Brian Keating takes us on an exclusive tour of the Royal Observatory Edinburgh with cosmologist Marcos Pellejero, exploring the mysteries of dark energy and the accelerating universe. From the historic halls where human "computers" shaped the foundations of modern cosmology, to the cutting-edge DESI experiment mapping galaxies across the cosmos, the conversation explores whether dark energy is truly constant—or if our cosmological model is beginning to show cracks.
Key Takeaways: 00:00 "Dark Energy and Cosmic Clues 04:42 Light Pollution Ruins Observatories 07:03 Royal Astronomer's Electric Chair Solution 11:06 "DESI Challenges Vacuum Energy Constant 15:48 Advancing Simulations and Synergies 19:14 Science and Art: Problem Solving 20:29 Exploring Dark Energy's Secrets ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Join this channel to get access to perks like monthly Office Hours: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmXH_moPhfkqCk6S3b9RWuw/join
📚 Get my books: Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with productivity tips from 9 Nobel Prize winners: https://a.co/d/03ezQFu
Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with life-changing interviews with 9 Nobel Prizewinners: https://a.co/d/hi50U9U My tell-all cosmic memoir Losing the Nobel Prize: http://amzn.to/2sa5UpA
The first-ever audiobook from Galileo: Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems: Ptolemaic and Copernican https://a.co/d/iZPi9Un
Some of the strongest evidence that the universe is accelerating doesn't come from one telescope
or a single experiment. It comes from a tiny ripple frozen into how galaxies cluster across the cosmos.
Today, from the Royal Observatory in Edinburgh, we're following that ripple with cosmologist
Marcos Pelleiro to see what it really says about dark energy. I'm Brian Keating and this is an
exclusive tour of the Royal Observatory Edinburgh with cosmologist Marcos Pelleiro. We'll go from
this historic telescope to cutting-edge simulations to the DESI experiment,
one of the most ambitious galaxy surveys ever built, to ask a simple question.
Is dark energy really constant? Or is our entire cosmological model starting to crack?
Long before silicon chips, the computers up here weren't machines. They were people. Often,
they were women hired to comb through photographic plates, measuring every faint smudge of light by
hand. Their names rarely made it into papers, but their measurements are literally baked into
the datasets we still build our modern cosmological models on. This building was
designed as a cathedral for starlight. The telescope sits on a massive pier that sinks
onto the hill, isolated from the floor so footsteps don't shake the images.
As our cities grew brighter, places like this became less useful for frontline observing,
but the engineering mindset behind them is still the same one we still use today
to measure the universe's properties.
Not far from the Simons Observatory.
Okay, and just one more question. Sorry, I know that you have been here for quite a long time.
Do you see any weird wall in this room? Yes. Which one? Why do you think it's weird?
There are two reasons. Well, it has a picture. Yes, this one is weird, but this is a door,
this is not a wall. Welcome to the dome. Do you see something weird in this dome with respect
to other domes that you might have seen? It's not a dome, exactly. It's like a cylinder,
and this relates to what I was saying before, that they were not trying to do a functional
building. They were trying to do a beautiful building, and then they were thinking on
building something that was like a cathedral for science. A cathedral needs towers, right?
Again, this is quite old, and when I was telling you what we would find at the end of that weird
wall, the reason is this thing. This square here goes all the way down and into the hill,
and it is separated from the rest of the building because you need to do very precise observations,
and if this is connected to the rest of the building, then if the building moves,
this moves, right? And you want to avoid that. So basically, what you do is you create a pyramid
that goes, that puts its roots deep into the mountain, and it moves at the least you can.
This specific telescope was built in Newcastle in 1928. Okay, so it's not as old as the
building. This would not be the first telescope that was here, but it's quite old.
And what's the diameter, Marco?
I think this is a 40 centimeters one. This is the primary mirror. 40 centimeters,
I don't know in inches. I have no idea. It's less than, say, 18 inches?
I don't know. 18 inches, yeah.
