Love Story: JFK Jr and Carolyn Bessette Ep 9 Finale Recap + Reaction (Podcast Full Ep)

Cupid’s Compass
15 followers
70 Video Views·Mar 30, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello.
Welcome to the previously on podcast.
I'm Jillian Benani and joining me today, a guy who wanted to do a live
podcast right after this finale.
It's Tyler Branch.
He really outed me right there.
You know, it seemed like a good idea at first.
I was like, this is the TV event of the season.
But, uh, I forgot what a gut wrenching show this is.
And that was quite devastating.
I mean, I think my eyes are still red from crying.
I mean, once I started sobbing about 20 minutes in, I couldn't stop.
I know we're recording this right after watching.
And every time I looked at Jillian, it was just, I don't even know how
you could see the show.
Like you were bawling your eyes out.
You were doing like wellness checks on me throughout and I'm not
typically somebody who cries at TV shows mainly because if I know
what's going to be sad, I typically don't cry.
It's like my body prepared itself so much that then I don't end up
crying because I was so ready for it.
So I was kind of surprised that I, I mean, I was really crying at this
one.
It was, we were taking pause breaks for you to wipe your eyes.
It was tough to watch.
You kept looking over.
I mean, like, are you okay?
I didn't know if you were going to be able to do this or not.
Well, if you couldn't tell, we are just off the big finale of Love
Story, John F.
Kennedy and Carolyn Bessette, the final episode, episode 9 called
Search and Recovery.
And obviously we knew this was going to be a tough one.
We, we know how this ends.
We've been dreading it.
We know it was going to be bad.
But I still don't think I was prepared for how bad it was.
And Constance Zimmer, who plays Carolyn's mom on the show, said in
an interview that the finale would be very, very difficult for everybody
to watch.
And I can confirm that that is true.
It was a little piece of me was holding out for the Quentin Tarantino
ending of just where he rewrites history, like in a glorious bastards
or once upon a time, like Sharon Tate lives.
Yeah, we love that spoiler for those movies, but he rewrites history
a little bit.
But unfortunately, this was pretty true to events.
Yeah, which just made it even harder that reminder.
Yeah, and they really did this episode in a way to of showing their
relationship and them rekindling and working on things and it just
made it even harder.
I know, I know.
It's because the show, you know, as much as it is like the 90s
nostalgia and the New York and the fun love story of it all, you do
deep down know you're watching a tragedy and that's part of what
makes it so terribly compelling because these people don't get to
live the hopeful lives that they're dreaming of.
Well, I was trying to forget that part.
I was trying to ignore the tragedy this whole time.
Yeah, I kept being like that's for me to deal with next week.
That's next week's problem that and next week is now here.
Yeah, you thought maybe no ordinary love was going to come back on
and they would just live and live happily ever after.
I thought maybe they won't show it.
Maybe it will just be like, well, you know what happened.
We just I gotta say they got pretty close to show it in a way that
I didn't surprise.
I didn't think we were going to see in the plane and I was like,
whoa, we're getting up to some some dire moments right here.
I know I did not think they were going to show that I was shocked
by that too, but I thought they handled it in a good way because
they kept bringing it back to John and Carolyn's relationship.
So even in the plane, it's about the two of them and kind of how
they were dealing with it in that moment and we saw her go to sit
by him.
So they kept bringing it back to the two of them.
And this is a reminder before I get even more into this episode
that we wipe your eyes a little.
You okay?
We're good.
You breathe.
You're going to have something to breathe throughout.
We're discussing the events of the show.
Not the real life people.
If you do want to hear us talk about what actually happened go and
listen to our fact-checked episode.
That's where we talk all about the real-life John and Carolyn the
Kennedy's what's real what isn't but in this episode, we're focusing
just on what we saw on the show.
And if you haven't already please subscribe and follow our podcast
give us five stars like our vids on YouTube share with your friends.
It all really helps.
We would love that.
Well since this episode was such a doozy.
Let's just get into our top five because the top five is top five
heart-wrenching moments from this episode.
