How Much Neck Pain Does it Take to Qualify for Long Term Disability Benefits?

Disability Insurance
6 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 15, 2026
Neck pain is one of the top five reasons that people claim disability benefits. It is also the type of medical condition that disability insurance companies dispute every day. How do you know if your neck pain or neck disorder is severe enough to qualify you for disability insurance benefits. Attorneys Gregory Dell & Cesar Gavidia discuss the most common issues associated with neck pain and obtaining long term disability insurance benefits.
Hi, I'm attorney Gregory Dell joined by attorney Cesar Gavidia.
And today Cesar, we're going to talk about how much neck pain
does it take to get a long-term disability insurance claim
approved? And you know right away that when we talk about how much pain
that you're probably thinking like what are you talking about because
how are we supposed to measure pain when it comes to proving a disability claim?
And right off the bat, why isn't there a measure of pain?
And why is that one of the biggest aspects in every claim?
That's kind of like what I think the measure of pain is this fraudulent
concept amongst disability carriers. And I just want you to address that
issue in this video about talking about pain.
And also with regard to all types of neck disorders that we've dealt with
through helping thousands of claimants dealing with this,
providing some tips about how to protect themselves if they're already on claim
and things that will help them to get on claim if they're either applying
or they've been denied. So getting right into it,
why is it this concept of measuring pain is a real falsehood?
So yeah, I mean it's a real trivial kind of issue and question because
there really is no way to measure the amount of pain somebody's in.
It's a completely subjective real thing because it's reported by the patient,
by the claimant. And the frequency, the intensity,
that all has to be reported by them. There's not going to be a machine
or there's not going to be anything the doctor is going to be able to
visualize and see on you that's going to tell them,
oh, now I see how much pain you're in. I mean, you could be in the examination room
screaming in pain. They're going to believe you're in pain,
but that's not how generally they're assessing your level of pain.
You're reporting to them that this is what's causing my pain.
This is how often it's occurring. This is how intense it is.
They sometimes even give you a scale. Like where would you measure it on a scale of
one to 10? And if you look at some of those forms that you fill out
when you go to your doctor's examination, that might be something they're asking about.
But other than that, I mean, really it's just a measure of what you report to them.
And so when we talk about specifically with neck disorders, pain is subjective.
It means it's something that is a complaint. It's not something physical that you can see.
And objective evidence is things that you can't obviously see.
What is the types of objective evidence that are the best types of evidence that somebody
can obtain who has a neck disorder type disability claim?
Yeah. So what we're doing with their insurance companies looking for,
the disability insurers looking for is that correlation of your diagnosis or your symptoms
to the pain that you're experiencing. So certainly with the neck disorder,
just one of the fundamental diagnostic studies and tests that you want is an MRI.
And that's something that your doctor will most likely order if you report that you are
having this intense pain in your spine, in your neck.
The other thing is if you're having symptoms that are radiating,
or that are basically traveling through your extremities, through either your legs or through
your upper arms, since we're talking about the neck here, upper your arms into your wrist,
into your hands, then they may ask or look for some sort of neurological issue.
They may be asking, is there something neurological here? Is there some sort of nerve
involvement, nerve damage, nerve compression? That's something they might find on the MRI.
But also to see if there's any damage or injury to those nerves, they might
report or request an EMG nerve conduction study.
And so the nerve conduction studies can be good sources. Obviously, if you come back,
it's going to show that you have some kind of radiculopathy, which is going to be another type
of objective evidence in addition to an MRI, in addition to an X-ray, which is only going to show
the bones. But it's going to be almost impossible to get approved on a neck disorder claim if you
don't have some kind of objective testing. Now, that doesn't mean that you need to have
a result of an MRI that shows you have some giant herniation, which is impinging the nerve
root, or you have severe osteophytic formations or neuroforaminal narrowing in your neck.
Because every doctor will say, look, I don't treat the chart, I treat the patient.
