BEST LUXURY BEAUTY | Guerlain VS Sisley | Battle of luxury beauty

Cosmetics and Makeup tricks
241 followers
12 Video Views·Mar 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Bonjour tout le monde. Hi everyone. It's me, Ali, your fancy friend in Montreal.
And for today's video, we're doing a battle. I'm comparing Sisley makeup products versus
Garnier. Both of these brands in my mind are part of the upper echelon of very prestigious,
very luxury makeup. And I have a lot of similar products from each brand. So I thought we could
do a half face, half Sisley, half Garnier. And then at the end, you can vote on which side you
like the best, which products you like the best. That's today's video. But before we go any further,
let's take a second to grab our iced coffee or a hot coffee. Let's take a sip and let's get
started. Everything that I'm mentioning today that I'm using, the brushes, it's all going to
be listed in the description box down below. So go ahead and have a look there. Okay, so the first
items we're going to start with are eyeshadow. I always do eyes first. So we have the Sisley
palette here in Tender Toffee. And then from Garnier, we have the Wild Nudes. So both of these
off the bat, they look kind of boring in the palette, which is great because oftentimes the
most boring looking eyeshadow looks the most complimentary. But which one is the most
complimentary? That is really the question we're trying to get to today. On this side here, we're
going to go into Sisley. So I'm starting off with this color here. What's to note is that for the
quads, Sisley only has two quads. They have a lot of singles, but as I'm filming this today,
they only have two quads. And this one here is the more neutral, warm option. The other one was a
little bit too pinky for my taste. So I chose this one. And this Sisley palette has a combination
of matte shades on the bottom and then more satin on top. I'm simply knocking the excess of the
eyeshadow on a tissue here. It's much easier to add makeup than it is to remove. So I often like
to just pick up some shadow and then knock it off here. I'm mixing both of the bottom colors here
just to create a beautiful, rich color. So this is Tender Toffee. It really is very pretty. If you
want something more in like the neutrals or maybe a little bit more of a richer brown, a richer
toffee color. But I'm also a huge fan of their singles. I have several and I'm doing maybe close
to 10 singles from Sisley now at this point because they're just so pretty. They're just
one and done. It's really one and done. But this quad here, it's really pretty. And I do think
mixing both of those matte colors is where it's at. So I added both of those matte colors with
one brush and then I'm going in with a bigger fluffy brush very lightly to blend it out. If you
only learn one thing from today's video, use one brush to add darker color and then a separate one
to blend it out very softly. This way you get to control how dark your makeup will be. I'm just
going to pass this under the bottom lashes very quickly just to act as my bottom eyeliner here.
Now using the same brush that I used before for that first color, I'm just going to go use the
clean side and pick up the lighter color here just to add a little bit of brightness. Now the lighter
color has a little bit of fallout. I think the formula is slightly different. I'm gonna use my
finger just like this just to add a little bit extra brightness. As far as fallout goes, there's
a tiny bit but not much. I think it's a very negligible amount. I'm a big fan of eyeshadow
first because I just find it such a waste of time and money and spirit and energy to do
your concealer, your powder, and everything and then do your eyeshadow and then have to fix it.
I'd much rather do my eyes first, clean it up a little bit, and then move on to the rest. That's
just me. Let's go into wild nudes. Now Guerlain has several if not dozens of, I don't know, at least a
dozen of these quads available. They have lots of options, lots of color stories. I do not believe
they have any singles, so if you want eyeshadows from Guerlain, it's going to have to be in this
formula here. Now this is three matte with one satin here, so we're going to use this one first.
So if you want more color story options in a quad, Guerlain would be your option. However,
I find that sometimes with Guerlain, with the quads, some of them are a little bit powdery,
like a little bit too dry. It depends. They do have some very fun color stories, some
pinks and purples and some greens and things like that. Some of them are a little bit dry,
a little bit chalky sometimes, and we're going to see how this one wears. So I will go ahead and mix
these two here. I think it should also be noted that Sisley has several friends and family sales.
I think they have at least two a year where they have, I believe it's 20 or 25 percent off
site-wide. I do not believe Guerlain does this. Perhaps they should. I would appreciate it.
What I like about both brands is that they really do things to the beat of their own drums.
I think Guerlain follows a little bit more of a seasonal formula than Sisley. However,
both of them just come out with products whenever they feel like it. Their permanent
collection items really just, new ones launch when they launch. They don't seem to be following
anyone else's formula, which I really truly appreciate. Let me add a little bit of this
one here as well. Even though Wild Nudes, the name wouldn't make you suspect that it is
nude, I would say it is much warmer than the Sisley Tender Toffee. And I am in fact using
the correct brushes on each side. Don't worry, there's no cross-contamination here.
But just looking at this, Wild Nudes looks much warmer. When we just looked at these quickly,
you know, when we're passing by the makeup counters really fast, you might think, oh,
they kind of look similar. These look quite different. Let me add a little bit of this
color here just to see if this will, it'll lighten a little bit. But there's only one
satin color. I put a mascara on from neither brand, so we're in neutral territory there.