So actually, I mean, I guess you know quite a lot about telescopes already. The primary mirror is
not here anymore. The secondary mirror, which is up there, you can still see it. That's there.
And the detector is completely missing, right? This is empty. Now, what's the reason for this?
Well, it's basically the same reason why the original observatory was completely useless
by the mid-19th century, which is the cities in Europe started being lighted with electric lights
and not candles, as had happened before. So no fire anymore, okay? So basically,
they were very, very bright. And if you had an observatory close to the city center,
then you could see nothing, right, of the night sky. So they built this one far away from the
city, but the city grew, right? So at some point, the light pollution of the city made this
observatory useless. Not useless, but in comparison to other observatories, basically useless, okay?
Now, not anymore, but since 1975 or so, this was used for checking the stability of detectors.
So they were building detectors in the lab in the other building. They will put them here,
and then they will shake them, basically, to see if there were any loose pieces that they
had forgotten or something like that, okay? Yeah, so that's basically how this worked.
But you have to think about an astronomer in 1895, okay? Basically, coming here with a candle,
right? And then, do you want me to show you how they will open the dome? It's very cool,
because it's just with ropes, and there's no technology, no weird technology happening here.
Come with me, let me show you. So, do you see the wheels? The wheels are all around
the dome, so those will be used to actually rotate the dome, okay? And then, you will have to open
this, and it is as simple as this, even though it's a bit heavy, yes. But that's the way one
will open the dome. Yeah, yeah, very cool, right? Now, what if you want to open it up there,
straight up? Yeah, so the thing is that there's two, right? So one is this one, the other one
is that one. That one will go... Do you see all of the levels there? And so, you will have to use
those. So basically, what I was telling you is that the moment... Okay, so these finders, okay,
so the small telescopes, the ones that basically tell you in which way you're looking at,
are very high, right? So in the moment you tilt this, they are even higher. So to reach them,
you will have to go up a ladder, okay? And the Royal Astronomer will have to go up a ladder.
But he couldn't have his Royal Astronomer as going up a ladder, because he was the Royal
Astronomer, right? So he asked for this to be built, okay? Which is an electric chair,
but a good kind of electric chair, okay? So the one in which you will sit down, and then you will
press the button, and then this will elevate you, okay? And then you can do observations without
having to be up the ladder and so on, which is very cool. If you just threw galaxies into the
universe at random, you'd get a smooth fog of matter. But when you actually map them, you see
a faint preference, a ring, a scale of about 150 megaparsecs left over from sound waves in the
early universe. But these patterns are called baryon acoustic oscillations, and they behave
like a cosmic ruler for measuring how fast the universe has been expanding. So first of all,
what's a baryon acoustic oscillation, Marco? Well, baryon acoustic oscillations, well,
first of all, the way I like to think about them is how galaxies are distributed in the universe,
okay? Because they don't follow just random patterns. They have very distinctive patterns,
and the first one that catches your eye is basically this cosmic web that you know about.
