Matt Kaplan is a science journalist at The Economist and a trained paleontologist. His new book I Told You So!: Scientists Who Were Ridiculed, Exiled, and Imprisoned for Being Right is a candid investigation into how science actually works — and why the engine of discovery is badly in need of a tuneup.
In this conversation, we discuss why the pandemic exposed science's dirty secrets to the public, how Ignaz Semmelweis discovered handwashing saved lives and was thrown in an asylum for it, why Katalin Karikó survived where others didn't, the replication crisis and how funding models are making it worse, whether older scientists should control research dollars, why Galileo was never actually tortured, and what journalists and scientists must do differently before public trust collapses entirely.
Matt Kaplan also recently discussed science communication and dysfunction on other outlets — in this conversation, we go deeper on the replication crisis, the Semmelweis story, and why the funding model is quietly corrupting the scientific process.
🔔 Subscribe for new episodes each week 🎧 Ad-free episodes on Patreon: patreon.com/drbriankeating
INTO THE IMPOSSIBLE — where Nobel Prize winners, physicists, and bold thinkers explore the biggest questions in science.
Key Takeaways: 00:00 Why the pandemic was science's most damaging moment of exposure 03:30 The scientific-industrial press complex — and who's really to blame 06:50 How science journalism fails the public 85% of the time 10:00 Ignaz Semmelweis: the man who proved handwashing saves lives and was destroyed for it 20:10 Why infection rates dropped from 21% to zero — and nobody listened 24:30 What Katalin Karikó had that Semmelweis didn't: shelter 28:00 The replication crisis — why nobody is funding the most important work in science 33:00 How funding models force scientists to run experiments they've already won 40:30 Should older scientists control research dollars? A Nobel laureate weighs in 43:45 Why Galileo was never tortured — and why the myth won't die 47:00 The rhinoceros tooth: a paleontologist's lesson in confirmation bias
📚 Get my books: Think Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with productivity tips from 9 Nobel Prize winners: https://a.co/d/03ezQFu
Focus Like a Nobel Prize Winner, with life-changing interviews with 9 Nobel Prizewinners: https://a.co/d/hi50U9U My tell-all cosmic memoir Losing the Nobel Prize: http://amzn.to/2sa5UpA
The first-ever audiobook from Galileo: Dialogue Concerning the Two Chief World Systems: Ptolemaic and Copernican https://a.co/d/iZPi9Un
One in ten mothers died after giving birth. One doctor figured out why,
and then they destroyed him for it.
Roughly one woman in ten would get a disease called Preparal Fever, and once they got it,
they died. He got all of the other doctors to sign on to this, and the infection rate went from 21%
to zero. And he would say this in front of powerful people like the director of the hospital,
and when he said, no, your hands are dirty, they said, sir, we are gentlemen, all of us,
our hands cannot be dirty. And for all of that, he got thrown in an insane asylum after being
exiled to Hungary by his peers, and he died there. The more the pressure goes up, the more likely a
scientist who has built a career on a certain paradigm, the more they will defend that paradigm
vigorously, even if the evidence is staring them in the face that some upstart newbie to the field
might be right. 85% of the time, science journalists do not do a good job of talking about
how science works. This is instrumental to the problem with modern science.
You speak to your ethics, and you speak candidly about how sometimes there's pressure,
because you have to report the facts, but you also are embedded, and maybe you know too much. So
talk about your proposal to embed journalists with scientific teams,
and what reaction do you expect that might have?
So you got to be talking about how science actually operates, right? A lot of the friction
that we face with science in the general public today stems from the pandemic. It was almost like
walking into a dressing room and seeing science naked, right? It was like people had not really
seen how science operates, because frankly, 85% of the time science journalists in most papers
do not do a good job of talking about how science works. And now suddenly,
the whole world is paying a lot of attention to science and how it works, and they're aghast
when they see scientists shocking, disagreeing with each other, or scientists not sharing
information with one another as they should, or scientists, wait for it, being wrong.
And that, of course, to you and I operating in the scientific realm, we understand that. We know
that that's normal. The general public doesn't know that, and we've done a bad job of communicating,
and we need to do a better job of it. To get more down to the point, it's not just talking about
the process, because my newspaper has long argued that laws and sausages, you do need to know how
they're made. If you want to be a good democracy, and if you want to have good media, you have to
talk about how legislation is passed. It's ugly, it's disgusting, but you need to know.