Moving on to the complexion, I have the Guerlain Jolietain Terracotta. This is the shade 20 golden.
And I don't currently have a complexion product from Sisley. Listen, I think each brand has its
own strength. There is something about Sisley shade ranges that rarely suit me. I find that
their shade ranges skip and jump. They're often very limited. And instead of, like, let's say
it's 20, 30, 40, up to 90, I don't know, whatever, or 100. I find that instead of it being a gradual
progression, a little bit deeper, a little bit deeper, it's the next shade is deeper and
significantly cooler or significantly warmer. And I've simply had a difficult time finding the
correct shade match. And I didn't feel like going through that for today's video. So I opted out.
And yeah, throw your tomatoes in the comments section if you want. But I do know that Sisley
is coming out with new products for the summer season. So hopefully that means something
complexion wise. And yeah, I think many of you who have purchased Sisley products know what I'm
talking about. There's just big jumps that are difficult to figure out, especially if you're
shopping online. I think in person it's easier. But anyway, this is the 20 from the terracotta
line. I think this is fine. I wish it was... I wish I'd gotten the 30. It could be a little bit
deeper. I do love this. It's a tinted moisturizer. It glides on so easily. It feels like butter. It
feels like an ice cube melting on your skin. It's a really beautiful application. I just wish I had
gotten a slightly deeper shade. For the concealer on the Sisley side, this is the PhytoCell Eclat.
This is the shade number four. And this application is amazing because it has like a metal
tip application that feels really cooling when you apply. And then for Guerlain, it's the
Terracotta Concealer. This is the shade 3M01. I think that's what it is. It'll all be in the
subtitles or the description box. That is the correct information. I'm placing this here.
The one from Sisley is the better option. I can tell you that immediately right away.
The concealer from Sisley. Wow. I don't know what they put in this. Magic, witchcraft, whatever.
Keep up the good work. Honestly, where I think they're lacking in the foundation complexion
products, the concealer knocks it out. The concealer, it's honestly top, top, top tier. It's
really pricey. I don't care. I think it's worth it. Definitely. There's something about the formula.
It's rich. It's creamy. It blends easily. It covers so well. It doesn't crease. It doesn't
move. It sets beautifully. It brightens. It's just it's exactly what you want from
a very expensive concealer. So that's that. The Terracotta Concealer is good. It's just not as
good. Like I think this one here, it's a good it's a good product. It's just that it's being
compared to one of the best I've ever tried. If I was only going to pick one concealer,
Guerlain wouldn't even stand a chance. Sadly, it would be Sisley all the way. That being said,
this blends really nicely. It leaves a really beautiful, smooth application. There's nothing
wrong with it. It's just, you know, it can't it's just not really I don't say not comparable,
but it's just, you know, one is just really extraordinary and one is just good.
To me, the Sisley side looks even more lifted. It looks more plumped and just better. So for
the bronzer, I'm going into the Sisley bronzer here. This is the Fito Touch, and this is like
a nice gel bronzer. It reminds me of the one from Chantecaille, like that sort of texture.
So I'm just going to apply and there's just something about this. It melts into the skin.
It's like a nice soft gel to powder finish. It's very natural. Moving on to Guerlain,
we have the Terracotta Light. This is the shade 03 Medium Warm. This one,
it's a bronzer and a blush and a highlighter, three in one. This is a spectacular product as
a multi-use product. I mean, it's great on its own, but usually when I wear this, I skip blush.
I skip everything else. It's everything I want mixed together. So there's that. And I love this
shade because it has a little bit of like a tangerine color. I think it's gorgeous for
summer. It is not summer in Montreal. I can see snow outside. I don't care. I'm just, you know,
living in my warm weather fantasy here. But this one is very pretty. There are more shades to
choose from, from Guerlain for the bronzers. They're very strong in the bronzer game. I think
if I was just going to pick one bronzer, that's really hard. I don't know. They're both very
pretty. I think I, I think the finish I like a little bit more is from Guerlain,
even though the one from Sisley is very nice. There's something about this finish where it's
like a soft velvet powder. The one from Sisley is quite nice, but it's just not the exact same.
Speaking of blush. Okay. Sisley here has basically perfected blush in the sense that these,
this blush series, this is the number three coral. Listen, this is a work of art. It's a piece of
art. I've owned this for, I think a year now, maybe more. I don't know. I dig into it quite a
bit, but this exquisite packaging maintains its shape. It doesn't go anywhere. It doesn't get
smushed together. So I mean, let me just swirl this one and there's other, they have other
shades to choose from. They don't have that many. I would love to see them extend this
and have other color options. That would be great. I think this one is so, so pretty.
It sort of just sits on the skin, but it melts at the same time. And it's very lovely. It also just
feels very lovely to pull this out and to just see this little jewel in your makeup vanity. It's
quite lovely. I think maybe for this makeup look, I would have gone with something a little bit
warmer blush wise, but I think it works. This one has a soft, subtle highlight,
but it's, it's not a chunky glitter at all. It's more just like a beautiful luminous finish.