It's a secondary answer, which is like, yes, closer, but also when you are at a distance of around 150
megaparsecs, then you find, again, a greater likelihood of finding a galaxy. When you have
these kind of patterns, it's usually, the reason why they appear is because you have some kind of
border or frontier. Turning BAO into numbers isn't just about counting galaxies. You have to know
what the universe should look like if your dark energy theory is right. That means running huge
n-body simulations, and Marcus works on emulators that use neural networks to mimic those
simulations in a fraction of the time, so he can explore many more possible universes than ever
before. So one of the, okay, one of the main problems to study the distribution of galaxies
nowadays is that the gravity formation is very non-linear, and by this I mean that it comes with
loads of complications to solve the equations. So the only analytical solutions that we have
are those for the linear theories, okay, in the linear regime, which are like the regime of the
very big scales. In our simplest model, dark energy is just a constant, a fixed energy of
the vacuum that never changes. But Desi is starting to whisper something awkward. Is it true, Kyle,
that as our colleagues, my friends and colleagues, Suzanne Staggs, Mark Devlin, Lyman Page,
have demonstrated, David Spurgill, very clearly that the lambda is unavoidable, or some version
of dark energy is unavoidable using the CMB alone? I think that's true, right, Dan? Is it also true
from BAO alone? You can derive the imperative of dark energy's existence. Yeah, that is definitely
true for BAO alone as well. Our models, if we were to throw out any version of dark energy,
would basically be impossible to describe the measurements we see over the range of range we
make the measurements. We see a preference for something like 70% of the current energy contents
being dark energy, and that's hard to get around. The data seem more comfortable if dark energy
evolves over time. And when you combine that with the fact that cosmology wants neutrinos to be
almost massless, while particle physics insists that they aren't, you get a serious tension in
our best theory of the cosmos. Theoretically, it makes a lot of sense that it's a constant,
because if you think of it as the energy of the vacuum, then the more volume there is,
the more vacuum there is, it all compensates, and then you get a constant. So it makes a lot of
sense. But the latest results from DESI, and being part of the DESI collaboration, I trust them,
because I know that they have very, very, you know, very thicc in how to show the results and so on,
that those seem to show that there's a strong... Yeah, but there's strong evidence from DESI
to actually departure of this. And I think, like, the most... Okay, to me, the most interesting part
is that cosmology has very few predictions that it can make that can be checked with other kind of
areas in physics, for example, particle physics. And there's one prediction that cosmology has,
which is that we can measure the mass of the neutrino, okay? And if you go to the latest
results from BAO and DESI, and you combine them with other supernovae results and so on,
you find out that there's strong evidence to actually having massless neutrinos in the
universe. But particle physics experiments tell you that they cannot be massless, right? They
have to have a mass. So there's some tension here. There's a paradox here. There's a misunderstanding
between these two areas of science. And the only... Exactly, inconsistency. And the only way
of reconciling those two seems to be opening our framework to new ideas on what dark energy could
be. And right now, it seems that that's the most compelling way of moving forward, right? Because
there are other ways in which you will actually lose these constraints, but none of them actually
move your measurements. They just make them less accurate. But this one actually moves your
measurements in the right direction. This one being... The dark energy. Exactly. So having a
dark energy that is not really constant in time, but it works. The Hubble tension, the fact that
different models of measuring the expansion rate disagree, might end up being systematic error,
or it might be a sign of new physics. The only way to know for sure is to redo the key experiments
with ever more careful data. That's part of what surveys like DES and the upcoming LSST
are designed to do. So tell me about the Hubble tension. Because you found there was also some
discrepancy depending on what values to follow. So about the Hubble tension, I don't have a good
answer on what could be happening with the Hubble tension. Everything seems to show that it might
be due to systematics. But again, I'm not an expert. Do we need more data for both things?
Do we need more? Because we have 40 million galaxies. I think we need more consistent data.
Maybe that's the thing. Maybe we need to redo some of the things that we have done
already. And I know that this is not very attractive and no one really wants to do this,
right? Yeah. But sometimes you have to repeat some of the experiments. And this is being done by
the DES collaboration, for example. They have their own set of supernovae. And also the LSST
is going to have their own set of supernovae. And again, I know that this is not very attractive
in some way, but it's the only way forward. To test any model of dark energy, you need to
know what the universe's large-scale structure should look like if your model is correct.
That's what so-called N-body simulations do. They throw billions of particles into
an expanding universe and let gravity sculpt the cosmic web, and then we
compare it to what we actually see. Explain first, for a layperson,
what is an N-body simulation? How do you actually do it? Do you have a laptop, an iPhone? How do
you do it? Sure, sure. So they are usually done in supercomputers, right? The big ones,
they are done in supercomputers. An N-body simulation is basically just a simulation of
a very homogeneous universe that evolves with time according to a mixture between Newton's laws
and general relativity laws. So basically, Newton's laws on an expanding universe.
And it evolves only through gravity. And it tells you what is going to be the gravitational
potential, so what is going to be the structure that you expect to see in the light universe.
