American history is often told through politics and war. But the nation was also shaped in classrooms — by those who believed education could form both mind and character.
In this episode of American Legends, Tiffany Brannan explores the life of Mary Peabody, an educator, writer, and one of the key figures in the early development of American education.
Born in 1806 in Massachusetts, Mary grew up in the intellectually rich Peabody family, alongside her sisters Elizabeth and Sophia — women who played an important role in the American Renaissance.
From a young age, Mary was drawn to teaching. She worked as a governess, teacher, and writer, developing a deep belief that education should nurture not only knowledge, but also the moral and spiritual growth of each child.
Her life took a new direction when she married Horace Mann, one of the leading reformers of the American public school system. Together, they shared a vision for education that was both intellectually rigorous and deeply humane.
After his death, Mary continued their work — helping to establish the first kindergarten in the United States in 1860, inspired by the ideas of Friedrich Fröbel.
Through her writing, teaching, and leadership, she helped shape the early philosophy of American education, emphasizing:
• the importance of early childhood education • the role of creativity, play, and music • the moral development of each individual child • education as a foundation for a better society
This episode explores:
• the life of Mary Peabody • the Peabody sisters and their influence • the origins of kindergarten in America • her partnership with Horace Mann • the early philosophy of American education
Discover the story of Mary Peabody, whose work helped shape the foundations of education in the United States.
Welcome to American Legends. My name is Tiffany Brannon.
Each culture has its legends, and that could be myths or different stories,
but here in America, our greatest legends are the wonderful heroes who are right from our history
pages. Now, some of these heroes are very famous and some are obscure, but each person deserves to
be discovered because each man or woman stands as a great example of how we can be better Americans
It's a common trope that the middle child of a family is often the misfit, the one who's left
out. In the trio of sisters who are known as women who inspired the American Renaissance,
that middle sister turned out to be, although often overlooked, one of the most important of
the three sisters. I'm speaking about the Peabody sisters, whose influence expanded beyond the
things they did in their own lives to the great impact they had on their husbands and the other
important men of letters and arts who surrounded them in the mid-19th century. Today, we're going
to talk about Mary Peabody, that middle sister who proved to be not only a wife and mother,
but a great author and founder of American education, showing that when it comes from
a place of true caring in the heart, teaching is truly an art. Mary Tyler Peabody was born on
November 16, 1806, in Cambridge, Massachusetts. She was the second out of six children that the
Peabody family would eventually have, so she wasn't strictly the middle child of the whole family,
but you could really say that this family was divided into two halves. The first three were
all girls and the second three were all boys. Out of that first trio of sisters, she was the middle child.
Mary was wedged between Elizabeth, the oldest child of the family, who proved to be extremely
intelligent and strong-minded, and Sophia, the sensitive youngest daughter, whose ill health
required a lot of their mother's care. Thus, Mary was in the middle, but she was not without her
own attributes. Mary was noted as the beauty of the family. She had dark hair, looking different
than her other two sisters, and she realized right away, though, that she didn't want her appearance
to be the only thing that was distinguishing about herself. She, too, wished to better her mind.
Their parents were Nathaniel and Elizabeth, or Eliza, Peabody. Nathaniel, their father, was
a general practitioner-turned-farmer-turned-dentist who dabbled in experimental and often dangerous
homeopathic remedies. He was a mild-mannered man of changeable nature, who was unable to
effectively provide for his family at all times. Thus, his wife, who had a much stronger nature,
helped the family by providing a second income. It wasn't just financial necessities which caused
her to work, though, as a teacher. She had a great personal passion for education, and she believed
that girls deserved an equal education to boys. Throughout her children's childhood, she would
often tutor in other people's homes and have a school of sorts in their own home. They moved a
lot throughout the state of Massachusetts, eventually settling in Salem, where most of the
girls' childhood was spent. Because of this teaching-out-of-the-home, which their mother did,
all of the Peabody girls grew up in a very cultured intellectual environment, surrounded by
thinking and challenging ideas. It quickly became evident that the older two sisters
would be a pair. They were four years apart in age, and Sophia, who was three years younger,
proved to be sort of on her own as she was suffering from ill health from a very young age.
This spirit of education and learning, which surrounded the girls, inspired both of them to
become teachers themselves when very young. When Mary was only 18, she began teaching,
and her first teaching job was acting as a governess to well-to-do families in the city
of Hallowell, Massachusetts. She often took over for teaching jobs that her sister had had.
