Raw Vs Cooked Pet Food Which Is Better

Pet health
8 followers
11 Video Views·Apr 8, 2026
Both are natural, fresh food diets...but which is better for your pet?
What's better, cooked pet food or raw pet food?
Both are healthy, natural diets that can be incredibly nutritious.
But which one should you feed your pet?
Cooked pet food has a lot of familiar ingredients in it.
You'll see things like grains, meat, and vegetables take up most of the meal.
You may also see things like fish, eggs, and added supplements.
Raw meals, however, may look less familiar to some people.
You'll see body parts like necks, chunks of meat, and slimy organs.
Sometimes you'll even see seafood like fish and shellfish.
Raw and cooked diets are pretty different.
So to figure out which one is better, we're gonna compare them across four areas.
Convenience, safety, cost, and ingredient quality.
With a score of 10 being the best and 1 being the worst.
Let's start with convenience.
If you wanna feed homemade food, it will require a little more effort on your end.
You'll need to shop for ingredients, prepare the meal yourself,
which means cutting, weighing, and portioning everything out.
Then cleaning everything up afterwards.
When it comes to homemade raw food, it can take more time to clean and
sanitize all the utensils, surfaces, and containers that you used.
Some pet owners love having all of this control.
But many others just don't feel like they have the time for that.
So homemade raw food lands at a 3 out of 10 for convenience.
Now with homemade cooked food,
there is one extra step that you don't have with homemade raw food.
And that's, of course, cooking it.
But the cleanup may take a little less time because you're not handling raw meat for
very long before cooking it.
So homemade cooked food is a 3 out of 10 as well.
Now if that sounds like way too much effort, pre-made food may be a better option.
Pre-made cooked and raw food companies did all of this prep work for you.
All you have to do is go out and buy it and
keep it frozen until a day or two before feeding it so it stays fresh.
So pre-made raw and cooked both land around a 6 when it comes to convenience.
The next section is safety.
Because no matter how great the diet is, if it's handled wrong,
this could make you or your pet sick.
When many people think of raw meat-based diets, they think of bacteria and
parasites.
So naturally, a lot of pet owners wonder, is this even safe to feed pets?
Well, dogs and cats are built to handle raw meat and bone pretty efficiently.
They have sharp teeth meant for ripping and tearing flesh.
And their digestive system is short and highly acidic, which helps them break
down raw meat and bone and deal with the bacteria that comes with it.
So for them, eating fresh raw meat isn't usually an issue.
Raw meat sold in stores are also regulated and inspected for safety.
In places like the US, raw meat, poultry, and eggs are inspected for
bacteria levels before they ever make it to shelves or in pet food.
In fact, if bacteria limits are exceeded,
companies can be forced to stop production or even recall products.
Still, the risk of bacteria isn't zero,
because raw meat does naturally come with that risk.
But the fear of bacteria in fresh raw meat is often a bit exaggerated.
Okay, well, what about parasites?
It's kind of the same story as bacteria.
In countries like the US, Canada, and the EU,
animals are raised in controlled conditions and inspected before slaughter.
After slaughter, the meat is rapidly chilled or
frozen to kill off any possible parasites.
So parasites in store-bought meat, as well as for pet food use, are very rare.
Nonetheless, you still need to be careful when preparing and feeding raw meals.
For homemade raw food, you'll need to prepare your pet's meals within a few
days of buying raw meat, or else it might spoil.
It's also important to keep meals frozen until a day or two before feeding it.
This keeps the meat fresh.
And don't forget to clean anything that the raw meat touched so
you don't get sick.
Because of that extra handling and responsibility,
homemade raw lands at a four for safety.
With homemade cooked food,
you will still have to handle raw meat when preparing meals.
But once it's cooked, bacteria isn't really a huge risk.
So homemade cooked food gets a score of six.
Now, if you're someone who wants nothing to do with handling and
cutting up raw meat, then pre-made food is a better option.
Just thaw the package, scoop some food out, and serve it.
For those of you who are still worried about bacteria in pre-made raw,
you can buy raw foods that's gone through high pressure pasteurization,
which pretty much kills all the bacteria.
Or you could just feed cooked food.
So pre-made raw lands at a five,
since it requires much less handling than homemade raw.
And pre-made cooked lands at an eight,
since you don't have to handle raw meat at all.
Okay, these next two categories are usually what decide everything.
Whether someone chooses cooked or raw food, pre-made or homemade, or
even whether they stick with fresh food at all, cost and ingredient quality.
Let's start with cost.
This is where homemade cooked and raw diets really shine,
because you have complete control over how much you spend.
You can choose cheaper proteins, buy in bulk, shop sales, and
basically just work with what you've got.
In fact, many homemade diets actually end up being cheaper
than feeding high-end dry and canned foods.
But between raw and cooked, there are a few things that can affect the price.
For example, raw diets don't include much vegetables and never include grains.
It's exclusively meat, bone, organ, and other animal-based foods.
Meat is more expensive than plant-based ingredients, so raw can be a bit pricier
if it's compared to a cooked diet with a lot of plant-based foods.
So when it comes to cost, homemade raw lands around an eight.
Now, homemade cooked food.
Maybe you've seen some cooked recipes online that look pretty cheap to feed.
For example, this one for dogs.
