be a wonderful thing.
Focus on self-discipline
Montessori activities are designed to encourage deep concentration.
You might see a child carefully pouring water
from one small pitcher to another,
or patiently sorting wooden shapes,
or repeating the same activity over and over again
until it feels perfect.
Instead of constantly switching tasks,
children are encouraged to stay with one activity for a long time.
Over time, this can help develop focus,
persistence,
and self-discipline.
Weak stage classrooms
This creates a natural social environment.
Practical life skills
Another distinctive part of Montessori education
is the focus on everyday practical activities.
Children practice things like
washing dishes,
folding clothes,
cleaning tables,
preparing simple food.
They learn many real-life skills very early.
And from a parent's perspective,
this can be pretty appealing.
Because yes,
your child may become much more independent and helpful at home.
Which, let's be honest,
most parents wouldn't mind.
So, at first glance,
the Montessori method seems almost ideal.
Children learn practical skills,
they develop independence,
they build concentration and confidence.
So, what could be possibly wrong with that?
Well, the moment that changed my perspective
came when I started looking at this method
through the lens of the life and ideas of its creator,
Maria Montessori.
And once I did that,
I began noticing about the method
that I had never questioned before.
Things that Montessori schools never talk about.
And after learning this,
my perception of the entire method changed.
Probably forever.
To understand the method better,
I think it's really important
to look at the person who created it.
Maria Montessori was born in Italy in 1870
into a well-educated upper-class family.
From a very young age,
she was extremely ambitious.
At just 13 years old,
she entered a technical secondary school,
something almost unheard of for girls at that time.
Later, she graduated from medical school,
which was even more unusual for a woman
in the late 19th century.
Pretty impressive, right?
But what I personally found even more striking
was not her career,
it was her personal life.
After university,
Maria Montessori fell in love with a colleague,
a doctor working in the same psychiatric clinic
where she worked.
Their relationship resulted in the birth of a son,
Mario.
Her partner reportedly proposed marriage,
but Maria refused.
She said she did not see herself as a married woman.
Now remember,
we are talking about the late 19th century.
For a woman who had just had a child,
refusing marriage at that time
was extremely unusual and socially risky.
But what makes the story even more unusual
is what happened next.
According to historical sources,
Montessori suggested continuing the relationship privately,
without marriage
and without publicly acknowledging it.
And what about the child?
Mario was sent to live with distant relatives
in the countryside
and was raised there during most of his childhood.
Montessori visited him from time to time,
but she did not raise him herself.
At the same time,
her career was rapidly developing.
And to be fair,
she was doing something genuinely groundbreaking.
She began developing special learning environments
for children between the age of 2 and 7.
Small chairs,
blowshelves,
materials designed specifically for children.
Many of these materials were created
to teach practical life skills.
And Montessori noticed something interesting.
When children were given freedom of movement,
a freedom to choose activities
within a structured environment,
they often developed spontaneous discipline.
Some children with developmental challenges
even showed better academic results
than typically developing children
in traditional schools.
This success attracted attention,
the system expanded,
and eventually it evolved into an institute
where teachers were trained
to work with children
with intellectual disabilities.
Six years later,
Montessori opened what became her most famous
children's house.
For the first time,
her system was applied
to typically developing children.
The environment looked very similar
to what we now recognize
as modern Montessori classrooms.
And Montessori herself mostly observed.
She watched the children
and continued refining her ideas and methods.
Her approach was built on several key concepts.
The child's natural curiosity,
the observant mind,
and the belief that children can develop
many skills independently
if given the right environment.
And yes, in many ways,
this was revolutionary for education.
But there is also another way
to interpret these ideas.
In Montessori classrooms,
children are encouraged
to become independent
as early as possible.
They learn to walk alone,
solve problems alone,
and manage many tasks
which can be wonderful.
But it also raises an interesting question.
How much independence is healthy
for a very young child?
And how much emotional connection with adults
do children actually need
in the early years?
In looking at Montessori's personal life,
I couldn't help noticing a certain pattern,
a strong emphasis on independence,
distance,
self-sufficiency,
and very little focus on emotional closeness.
Of course, this is my personal interpretation.
But when I look at both her life
and the educational environment she created,
I do see a certain emotional distance,
almost a philosophy
that children should become independent
from adults as early as possible.
Interestingly, Montessori later
reconnected with her son.
But this happened when he was already older,
when he no longer required constant care,
daily nurturing,
and the exhausting emotional work
of early childhood,
when he had already become
a more independent person.
So, once you look at the Montessori method
through the lens of Montessori's personal life,
some of the potential downsides of the method
became easier to notice.
That's highlighting three important ones.
Less emphasis on imaginative play and teamwork.
Montessori education focuses heavily
on individual work and real-world tasks.
But imaginative play,
like pretending, storytelling, or room playing,
is often limited or discouraged.
And yet, pretend play from around age 2
is one of the key ways
children develop emotional intelligence.
Think about it.
How does a child learn empathy?
By pretending to take care of a toy.
How does a child practice courage?
By refeeding imaginary monsters.
How does a child rehearse real-life relationships?
Through role-play.
Imagination is not just entertainment,
it's emotional training.
And this is exactly what I discussed
in one of my recent episodes.
It might be helpful to watch after this one.
Difficult transition to traditional schools
Freedom of choice is one of the most
attractive aspects of the Montessori method.
Children can often choose what they want to work
and how long they want to focus on it,
but the real world rarely works like that.
At some point, every child will enter an environment
where tasks are assigned, not chosen.
Traditional schools require sitting at a desk,
following instructions,
and completing work on schedule.
And for some children who are used to full autonomy,
this transition can be difficult.
After all, even as adults,
we often have to do things we don't practically enjoy,
simply because they need to be done.
Discipline is part of life,
and children eventually have to learn that too.
Not ideal for highly active children
Remember how Montessori originally developed her methods
while working with children with intellectual disabilities?
These methods works very well for children
who've benefited from calm, structured, repetitive activities.
And they can also work beautifully for naturally calm children.
But not all children are like that.
Some kids are energetic, curious, constantly moving.
For very active or hyperactive children,
a quiet environment that requires
long periods of focused work
can sometimes feel restrictive or even frustrating.
These children may thrive better in environments
that include more movement,
group activities, and physical exploration.
So after looking at the Montessori method from different angles,
its philosophy, its strength,
and the life story of its creator Maria Montessori,
I came to a very personal conclusion.
I would not send my child to Montessori school or kindergarten.
For me, this method has too many downsides that are rarely discussed.
At the same time,
I don't think it makes sense to reject the entire approach.
Some Montessori ideas are genuinely excellent.
Montessori learning materials can be fantastic for early development.
Encouraging independence,
teaching practical life skills,
allowing children to make choices.
These are all valuable ideas.
But like many things in parenting,
I believe they work best in moderation
without turning them into a rigid ideology.
So this is simply my perspective.
You may agree with me,
or you may completely disagree.
And honestly,
I am very curious which side more of you will be on.
Would you send your child to Montessori school?
Let me know in the comments.
See you in the next video.