Through different forms of teaching and education, Mary found different paths for her life. Again,
she often followed in Elizabeth's footsteps, yet she herself had her own unique form of creativity.
Elizabeth was the more willful of the two, and she often would start things which
her sisters would follow. As the oldest child, Elizabeth thought it was her duty to help provide
for her sisters as well as the rest of the family. But Mary had great creativity in and of herself.
She was the most of a writer out of the three sisters, and she wrote many works which were
published throughout her lifetime. In 1825, before she was even 20 years old, Mary began teaching at
a school in Brookline, Massachusetts, which her sister had founded. Together, the Peabody sisters
worked at this school and developed it into something which flourished until it ended up
closing in 1832 because of a minor financial scandal, which really was no fault of the
sisters but had to do with some falsifying of records by another partner of the school.
This was just the first of many bold educational endeavors that the sisters would found.
It was around this time, though, shortly after they returned to Boston, where their family was
now living, that a very important member of their lives would enter the Peabody circle. In 1833,
Mary and Elizabeth Peabody were staying at a boarding house run by Mrs. Rebecca Clark. This
boarding house was called Ashburton Place, and it attracted an eclectic group of free thinkers.
Among them was a man named Horace Mann. He was a Whig politician, and he, at the time, was serving
in the Massachusetts state legislature. He also was deep in mourning, as his wife had died the
year before. He was 10 years older than Mary, and he didn't get along well at all with his landlady,
but he did find a kindred spirit in both the Peabody sisters. They enjoyed long and deep
conversations together in the evening at the boarding house, and he quickly found a solace
for his grief in their company. Now, in Elizabeth, he found a true intellectual equal, and they would
have very intense conversations about metaphysical topics, which Mary found herself unable to follow.
She often felt like they were almost speaking a different language. Nevertheless, Mary began to
hope that she might find some kind of common ground with the gentleman they called Mr. M,
because she quickly found herself falling for him. It particularly began one evening when he smiled
while holding a door open for her. Years later, she confessed the beginning of these feelings
in a memoir about him which she called Estimate of Horace Mann, saying,
Perhaps because she suspected that Mr. M and her sister Lizzie were developing a close bond,
Mary was embarrassed lest Horace should find out her feelings for him, and she began to
want to avoid his company. Despite that, she felt a great happiness in his presence, which she
really didn't feel with any other man up to that point. Now, by this age, she definitely was older
than the average age for a young lady to get married at that time, but all three of the Peabody
sisters were not afraid to delay or even avoid marriage altogether, as their mother had taught
them to be self-reliant and well-educated so they wouldn't have to rely on a marriage for
materialistic reasons, as she herself had had to do. In fact, it was a bit of a matter of pride
among the Peabody sisters that they had turned down many eligible bachelors. Right around the
same time, there was one young gentleman who was particularly desirous of Mary's hand in marriage.
In late 1833, Elizabeth arranged for Sophia to go to Cuba to help recover her health,
as she was really struggling with almost a complete nervous and physical collapse.
So the doctor advised a change of climate, and everyone agreed that the sensitive Sophia needed
a companion, so Mary seemed the logical choice, as Elizabeth was establishing a bookstore in
Massachusetts and needed to stick around. Mary was a bit reluctant to leave, since she feared
that she would lose Horace altogether if he were alone in Massachusetts with her sister, but she
decided that it probably was all for the best, since she wasn't sure she wanted him to know her
feelings. So she and Sophia set out for Cuba. Before she left, she received a proposal of
marriage from the other suitor, which she turned down, but which didn't stop him from continuing
to court her via letter. And she also received a very tender farewell note from Horace Mann. While
they were in Cuba, Sophia enjoyed learning different types of art as she recovered away from the
stresses of Boston. Meanwhile, Mary worked as a governess on a plantation, where she observed
firsthand the tensions and injustices which were present because of the slaveholding which was
still happening on that plantation. The things she observed there would prove the inspiration for
the soul novel she would later pen. This novel was called Juanita, a romance of real life in Cuba 50
years ago, and the name was 50 years ago because she didn't really get down to writing it seriously
until she was 80 years old, and it was published in the year 1887, shortly after she died. Elizabeth,
who outlived her sister, always maintained that it was a mere accident that it was published
after her death, but some have speculated that perhaps they purposely waited until afterwards
because Mary was a bit embarrassed by the fact that many of the characters were based on real
people. And it certainly does seem to be at least semi-autobiographical, as it is about a
young American woman who becomes a governess on a plantation, where she witnesses the romance between
the title character, a mixed-race enslaved woman, and the son of the master of the plantation.