And it solves the equations exactly, but for a given set of initial conditions.
James Clerk Maxwell, Peter Higgs, and the astronomers who built this place
were all chasing different versions of the same question. What is the universe really made of?
And how does it really behave? Marcos does it with simulations, surveys, and machine learning
instead of brass and glass. But the mindset is still the same. Take a vague intuition and carve
it into something the universe can't ignore. So what do we need more of? More galaxies,
more observations, more simulations, more CPU, GPU? What do we need more of?
Well, we need more of everything. If you ask me, more of everything.
So simulations, I think we have plenty. Of course, the bigger they are, the better.
But we have techniques to actually do these embodied simulations quick enough that I think
that's not a bottleneck anymore. It used to be, but not anymore.
But we also need machine learning techniques and artificial intelligence techniques to actually
use them in the smartest way possible. And for that we need synergies between the computing
science departments and the cosmology department. The bottlenecks that we have there in simulations
are more related to hydrodynamics and super visuals, which are the simulations in which
it's not only gravity evolving. It's gravity plus the pressure from galaxies, explosions of plasma,
exactly. So star formation and so on. Those are very far from being converged.
So if you run two similar approaches, the outcome will be completely
contradictory. So they will basically predict opposite things, which is something that is very
annoying because then you don't know in which universe you're living.
So this observatory, there's the Higgs Center that we're at right now. Did you meet Peter Higgs?
Did you know Peter Higgs? No, I didn't. I moved here one year before he died.
He was not coming anymore. The quick history here, was Maxwell ever here?
Maxwell is one of my heroes in history because it doesn't seem that he was also a very good
scientist. Apparently, he was also like a nice person. Ah, Edinburgh, the city where I first
chased light through the mist. At 14, I was already puzzling over the mathematics of curves
and colors, scribbling equations. I didn't pass every exam, mind you. Cambridge nearly said no.
But curiosity is a stubborn thing. It carried me from these cobbled streets to the laws that would
bind electricity and magnetism forever. Funny, isn't it? As my friend, Professor Brian Keating
always says, A, B, C, always be curious. So he was born here, and you can actually
visit the house where he was born. He wanted to come here, but at the time, he had not
made his most brilliant contributions to physics. And he was actually not accepted
in the university. A friend of his was accepted. And at the very beginning, I thought, who would
say no to Maxwell, right? But then you realize that they were actually very good friends since
they were kids. And they were part of this club in which they solved mathematical problems together
and so on. And then you think, I don't know, actually, probably Maxwell was happy that his
friend got started with physics. And he went on to get started. So how does it feel to work in a
place like this with all this history, castles, copper? And then you're doing some of the most
modern large-scale simulation ever done. I am the most mysterious force in the universe,
dark energy. I know, I know. I don't see any big leap in that sense, right? So in the end,
I mean, it sounds very old when you tell these stories and so on. But they were
dealing with the same kind of problem. How to make a bigger building and how to make a
bigger telescope. In the end, it's a very similar mind framework. And it's like a problem-solving
framework. When you have a problem and you want to find a solution, the brain works in very similar
ways. It's not like music, for example. I think music is different. In music, you don't have a
very well-defined problem, right? You just have an intuition of what could work and what couldn't.
Science is a bit like a mixture of those two, right? Problem-solving and a little bit of
inspiration. And when you live in a place where there's so many artistic stuff around you,
then you find out that science and arts are not that different and that you need inspiration from
both of them, which is a cool thing. That's beautiful. Thank you. From this hilltop in
Edinburgh to the edge of the observable universe, Baron Acoustic Oscillations and DESI are forcing
us to ask whether dark energy is really constant or whether our entire cosmological model is
starting to bend. A huge thanks to Marcos and the Royal Observatory of Edinburgh for opening
their doors. If you want to go deeper into DESI and dark energy, check out my conversations with
past spokesperson Kyle Dawson and Nobel laureate Adam Rees. They're linked right here. See you
next time on Into the Impossible. And don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe.