Manager vs Leader Which One Are You Actually Being

Professional Development
12 followers
8 Video Views·Apr 7, 2026
Are you just managing your team or truly leading them? This video reveals the difference between leadership and management. Discover the Leadership traits that transform managers into inspiring leaders, understand the difference between management and leadership, and learn practical strategies to cultivate leadership at any level.
Do you worry whether you're leading your team or are you just managing them,
especially if you're looking to get ahead into those more senior roles?
In this video, I'm going to show you exactly how to tell if you have that special leadership spark.
And don't worry if you think you're just a manager right now. I've helped hundreds of
people transform from having a manager mindset into being inspiring leaders and I can help you
will discover the real difference between management and leadership plus the exact
traits that I think separate true leaders from managers. Trust me, what I'm about to
share might completely change how you see yourself and your potential. Let's start
by understanding the difference between management and leadership. I was working
in a consumer products company with some teams. There were two team leaders handling similar
teams and similar projects. The first leader, James, was just so incredibly organized. He had
detailed project plans. He tracked every deadline and ensured everyone followed the processes
perfectly. His team met all the targets, but they worked in, I suppose, quite a mechanical way. They
did what they were asked to do. But when an issue came up, they immediately looked to James to solve
it. And on the whole, James did it indeed quite well. Then there was Sam. He was not as experienced
as James, but he had this ability to get his team excited about their work. He was always sharing
stories about how their projects would help customers and encourage that his team members
to suggest better ways of doing things. While James's team met expectations, Sam's team consistently
exceeded them, not because they were forced to, because they wanted to. And I think this demonstrates
how management is about controlling processes, while leadership is about inspiring people to
achieve more than maybe they thought possible. So managers focus on planning and organizing tasks,
prioritizing and delegating work, meeting deadlines and objectives, and following established
processes and procedures. In other words, making sure the work gets done. While leaders focus on
creating vision and direction, inspiring and motivating others, driving change and encouraging
new ways of doing things, and building empowering relationships and trust. Think of it this way,
a manager ensures the team follows the process correctly, but the leader questions whether it's
even the right process to begin with. It doesn't matter what level you are in an organization,
anyone can demonstrate leadership qualities. And in fact, I'm a firm believer in leadership
at all levels. So whether you're an intern, an individual contributor, a middle manager,
or a senior leader, true leadership isn't about your position or your title. I've seen entry-level
employees inspire and guide their peers, and I've witnessed executives at the top who struggle with
the basic leadership concepts. There's a common misconception that managers manage and leaders
lead. If we look a little deeper at how both management and leadership play in the different
organizational levels, we can see that they are both there. So let's firstly look at supervisors.
Their management focus is on day-to-day tasks, getting things done, scheduling, and immediate
problem solving. However, they show leadership by mentoring team members, building team cohesion,
and translating their high-level goals into meaningful action. While most of their time
is spent on management, leveraging their leadership skills can significantly improve
their team performance. Next, middle managers. Now for management, they're often coordinating
multiple teams. They're implementing processes, setting goals and strategies, prioritizing work,
and ensuring that the departmental goals are met. In leadership, they foster cross-team
collaboration. They're guiding on blocking obstacles, coaching, and developing future
leaders. They bring the strategic initiatives to life. And finally, senior leaders. They manage
by setting the organizational structure, establishing policies and priorities,
and overseeing resource allocation. When it comes to leadership, they create the long-term vision
and strategy, shape and model company culture, and inspire the organization to achieve its goals.
The key difference is that while management responsibilities exist at each level,
the need for leadership grows the more senior you go up the organization, because the number
of people you can lead and influence just goes up. This is why learning and nurturing leadership
skills at all levels is so important. Not only will it help you develop faster in your career,
you will get better results and engage better and with more people. Which brings me to the
signs that show you are already leading. These are really the mindsets and competencies of leadership,
and the more you adopt them, the more leadership influence and impact you will have. In my corporate
days, if there was one thing that I looked for in my team when I was looking for future leadership
talent, it was this. Work and leadership, I like to think, is about two things, people and problems.
Work gets done by people, and problems, they never stop, do they? So some people see the problems,
talk about the problems, but wait to be told what to do about them, whilst other people are what I
call proactive problem solvers, and I bloody love them. You are a proactive problem solver if you
see opportunities where others see obstacles. You stay calm under pressure when solving issues.
You're proactive, so you see what needs to be done and you just get on and do it, and you don't stay
in the hierarchy. You know who to talk to in other teams and departments to cut through issues and get
things done. The result is, over time, people end up coming to you for a solution. This is a vital
mindset of leadership, and natural leaders are just proactive problem solvers who don't wait
for permission. They see what needs to be done and they just start doing it. One of my daughters has
a weekend job in a garden centre, which she's had for the last two years, and she has become the person
who trains the other weekend staff on how to use the tills, the policies, and how to do the job well.
