【大師課】FBI談判專家,克里斯沃斯(Chris Voss)--談判大師課(完整版) P16 - 16.017 - 案例:綁匪殺人質

財富導航
16粉絲
2 次觀看·2026年9月28日
So here's the scenario. I'm going to be a bank robber, a bad guy, bank robber trapped in a bank
with hostages. You're going to be the hostage negotiator that talks me out. Now, you have four
restrictions. There are four things you can't do in the negotiation. And I'll walk all the way
through this. I'll summarize it. I'll give you a chance to ask questions. We won't dive in until
you're ready. So there are four things that you can't do. You cannot give me weapons.
You can't give me transportation. You can't give me drugs or alcohol.
And there's no sort of hostage exchange allowed. You can't say offer to come in if I let people
come out. Nobody can come in. People could only come out. When we get started, we'll simulate
being over the phone. You'll say ring ring. I'll answer. And that will start the negotiation.
All right. So if you're ready, say ring ring. Ring ring. I need a car in 60 seconds or she dies.
OK, let's just I want to tell you what my name is. My name is Pam and I'm here to help you
get through this. What's your name? I have no intention of telling you that, Pam. You have
55 seconds. Why would I tell you that? OK, look, I'm going to try and get you,
you know, what you need. You're going to give me a car. Excellent. You've got 50 seconds to comply.
OK, I just want to slow down and you slow down all you want. You've got 45 seconds. OK, I want to
maybe I can get you some food in there. Everyone's going to be out of here in 35 seconds. What do I
need food for? Right. Right. So I want you to just take it easy. I'm taking it fine. We're
going to get through this. Thirty five seconds. I want to I'm going to get out of here alone. OK,
I'm I'm not going to be able to get you that and that quickly. OK, so you can get me. OK,
we can talk about that. No, you said you couldn't get it that quickly. Well,
I think it's impossible to get it that quickly. You want me to kill her now? No,
I don't want you to do this or no on the car. Look, if you kill her, there's no way you're
going to get anything or no. OK, there's nothing you're going to get. Thirty seconds. There's
nothing that if you listen to me, if you kill her, there's nothing that's going to help you
right now. I want to help you. OK, I want to help you. I want to help you get through this. All
right. Look, it's not me you're helping. It's her. I'm going to make sure no one comes in there.
OK, that's what I already know. Nobody's coming in. I'm gonna start throwing up bodies if they
do. Well, I got 27 seconds left. Look, I want to resolve this with you. OK, give me the car. Look,
I want to see what's going on. Yes and no. What made you go in there today? I needed money. What
do you think I went into the bank for? You needed money. Well, money's better than killing people,
right? It's up to you. Money is better than letting you kill somebody. You got 25 seconds.
Well, OK, let's work. OK, is that a yes? You're not going to get it. Is that a yes?
You said you work on it? Look, yeah, I'm going to work on it for you. What does that mean? I'm
going to try to get you one. You're going to try? I'm going to try to kill her in 20 seconds. But
who knows how good try gets you? Look, I don't want you. She does. You want her. Don't worry
about me. Yeah, I I want her. No, you're not seconds. I promise you this isn't going to end
well for you. Oh, now you're threatening me. OK, 15 seconds. You think you're going to keep her
alive by threatening me? Seriously? OK, I misspoke. Why don't you just tell me what you
need the money? Why don't you just give me the car? You've got 15 seconds. We're going to go
with the car. I'm not telling you that. No. Why would I tell you that? You think if we give you
a car, you're going to make it out of here safe? Oh, she dies. Oh, you're going to take her with
you everywhere you go. You want me to? I will. 12 seconds. Look, you're not going to be able to
get a car, OK? You said not right now. How much time do you need? We can get you something. Maybe
tell me how much time in an hour. OK, in an hour she dies. Now you're changing things in there.
You said you give me a call in an hour and now you say you can't give me a car at all. I need
some. You're telling me I can't rely on anything you say. Look, I need some some guarantees from
you that you're not going to hurt anybody before that. You're not going to hurt anybody. That's a
nightmare. That was awful. Why? All right. So let's go. Let's go back over because you did
some stuff really well. OK. And there your ideas are good. But you don't really know how to
implement the ideas. And then you got yourself trapped. OK, to start off, you gave me your name.
That was awesome. OK, that was really good because just your first name to start off with.