The same applies to science. We have to talk about how the science is created. And I think
the book does a really good job of that by looking at how important ideas have been handled and
mishandled over the past 500 years, and then pairing that. Because my book is not a straightforward
one scientist, one chapter. I think a lot of people wanted to have that. The book is braided.
I'll talk about Ignaz Semmelweis in Hungary, and then I'll segue into Carl Woese or Kati Karikó,
and I talk about how what we saw in history is still very much alive today. These are important
discussions for us to be having. And the more we talk about it, the more we put it on the
agenda to try to fix it. You know, as I see the central thesis, and you left out one of
my favorite characters, my friend Galileo, he's a major figure in this book as well.
And quite frankly, I am getting a little sick of my friend, the maestro, as he demanded he be
called by his acolytes. And that was really due to the fact that stuff like AI and chatbots have
made it incredibly simple for the general public to propose wild scientific ideas, and then send
them to their favorite scientist as being chat GPT verified. And I always get letters like this,
Professor Keating, this is my new idea for crystalline vibrations that explain the
luminiferous ether, and maybe they throw in some, you know, germ theory of disease is wrong,
everything but the kitchen sink. And they say like, it may sound crazy, but people laughed
at Galileo too. And if you just help me with the math, I'll share my Nobel Prize with you.
So I'm wondering, you know, what, at what level do we need to kind of have a filter, a very strong
filter, people accuse me often of being a gatekeeper? Well, we have a gate around campus,
I don't want my, you know, $14 million telescope walking off with some person I don't know who
thinks they're Galileo, right? So we have a border fence where I have a pool fence, you know, if you
live in California, I have to have a pool fence, right? We need gates, how do we draw the line
between, you know, not wanting to exclude the Katis of the world, but also being, you know,
kind of not so open as another great science communicator and friend, at least his wife is a
friend of the show, Carl Sagan said, having your mind so open that your brains fall out.
Yeah. Okay, so two points. First of all, Galileo had a lot of people who really liked him and
thought his work was awesome. And some of those people were pretty powerful. So Mafio Barberini,
Cardinal Mafio Barberini, who became Pope Urban VIII, actually really liked Galileo's writings,
and he got on well with Galileo, so much so that Galileo, I think it was, of course,
a political decision, dedicated Il Sagittario, one of his major works, to Cardinal Barberini before
he became Pope. And that, I think, was to gain goodwill, but also they liked each other,
and Barberini was really interested in his work. Similarly, Galileo was phenomenally
friendly with Ferdinando de' Medici, who was the Grand Duke of Tuscany. I mean,
if there was anyone almost equal to power to the Pope in Italy at that time,
it was the Grand Duke of Tuscany. He and his brother owned like a dozen telescopes.
They were huge Galileo fanboys. So there was a lot of interest in what Galileo was doing,
and it was not a case of everyone saying,
we hate him. It was actually very much a decision by the church to come after him,
and I don't think it was Pope Urban VIII's real interest to go after him. I think he had to for
political reasons. But so let's segue to your second question about gatekeepers, because this
is really important. It's a separate issue. So I ran my book past Carl Zimmer at the New York Times,
who I've written with for years. I said, look, I'm going to be publishing this in six months.
I want you to tear it down. Go through it and tell me everything that's wrong with it. Carl's
really good at that. And he went through it and he said, there is a vulnerability here that you're
going to have people who are going to say you are paving the way for crazies to talk about their
ideas being really valid. I rewrote vast sections of the book to emphasize, first of all, science
has got us a phenomenal distance, and it is an engine of discovery. It's a clunky engine. It's
definitely not efficient. Could it be better? Yes. I identify lots of ways it could be better,
and we need it to be better because we've got some really, really big problems on this planet.
With that said, the engine is faulty, and one of the key ways in which it is faulty is
that when debate occurs between scientists, when we disagree, the gloves come off more
often than they should. The disagreement and the debate should be respectful,
it should be intelligent, and it should not involve character assassination. And yet,
more and more, we allow the character assassination to occur. And there are a lot of reasons for that.
Part of it, I mean, I'm not going to lie, we don't want to talk about the elephant in the room,
but budget cuts ratchet up the pressure dramatically on the academic community.