She refers to her team of weekend colleagues as my girls and demonstrates the next sign,
even though she's only 18 years old. The second sign is that you genuinely care about other people
and them succeeding in their role. You genuinely find joy in their success. You naturally support
and mentor team members. You're invested in helping them reach their potential and you will
have the difficult conversation, even if you don't want to or feel nervous about it, but because
you know it will help them succeed in their role faster. So sign two is that leaders find that they
genuinely care about the success and naturally mentor those around them. The next sign that
you're an actual leader is that you have great communication skills. Now this skill I always
think can sound a bit like blah blah blah because it's no surprise that if you're leading well,
you need to communicate well, but the challenge of communication is that it's a habitual skill
and what we may have developed bad or less effective communication skills over time and we
can be completely unaware of it. If I were to put my finger on what are the communication skills that
really differentiate the best leaders, I think it's this. During a recent workshop with a senior team,
I noticed just one person who just stood out. So while the others were all talking about the topic,
I could see she was fully present and when she spoke, she asked really thoughtful questions
reflecting what others had said. Everyone listened. She just had fantastic impact. So the third sign
of a natural leader is that you listen. As a consequence, people feel heard when talking with
you. You ask thoughtful follow-up questions and you remember important details about conversations
which helps you connect ideas and frame problems well. What these leaders do is listen to fully
understand, not just respond and they ask lots of questions. To assess how well you do this,
it's essential to become conscious for a little while about how you communicate. So ask yourself,
do you talk more than you listen? And in your conversations, who talks the most? This simple
check will usually tell you if you need to focus on and practice on your communication skills.
Years ago in my corporate life, there was a perfect example of this next sign and it is one that we
can all easily fall into if we're not careful. There was a situation where a team member shared
confidential information about some upcoming organisational changes with a few colleagues.
While this information was like wildfire and it quickly spread through the informal channels
and it created so much anxiety and speculation. It's all anyone wants to talk about. Now when
the official announcement finally came out, the damage was already done. Trust had been broken,
not just between people in the leaders but in the team. And what made this situation particularly
damaging was that some of the initial information shared was completely inaccurate, leading to a
necessary worry. It took months of consistent transparent communication from the new team
leaders to rebuild the trust that had been lost in just a few conversations. Now this perfectly
illustrates how gossip and breaching confidentiality can quickly unravel the trust in the team.
Natural leaders understand this. Trust is like oil in the engine of leadership. It takes a long
time to build and it can be lost in a moment. But the more you can build trust with individuals and
across your team, the better the teamwork will be. Trust building is important as a leader and signs
that you can do this well include you're consistent in your words and your actions. You trust others
and as a result you find that people naturally confide in you and you maintain confidentiality
and keep out of the gossip and all that negative stuff. So the fourth sign is that you build trust
easily. This next sign of leadership is particularly important in our world of constant
change and uncertainty. In 2006, Carol Dweck's book Mindset introduced us to the principle of a
growth mindset. Now this powerful belief system recognizes that skills and talents can be developed
through focused effort, learning and guidance from others. So when you adopt a growth mindset, you see
challenges as opportunities for learning and actively learn from your mistakes. You understand
that hard work and persistence are crucial for success. You're not discouraged by failure and
viewing it as a chance to improve and consequently stay optimistic during challenges. You're willing
to seek guidance and you learn from feedback. But here's the powerful impact of this mindset.
By bouncing back from failures, you develop resilience. This resilience in times of change
and uncertainty is vital for your mental health and your ability not just to cope but to thrive.
So side five of being a natural leader is that you view challenges as learning opportunities
and as a consequence you're resilient in the face of setbacks. At this point you may be asking
if these mindset and skills are learnable and the answer is yes and they're even more attainable
if you have this final sign of being a good leader in place. So when I run workshops, I always ask
what's the biggest challenge that leaders face and the answer is nearly always the same, time.
They tell me they just don't have enough of it and feel like they're always on the back foot.
Now President Dwight D. Eisenhower had a lot on his plate not just as the 34th U.S. President
but also as the U.S. Army General leading the Allied Forces in Europe during the Second World
War. I imagine he felt pressed for time yet he created a time management concept to help him
prioritize and manage the numerous high-stakes issues that he faced throughout his career
and decades later the author Stephen Covey in his book Seven Habits of Highly Effective People
took Eisenhower's concept on and developed it into the widely recognized Eisenhower Matrix.
This is a gem of a thinking and planning tool yet many managers don't know about it or don't use it
but those who do are showing natural leaders by number six. They manage their time effectively
while ensuring that they have space to think about strategic challenges and actions that will
strengthen their leadership. Let me explain how. So the Eisenhower Matrix helps prioritize tasks
based on two dimensions urgency and importance and it divides tasks into four quadrants. So the
first quadrant is urgent and important which is short-term issues pressing their minds and
emergencies. The second quadrant is important but not urgent. Now this incredibly valuable box
covers strategic planning, relationship building and personal development. The third quadrant is
urgent but not important and this includes some meetings, routine tasks and some emails. Quadrant
four is neither urgent nor important and this often fills up with time-wasting activities,
inefficient work and even more non-essential emails. One of the biggest challenges that managers face
is spending too much time on the urgent side of the matrix. Constantly putting out fires,
dealing with issues, this reactive approach leaves little time for true leadership activities
that typically fall into the important but non-urgent quadrant. So true leaders understand
the importance of prioritizing the non-urgent but important tasks that prevent future crises,
solve bigger challenges and drive long-term success. They create systems to manage their
time well. They delegate effectively to reduce time spent in the urgent zone allowing them to
focus on strategic thinking, team development and innovation. So what these leaders are doing is
creating systems that make leadership more sustainable. As a result they ask themselves
the right questions at the right time which helps them to be even more effective problem solvers,
think about the needs of their teams and stakeholders and build trust. They also have
time to focus on their personal development. Now if you're wondering how they do that, what would go
into an effective leaders planning system? In this video I'll share the exact framework I use
with my coaching clients to strengthen their leadership planning skills and as a consequence
their natural leadership abilities. So I'd go there next.