And it's the same thing in a disability claim. You're dealing with your complaints. The problem
is that just like a doctor doesn't treat just the chart and treats the patient,
the problem is that the disability company, they treat the chart. Meaning they only look at the
records. They don't necessarily care so much about what you tell them. They care about what's in the
record. So how do you work with your clients and what do you recommend in terms of getting the
best possible documentation into the medical records so that they can be in the best spot
to get their benefits approved? Yeah. So that comes with that fundamental
thing we talk about in our field, which is you're almost as disabled as you appear in your medical
records and in those charts. Because that's exactly right. They do treat the chart. They
look at the chart and the records very, very closely to see what your issues are, what the
diagnoses are, what the symptoms are, how you're being treated for them, how often you're reporting,
how intense this pain is, how frequent this pain is, and where it's occurring,
and what types of activities, and how long you've had it. So how do you prepare for that? Well, it's
the only way to do that is just constantly reporting and frequently reporting to your
doctors. And you really have to be sometimes your own best advocate reviewing and having these
medical records on hand to ensure that they're being accurate, that your complaints are accurately
being documented. And doctors are not often the best historians and record keepers.
Sometimes they farm this type of stuff out. And their medical assistant may be the one who's
doing the dictation or putting these things into the notes. So you need to really have a
fundamental understanding of what's in your medical records and report often and report
frequently. Or keep charts, keep logs, keep things so that you, when you report to your doctor, you can go in
and you can say, here's when I experienced these problems. Here's how often it occurred. Here's how
intense it was. Here's what type of activity I was engaged in when it was happening.
So along the lines of what you're saying, these are some additional tips that I always like to
offer for my clients also is this theme of looking messed up on paper is what I call it. Is that you
have to, you probably have a view to say, look, I'll try that. I'll try this. But I don't think
it's going to help because I've done other things or I've heard from somebody else.
But when you're talking about how you're going to look on paper, you need to communicate with
your doctors and say, doctor, what other types of medications can I try? I know we've tried two or
three. Can we try another one? What other types of testing can I get? I know we did an MRI. Is there
something else I can do? Is there something new? Can you send me for an EMG or nerve conduction
study test? Is there some kind of new fluoroscopic type exam that I can have done?
What other types of injections can I possibly get? Can you send me to a pain management
anesthesiologist or a physical medicine and rehabilitation doctor? And should I go through
a set of injections in my neck so that I can see if those are going to work?
And what happens is we like to paint a picture for our clients where we can basically say, look,
our client has tried everything there is to try short of surgery because there are other things
you can do. Also, did you do all the therapies? Did you try all the medicine? Did you try the
injections? And I'm not saying you have to get injections, but they often say if you're in so
much pain, why didn't you try a potential remedy? So the more you do, the worse off you're going to
look on paper and the better position you're going to be in with a claim. And Cesar, since
I touched on surgery, we often recommend that claimants treat with a, or at least consult with
an orthopedic doctor or a neurosurgeon. And the reason for that is because we want to know if
there's a surgical remedy. Now this can be a double-edged sword, as you know, sometimes because
the doctors, you know, people think you walk into a surgeon's office, they're always going to say,
yeah, you need to have surgery because they get paid if you have surgery. But my experience is
if you're going to a quality doctor, it's not the way it's going to happen. And they're usually not
going to recommend surgery unless you're in a situation of paralysis, meaning where you're
going to have some serious spinal cord damage that if you don't have the surgery, and we're
talking about the neck, that you could become paralyzed. You could lose complete feeling in
your hands or your arms or movement or something like that. And they're doing surgery to try to
stabilize your condition. But the double-edged sword type situation is that if you're not
already treating with an orthopedic doctor, you're not treating with the neurosurgeon and you go to
them, they may not want to fill out anything about your restrictions and limitations. They
may not want to fill out paperwork for the disability company. And why can that become
a problem for someone? And how important is the quality of the attending physician statements
that are completed by treating doctors? Yeah. I mean, they're extremely important.
