Halberds and Hooks [Weapons of Ancient China] | China Documentary

Discovered in China
13 followers
The formerly prosperous Eastern Han Dynasty had become a crumbling empire
plagued by continuous conflict among warlords.
In 215 A.D., Sun Quan, leader of the Kingdom of Wu, attacked Hefei.
Hefei was an important city in the territory of Cao Cao, leader of the Kingdom of Wei.
Instead of organizing a defense and waiting for assistance,
General Zheng Liao led a small group of just 800 warriors
to attack Sun Quan's forces before they could set up camp.
Zheng Liao, wearing armor and holding a halberd,
raced towards Sun Quan, who decided to run for his life.
This incident was described in the records of the Three Kingdoms.
This encounter made Zheng Liao's iron halberd and his bravery famous.
A halberd is a unique and highly effective ancient Chinese weapon.
For more than eight centuries, it was standard issue for Chinese armies.
Zhou Zhengwu, ancient weapons expert, is recreating this weapon.
A halberd is a combination of lance and dagger axe.
It was originally made of expensive bronze.
In the Han Dynasty, newly developed steel took the place of bronze.
This type of carbon steel went through many stages of tempering
to remove impurities from the iron.
To ensure it was strong enough, the head and body of the halberd
were usually made of a single piece of steel.
To demonstrate its power, we've invited martial artist
Cheng Yugeng to carry out a test.
Cheng Yugeng is an expert with a spear.
Now he's going to show how powerful a legendary halberd can be.
The halberd was created when chariots were used in battle.
The warriors in the chariots were traditionally armed with lances and dagger axes.
The halberd was created to take advantage of the strength
of both a lance and a dagger axe.
With a halberd, a soldier only needed to carry one weapon,
one that combined the functions of a lance and a dagger axe.
One strike, two push, three fold, four cut.
And when the two sides are at war,
when the two sides are at war,
the halberd can turn around and make a hook.
So it has five basic moves.
Its power was often noted in historical texts.
We will now demonstrate how powerful these techniques are.
Since both the halberd and the spear are good at stabbing,
we're going to do a comparison test
using a pig carcass with leather armor to represent a human.
We want to see if the halberd can penetrate the armor.
The power of the spear is very strong.
It didn't take much effort to pierce through the leather armor.
It penetrated through the body armor.
The leather armor didn't do much.
It must have been fatal on the battlefield.
The design of the halberd limits its effectiveness
for directly piercing an enemy's body.
A different technique is to peck the enemy
with the halberd's branched blade,
much like a woodpecker pecking a tree.
This is a powerful and effective technique.
The halberd is certainly a lethal weapon.
But so far, we haven't seen much advantage
over a lance or a dagger axe.
We may not have found the right technique to maximize its power.
Warriors of all ages and backgrounds
Warriors using halberds and dagger axes
were often called hook soldiers.
Perhaps the major function of these two weapons
was to hook the enemy instead of piercing or pecking them.
According to the book of Sun Tzu,
someone hooked on the neck by a halberd
would lose all their fingers.
It turns out that all other techniques
could be turned into a hooking technique,
especially when the initial strike is ineffective.
When the warrior pulls his halberd back,
it naturally becomes a hook.
When he strikes the target with the hooking technique,
it makes a cut about eight centimeters deep.
In the Eastern Zhou Dynasty,
the halberd was the go-to weapon for the army
because of its effectiveness in battle.
Our tests have shown
that the halberd was a very versatile weapon,
combining the functions of both spear and dagger axe.
Its many strengths
helped it become the most popular weapon of the era.
As use of the halberd became more common,
soldiers became known as halberd carriers.
During the Warring States period,
a famous war strategist
even described the army of the Kingdom of Chu
as a million halberd carriers.
A strange stone carving was discovered in Jiangsu Province
that has mystified the experts.
It clearly depicts a warrior with a halberd
next to a man naked from the waist up.
His armor and strange hook and shield weapon
lay on the ground.
The hook and shield is a weapon
that combines a long hook
and a small shield mounted on the shaft.
Like weapons made in the Han Dynasty,
it was made of strong steel.
It's hard to see how such a strange weapon
could be effective in actual battle.
It looks more like something used in some religious rite,
but it makes more sense as a weapon
that was somehow effective in battle.
We tried several techniques
based on the way it's held
and the sharpest part of the blade,
but the results were far from ideal.
The ancient Chinese military book Wei Liaozi
notes that an arrow can kill someone
from 100 paces or more,
but a lance or halberd
requires a distance of less than 50 paces.
This means that an army
would be attacked first by arrows.
We set up two rubber dummy targets,
one with a regular shield
and the other with a hook and shield weapon.
We fired six arrows at each
to see how effective they were against arrows.
The regular shield successfully blocked all six arrows,
but the hook and shield blocked only one,
allowing the five other arrows
to hit the rubber dummy.
And Cheng Zajian are now going to simulate a fight
between one person armed with a hook and shield
and one with a lance.
The two rounds of tests have shown
that this strange weapon is not particularly effective
against arrows or lances.
but it seems possible that it was designed to counter the Halberd.
The stone carving from the turbulent Han Dynasty
seems to indicate that some soldiers with Halberds
encountered opponents they had never seen before.
They were carrying hook and shield weapons
as they awaited the attack of the Han soldiers.
But were they really effective against soldiers armed with Halberds?
Images from the Han Dynasty seem to indicate
that the hook and shield seems to be closely related to the use of the Halberd.
They also give some idea of how the weapon was wielded.
Cheng Yugeng and Cheng Zajian theorized
that its fundamental purpose in battle was to hook the Halberd,
specifically its branched blade.
On the other hand, if the hook failed to engage the Halberd,
the soldier wielding it would be in immediate danger
from the Halberd's powerful blade.
The next step is to see how effective it is
in countering the hooking and pecking techniques of the Halberd.
A soldier would try to hook the Halberd with the weapon in his left hand,
then pull back to get it away from his opponent,
after which he would attack his opponent with the sword in his right hand.
The combination of a hook and shield weapon with a sword
can be effective against a Halberd,
but would require an impractically high level of skill.
With equally matched opponents,
the hook and shield is effective in blocking a Halberd
and opening up an opportunity for a fatal strike.
The tests show that this strange weapon was designed to counter the Halberd.
We can imagine the shock of a group of Halberd carriers 2,000 years ago
as they were about to attack opponents wielding hook and shield weapons.
The enemy would quickly disarm and kill the Halberd carriers.
In a sense, the hook and shield knocked the Halberd off its pedestal.
When the Halberd became the most popular battle weapon,
the hook and shield weapon was created to counter it.
But the Halberd was fairly ineffective
against the stronger harmony that emerged in the Northern and Southern Dynasties.
Along with the hook and shield, it gradually fell out of favor,
to be replaced by the cavalry lance.
But the memory of the competition between the Halberd and the hook and shield weapon
is preserved in those ancient images.
Times of war give rise to better and more effective weaponry.
Two examples are the so-called bright light armor
and the heavier and more powerful lance for mounted soldiers.
Join us for Part 7 of Weapons of Ancient China.