And the more you cut the budget, the more people really worry about the kitchen table issues. And
when I say people, I mean the scientists. Scientists have mortgages too. They have families,
they have kids who they need to feed and clothe. And if you lose your job because you can't get
grants, that's bad. And so the more the pressure goes up, the more likely a scientist who has
built their career on a certain paradigm or group of ideas, the more they will defend that paradigm
vigorously, even if the evidence is staring them in the face that some upstart newbie to the field
might be right. And that doesn't help us. We need to be able to have that newbie upstart lay out
their evidence and then have the established scientists say, okay, well, let's hear this.
Let's talk. Okay, no, I think you're wrong there, but this point has merit. And I think this point
might be off. And that's healthy. Healthy debate is critical. But when you tear people apart,
which we see happen, especially when there's territoriality in science,
we do all of ourselves, everyone, a vast disservice. The problem is, as I've said in the
past, I don't really know if there's a solution to it, but science is an infinite game, right?
You can't win science. You can win a Nobel prize. You can get a high H index. You can do all sorts
of things, but you can't win it, right? You're fighting all powerful enemy, mother nature,
right? She's undefeated. On the other hand, you can win all these finite games along the way,
tenure, getting into grad school, getting into undergrad, getting a postdoc, getting a faculty
visit. It's all these academic hunger game hurdles that we can get past, but there is at every level
a gatekeeping and there is at every level a temptation to punish the heretic rather than
reward the truth teller. And I think that is endemic. You propose some ways we can get around
it. I agree. The elephant, the mastodon in the room, as they say, is funding, but the real
character is really a tragic figure. So much so that my son was talking about him. He didn't know
his name, but he was talking about the Semmelweis effect and what Ignaz Semmelweis discovered. He
had it kind of conflated with they killed him. That's not really what happened. So talk about
Ignaz Semmelweis. He is a real tragic figure, this brilliant Cassandra who saw the future
and was punished for it. He is a fascinating tale. And what I find most fascinating about him
is that he's not alone. There were so many other folks who went down exactly the same path
and most of them had poor outcomes. Their outcomes were different. Semmelweis was working in the 1830s
and 1840s as an obstetrician. He was Hungarian by birth, but he was pretty good at his work.
And as a result, he ended up working as an obstetrician in the Vienna hospital in Austria.
The history element of it is important because it's relevant to his story and what happened to
him. It's relevant to his science. As a Hungarian, Hungary was a vassal state to Austria at the time.
The Habsburg empire effectively controlled Hungary, but because Semmelweis was so capable,
he was able to work at the Vienna hospital as an obstetrician. So even though he was working there,
even though he was very good, he was working for doctors who were mostly Austrian aristocrats.
Very well-established, very wealthy. Semmelweis did well, but he was always going to be a second
class doctor in that hospital. And Semmelweis, as he was doing his work, noticed that patients,
when he delivered babies, roughly one woman in 10 would get a disease called preparal fever.
And once they got it, they died. There was no saving somebody from preparal fever.
And it was a vile disease. Swollen black and blue splotches would appear around the abdomen
and the upper thighs. The patient would develop a horrendous fever, become delirious,
suffer seizures. And in the last two days, and it usually lasted about five or six days,
the last two days of the disease, their abdomen would become so exquisitely sensitive and painful
that even the gentle pressure of sheets on the hospital bed touching their belly would leave
them frozen in speechless terror. And they died with these frozen screams on their lips.
The baby would always follow them to the grave. So mother and baby would be buried together.
And it's going to sound really terrible, but doctors really didn't care. Most doctors just
shrugged their shoulders and went, it happens. But the thing is it didn't happen. There were places
where it didn't occur. And so if you went to a private medical clinic to have your baby delivered
instead of a hospital, the rate of preparal fever was much lower, but people weren't keeping notes.
The notion of having an Excel spreadsheet and writing down who gets it and who doesn't
was not really done. Semmelweis was different. He started taking notes. He had learned from
a statistician named Joseph Skoda, who was really into numbers, but he was an oddball
and considered kind of an outsider. He was Austrian, but not liked by most of the other
doctors. And the fact that Semmelweis got along well with him did not do a lot for Semmelweis.
Semmelweis started keeping notes and recording who got the disease, who didn't, how often,
and he made an extraordinary discovery. There were two maternity wards in the Vienna hospital,
one that was dominantly controlled by nurses and one that was effectively controlled by doctors.
And as Semmelweis kept his notes, he made this extraordinary discovery. The rate of infection
was 6% in the nurse's ward and 21% in the doctor's ward. So something was different.
And so he was, again, an extraordinary doctor. There were others like him, but not many,
because most doctors in that day and age were taught diseases brought by the sun,
the moon, and the stars. Which way is the wind going? What position is Apollo in?
