Historical Naval Wargaming Kit Demo (US Naval War College Museum)

Historical Identity
26 followers
Museum curator, Rob Doane, gives a demonstration of a historical naval wargaming kit used by the US Navy in the late 20th century. Though similar looking to a modern strategy game, it was actually issued by the US Naval War College for officers to practice their command, control, and decision making skills whilst off campus out on the fleet. As you can see the kit includes a map, us navy ship miniatures, dice, rules, reference charts.
The US Naval War College has historically made great use of naval wargaming as a part of their curriculum from just after the US Civil War through to the World War and even today in the modern era. In another video I showcased their historical wargaming facilities.
#History
#Wargaming
So I wanted to get out for you one of our manual wargaming kits that's in the museum collection.
And this is a kit that was from 1963 and it all comes in this folder, which you can see,
that is meant to be very compact and portable. So this game that you're seeing the components of
here is based on the games that they played, the tactical level games that they played
here at the college. But this particular game is actually meant to be sort of a component of
something the college was doing a lot more in the post-war years, which is more distance learning
education. And so what they did is they made up these wargaming kits to provide to people out in
the fleet. So instead of you having to come to Newport and be a student and spend a year here
and play these war games, they also wanted people who were out on a ship at sea to be able to war
game too and to absorb some of the lessons that they were learning by playing these games. So
they made up these kits that were meant to be sent out so you could play these just about anywhere,
wherever you had space enough to set them up. If you were on shore at a base somewhere,
you could play these in the barracks or if you were out of the ship, you could set them up on
the bridge or the wardroom or wherever there was room to do this. So it was just a way that the
War College sort of made its presence and its influence felt throughout the whole fleet and
not just for the students here. Great. So can you walk us through what this includes? Sure. So for
this particular game, this is from 1963, so it's very much a product of the Cold War. The components
are really not that different from some of the games from much earlier, from before World War II.
The rules, of course, have changed now and they're much more focused on things like aircraft,
surface-to-surface missiles, surface-to-air missiles, submarines. Those are all given a
lot more attention in the rulebook in games like this than they would have before. But the basic
layout is very similar. So in the primary rulebook here, so this is, you can see about how thick the
rules are. It's not too terrible by the standards of other games. You don't have like a dictionary
size thing. It's something that's easy enough you could absorb in a day or two of reading and get
the basic idea of how it works. What is intended to happen is, ideally, this game is supposed to
be played by two different teams, just as in the pre-war years. They basically usually called them
the red team and the blue team. The blue team being the friendly side, the red team being the
opponent's side, and of course in this era that's going to be the Soviet Union. So however many
people you had to play with, you usually have one person be kind of the overall person in charge,
and then whatever size scenario this was, if you had squadrons of ships or individual ships, you
might have your other players being in those subordinate positions. Each team was divided into
three components. The surface fleet, the aircraft, and then the submarine, the subsurface forces,
and each of those teams supposed to be in a separate room. The idea being that if you want to
coordinate, come up with a plan for your side, if you're on a ship and you want to talk to the guy
who's in the submarine below you, who wants to torpedo the enemy ship, you can't just in real
life pull him aside and say, hey go after that guy. You've got to have a communication system in
place. You can radio an aircraft, you can do other things, but it's meant to simulate
kind of those real world difficulties. So the teams would be kind of divided into those three
components and ideally put in separate rooms. Each team would have a plotting chart, which
you're seeing here. This is kind of the main plane surface for each team, and it's obviously
nothing very complicated. It's just a big grid for the most part.
The grid is divided, you can see, into numbers to make grid coordinates very easy.
So when you're plotting a ship and you're doing your move, you can say that you're moving from
a certain grid position to another grid position, and then it's very easy to show that. If this
scenario was one that was taking place by land, if there were land features and geography coming
into play, they could just draw that on this very easily. They might use a plastic overlay so
they didn't have to draw right on the map. Any number of ways to show that. The most important
facet I think of this is that this game is meant to be run by umpires. It's not a case where the
two teams are sitting across from each other playing sort of like a traditional board game.
They're off in a separate room, and as they do their moves, the umpires and the control group
that's actually running the game is plotting both sides moves on a master plot board that
basically is a bigger version of this. It might take up the better section of the whole floor,
but they would be tracking both teams' movements throughout the game.