It's extremely important to have that paperwork and documentation completed by your treating
doctors. The problem is, is that, you know, primary care, family physicians, general practitioners,
they often don't want to be completing this paperwork. So a surgeon, a neurosurgeon,
orthopedic surgeon, it's even less likely that they're going to want to complete this type of
paperwork. So, you know, despite how important it is, it's important that you have this communication,
a good communication, good rapport with your doctor, with your surgeon, so that they understand
what it is that you need. Sometimes that conflicts with what they're setting out to do for you. If
they're going to be doing a spinal surgery that is supposed to be, you know, alleviate or resolve
in their minds your problem for you, I mean, that's why they're justifying this surgery,
they're most likely going to expect that you're going to be back at least a physical capacity
to return to a certain quality of life or even work capability. So you really have to
engage your doctor and they have to understand, you know, before surgery and after surgery,
what the ongoing limitations are that you have. And that is a great point that you brought up
that I wasn't even thinking about before, about the fact that surgeons are like proud of their work
and they feel like, wait a second, I just did surgery on you, why aren't you back to normal?
But more often than not, the surgery is like a stabilization and a stop the bleeding. It's
to stop making things get worse than they already are. And the reality is every claimant we have,
if they could have a surgery and go back to work, they want to, because they're always going to make
so much more money working than they are on disability. So it's a falsehood when the disability
carrier is like, well, you had surgery and you should be better get back to work. Well, it's
insulting because if you're the claimant, you want to go back to work, you would love to go back and
do your job if you could. So surgery doesn't mean you're better. It means the condition got so
severe that you couldn't take it anymore. And maybe you have less pain, but you still have
symptoms and you still have functional limitation. I mean, think in terms of a race car and the
engine blows out and you, you know, you replace the engine while you have a whole new engine,
but surgeons aren't replacing your entire spine, right? They're fixing a component of it.
And you're not going to go back to racing. You're not going to most likely in most cases, go back to
capacity. I've had many clients that they've had surgery, neck surgery, and they've successfully
returned to some level of work, but that's not every case. Every case, you know, is unique.
In some cases, they're going to remain totally disabled and they're not going to be able to
return because really the surgery, like you said, is, is kind of to stop the bleeding,
to kind of stabilize and now maintain a certain ability in life, quality of life.
If they go back to, you know, standing for four or five hours and in, in their, in their job
and performing their job duties, how soon before they are, they start to break down again.
Right. And, and, you know, the other thing with the neck conditions is that they're almost
always chronic medical conditions and someone doesn't just wake up and be like, Oh, I have
a neck condition. I'm out of work. They're usually dealing with them for six months, a year or two
years. And then they, you know, and hopefully they've been getting medical treatment, which is
what you really need to do to support the claim. And then they stop working. And the classic
argument is, well, you had those symptoms and that diagnosis for two years, and now all of a
sudden you stopped working. So, you know, we're prepared to deal with that issue. It's probably
the most common issue that we deal with on a daily basis. The other issue that comes up,
all the time, which really infuriates us, but it's probably 90% of the denials we do is
the claims get approved. They put them on claim for a year or 18 months or four years. They have
a chronic cervical condition. And then the carrier says, Oh, we had your file reviewed by somebody.
We don't think that your complaints are supported by your objective evidence. And we think you can
work now. And that always blows my mind. I mean, how could you have been better? Your neck is
degenerative by nature. It's only going to get worse over time. How now are you better?
And that goes back to what we were saying in the beginning of this video, where you got to exhaust
all of the available remedies for treatment and care and see all the doctors and therapists and
consultants that you can so that you always fall back on that argument to be able to say, look,
I've done everything I could. It's been a year. It's been two years. It's been five years
unless some miracle drug came out or some miracle type surgery or something happened.
I'm not getting better, but you can't rest. You got to keep up with all of that treatment. So
if you're a claimant who has a neck condition, we encourage you to reach out to myself or Caesar.
We help clients all over the country. We always provide initial free consultation where we're
going to review your policy or review your denial letter. We're going to let you know
immediately how we can help you. We encourage you to spend some time looking through our website,
looking up by your medical condition or your disability company or your occupation.
We have lots of summaries about lawsuits and other cases that we've handled,
reviews from other clients about your company, questions and answers that you may be thinking
that we've already answered. And we want you to have this information because the more educated
you are, the better position you're going to be in to get your benefits approved. This is a game,
Caesar, as you know, in terms of having a strategy, being prepared and thinking like the company.
It's also a war. I hate to use all these cheesy analogies, but you have to be ready and you have
to think like them in order to be in the best position to get benefits approved. So we look
forward to the opportunity to help you and we'll be here should you need us at any time in the future.
Thank you.