You know, all of this stuff, what's going on on the planet. And we laugh at that and say,
that's crazy. But actually, chickenpox has a season. It's spring. Influenza has a season.
It's winter. So the notion that certain diseases arrived with the stars made sense,
but they tried to explain everything with it. And Semmelweis started keeping notes and said,
well, wait a minute. Why, if the stars are in alignment for peripheral fever,
causing 21% infection in the doctor's ward, do we see only 6% in the nurse's ward?
So he started running experiments. He tried giving all of the patients in the doctor's ward,
the food that the patients in the nurse's ward were getting. And that didn't change a thing.
Then he tried burning all the sheets in the doctor's ward and replacing them with sheets
from the nurse's ward. No change. He even went so far as to ban the priest who wandered around
with incense to visit patients giving last rites. Because of course, if you've got more
peripheral fever in the doctor's ward, then there's more incense in the doctor's ward than
there is in the nurse's ward. Maybe the incense is causing it. Maybe it's the bell that the
assistant to the priest is ringing as the priest comes. Maybe that's filling people with dread and
making them ill. So he banned the priest for three months and kept notes. No change.
Finally, he made this extraordinary discovery. He was in the morgue in the morning as all doctors
across the world did every morning. He would dissect the patients who had died the previous day
to try to understand why they had died. He then washed his hands with soap and water and went,
still smells like corpse. Wait a minute. I go and deliver babies with these hands.
I remove the umbilical cord from the neck of the baby. Sometimes I sometimes rotate the baby inside
the mother to help avoid a cesarean. I wonder if having aura of death, because he had no idea
about microbes, bacteria had not been discovered yet. Pasteur, character that he was, would not
make that discovery for 40 years. Someone went, my hands still smell. So he made a visit to the
local sewage treatment plant where they were dumping chlorine in the sewer to get rid of the
smell of raw human waste. And he said, could you give me some of that? So they gave him this very
concentrated chlorine solution. He dipped his hands in it and smell went away. Incidentally,
the skin on his hands went away five days later, according to his journals,
because the concentration was so strong, the skin cells all died and his hands shed like a snake.
I didn't write that in my book in the end because I didn't think it was really relevant. It was
hysterical. He got all of the other doctors to sign on to this, which is extraordinary. I mean,
really that he could get other people to do this is amazing. And the infection rate went from 21%
to zero. You didn't need statistical significance. You didn't need P values.
You didn't need to do any kind of statistical analysis to know that this worked. And yet,
in spite of that, he made so many political errors, so many diplomatic faux pas, largely
because of his Hungarian background, but also because he was kind of a Sheldon Cooper of the
medical world. He said it like it was when other doctors were talking about the sun and the stars,
he would openly defy them and say, no, there's no evidence for that.
And he would say this in front of powerful people, like the director of the hospital
or politicians. And it got him into tons of trouble. And ultimately the doctors rebelled.
And when he said, no, your hands are dirty, your hands are dirty. They said,
sir, we are gentlemen, all of us, our hands cannot be dirty. And for all of that,
he got thrown in an insane asylum after being exiled to Hungary by his peers.
And he died there.
What do you attribute the perseverance of another Hungarian, you know, a century and a half later,
and a friend Kati Karko, where she was able to not go crazy, carries no bitterness,
even against people like her postdoc or her advisor, Sudolnik, who threatened to deport
her for the time of considering a job offer with almost no repercussions on him. I mean,
she was simultaneously so valuable that he had to threaten her with deportation,
but also he wouldn't give her a raise or advocate for her to get a permanent position.
How do you think she persevered? But people like Semmelweis and later Boltzmann,
who you don't write about in this book, went crazy, committed suicide.
This is what the book is all about. And I can't talk about all the scientists here.
Obviously, the book has so many characters.
You have to buy the book and we have to review the book.
I listened to the book. It was great.
Kati Karko, I really sat down and analyzed because she's Hungarian too. I mean,
that shouldn't really be relevant, but I found I almost called the book a tale of two Hungarians.
Their two stories are so compelling. There are dozens of others.
So you really get down to the analysis. And Kati, I asked myself, does Kati have the diplomacy and
guile that Galileo had? Because Galileo, we appreciate him as a scientist and he was a
great astronomer. He was really, he was so charismatic. Everybody liked him.
He made all these very shrewd political moves. And we don't respect him enough for that,
because that was his everything. I mean, he was so capable.