And that's how you bring in fog of war to these games. They would not, if you're on
one side and your ships are out of range of the other sides, you're not going to know that
they're there in real life unless you've detected them somehow either visually or through radar or
any other means you have. So in the game, if your ships are too far away to see the enemy's ships,
you don't get the perfect god's eye view of the battle. You only see what the umpires tell you
that you can see. And so they're tracking that on their plot board. Then they'll come into the room
and tell you, okay, you see two destroyers on the horizon, or you see on your radar,
there's a radar signature of an incoming aircraft, something like that. So that's how
they try to make it, again, kind of real world conditions as much as they can within the limits
of a physical game and one that isn't computerized, of course. So they have the teams in the
separate rooms. The umpires are in the middle. These games are played, I would say, much more
loosely than we might be used to playing if you're sitting down playing a game with friends
or something like that. They're played in turns, but the turns are scalable. So for example,
it's up to the umpire to decide, or the game controller or game director, they might call
them, how long each turn is. So in the beginning, when presumably both sides are going to be kind
of far apart and they're supposed to meet somewhere in the middle, the first turn might be
two hours, three hours, four hours of game time. Once the fleets are in range of each other,
and once where they're within range to start shooting at each other, they're going to scale
that down. And they might say, okay, the next turn is just three minutes or one minute or 30
seconds, plot a move for 30 seconds and turn that in. So that's how they, otherwise you're
going to spend a lot of time just having the fleets kind of close to each other. So that's
how they work around that. And then most times these turns are timed themselves. So the umpires
might say to the team, okay, you've got two minutes to write an order and figure out what
you're going to do. So the two teams are sitting here with their map chart and they're using,
sometimes they might use actual models. So we have a collection of some of these little model,
just very simple metal ships to kind of show the positions of where everybody's at. And you can see
how they're numbered. So you can use those to refer to different squadrons or however you divide
up your fleet. So you can do that. You can show them on here and they have tables that tell them
how far each ship can move in a certain amount of time. They've got things, they keep track of
things like fuel consumption. So in a small tactical level game, you're probably not going
to be worried too much about tracking fuel. But if the game represents a scenario that happens over
days or even weeks, then fuel is something you want to track because your ships might run out
of gas and that can be a big problem. So this chart tells you by looking at the graph here,
and everybody starts out at 100. So they would have one of these for each ship that they're
playing and it starts out at the top here. And you can see here, this graph is telling you
at a certain speed, this is how you should be plotting your fuel consumption. So the faster you
go, you can see how the fuel is going to exhaust itself much quicker. So they're tracking that for
each ship that they have. And they're going along here once the time that's simulated. So you may
be playing these in real time where they would give you clocks to use. And so if the first
move is say an hour long, then they'll physically, this doesn't have the actual hands of the clock
but if you have the actual clock, you'll just move the hands of the clock to show how much time has
passed. When they were playing larger scenarios, if they did want to play something that was supposed
to represent a multi-day scenario, you obviously don't want to have the players doing that in real
time where they're actually in the game room for three or four days playing it on a one-to-one
scale. So the way they handled that is they gave them different clock templates to use
that were scaled up. So this one, the clock time to real time is four to one.
So what that means basically is each minute of real time that you're playing the game
represents four minutes of game time or of real time. So well, I should say that again.
So one minute of real time equals four minutes of game time. That's what I'm going for.
So that's how you can play a longer, bigger scenario still in a reasonable amount of time
and finish it and get something useful out of it. These games did not generally have
rules for how to win, victory conditions, things like that. That was pretty much up
to the game director to decide when it was time to call the game. Sometimes they didn't,
they didn't really play to the point where there was a clear winner or somebody had come out ahead.
If they were just playing it to prove a point or to practice a certain type of operation or
maneuver, sometimes that was enough. So they didn't even bother trying to make a determination
of somebody had won the game or not. But sometimes they can just do a simple tally of how many ships
were sunk or total up all the damage that was done and then try to come up with something like
that. But there wasn't a score. They didn't keep track of any kind of points or other ways to
determine victory. It was pretty much a judgment call based on the damage done in the game about
if you wanted to declare a winner or not. So to figure out what has happened in the move.
Once you turn in your move, the umpires are going to plot on their plot where other ships have
moved. Then if you are close enough to see another ship or they tell you've detected a
ship, you can write on your order that you're going to shoot. They have a form that you fill
out that says what type of weapon you're firing, how many rounds or how many missiles you're firing,
which target you're shooting at, and specify exactly what you want to have happen there.
And so then to figure out what the result of all that is, they have a booklet full of tables.
And you can see here this one is for specifically shooting at destroyers. So they have these for
cruisers, aircraft carriers, you know, any other ship type that they might have in this scenario.
They've got a chart made up that shows over the top here you're looking at what type of weapon
you're firing. And then you're going to cross-reference that on the side with the range
to the target. And the number that you get in there is giving you a number that tells you how
much damage is done. Now the judgment call part of this comes into sometimes with these games.
In order to speed it up and to make play easier, they simply took that number and said, okay,
that's the amount of damage you did. It was a fixed number. So there was no chance,
there was no randomness involved. It was just you knew exactly what would happen
if you fired at a certain ship from a certain range.