It's just ground turkey, brown rice, and a frozen mix of broccoli, carrots, and cauliflower.
Then some random dried rosemary for, I don't know, it to smell good?
Yes, this is cheap.
But recipes like this are severely low in nutrients that dogs need to stay healthy.
So if you built a cooked diet that's properly complete and balanced,
the cost can end up being pretty similar to raw food,
even when including plant-based foods.
A big reason for this is because cooked diets need leaner,
pricier cuts of meat because too much cooked fat can cause GI upset.
Cooked diets also require a few additional supplements.
So I'd put homemade cooked food at an eight as well.
Then there's pre-made raw and cooked food.
And this is where pre-made food is at a big disadvantage.
Because pre-made raw and cooked diets can
easily be some of the most expensive ways to feed your pet.
For example, if we're using chicken as the main protein
and looking at the price for a 50-pound adult dog,
a popular cooked brand like The Farmer's Dog would cost $8.13 a day.
And another popular brand, Ollie, would cost $8.66 a day.
For pre-made raw, which uses little to no plant-based ingredients,
comes out to around $8.89 a day when feeding We Feed Raw
and $8.13 a day when feeding Viva Raw.
If we compare this to homemade food, a homemade raw diet for that same 50-pound dog
that includes multiple proteins would be closer to $4.17 a day.
And a homemade cooked diet like this would be closer to $5.11 a day.
So when it comes to cost, both commercial raw and cooked food score a two.
And finally, ingredient quality.
Ingredients are the main reason why people switch to cooked and raw food in the first place.
Because it's fresh, real food.
But which has better ingredients, cooked or raw?
Let's start with homemade raw food.
Unlike dry and canned foods, which are heavily processed and rely on powdered meats and grains,
homemade raw food is made of fresh meat in its natural, raw state
that supplies nutrients your pet's body needs.
Bone helps clean teeth and supports strong bones.
Meat builds and maintains muscle.
Organs provide essential vitamins and minerals.
And beneficial bacteria and enzymes support gut health and the immune system,
which is unique to raw diets.
In an unprocessed, natural state, raw meat, bone, and organs provide the most
bioavailable nutrients, meaning your pet's body can easily absorb and use those nutrients.
So when it comes to ingredient quality, homemade raw gets a solid 10.
Now, what happens when you cook the food?
Well, some ingredients do change.
For example, the bone.
Cooked bone is dangerous for pets to eat,
so bone needs to be replaced with something like bone meal or seaweed calcium.
Some nutrients are also lost when the meat is cooked.
A big one being B vitamins.
They're water-soluble and found in the meat's juices.
And when those juices are lost during cooking, those vitamins go with them.
Taurine, which is important for cats, is sensitive to heat and oxygen.
So that's another nutrient that'll have to be supplemented back in.
Heat-sensitive fats like omega-3s can oxidize during cooking and become less beneficial.
And fat itself changes too.
Fat is needed for energy, but once it's cooked, it becomes harder to digest.
This is why many cooked diets rely on rice and potatoes for energy.
But this is a problem, because rice and potatoes lack nutrients that dogs and cats need.
So, since some nutrients are lost when cooked,
and grains take up a big portion of many recipes,
homemade cooked food lands around a 7 when it comes to ingredient quality.
Now, premade food.
Starting with raw.
When you look at the ingredients list, you'll often see bone, a single protein,
one, maybe two organs, and maybe a few other animal-based ingredients.
It's nice to see an ingredients list without a bunch of unnecessary fillers.
But most premade foods don't include many organ meats,
which really helps make the food more nutritious.
The fewer the animal-based ingredients there are,
the more the food has to rely on supplements to fill those gaps.
And supplements have their downsides.
They're basically synthetic forms of nutrients.
And on paper, they do help meet a dog or cat's nutrient requirement.
But the body doesn't always absorb isolated,
synthetic versions of nutrients the same way it does nutrients from whole foods.
So, because it includes less animal-based ingredients and leans more on synthetic nutrients,
premade raw gets a rating of 8 when it comes to ingredient quality.
With premade cooked food, ingredients aren't looking much better.
Cooked diets also rely on synthetic nutrients.
And they have a lot more plant-based ingredients like vegetables and grains.
These foods do contain nutrients.
But dogs and cats aren't built to consume a ton of plant-based ingredients.
Their bodies produce fewer starch-digesting enzymes than humans and herbivores.
So a lot of those nutrients aren't even absorbed.
So premade cooked drops closer to a 5.
Now, it's time to determine the winner.
Premade raw and premade cooked actually came in at a tie.
Coming in at second, with 3 points higher than premade food, is homemade cooked food.
And coming in at number one, with just 1 point higher than homemade cooked, is homemade raw.
Now, all of these foods are great options.
And much better than processed, dry, and canned foods.
And really, it all just comes down to what you value more.
If you just want to feed your pet a fresh, whole food diet,
and don't mind paying for the convenience of it being made for you,
then premade raw or cooked food is definitely the best option.
But for someone like me, I want to provide the most bioavailable nutrients,
I don't mind the extra effort,
and I'm comfortable working with raw ingredients to keep things as natural as possible.
So homemade raw is my top choice.
If this sounds like you, but you have no idea where to start,
then my beginner guides on how to feed your dog or cat a raw diet is exactly what you should watch next.