Kati didn't have that either. You've talked to her, you've had her on the show.
You know that she's not diplomatic. She's hard to follow. She's a whirlwind of ideas.
Kati, if you look, had something that Semmelweis didn't, and that was she had shelter.
So she had Eliot Barnathan, who became her friend at Penn. And Eliot, when the storm came,
Eliot stepped in and said, I've got your back. David Langer, who was originally just a student
in the lab with Eliot Barnathan, went on to become a doctor and ultimately really
shielded Kati for years to ensure that she could keep doing her very important work.
Semmelweis was an odd duck in terms of social ability. And again,
the connection I think to Sheldon Cooper is poignant. Many people know
young Sheldon or Big Bang Theory, and that's relevant because Semmelweis got along with
this Joseph Skoda, who was a numbers guy, but he was also esoteric and awkward socially.
He's written about as wearing threadbare clothing into the hospital. He was mocked
for his odd clothing choices. All you have to do is look at Sheldon Cooper's clothing
choices and ask that question too, right? So Semmelweis really didn't build allies,
and he didn't get alliances. And so when the storm came, he didn't have shelter.
Kati had for well over a decade, she was shielded by people who respected her,
and we're going to pull out all the stops to make sure that she was shielded.
We look at the other main character, the thread and the story that's braided together
involving your field, paleontology, we see sort of this notion of the infallible scientist and
this trope that no scientist believes this. I mean, I was talking with Nick Lane, who's a famous
biochemist at UC London. He was saying, one of the biggest kind of mental models that people
get wrong is that the scientific theory of mind is that I'm never wrong, but you're always wrong.
You don't know anything as another scientist, but we don't realize that to them, we're them,
right? So we can't conceive of the fact that we're wrong. And yet, if you don't have that,
you can't do anything in science. You have to have this balance, I say, of chutzpah
and humility. And people like, we see the Einsteins and the Feynmans, but for every one of
them, there's dozens more that didn't have this kind of outsized ego. But Katalin, she claims
it's the ego of the scientist, perhaps, you point out is the root cause. Let's talk about the
scientists, because we are not without blame. So what can we do to reform that? Because we make fun
of our friends in the law school, but at least they take an ethics class on the business school,
the medical school. We never teach ethics as if you're going to learn it by osmosis. I say to my
colleagues, do you learn quantum mechanics through osmosis? So you teach what you think is valuable.
What's your solution to the core, the real, the central gear in the worm is the scientist.
So what can we do? For starters, we can talk about it. Because as long as we have the perception
that there's an ivory tower, we put ourselves on the back foot. It's really important that we
talk about how science works. And we accept that the engine of discovery needs a tune-up and that
we need to do better. Look, I've worked at The Economist for two decades. And so that does
funny things to your brain, makes it hard to write in the first person, for example. It will be known.
But it also makes you think about financial models and the implications that certain types
of funding have on the behavior that we've got. When we have systems that reward first,
but not second at all, that's unhelpful. When we have systems that do not at all monetize
replication of research, that creates a distinct threat to science. Because if we're not replicating
our work, we function on a 95% confidence model. If we're not replicating thousands and thousands
of papers, there's going to be a lot that we're 95% confident that there was results. But in fact,
it was statistical fluke. And we currently don't support replication at all anymore.
It's really, really hard to find a replication. This is crazy. But that's not the fault of the
scientists so much as it's the fault of the system. The journals are not reporting replications
because they think nobody wants to hear them. The scientists aren't doing it because there's
no funding for it. The journalists don't write about replications because they think the public
won't care. I would like to say, by the way, I pitch at least a dozen replications a year
to my editors. I hope you're listening. And my editors very rarely allow me to write a piece
about a replication. And if I do, it's because something fails to replicate and it has
implications. I don't think I've ever written anything where a replication was done on an
important experiment. And I've said, this replication occurred and it's a big deal because
this study that we thought was right really is right. Isn't that great? That's a very hard sell
in news, but it shouldn't. So it is in science, by the way. Sorry to interrupt, but we don't teach
all the wrong turns that scientists went down. Galileo was wrong almost as often as he was right.
Same with Einstein. And this is actually an important point. So, I mean, Samuel Weiss,
he did the thing with the priest, right? He threw the priest out. He burned the sheets. He fed people
different food. He did everything. And he was wrong over and over again for years. He was wrong.