If you didn't want everything to be necessarily predetermined though, there were
allowances for using dice to modify that result. So you might do a little bit more, a little bit
less. You could also have mishaps. Like with missile launches, there was always a chance that
the missile might malfunction. And so they might roll a die to determine if that were going to
happen. So these particular games used, believe it or not, a 20-sided die to come up with that.
The strange thing too is that these were all based on basic 1 to 100 percentages.
So even though there are 20 faces on this die, the results are really just you're rolling two dice
and getting results from 1 to 10. And the first number being the 10s digit, the second number
being the 1s digit. So you would roll two dice and if you got a 9 and a 1, that was like a 91.
Meaning if there was a 91% chance that something would happen, then you got it if you rolled
anywhere from 1 to 91. So each number is printed on here twice on a 20-sided die. So instead of
using a 10-sided die, they included 20-sided dice and just had the same result twice on the die.
So that's one way that they could introduce randomness and unpredictability into because
they did want to make these games very much a tool for training people to think on their feet.
So not knowing the result ahead of time and not knowing what could happen forces you to think on
your feet and to come up with alternative plans when that missile doesn't fire or the gun,
the shell doesn't hit the target or their torpedo malfunctions and it's a dud.
Anything like that. So you go through these various tables. There's another table here for
so this one is to a chance of if the shot has penetrated the ship what chances are that that
will cause the ship to sink. So there's a table for that. There's tables for a lot of different
things in here but it's meant to be something that's very easy to reference and to look on here
and to roll the die if you need to and then figure out the final result.
The umpires again are the ones doing that. The players are not doing that.
They are just simply being told what happens in very general terms. So sometimes you know if you
get say a chance hit on an enemy ship that happens to penetrate down to the engine room and it
explodes and sinks the ship they might just tell the other player that you know you see one ship
explode and it's not there but it's obscured by a cloud of smoke or something like that and you
don't necessarily know what has happened you know is it just damaged or is it actually out of you
know sunk completely. That's more so the case I'd say when ships are just damaged and not sunk.
They might say well you can see that you did two hits on the ship but they're not going to tell
you how much damage you caused to the ship only that you scored two hits. So you don't necessarily
know well I've got to get three more hits to sink it and it's it's all part of that process of
training the players to think how much firepower should I allocate to that one target or should
I shift to somebody else. There are a lot of unknowns they deal with. Cool so let's um now
that we've kind of described what's on the table can we pivot to like continue to talk but over
there there's like a games in progress. Yeah sure yeah so this in this case we've got a kind of
representation of one of these early tabletop games as it might be laid out in practice here.
So you can see kind of what's what's going on some of the tools that they use to govern the
movement of the ships that you can see here are are nice to have out. So they they're using things
that are pretty much like simple protractors and measuring tools to decide exactly how the ships
can move. This one in here in particular is showing you when a ship is going at a certain
speed which you see on the numbers there on each line that's showing you how tight the ship can
turn if it's making a turning movement. So the faster you're going the the harder it is to turn.
It's basically the lesson there and it's showing you. You would use different tools that again are
like protractors to measure the bearing to a target. Most of the damage tables gave you a
better chance to do damage if you're hitting the ship basically at more of a 90 degree angle and
if you're hitting it more bow on or on the stern then you're going to be doing less damage because
it's more of a glancing blow than a head-on shot. For some of the uh no so I was going to look at
these range sticks but those are for like the bigger the not these games those are used in
well here so yeah and for a tabletop game they would have little measuring tape kind of devices
that look just like a measuring tape today to figure out the ranges for where they were firing
at. For the larger games that were more played on like a basketball sized floor they might have a
range wand like this that's almost like a souped up yardstick or something much larger than that
and you can see the increments here that again have the ranges printed on them so you can play a
much much bigger game with this but the idea is the same you're just basically have tools that
let you measure ranges measure angles for aircraft to measure height above the ocean or the water or
the surface wherever they're playing to be able to figure out all the modifiers that go into these
tables to tell you what has happened when you're shooting at somebody. I'm going to put this back
up before I break it so yeah this is just a nice you know again the sample of a simple wargaming kit
that was used for to train officers to think about potential battle tactics tactical operational
scenarios they might be involved in in a real world situation. It always kind of strikes me how
how simple the tools are certainly they had computerized war games by now not ones that
were easy to pack up and take with them the way this is so for these portable games they're
definitely paper little metal models physical games that are easy to use but
the rules are certainly a little more complex a little more detailed there's more math involved
but at the end of the day they're not that different from board games that you and I have
probably paid things like Stratego and Risk or Battleship they're at that same kind of idea
but certainly more detailed more realistic as realistic as they can make them but it's just a
simple tool that the Navy uses to always kind of have officers in that mindset of thinking about
what they would do in a real world situation and this is a very easy way to train them to do that.