It helps me to know, understand as a human being on the other side.
Now, what you wanted to do after that is you got my name. No, no, no. Let that go. My name's a
precious commodity. If you try to get my name, we're not bargaining quid pro quo. Do you want
to owe me? No. Yeah. So you want to get in. You want to stay out of bargaining. You want to stay
in negotiation. OK. A lot of people have a tendency to be really get into a lot of trouble and have it
just go horrible at about 90 seconds. You're well past that. That's me. Great question. You know,
you know, what do you need the money for? What are you doing here? Would you need the money?
You really stop the clock entirely with that. That was a great move. OK, good. And what question,
you know, what's the motivation? What's going on behind this? That's really where you want to get
into a negotiation that's negotiating. That's not bargaining, trying to find out what's going on
the other side. So let's reverse the role. Oh, no. Do you want to be the bank robber? OK, sure.
You ready to pay me back? Yeah, I don't think I'm going to be able to do it as good as you.
But just be me. OK, cool. So I'm going to call in and we're going to talk. OK. Ring, ring. You need
to get all these cops out of here. OK, I can see them all. Get him out of here. I'm going to start
shooting people. Is that what you want? Sounds like you want to stay safe. You want that on you?
Sounds like you want. Yeah, I want to stay safe. Get them out of here. All right. That's going to
be hard for me to do. In the meantime, how can I make sure that you stay safe? Give me a car.
Give me something to get me out of here. OK, I want a bus and I'm going to take all these people
with me. Sounds like you want to make sure you live. Yeah, I want to make sure I live. I don't
care about these people. I don't I just want to get out of here. All right. Sounds like you want
to see a life beyond this. Yeah. Get me out of here. What's this all about? I'm trying to get
out of here alive. I don't want to kill these people, but I'll do it. I'll do it. I know this
isn't what you had in mind for today. Let's get started. How did you get here? Look, I made a
mistake, OK? I made a mistake. You need to help me get out of here, OK? Sounds like you regret all
this. Yeah. Yeah, I regret it. How'd you get here at the start? Just get me get me a car. Get me out
of here. I'm still seeing cops on the street. My job is to make sure nothing happens to you.
Well, tell these cops to back off then. All right. That's going to be hard. But I can absolutely
guarantee you is nobody's going to make any threatening gestures towards you. Well, I'm
feeling threatened right now with all these cops. All right. Well, we're trying to keep everybody
away from the bank also. So this doesn't get out of hand. Well, get me out of here. I need I need
a car to get out of here. They're out there to make sure that people don't come running in on
you. Do you want that? No, I don't want that. I don't want to kill these people, but I'll do it
to sound like you mean it. Yeah, I mean it. How do we get here today? How did this start? What's
this all about? I got to get. Look, you find yourself in this position. Look, things didn't
go the way that I wanted them to go, OK? And now I need to get out of here. All right. I need your
help. Are you going to help me? I'm here to absolutely do everything I possibly can to make
sure you don't get hurt. Things didn't go well. This isn't a life you had in mind. Yeah, but here
I am. How do I get you out of this safely? Get me a car and guarantee that no one's going to shoot
at me on the way out. I got to get out of here, OK? You want to make sure you survive this? Yeah.
I want to make sure nothing bad happens to you in the back. OK, you get me out of here. I'm
working on getting you out of there, but I want to make sure it doesn't get any worse either.
Well, I could send out somebody. That's a great idea because that's going to that's a first step
towards making sure this doesn't get any worse. Who are you going to send out? I'll send out one
of the tellers. OK, that's awesome. That's amazing. That's a really smart move. That's a
way for you to basically stay in charge. OK, I'll send out one of the tellers then. All right.
Send the teller. And next thing I know, you're offering to send a bank teller. I know you just
were asking me, like, well, what could I do? What could we do? I wanted to be angry and I wanted to
be frantic, but you kept talking so slow that it kept slowing me down. Right. And I wanted to be
threatening to you, but you just kept being like caring to me. What I wanted to do in that on my
end of that when I was a negotiator was make you feel that I was there to collaborate with you
any way I possibly could without really rejecting your ideas or making you feel rejected. Yeah,
that's what it felt like. All right. I'm happy to hear. Yeah, I don't know. So I didn't think
yeah, I didn't feel I didn't feel foolish. I felt like you were there to help. Yeah.
