The Only Potato Salad Guide You’ll Ever Need

Gift from the Earth
467 followers
Between the two recipes that I'm sharing today, you'll pick up all the skills that you need
to make any type of potato salad. I'll cover everything from texture to flavour, dressing to
consistency and how to cook your potatoes just right. By the end of this video you'll be equipped
with the knowledge to make great potato salad. For this first recipe I'm using one kilo of new
potatoes. I won't dive into the specific varieties I'm using here since it varies depending on where
but like with most new potatoes their starchy texture and delicate skin make them a great
choice for potato salad. A lot of recipes recommend using all the same size potatoes for
even cooking. Whilst this is great advice, it's not always possible. It's not exactly practical
to buy five kilos of potatoes just to sort through them and end up with one kilo of the same size.
So I've got a mix of sizes here which is a good reflection of what most people can actually get
but the question is... Luckily this is actually very simple. I just have to pay attention to a
few little details. The first is using a large saucepan and the second is covering the potatoes
with cold water. The idea behind using a large saucepan is to give the potatoes space so they're
not crammed up on top of each other. They have a little bit of space to move around and starting
with cold water lets the potatoes and water heat up together evenly and gradually. When you start
with boiling water, the outer layer cooks too fast leaving the inside raw for much longer. These
two small details make a big difference when it comes to cooking potatoes evenly no matter the
type. Then I'm adding a little salt and over to my stovetop. I'm putting this pan onto a high heat
and placing a lid on. Once it's up to a boil I'm turning it down to a simmer so the water is just
bubbling and I'm going to leave that simmering for three to four minutes. After a few minutes
of simmering the potatoes still feel very raw but at this stage I'm turning the heat off and placing
the lid back on and I'm going to leave them to sit in this hot water for 15 to 20 more minutes.
This very gentle passive cooking technique is the third detail that helps to get unevenly sized
potatoes cooked evenly. All I have to do is leave them in the hot water but crucially using a lid to
maintain the temperature in the pan as much as possible. This is a very slept on technique and
it works very well. Okay so whilst I'm waiting for them to cook I can get on with the rest of the prep
and I'm going to start with some fennel. This is going to bring a fresh vibrant flavor and a much
needed crunch to this potato salad. The same way some raw onion would just without the raw onion
breath. For this reason this is one of my go-to potato salad recipes for things like networking
events because people get self-conscious about having onion breath particularly when they're
meeting for the first time. I'm only going to need half of this average size bulb for this recipe
and I'm slicing it thinly starting from the top working my way to the base. If you're not a fan of
fennel then some thinly sliced carrot, celery or even some radish are great alternatives to the
standard raw onion. The only downside with fennel is it likes to turn brown once it's sliced so to
stop this I'm adding the juice of half a lemon but anything acidic will work here. After a good mix I
can put that to one side and move on to the herbs. Here I've got a small handful of parsley and the
same amount of dill. With the parsley I'm just picking the leaves from the large main stalks.
These can be a bit woody and it's not something that I want in my potato salad. I want to show
you a trick that I use to cut herbs like parsley. So I bunch all of the leaves together then I begin
to roll them like this using my fingers pushing into the chopping board slightly until I have a
kind of parsley cigar like this. Then I can just take fine slices from this compact bunch of parsley.
The idea when chopping most herbs is to chop them as little as possible so when you want them cut
reasonably fine it's good to use techniques like this. Then once I'm all the way through I like to
give the whole pile a 90 degree spin and I just chop through that a few more times. This cutting
technique works for small amounts like this all the way up to a few handfuls of leaves. It's
something I use all the time. Anyway, on to the dill and this herb is a lot more delicate so I
treat it a little differently. Same first step, I just pick the leaves from the woody main stalks.
Don't worry, none of these stalks will get wasted. I'll show you what I do with them in a minute.
Then with the leaves or I suppose they're actually fronds, I like to tear them down with my fingers.
You can also chop them with a knife but I find this tends to break them down too much and they
end up coating absolutely everything in the potato salad. By tearing them like this I get little
pockets of dill here and there rather than a homogenous dill flavor across the whole salad.
Okay, so that's the herbs I'm going to use today. Lastly, I'm going to prep some spring onions.
Here I've got three large-ish spring onions. I'm doing the usual, peeling off any dry looking parts
and taking the very ends off the tops which always tend to be a bit dry if they've been cut.
Then I'm slicing the top green part as fine as I can. This is going to bring a fresh mild onion
flavor that works so well in potato salad just without the risk of bringing any of that raw
onion breath that I'm trying to avoid for this recipe. Just a little like this goes a long way.
So, as promised, let's use up some of this waste. I'm saving this lemon half for something else
but here I've got the parsley and dill stalks, the trim and dry outer layer of the fennel
and any of the trim from the spring onions. I'm going to place all of that in with my potatoes
which are still sitting in the hot water on the stovetop. They've been in the water now for around
10 minutes so I guess they've got anywhere between 5 and 10 more minutes until they're where I want
them to be. Eight minutes later, my potatoes are ready. Looking at one of the medium-sized ones,
my fork goes in easily. The texture feels firm but cooked. The skin isn't split anywhere. This feels
and looks perfectly cooked. But what about one of the larger ones? My fork goes in easily. There's
a tiny, tiny amount more resistance in the center but this feels great. In terms of doneness, I'd
say the two sizes are about 5% apart. If I'd simmered them the whole way, the medium ones
would have ended up with split skins and a mushy texture by the time the larger ones were cooked
through. So this simple technique has worked well. After draining them off, I can take a closer look.
They all look great. Absolutely no split skins. None of them look soggy or overcooked. They feel
firm but with a tiny amount more give when I squeeze them. This is exactly where I want to be.
From here, I can just leave them to cool naturally like this until you can handle them with your bare
hands. 5 or 10 minutes should be enough. If you don't like potato skins in your potato salad,
then at this point you can just run a small knife lightly over the surface and the skin will easily
come away like this. This isn't something I'm going to do for this potato salad. I like the
flavor the skin brings, particularly with new potatoes like these. Then it's just a matter of
cutting them up. I tend to go on the larger side. This helps the potato slices to stay whole and not
break apart too much. But this is personal preference. Then into a bowl with the shaved
fennel, a little salt, some cracked black pepper, a dash of extra virgin olive oil. I'm starting
somewhere between 50 and 100 mils. Then a good mix to get every piece of potato coated with the
seasonings and the olive oil. So from here, it really is your choice on what you want to do.
My potatoes are still a little bit warm and I'm going to add my herbs and the spring onions now
and mix them in and I'm going to eat this as a warm potato salad. There's only one downside to
this. If you want to save this potato salad for later or tomorrow or in a couple of days, adding
the green things now, they'll just lose a lot of their freshness and their color. So if you want to
eat this now as a warm potato salad like me, add everything, give it a mix, serve, very nice. If you
want to save this for another time, then let these cool completely and mix in your herbs. I would mix
them in an hour before you want to use it so they can get some of their flavor going, but then you
still keep the freshness of the onions and the herbs. That's kind of the two ways this can be
done from here, but this looks fantastic. The fennel is softened, the potatoes have sucked up all that
olive oil and the lemon juice. This is a great basis for a potato salad. So it's as easy as
adding the herbs and the spring onion, mixing them in and then tasting and seeing what you need to
get in balance. You might need more olive oil because the potatoes have absorbed it all, more
acidity from the lemon juice or just some more salt and pepper to bring everything to life. Okay,
so it looks amazing, very fresh, very vibrant. The fennel is really softened, it's still raw,
like shaved crunchy fennel, but it's just lost that really raw edge. The herbs are fantastic,
you can taste the lemon, the olive oil is in there, you can taste it but it doesn't feel greasy.
It's really fresh, really vibrant, this could go with just about anything. It'd be a great addition
at a barbecue with some fish. That's a side plate in the middle of the table, it's such a good
alternative to just the standard potatoes and mayonnaise. If you don't like the idea of fennel,
you can just take it out. This is fantastic. On to the next. This recipe is a traditional
potato salad from southern Germany. It's very unique and very delicious. It uses some unusual
techniques to make a dressing that's packed full of flavor and clings to the potatoes perfectly.
So here I've got one kilo of a waxy variety of potato. I want to use a large fully grown variety
so you can see how I go about preparing them for a potato salad. It's really common to get hung
up with not knowing what type you have. Floury, waxy or all-purpose. And because there's literally
thousands of varieties out there, I can't go through them all. So if it's not clear when
you're shopping, simply googling it is the quickest solution. So same as before, into a large saucepan,
cover them with cold water, a little salt, lid on and over to the stovetop. Onto a high heat,
I'm bringing that pan up to a boil and once it's boiling I'm turning it down to a very gentle
simmer. The gentler, the better. This is going to help the potatoes to cook all the way through to
the center without breaking apart. And at a guess, this is going to take anywhere between 20 and 30
minutes. So whilst that's happening, I can get on with the rest of the prep, which is really simple.
