Marking 20 years of a landmark health care law in Massachusetts

WBUR
30 followers
Apr 10, 2026
WBUR's Morning Edition looks back on two decades of a bill that created comprehensive health care reform in Massachusetts and paved the way for the federal Affordable Care Act.
This is WBUR's Morning Edition.
Nearly all of Massachusetts residents have health insurance.
That's because of a bill Republican Governor Mitt Romney signed 20 years ago this weekend,
creating comprehensive health care reform in Massachusetts.
Today we're looking back on that bill. It paved the way for Obamacare.
We'll look at what it did then and what's left to do.
Joining us, Dr. Kiame Mahania, Secretary of Health and Human Services for the Commonwealth,
and John McDonough, a professor at Harvard's T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
Secretary, Professor, welcome to both of you.
Delighted to be here. Thank you.
So, Professor McDonough, I'm going to start with you.
Chapter 28, Romneycare.
20 years ago, you were instrumental in passing the law.
Briefly, what did it do?
Mainly, it reduced the share of Massachusetts residents who didn't have health insurance
to the lowest of any of the 50 states, to the lowest it has ever been,
and it has stayed there over these 20 years.
And so we established an approach and a model which had relevance
in terms of what became the Affordable Care Act.
It was an important model, not the only one, but an essential one
in terms of how that law was structured and how it was rolled out, implemented, and maintained.
One more question for you before I turn to the Secretary for a moment.
It was a bipartisan effort.
I mean, the bill signing, you've got Senator Ted Kennedy and Governor Mitt Romney,
opposite parties, together.
What was the pain that created the will for bipartisan cooperation
to do something that was this groundbreaking at the time?
So Massachusetts had had a lengthy history going back to the 1980s
of attempts at advancing toward universal coverage.
And along that journey, it negotiated certain levels of special Medicaid payments
to Massachusetts, particularly through the Clinton administration in the 1990s.
And under the Bush administration in 2004, they decided they were going to cancel
all those extra payments, which over three years would have taken over a billion dollars
out of the Massachusetts health care system.
When it became clear that that threat was facing the state,
Governor Romney, with Senator Kennedy, put on a full-court press to say to President Bush,
Don't take the money. Let us keep it.
And we will use it to create a near-universal health care system in Massachusetts
that might be a model for the nation.
And echoes there of a moment that we're in, and we'll come to the current day in a bit.
But first, Secretary Mahanian, so what changed?
So over the next several years, what happens in Massachusetts that is good for people's health?
I think it's difficult.
So at the time, I was a young newbie physician at a community health center.
And it's difficult to emphasize the difference it makes in people's lives
to know that they have insurance coverage.
In terms of the dignity that it confers to you, the certainty and the peace and the serenity
that it confers to your ability to know that you'll be able to take care of your family
was extraordinary.
As a physician, it was extraordinary to go from a place where, you know,
you have to have up to 10%, 15%, 20% of your patients without insurance.
And so you're really juggling what are you going to do
to a place where essentially everybody you see, you're talking about their care,
you're talking about their conditions, you're talking about how to get them better.
And so it just elevated the conversation.
And I think that we often don't talk of it from that spiritual dignity perspective,
just what it meant to be in a society where you knew walking down the street
that everybody was able to access health care.
It was really a deeply revolutionary moment in the history of America.
So I want to do a quick little lightning round with the two of you.
I'm going to say a factor, and you'll say whether you think it increased or decreased
as a result of RomneyCare 20 years ago.
This is not a test. This is just to kind of give us a sense of things.
Dr. Pei, increased or decreased?
Increased.
Insurance profits?
Stayed the same, which is high and a lot in growing.
That's a back and forth,
and I don't think this law had a huge impact on that in either direction.
And patient wait times?
That's a good question.
I think it depends what you're talking about.
So say some more.
I think that for primary care at the time,
it actually decreased your wait times because primary care institutions
were suddenly much more stable, financially stable.
So you could afford to hire nurses.
You could afford to hire people to answer the phone.
You could afford to hire physician NPs and PAs.
But I don't know that instantly the hospitals increased their ability
to provide cancer care or MRIs or surgery.
So I think there was a moment there where the supply likely increased,
was not able to respond to the demand.
But I would say it adapted very quickly.
And in the end, I do not think –
I'd be curious to know what John thinks,
but I do not think it had a significant impact on wait times.
So actually, I'm going to jump in there, Professor,
and I'll give you a second to answer the Secretary.
But I want to put a little more sound in here
because this is where we come forward now too.
So this is David Sells.
He's on the Health Policy Commission.
And he's talking about how hard it is now to access primary care in the commonwealth.
Almost 40% of emergency department visits are for conditions
or diagnoses that could have been treated in an office setting.
And for reasons of they couldn't get an appointment or it's after hours,
they're showing up in the most expensive setting.
So a lot of good stuff happened.
But, Professor, what are the challenges that remain today?
Well, there's many, many challenges that remain today
in terms of affordability of premiums and cost sharing for people,
particularly with commercial insurance, employer insurance.
There are problems around all kinds of prior approvals
getting in the way that the state is working aggressively to address.
So lots of challenges.
What I would just say is that there are a lot of people who say
when they see something wrong, they say,
that's because we did that universal health care law in 2006.
The truth is there's not a state in the country
that's not facing a primary care crisis right now
or difficult cost-sharing deductibles and co-pays and so forth.
So it's important to separate what happened in 2006.
And one of the things I noticed were so many physicians who said to me,
all of a sudden, for the first time in their careers,
I never see patients anymore who don't have health insurance.
So last word we've got.
Oh, I got a little more time than I thought.
I will turn to you, Secretary Mahanian.
Okay, so now my colleague Martha Biebinger is reporting
Healy administration expects to lose $3.5 billion in federal health care funding
every year once Medicaid cuts that were approved by Congress last summer
go into effect, with about a minute left now.
What is the biggest concern you have
or the biggest thing you're watching for going forward
as we're at 20 years of Romney care?
I think there are challenges that are coming from the federal government.
There are also some inherent challenges that we have with costs,
which is why Governor Healy has launched the Health Care Affordability Work Group
because I think that as an economy and as a society,
we simply cannot afford to have health care keep growing
as a percentage of what we use our budget for
in terms of personal budgets, family budgets, state budget.
And so I think it's the cost that really is something that keeps me up at night,
especially since it has not bought us a stability within the health care ecosystem,
meaning it's a tough health care world out there for virtually all the players,
and we need to figure out a system by which it's more affordable
for the individual premium payer, but also that we can stabilize the system
so that our health care system feels confident and feels comfortable moving forward.
And just to underscore, Boston this week says its health care costs
for the new fiscal year are nine times what they were for the previous.
Dr. Kiame Mahania is Secretary of Health and Human Services for the Commonwealth.
John McDonough is a professor at Harvard's T.H. Chan School of Public Health.
Thanks so much to both of you.
Thank you.
