How to Make Potato Salad (NO MAYO) from Sicily

Health Food
429 followers
Today we're making a potato salad, but not the one you're thinking of. This one
has no mayo. The first time I had a potato salad with mayonnaise, I was at my friend's house.
They were having a barbecue and his whole family was laughing at me because this was the potato
salad I was used to. So today we're making a Sicilian potato salad. This is the way my
grandmother used to make it. She used to buy a 50 pound box of potatoes and we used to eat
potatoes all the time and especially as it started to get a little warmer, spring, summer, a lot of
different ways. So I think you guys are going to love this recipe. So let's put it together.
So for the main ingredients for this potato salad, potatoes, we have golden Yukon potatoes,
a red onion, some tomatoes, olives. These are just mixed olives and capers. So that's really
the bulk or the main part of the salad. And then we have some olive oil, salt, pepper,
white wine vinegar, and oregano and basil. And that's really it. So what we're going to do is
we're going to start off by cutting up the potatoes. We're going to cut these potatoes in
cubes and we want to shoot for like even cubes so that they cook evenly. And there's really a lot of
different ways that you can cook the potato. You could bake it, you could put them in the microwave,
you can cook them whole. But what I find is that cubing them and cooking them this way,
it's really like the quickest way to do it. So this is the way I like to do it.
So I got a pot of boiling water over here. I'm just going to salt it real quick.
We'll add in the potatoes. And if you cook them this way, they really take about 15 minutes.
So you definitely want to set a timer because you don't want to overcook them. Otherwise,
you'll have like mashed potato salad, which is not a bad thing, but you want these to keep their
shape. All right, so we're going to let these boil. I'm going to set a 15 minute timer.
Put that on here. All right, 15. So while those are cooking, we're going to prep all the other
ingredients. I have an onion here and for the onion, I want to chop them finely. So I'm going
to use a mandolin. It's really the easiest way to get them really fine. And I mean, if you don't
have a mandolin, you could use a knife, but this is just a lot easier. And I want them really fine
because the onions will wind up hugging the potatoes. So if you get them really fine,
it really makes a difference in this potato salad. So we'll set these aside and we'll start
chopping up the cherry tomatoes. And these are really good because they're in season right now.
And we're just going to split them in half. That's really it. If you want them even smaller,
you can cut them in quarters, but I feel like half is good. If you don't have cherry tomatoes,
you could really use any tomato. If you have tomatoes in your garden, even better.
But these look really good. And I mean, that's really it for the prep, but I just realized the
onions, we left them in like rings and these are kind of annoying in a salad. So what we're going
to do is we're just going to give this like a little rough chop just so that it just goes
everywhere in the salad rather than just these big circles. So prep work is pretty much done.
We still have a few more minutes. Let's check out these potatoes. Yeah, they still need a little
more time here. You could see they're still raw, but definitely want to keep an eye on the potatoes,
especially once you hit that 15 minute mark, because they go from raw to overcooked. So
these potatoes look pretty good. We're going to get them out of here and we'll add them to a bowl,
let them cool off. And what I like about this potato salad is that you can really do a lot
of different things with it. A lot of times my grandmother would add different ingredients,
sometimes green beans. She would top it off with tuna. It was really like whatever you got. So
whatever you got, you add it to the potato salad. So it was always different every time, but this
was like the go-to way. This was like the baseline of the potato salad. So we're going to let these
potatoes just cool off for a few minutes and then we'll add all the ingredients in. If you want to
speed up the process, you can kind of give them a quick toss and they cool off pretty quick though.
So we'll just let this sit here for a few minutes. So these aren't piping hot anymore. They cooled off
a little bit and you kind of want the potatoes a little warm because when we add all the ingredients
right over the warm potatoes, it really helps bring all the flavors together. So I don't know
if this is like a grandma trick, but putting all these ingredients in here over the warm potatoes
actually makes this potato salad taste a little better. So now we're going to go in with some olive
oil, some white wine vinegar, salt, pepper, Sicilian oregano. It's a Sicilian salad, so
need the real oregano. And some fresh basil. And that's really it. Now we're just going to mix this
up. You kind of want to be gentle here because you don't want to break the potatoes. And that's
why I said, you know, don't overcook the potatoes. These are cooked pretty good. Let everybody become
friends. Let the potato say hi to the onion. So this looks pretty good. And pretty much the salad's
done. You could take this, put it in the refrigerator. You could serve it. You could take it to a party. I
taste good at room temperature, cold, and it even tastes good the next day. So if you want to make
it a day before for a party, this is something really easy you could prep. It's also great, like we
usually make it at the beginning of the week and then we'll pick at it all week. So it's a good
leftover. I'm not really big on leftovers, but this is great. And if you really think about this salad,
it's really like the summer salad of Sicily because you kind of build a lot of meals around
this salad, you know, put tuna over it, serve it up with some grilled meats, fish. I mean, it really
gives you an idea of what, you know, people are eating in Sicily in the summer. So it's a really
good potato salad. So I highly recommend it. I think you guys should definitely try it. And if
you like it, let me know how you like it in the comments. And don't forget to hit the bell, like, and subscribe.
