How Women Handle Betrayal: Oprah and Belle Burden Unpack This

Oprah Winfrey
8 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Listen, I know this is a big club, a lot of members in this club, women who've been betrayed.
You're going over in your head all the things, all the signs you could have, where could
I have seen the sign?
What did I miss?
And one night you became convinced that James had fathered the other woman's toddlers because
he told you that she had toddlers, right?
Yes, toddlers about three and one year old.
Yeah.
And when you confronted him, he said what?
Well, at that point he had stopped answering my phone calls and told me that I was too
upset for him to speak to, but I caught him in the middle of the night.
He picked up the phone at about 1 a.m. because I was spiraling, thinking that he had actually
fathered them.
And he said, stop, you have lost your mind.
And he hung up the phone.
But that seemed in this world where everything that I thought was impossible was now possible.
I thought even that could be possible.
Yeah.
That it hasn't been two weeks or a month that you're now the father of the toddlers.
Pedological thought for somebody.
It happens.
Yes.
It happens all the time.
And you write, I felt like I had lost my mind.
Like his exit had transformed me suddenly from an intelligent, stable wife and mother
to an unhinged lunatic, a mad woman.
Somehow I had become the dangerous person in this story.
The volatile character, rather than he, the man who had left his family.
Yeah.
It's amazing to me.
And I think this happens to a lot of women.
Overnight, somehow we are transformed into the hysteric.
But I do think that, based on all the people I know who've gone through this, that that's
a tactic.
Yes, I think it is.
It's a tactic that the men use.
Absolutely.
In many instances, I realize where, I'm laughing because I remember it goes, I am not crazy.
Exactly.
Yes.
In many instances where the man, the husband, the spouse, is saying, you're crazy, you're
hysterical.
And I think there was a wonderful line that you wrote where you said, once a woman is
painted as a hysteric.
The rest of the story is washed away.
She's dismissed.
Yes.
She's absolutely dismissed.
And it happens very quickly.
Even though he did something that was fairly unhinged to walk out on your family during
a pandemic.
Yes.
Within 12 hours, I was too upset.
I was too angry.
You're overreacting.
I'm overreacting.
You're hysterical.
When everything, actually, everything is fine.
He kept saying, everything's fine.
This is fine.
So let's go to the everything is fine.
Yes.
So how long before you all told the girls?
Because this is what is so unbelievable.
I'm always amazed at working mothers, working parents who have a whole life outside and
then have to come home and be present for their children and not be hysterical for their
children.
So you didn't tell the girls at first?
I didn't.
A therapist advised that I wait because the pandemic was so scary.
And so that we should wait till the pandemic was less scary.
And of course, that never happened.
And I thought I was hiding it from them.
I did not do a good job.
I was crying all the time.
I had trouble getting out of bed for a very long time.
And what are you telling them is the reason for that?
I just pretended like I was okay, even though my eyes were swollen.
My older daughter actually knew.
She read a text on my iPad almost immediately, which happens a lot, I think.
So she knew and she had to pretend that she didn't know.
And then my younger daughter didn't know.
But then I think after...
How old was your older daughter at the time?
15.
Yes.
And then my younger one was 12.
And I also have a 17-year-old boy who was with his friends.
And the younger one did not know.
But then when she found out afterwards, she felt betrayed that I hadn't told her.
So I think that was a mistake.
I wish I had told them.
I said their dad had gone back to New York to go to work, even though New York was shut
down.
And I wish I had just said, this is happening and told it in a factual way so that we could
all go through it together.
I think you needed to give yourself a day, though.
I mean, yes.
It's true.
You have to collect yourself.
As I say, many years ago, in the 70s, I interviewed Betty Rollins, who wrote a book called First
You Cry.
It was one of the first books about breast cancer, First You Cry.
And I remember saying to Gail that somebody should write a book for women going through
divorce that says, first you pick your head up off the floor.
Because you're so...
Literally, every person that I know who's been through it, who finds himself in the
midst of betrayal for the first time, it's like you're a chicken with your head cut off.
And it's disconcerting, really, to...
To your whole being.
And I spend a lot of time on the bathroom floor, which you think is a cliche, but it's
actually not.
I think we spend a lot of time there because no one will come in the room.
And also, it's like this cold floor that it made me feel like I wasn't going to fall through
the earth.
It holds you up.
Okay.
And a lot of tears.
So how long before he comes back to tell the children?
It was a month.
Wow.
I thought, we've got to tell them.
This is crazy.
We've got to tell them.
And initially, he didn't want to come.
He wanted me to tell them.
And then didn't he want to Zoom?
Then we were going to Zoom.
Oh, crazy.
And I felt mixed about him coming because he was in New York.
I was worried he would bring COVID.
I didn't know what kind of person was going to show up because we had not been in...
We had not been communicating, but finally decided he should be there in person to tell
the girls.
And we called my son beforehand.
And then he arrived.
And my first thought when I saw him coming up our walkway was that he seemed really happy.
He seemed elated, which was so incongruous to the wreckage that he had left with me.
And he came in and we sat in our living room.
I had my arms around both girls.
And he told them that we were divorcing, that he hadn't been happy.
And it's just that terrible moment.
It's terrible for any family when this news is delivered to kids.
Okay, but here's the thing, that you're leaving out Belle.
This is the good part.
Oh, yes, yes.
You're leaving out...
This is the good part.
He's telling the girls.
And in the midst of telling the girls, he says, can you get me a sandwich?
He did.
He looked at me and he said, I'm starving.
It's like a scene of a movie.
Yeah.
Can you make me a sandwich?
And part of my brain thought, part of my brain thought, you used to live here, go make your
own sandwich.
I'm not going to make you a sandwich.
And then my younger daughter had run down the stairs.
She was very upset.
And my older daughter is sitting there with her arms crossed looking at her father.
And I'm having a dialogue with myself that I think a lot of mothers have, which is, I
should model that we are going to be kind to each other, that we're going to work together,
that we're not going to be nasty ever, that there will be love and caring here, even if
we're divorcing.
So you made the sandwich.
And that side won out.
And I went into the kitchen and I made the sandwich.
And as I'm making it, I think, I am going to make the best sandwich ever.
I will not make a terrible sandwich.
I want him to leave thinking, how could I leave this woman who makes such a great sandwich?
And of course, the sandwich represented so much else.
It represented home and the warmth of this life.
And my caring for you and what you've received here.
Exactly.
But I don't think he saw it that way at all.
I think he ate it and didn't think about it again.
One of the things you write in Strangers is that some people say the end of a marriage
is 50-50, always 50-50.
But you ask, is it 50-50 when the unhappy person doesn't say that they are unhappy?
Is it 50-50 when you didn't know that there was this disruption going on?
And I'm wondering, does it matter in the end?
Does it, whether it was 50-50 or 20-80?
I think it's one of those things that if it happens like this to you, it's frustrating
when people say, oh, well, it takes two to tango.
Two people have to end a marriage.
And I don't think that's fair because I think that you need at least a beat to be able to
work on it.
That's not somebody who's been through it.
No, that's definitely not.
And in some cases it is because there's conflict and there are a lot of issues.
But you have to communicate that you're unhappy.
You have to give someone a chance to go to therapy or discuss or something like that.
So I resisted, and I still resist that idea that it was 50-50.