It took him five years of experimentation to work out what was really going on, but he kept being
funded. And this, this is instrumental to the problem with modern science. And it really is
that we, you apply for a grant with NSF, and if you then run work based on that funding,
and it doesn't yield interesting results, you are very, very unlikely to get that funding again.
As a result, what happens, you already run your experiment. You know the results are going to be
good. And then you apply for funding for the experiment that you've already succeeded in
because you know that's there and you can publish it and make NSF happy. So they'll give you more
money in the future. So you're only running experiments with funding that you already had.
And it makes us much more cautious as well, because we're less likely to run an experiment
where we think it might not yield interesting results. So the really cool stuff like Katikariko
with mRNA, which was really out there, doesn't get done very often because people are being so careful.
And that's not the fault of the scientists. That's the fault of the economic model.
But where the fault of the scientists does lie, scientists need to be better about discussing what
they're actually doing, what their question was, what they did, why they did it, and what the
findings were and why it matters. And it's going to sound crazy. It's just a beginning, a middle,
and an end. It's a simple narrative. But simple narrative is why Disney is a multi-billion dollar
company. People really latch on to stories. Having a beginning and middle end is critical.
And when a scientist says, we found this, without the other stuff, first of all,
it gives people a false impression of what's actually going on. That's damaging. But it also
strips away why money needed to go to it in the first place. Why was it expensive?
I do think that people don't do enough, not just talking about how science works, but
talking about science in general. I mean, my colleagues, if I tell them I have a YouTube
channel, half the time they'll look at me, roll their eyes, what do you think you are, Mr. Beast?
Like a real scientist doesn't do that. And there are very few tenured professors doing what I do.
I mean, I can only think of two or three. This is my side hustle. I like to talk to interesting
people like yourself. So it gives me a sense of joy. It's more of like a hobby. But I tell my
colleagues, I think we have a moral obligation. We're taking money from the public. Besides the
practical element that if they don't understand what we're doing, I mean, I often say, if I told
you, Matt, I'm working at a law firm and the lead partner comes in and says, Brian, what are you
working on? And I say, oh, you can't understand it. And my techniques, Matt, you can't understand
that either. We'd be out of a job almost instantaneously, all the more so for taking
public funding. Every scientist, even at a private institution, gets copious amounts of public
support. So I think we do so at our risk. And yet every time I try to propose that our colleagues,
my colleagues, spend 10% of their time, they'll either say, no, I'm better, more useful in the
lab, or I'm not good at it. And to that, I always say, well, I forgot you came out of the womb
knowing quantum electrodynamics, right? And of course, they'll say no, but it just means they
don't prioritize it. But I think we're in a new era, right, Matt, that if we don't have more
transparency and accountability, this way we've done science is not going to continue much longer,
especially in the age of p-hacking, Epstein, and AI, right? It is a very delicate balancing act.
So as a science journalist, having done this for over two decades, I read the papers,
I read the abstracts. If I think the abstract is interesting, I then look at the discussion.
And I think the discussion is interesting. I read the methods and the results and say,
this stands up. I think we should write about it. That is how I get 95% of what I write in
The Economist. I do on occasion have scientists email me. Some scientists email me with stuff
they want me to write about a lot more than others. And it's interesting, just doing a
psychological analysis of myself. If a scientist emails me roughly once every two months,
their emails are almost certainly ignored. If I only see an email from them once in a blue moon,
I will give what they've proposed to me attention. It's usually corrected proof of a paper that's
been accepted because I tell people, look, don't pitch ideas to me unless they've gone through
peer review. It doesn't have to be published yet. In fact, it's better if it hasn't been published
yet. But if it's been accepted, it's in the process, tell me, and I'll line up coverage
in the newspaper and make sure it goes in, especially if I think our readers are going
to care about it. But I don't like people who push the salesmanship too far because that feels like
they've departed science and gone into salesmanship, which is a weird thing. It's not fair,
but it is what it is. Similarly, scientists who are set on transmit a lot, I think, are using a
gift, but that gift needs to be wielded carefully. That gift needs to be used like you're using it
to communicate how science operates and have interesting conversations rather than trying to
push their specific research out there more. That doesn't mean they shouldn't try to push
their specific research. When a journalist contacts them, if they're ready to talk about
the narrative of their finding, great. That's wonderful. We need that. And there should be
training in it. And there should also be an acknowledgement that not everybody is Galileo,
that if I sat with Semmelweis and spoke Hungarian, which I don't, but if I did, or German, I think
he spoke German too, if I sat with him and explained to him how he needed to hone his message,
I think it would have been like sitting with Sheldon Cooper to try to explain why he should
explain string theory to the public. It would be laughable. And I don't think Semmelweis would ever
get there, but that doesn't mean Semmelweis shouldn't be a scientist any more than someone
like Sheldon Cooper should be out there. We need people with those kinds of minds. They are
critical. And so we also have to be able to say, look, we try to help people to communicate their
science. We accept when they can't. We celebrate when they can. And there are going to be people
in between, and we need to wield what we've got to get the message out there. And when people
can't do it, that's why we have science journalists who can pave the way to bridge that gap. And you
want to have a science journalist who understands the paper and can do the research justice,
rather than just saying, look, it was discovered. When I see these newspapers that are laying people
off and saying, well, we don't need journalists anymore because we can have the AI do it.