This was very poignant and meaningful because Mary was a passionate abolitionist, as were all the
other members of her family. While she was in Cuba, Mary wrote extensive letters to the folks back in
Massachusetts, but surprisingly she didn't really write letters to Horace. He wrote to her, and
instead she would write to Elizabeth. Meanwhile, she grew rather jealous, as she knew Horace was
visiting Elizabeth at least once a week, having very deep conversations and emotional moments
with her sister, so she was resigned to the fact that they were falling in love. Elizabeth insisted
that it was strictly the love of siblings, and she would frequently read the letters from Mary
to Horace. It turned out that Elizabeth's insistence was true, as the main reason Horace
wanted to come over to visit her was to hear the letters from Mary. Although Elizabeth was one of
his closest confidants, he did regard her as a sister. In 1835, Mary returned to Boston,
and at this point she became one of Horace's closest confidants. She began working as his
private secretary, and she also contributed to the publication he had founded, the Common School
Journal. On May 1st, 1843, after knowing each other for 10 years, Horace Mann and Mary Peabody were
wed after one month of engagement. This came as quite a surprise to many people, as most had assumed
that he was in love with Elizabeth, and vice versa. But this would be one of two very noteworthy
occasions in which Elizabeth ended up being the bridesmaid, but never the bride, to a man who
meant a lot to her, but ended up marrying her sister. Horace and Mary enjoyed 16 years of
marriage together, from 1843 until his death at the age of 63 in 1859. During that time,
Mary found great happiness as his helper, as well as his wife, and she helped inspire him to do some
of his greatest work. In addition to contributing to his writings and acting as his secretary,
she helped him in what would become his greatest work, as he was the president of the newly founded
Antioch College in Ohio from the year 1852 until his death. He was the first president of this
learning institution, which was one of the first co-educational colleges in America. They both
believed very strongly in the idea that women should have the right to have a fair and equal
education, but it was no easy feat, and she served as the unofficial dean of women, as well as in
almost a first lady role as the wife of the president. They had three children, all sons, and
she gave up her public teaching to homeschool all three of the sons, which is ironic considering the
that both she and Horace were great proponents of the public school system. Nevertheless,
studying more about what Mary believed in terms of education, it's not surprising that she wanted
her sons to have the private attention of a homeschooled education, and it must be noted that
the public school system really had very little founding at this point, as Mary herself would be
very instrumental in that after her husband's death. Despite her busyness as a wife, mother,
and first lady of Antioch College, Mary found time to do quite a bit of writing. Other published
works of hers included an 1838 children's book, The Flower People, being an account of the flowers
by themselves, which she wrote and published before her marriage, and then during her marriage,
she published the religious yet health-conscious 1857 cookbook, Christianity in the Kitchen, a
physiological cookbook. This was a very interesting work, and very advanced in that it talked about
the importance of avoiding certain foods which aren't healthful, but it also connected
the strong spiritual background she had by presenting the idea that the body as the temple
should be nourished for greater moral improvement as well as physical health. After her husband's
death, she wrote the 1865 biographical tribute to him, Life of Horace Mann. After Horace died
quite suddenly in 1859, the grief-stricken Mary went back to live with her sister Elizabeth, and
she purchased a house in which they could both live in Concord, Massachusetts. They began working
together on what would continue to be the passion for both of them, which was public education,
particularly in the pre-school years, as Horace had done a lot to found the public school system
in the more primary years, particularly in the state of Massachusetts. Inspired by her husband's
belief that education should build up the moral content of children while not promoting one
particular religious denominational belief, Mary and Elizabeth founded the first kindergarten
in the United States in 1860. They were greatly inspired by the work and writing of German educator
Friedrich Froebel, who talked about and founded the kindergarten system in Germany. It makes perfect
sense when we consider the fact that the early school system in America still has an extremely
German name, which literally means child or children's garden. Mary and Elizabeth dedicated
the last few decades of their lives to founding kindergartens and writing about them and the
theory behind them, so that dozens of other kindergartens were founded throughout the United
States. At this point, and inspired by the works of Herr Froebel, the idea of the kindergarten wasn't
just a place where young children could learn how to sit still for a few hours before actually
learning how to be educated. It was founded on such a noble and truly inspiring idea of the
well-rounded education which children truly need. Reading this book is, I think, something that every
educator should do, especially when considering how most school systems go astray these days.