Now, normally on this side here with the Guerlain, I would just leave it as is, but I'm going to add
a little bit of blush and they have a blush series. The ones that I have are a little bit
more cool toned. I'm using the 01 light pink. They have other blush options. They have more
blush options from Guerlain and the Guerlain blushes are really, really nice. Like I use
these all the time and they, they last all day. Like these blushes do not fade. If you want to
blush, it's going to last eight, nine, 10, 12 longer hours. Like this is it. This also has
a beautiful luminous finish. There is a huge difference in price point. The one from Sisley,
it's a astronomical, but the one from Guerlain in comparison is just so reasonable. Honestly,
I think the one from Guerlain is a little bit more of a slow build. You gradually add and all of a
sudden you see it there. I think they're both quite luminous. I think Sisley is more luminous,
but I think they're both quite lovely. Moving on to the lips. Sisley is very strong when it comes
to lips. It's the phyto rouge, the phyto rouge velvet. They have a glossy version,
all of their lips. I think I've tried every single lip formula that Sisley has come out with and I've
loved each one. The question is usually a price point issue for me because it's so pricey, but
I'll wait for the sale and then I get what I want. As far as lipsticks go, I, I, I don't think you
can go wrong. I think it's just a question of finish. I love the regular phyto rouge, which
is like a classic bullet with like a satin finish, but I have the velvet here. This,
it's a classic bullets with a more matte finish. And this one is 41. I'm going for a more of a
classic red lip look. This one is a gorgeous shade. 41 is more of a classic red with a little
bit more of a yellow undertone. It's more like a tomato red. I also have one called rose punch,
which is a little bit more of a raspberry color, which is really lovely. But now we have
the Guerlain cases. Look at this. This is bumblebees on denim. Are you kidding me? And
this shade here is 880. Oh, I think this Sisley one is a little bit closer to a yellow and then
a little bit more blue based over here from Guerlain. A little color theory here right for
you live. But there is something to mention about the Guerlain lipsticks. This lipstick and case
from Guerlain here is the older version. If you go into the store now, my case and lipstick will
not fit. I was super annoyed when that happened because this came out, I think two years ago.
I have multiple Guerlain lipsticks and then they came out with a new case and my lipsticks no
longer fit. So I was really annoyed. So I haven't purchased any new lipsticks from Guerlain because
I would have to start I would have to buy a lipstick and a case just to start over again,
which is I find very frustrating for the client. Like this is so annoying. I buy these thinking
I'm going to be able to enjoy them for a long time. And that was not the case. So there is that
caveat just to mention to you guys. And now is your time in the comments. OK, so I have to say
that wild nudes should be renamed to like warm nudes. On me, it's much warmer. I think I feel
like I'm noticing it fading a little bit. Not a lot, but I just feel like the Sisley side has
more punch. It could be a texture thing that there's a better mixture of textures with
satin and matte as well. I don't know. They're both nice. I do like the softness of these mattes.
It's much warmer than the name would make you think. On me, it's a warm nude more than anything
else. I do like that we have a mixture of satin finishes with the mattes here. Now, what about
the blush and the bronzer and the lipsticks and everything? I don't know. I think bronzer.
I think Guerlain. Yeah, I think bronzer for me goes to Guerlain. I think blush goes to Sisley.
I think concealer goes to Sisley and lipsticks. I mean, I really love my old
Guerlain lipsticks. I'm not buying any new ones this exact moment. I do love these Fitu Velvet
lipsticks. They're very nice. We should also add some fragrance. I have the Sisley hair perfume,
hair mist, and I have a couple other Guerlain perfumes. I have the Aqua Allegoria. I have
three of these. I have this one here. It's called Coconut Fizz. This was discontinued very sadly,
but these ones here, the Aqua Allegoria, it's like eau de toilette. It's very light.
Sometimes what I do is I put on my body moisturizer and I spray. It creates a beautiful, luscious,
scented body lotion. Let's go ahead and smell like a coconut. This is crazy. I can see so much snow
outside and I'm like, no, no, no. It's summer. Let me just do that. This, the Sisley perfume here,
it's a hair body mist. It smells like a spa. You know how a spa smells? This is exactly how it
smells. So let me know what you think. What do you think of this battle royale of Sisley versus
Guerlain? Next time you're at the makeup counters and you're looking at them, you can sort of see
them side eyeing each other. I would love to hear from you down in the comments. Let me know which
products from each brand you like most. Overall, do you have a side you prefer? It's interesting
because the Wild Nudes, because everything is more matte, it does look more subtle. It kind of looks
more natural in a way. I don't know. I don't know. Sound off in the comments below. If you made it
this far to the, if you made it to the end of the video, if you made it this far into the video,
maybe leave a green heart emoji in honor of my tank top. And if you're not subscribed to my
channel, please take the time to do so. I do lots of reviews and tutorials, and I like to mix and
match new and old makeup collections. So I'll give you lots of inspiration at home on how to use up
what you have. Anyway, that's all I have for you guys for today. Thank you so much for stopping by.
Hope you have a beautiful day, and I'll see you next time. Bye.