And then you read what the AI produces. It's very worrying, especially when it tries to explain
natural selection. Arthur C. Clarke has many quotes and many quips. And one of them is that
the only way to determine the limits of the possible is to go beyond them into the impossible.
And that's the origin of the name of this podcast. He also said the following, he said,
which is echoed by a proposal you make in the book. He said, when a distinguished but older
scientist says something is possible, he, and I assume he would have said nowadays, she is very
much likely to be correct. But when he says something is impossible, he's very much likely
to be wrong. And you very provocatively write in the book that older scientists at the top of the
game, quote, suck up valuable resources and are resistant to novel ideas. Should there be a
mandatory retirement age for my colleagues or forced research reallocation in scientists such
as my colleague? I'm not old. I have taken so much heat for that paragraph in the book.
So I was sitting with Venky Ramakrishnan last year, who wrote Why We Die, he's a Nobel laureate
in biochemistry. And we were talking about exactly this issue. And he commented to me,
you know, Matt, in my field, it is very rare that I find someone in their 70s or 80s,
who I can't think of someone who's in their 20s or 30s, who could do a better job.
And it's astounding how many cling on, rather than gracefully stepping down. I do think that
as we sit in our fields for longer and longer, we adhere ourselves more and more to the paradigms
that we've known for 10, 20, 30 years. And it's all the harder for us to let go of those ideas,
because they become more entrenched in our sclerotic minds. But we do become more entrenched.
There's tons of research in the journal Cognition showing this, I've written about it.
So we know we become less flexible, less adaptable, less open to change as we get older,
it is fact. Does that mean that those folks need to retire? Absolutely not.
But I think we need to be having a conversation about shifting gears, and who is really in
control of the money and where the research is going. And whether we want someone who is very,
very set in their ways, deciding how a million dollars in NS funding is going to go in their
labs. Maybe that ultimate decision should shift to somebody who is more recently stepped into the
field, because they're in a better position to say, well, why do we do things this way?
Why do we accept that idea? Have we replicated that? That's a common theme. Like,
didn't we replicate that? Or, you know, just asking questions, and being more open to the
possibility that the way we've done things for decades might be wrong, is so critical. And
the older we get, and I speak personally, the harder it is for us to accept that something
that is enshrined in our head might be off, or might not be true. I mean, that's what science
is all about. It's about being open. And this is where I go back full circle. You don't want the
gloves to come off. And as we get older, when our core beliefs get challenged, we often feel more
threatened, and our behavior declines. You talk in the book about this famous
misapprehension about Galileo, that he was tortured, you know, for his beliefs, he stood up
bravely to the church. Of course, nothing of the sort is true. In fact, I've hosted multiple
conferences in Galileo's prison in Arcetri, Italy, which I don't know if you've been there,
but if I had to do my time, you know, anywhere like that, I would consider myself quite lucky.
The view of Il Duomo, and the resplendent Tuscan hills. But why do you think he's persist? I mean,
is it this need for hero worship that kind of promulgates this notion that he was tortured
for science, that lone geniuses persist? What is the, is it some sort of urge, like in the movie,
A Few Good Men, you know, that we want you on that wall, you know, we want these scientists
out, these dispassionate arbiters of truth, we need them on that wall, right? As Jack Nicholson
said, no matter how the sausage gets made, as you said, is it just some impulse or need that
the public has to worship heroes, and those heroes have to wear lab coats?
