Abusive Practices in Global Economic Expansion (virtual) - Hon. Matt Pottinger

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
1 Video View·Apr 6, 2026
20th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum | Washington, D.C 🇺🇸 | December 6, 2021
-Hon. Matt Pottinger
Former Deputy National Security Advisor (virtual)
It was a terrific short speech by the congressman. Thanks for making those remarks and
thanks for reminding us that this competition is about our values. It's about a lot of our
traditions. It's about a very different kind of system, a totalitarian system. I used to refer to
China's system as authoritarian, but it really goes beyond that now. I think that once you've
immersed yourself, as the congressman clearly has, in all that China is trying to achieve and the
means by which it's trying to achieve it, the Communist Party's aims, you realize that this
is actually about a competition between very different systems. I think it's very hard to
find a word other than totalitarianism to describe what the Chinese Communist Party
is about today in particular. We've now seen, with the rise of China's leader Xi Jinping,
and more recently, just last month, the Communist Party's reassessment of its own history. Remember,
the Chinese Communist Party is 100 years old, and Xi Jinping has just undertaken what is only the
third official reassessment of their history, formal reassessment of their history. What he's
done in that revision of their history has been to close the door on the era of reform and opening
that we grew up in. The idea that Deng Xiaoping, when he came to power at the end of the 1970s,
following the cataclysms of Mao Zedong's cult of personality rule, the Great Leap Forward,
and the attendant famine, the largest famine in human history, the decade-long cultural revolution,
Deng Xiaoping emerged and allowed the unleashing of market forces, at least to the extent that
China was able to go from a total backwater, with less than a dollar a day in per capita GDP
terms, to becoming the world's second largest economy. What Xi Jinping remarkably has done now
has been to shut the door on that era, and to make very clear that the reform and opening era
of Deng Xiaoping is over. And the vision that he is now pursuing, and that the party under him is
pursuing, is one that in many ways goes back to the period before Deng Xiaoping and reform and
opening. It is a period that he calls common prosperity, which has a nice sound to it until
you start to really look under the hood at what it really means and its implementation. It is
one that begins to close the door on market forces, and to put the powers of the party,
to inject those powers into all aspects of regular life in China, the economic life,
political life, now increasingly the cultural life as well, and to make sure that what the
party is really pursuing is the demand for loyalty to Xi Jinping personally. So, we're
going back to something more reminiscent of the cult of personality politics of Mao Zedong.
The competition for us really boils down to what the congressman will do too, which is
having the courage of our own convictions and holding fast to our values, and realizing that
our values are actually one of the most potent instruments that we have in our competition with
China, particularly given that China's view, what it really stands for is its own power, and
beyond that it's a rather hollow vision. But it also comes down to three areas that I just
want to touch on briefly, and that is the competition for capital flows, technology,
and data. And I think that as we, in countries that enjoy the rule of law,
countries that aspire to have or enjoy democracy, these are the areas that we really need to
focus on. So, what we have in the way of technology is a competition for semiconductors.
It's critical that the West invests heavily into our own ability to conduct not only R&D,
but the actual manufacturing of semiconductors. All of the other technologies of this era rest
on the pillar of semiconductors. Second is the capital flows. Now, Beijing, as you've seen,
is beginning to actually decouple its companies from U.S. capital markets. It doesn't want to
be regulated anymore by U.S. companies, by U.S. regulators or the U.S. stock markets,
but it wants to continue to tap the flow of American capital, and most of that capital
is flowing impassively through the indices. I think it's beyond time for the Securities
Exchange Commission and members of Congress to begin investigating the major index providers,
MSCI, many others that have weighted Chinese companies heavily, so that American capital
now passively flows into Chinese companies, including companies that are committing human
rights atrocities, including companies that are at the forefront of China's military industrial
complex, and including many companies that are actually sanctioned by the U.S. government.
So, we sanction Chinese companies, we forbid exports to certain Chinese companies,
but we don't forbid Americans from investing. And that's what's happening with American pension
funds. It's what's happening with endowments that are investing American savings into these
Chinese companies unbeknownst to those American savers themselves. Finally is in the area of data.
Beijing is seeking to become the world's greatest data broker. We are playing into that by not
coming up with a holistic strategy that would allow free market rule of law democracies to
share data with one another in order to promote innovation. But we should be rolling off that data
from China. China is very easily accessing our most intimate data, whether it's our DNA records,
or our online habits, or the supply chain flows of our companies. So, those are really the three
areas where those are the three fronts that we need to be fighting on. Data, capital flows,
and technology flows. Thanks very much. Well, thank you, Mr. Pottinger for that very
helpful and concise overview of China in the last 20, 30 years. Let's go to our next speaker.
You're welcome to come up to the podium or you can stay in your seat.