In the introduction, which she wrote for the second edition, Mary describes the concept behind the
kindergarten as a place to really form not only the mind but the spirit and the soul of the child,
inspired by that individual unique spirit which is in every distinct individual from earliest
infancy. How education must be well-rounded to include not only reading, writing, and arithmetic,
but physical education, and most importantly music, as well as other artistic pursuits.
That children in kindergarten should be given freedom to play and taught how to play completely
quietly, but given a selection of a wide range of quiet toys, so that the educator can see
which toy seemed to attract the child and thus learn more about the child's distinct nature. All
these ideas were gathered together into the 1863 book which the sisters wrote together,
Moral Culture of Infancy and Kindergarten Guide. This book included not only a simple, clear, but
deeply profound set of ideas for how kindergarten to be formed, but also a collection of songs that
should be instituted in kindergartens. Following the example of her late husband, Mary and Elizabeth
began to develop different schools to educate teachers who would be in charge of kindergartens,
focusing on the feminization of the teaching force, because women weren't exclusively the
teachers up to that point. There were an equal, if not greater, amount of men, but the Peabody
sisters, as well as Horace Mann, believed that women were better teachers for young children, so they
encouraged the foundation of good schools, and this also helped make teaching a legitimate and
sustainable profession for young women, and even women of older ages, whether they chose to be
married or not. In all her work, writing, and teaching, Mary was influenced by the strong set
of beliefs she had, and these beliefs were primarily guarded by two distinct schools of
thought. Her Unitarian Christian beliefs, which came from her childhood and her upbringing,
as well as her sister Elizabeth in particular, and her influence from the Transcendentalist
movement, which was a very powerful school of thinking that was in the literary circles of the
day. For instance, Bronson Alcott, who was the father of Louisa May Alcott, an important writer
at the time, as well as writers like Ralph Waldo Emerson and Henry David Thoreau, were all influences
in the literary and intellectual circles that Elizabeth helped found in her bookstore and these
lecture evenings she would have. Mary blended her Unitarian Christianity with this Transcendentalist
ideology to create a very generous and reform-minded moral compass. It included the
idea that children are basically good in their nature, but that they could be easily corrupted
by bad education or a lack of proper guidance. She believed that it was the job of every teacher,
mentor, and educator to find that spark and that spirit in each child and develop it to its
highest moral as well as intellectual potential. Along with her sister Elizabeth, she helped guide
Horace Mann away from his depressed view on religion, which he had gotten from the very strict
Congregationalist Calvinist upbringing of his youth, which made him almost anti-religious,
because it seemed so harsh to him, which was similar to what their mother had had. She too
ended up turning away from that really strict Calvinism, which hadn't bred a deep personal
faith in either of them. But through the more charitable Unitarianism, Horace Mann was able to
find the sort of charitable faith that his wife and sister-in-law had. Mary was a champion of
social causes like abolitionism, believing very strongly in the evil of slavery, as well as
women's rights in a traditional way. She wasn't too much of a feminist per se, but she did believe
that women should have the right to equal education and a somewhat equal position intellectually in
society, being able to earn a decent living for doing a job. She also believed in temperance and
such other reform-minded causes. There are many interesting and inspiring quotes from
Mary Peabody Mann, but I think one of the things which really sums up her goals in life is something
she wrote alongside Elizabeth in the book Moral Culture of Infancy. Quote, kindergarten means
a garden of children and frugal meant to symbolize by the name the spirit and plan of treatment. How
does the gardener treat his plants? He studies their individual natures and puts them into such
circumstances of soil and atmosphere as enable them to grow, flower, and bring forth fruit.
Through her tender-hearted love and intelligent guidance, Mary helped her husband, her children,
and countless other children throughout the nation bring forth beautiful fruit through
her charitable guidance and the educational background she provided. Thank you for
spending this time with me and I hope you'll join me next time for more American Legends.