First I need to finely dice one brown onion. Nothing too fancy, just a fine dice. If you can't
get small brown onions like this, then you can use half of a larger white onion. Then that's going
into a saucepan along with 250 ml or roughly half a cup of beef stock, 60 ml or 4 tablespoons of
white wine vinegar and a couple of teaspoons of Dijon mustard. Then that's going over to my stovetop
onto a high heat on my small burner and I'm going to bring that up to a boil. Then simmer it for
around a minute. This is just going to soften the onion and take the harsh acidic edge off of the
vinegar. Once it's had that minute, I can turn the heat off and just place a lid on to help keep it
hot. Whilst I'm here, I can check on my potatoes. Not much has changed. My water is just simmering,
which is exactly where I want it to be. And that's all of the prep I need to do for this potato salad.
From here, I just need to wait until my potatoes are cooked. 15 minutes later, my potatoes are ready.
When I pierce them with a knife, there's a tiny amount of resistance in the middle, but not much.
This is where I want to be. I'm draining the hot water, keeping the potatoes in the hot pan. I'm
putting the lid back on to let them finish cooking in the residual heat. So just to talk a little bit
more about this texture of the potatoes. Mine is sitting here hot in this pan with absolutely no
water at all. They're just going to finish cooking in the centre. It's hard to explain the texture
in the centre without feeling it, but you can feel as the knife goes in, the knife or fork, as it goes in,
it's softer, then there's just a little more resistance in the middle. Like with the new
potatoes in the first recipe, it's going to help the inconsistent sizes of potatoes to gradually cook
and kind of even out. The beauty of this final 10% of cooking in the pan is there's absolutely
no water, so they can't overcook. They're just going to gently finish, basically. It's a really
good method if you have the time. If you don't have the time, you've just got to continue simmering
them on the stove in the water until they're done. And now I'm just going to leave them to gently cool
and I'll do the next step once I can handle the potatoes with my bare hands.
Because these are a larger, fully grown variety of potato, I don't want the skins for this potato
salad. So I'm going to scrape the skin away, exactly like I briefly demonstrated in the first
recipe. It's really easy, just run a knife along the surface and the skin comes away with ease.
Once they're peeled, I can cut them into large but bite-sized pieces. So to recap, because of
cooking the potatoes whole with their skins, super gentle simmering on the stove top and
letting the potatoes finish cooking in the residual dry heat of the pan, I've got evenly cooked but
crucially not waterlogged pieces of potato, which is now the perfect vehicle to get mixed with
and absorb a dressing. So into a bowl and I'm completely covering them with the dressing.
What's really important at this stage is the potatoes are still warm and the dressing is hot.
It may look a bit sloppy at this stage, but believe in the process and this will change over
the next few simple steps. After a thorough but gentle mix, I'm covering them and I'm going to
leave them to sit for 15 or so minutes to let the flavours mingle. 15 minutes later, I'm giving them
another stir. You can see how the appearance is changing. The potatoes are absorbing the dressing
and some of the starch from the potatoes is thickening what's left of the dressing.
I'm going to leave them to rest for another 15 minutes or so. Another 15 minutes later and you
can now see the potatoes have absorbed the majority of the dressing and what's left of
that dressing has fully thickened and is coating the potatoes. It's time for me to finish this
with a little salt, some cracked black pepper and keeping with tradition, a little oil. This
doesn't need to be much, a few tablespoons at the most. Then the last gentle mix and all I'm looking
to do here is get the oil emulsified into the dressing and this happens very easily. I don't
need to be vigorous and this simply gets served with some chopped chives on top for a touch of
freshness. I know a lot of you out there don't like a mushy potato salad or an overcooked potato
salad. This isn't that. This has the appearance of that in a way because some of the pieces of
potato have broken down but that's what makes the dressing, the sauce, that's what kind of
thickens it up and makes it all emulsified. So that I think is the key to this. This is like
classic German comfort food. The potato still has some bite, a little firmness. The sauce is
incredible. It's meaty, it's umami and it gets lifted by the the mustard, the oil, the acidity
from the vinegar. It's really balanced, it's really nice, it's not sweet which is not something I look
for from a potato salad and the best thing about this, remove the chives so don't put the chives
on. This can stay in your fridge and it will just get better with time so tomorrow will be even
better. The next day I think will be a touch better and that's probably about the limit.
But you've got a potato salad that will last for a few days in your fridge, it's fantastic.
It's not full of nasties, it's not full of oil, there's just a little bit of oil in it.
So it's a really good option. This is very nice. Out of the two today, this is the one I'd make.
If you enjoyed this video today then I know you'll enjoy this one too so go check it out next.