So in this case, it's not that. So I've written two other books on science of monsters and science
of the magical, which looks at the folklore beliefs that stem largely from our misunderstandings of
the natural world. And those books deal with a lot of stories that were created by our ancestors,
in some cases, thousands of years ago, and point out that once narratives are established,
they're incredibly resistant to change. Once we tell a good story around the fire,
even when it's only orally transmitted, there's some really great evidence that those stories
persist. So the message and the story that were stated back in the day of Galileo,
you know, we're talking like 1620s here, was that he was tortured, and that he answered
once he was tortured in a Catholic manner, which meant, you know, Pope, he's telling the truth.
And that's what the Pope needed the followers to hear. So that's the narrative that was shared.
That's the story that was told. A couple hundred years later, evidence emerged that Galileo was
definitely not tortured. Evidence emerged that he actually was never even housed in a cell. He was,
you know, very comfortably put in a five-bedroom apartment, which is a marvelous story in the book.
It's definitely a lot of fun to read. And because those narratives, the torture and recanting
and prison cells were told hundreds of years earlier, those narratives had spread,
and countering them, even with all of the evidence that it wasn't true, has proved
incredibly hard over the years, because stories get entrenched. And that's just the way the human
mind works. Written language with editors, like you do, has been around for like a nanosecond
on the cosmic clock and storytelling around the campfires. Much older, but again, not much older,
not that old as a species, as you know, studying ancient mammals. And maybe we can kind of, you
know, conclude with just a vignette from your days as a scientist and paleontology. I was struck by
kind of the biases that you speak about. Very candidly, you were certainly such a wonderful
journalist, not the least of which because of your vulnerability. And you talk about your own,
you know, kind of lacunae in the past. And one of them was, you know, like you're on a dig and
you literally mistook, you know, the find of a graduate student's, you know, career or whatever.
Talk about that. Talk about the biases that all scientists, good, bad, medium, indifferent,
were all victim to. I studied small mammals. I was looking at isotopes in the teeth of these
animals to work out what kind of environment they had been living in millions of years ago.
And when you're looking for small mammals, you're mostly looking at rodent teeth because,
you know, our teeth, you have to dunk them in Coca-Cola overnight to dissolve them or, you know,
other types of acids. Our teeth are subjected to vast amounts of punishment and they don't
erode away. So mammal teeth are great because you find them in like riverbeds and such.
And once you develop a search image for certain types of mammal teeth in your head,
you get really good at finding them really quickly. It's like a super ability to go,
there's one, there's one, there's one, there's one, there's one. And I remember vividly sitting
there in the sediment in the baking sun in Oregon or rattlesnakes all over the place.
Hate snakes. My research supervisor comes up behind me and says, hey, I can see a shadow
kind of bleeding over me. And he says, Matt, you missed one. And I'm like, what are you talking
about? I found everything. How are you? How have I missed something? And he points and right there
in the middle of the sediment is this rhinoceros tooth. And because I hadn't been looking for
anything like that, I just, my brain dismissed it as it's a rock. And this happens to all of us.
And it's why replication is so important. It's why we need to double check what we're doing.
It's why we need to keep questioning. And we're not doing it as often as we should.
I think we're doing it less and less as years goes by. It's going to catch up with us.
So we got to change our ways. And that's part of what the book's about.
Well, it's an excellent book. You'll be congratulated on this great work. And I think
it'll be of interest to scientists and non-scientists alike, which covers everybody,
of course. But I do want to make sure that in particular students read it because we do a bad
job, as I said, of doing what should come easy to us, which is unfortunately very rare. It's
ethical training. We have these mandatory two-hour seminars each year about sexual harassment. But
it's all these online things and ethics and research. And you can never tell if you've
passed it or failed it. I think we could do well by doing what our colleagues do in journalism
and business. And even in the law school, those lawyers, you got to keep your eye on them.
Matt Calvin, thank you so much for taking us on this tour of scientific history,
the legacies. Thank you so much. Congratulations on this great book. And I hope we do get to meet
in person. And I hope you get your luggage eventually, wherever it may be in space.
Brian, thank you so much for having me.
I think you agree that Matt Kaplan just made the case that the way we fund science is actually
suppressing the next big breakthrough. If that changes how you think about the replication
crisis, hit subscribe, turn your notifications on so you don't miss what's coming next.
Drop me a comment and let me know, do you think there should be mandatory retirement ages for
scientists? If you want to go deeper into how paradigm shifting resistance is nearly
killing discoveries, check out my conversation with Nobel prize winner,
Catelyn Carrico. It's linked right here. Go ahead, click it and don't forget to subscribe.
See you next week on Into the Impossible.