I mean they were heart-wrenching.
It was it was sad.
It was a tough watch because they they set you up and you knew they were
setting you up at the beginning.
They were showing you these good times again and playing the hits, you
know, and you just knew the hammer was going to drop it made it harder.
You know, I was like, why are they doing this to me?
I know I know.
But they did give us some lovely moments of them together and for sure
callbacks to past episodes.
So that's all in this top five heart-wrenching moments to so it's not
all the back half of the app.
Don't you worry people were talking about some of the good stuff to so
number five heart-wrenching moment goes to John and Carolyn rekindling
after marriage counseling.
You caught it rekindling.
I think I told you I thought it was a good moment when they got a drink
and banged I would prefer you say have sex.
But yes, I prefer to call it rekindling because I think it was all of it.
It was them at the dive bar having some cutesy moments getting all close
together reminiscing on the past them hooking up like it was all just
really fun and it was such a callback to the beginning of the relationship.
They're both very good at flirting.
Oh when he says you mind if I come back and get my linen jacket, I mean
what I was like, let's go.
Let's go get that jacket got the lines.
Yeah, he was ready to go.
Although I don't think that counselor was fallen for either one of them.
She did seem I think he's right that they are.
I think Carolyn said that counselor hates us, but I think she might be
right.
They did the opposite of what she told them to do.
She said take time apart and let me tell you counselor.
If you tell these two to take some time apart, they're just going to get
closer together and maybe that was her game plan the entire time.
This is so that couple though that if people if people recommend to them
that maybe they should like separate.
They're like we're going to hook up right now.
Good.
I know and you know what that type of couple is fun to watch.
Yeah.
Yeah, these these people have been walking around New York with no
security as if there aren't mobs of photographers threatening them at
all times.
These people ain't going to listen to your advice.
No, no, they're like that's for different people.
They live in their own world.
Yeah, I love their to that.
She's like, well, you don't want to get divorced and you don't really
want to be together as is right now.
So something has to give here people.
They're both pretty stubborn.
They are.
That's what's fun about it.
They're that kind of just like fiery flame of a couple.
Yeah, they are.
Well, our lot of passion lot of fights.
Yeah, and that's why it's fun to watch our number four heart-wrenching
moment goes to Carolyn showing up to the George Awards and meeting up
with John at the Indian restaurant.
Their first date spot.
Yes, it was fun to see that place back, which again, we've been there.
What is it?
Pana to yeah, we have been there now.
You can barely get in.
This show really that restaurant.
I think there was a line at the door.
Yeah, it's an old school New York place.
That's fine.
No, it was great to them saying their lines again.
Like I love that.
I love that so much.
I fall for that in a TV show every time.
Normally a show does that, you know, season four in or something.
They like give a call back to that, but I appreciated that they called
back to it in this episode.
But part of why these moments are so heart-wrenching is because you
just know what's to come.
Yeah, so tough to watch them knowing these are like their final moments
together.
Well, and it's sad to see them getting to where they want to be and
to see them growing together and finally compromising and meeting
each other in the middle.
I mean Carolyn going to the event when John really wanted her to go
and that meant so much to him and you're like, oh, we're getting
somewhere with them.
They're getting through it.
They're getting through these problems.
They're figuring it out.
And that's what makes it even more sad is you feel like oh, they can
make this work.
They can do it.
They're they're meeting in the middle.
They're finding their old spark again.
They're going back to that first date spot and they're being vulnerable
with each other.
Well, and then when she walks in it's such a like, you know, movie
star moment.
It feels like they're both on the glam cam all of a sudden.
Yeah, it's like you get to watch these stars be in love and the way
they look at each other.
And even though there's a million people there taking photos.
It's like they're just looking.
They only see each other.
Yeah, and they look so happy in that moment.
They do.
It could you could tell it meant a lot to him that she came.
Yeah, and sometimes that's all you need.
He just needed that support and after they go on that first date
again, they really you get the sense that they are going to work on
this relationship and that they're going to figure it out.
Carolyn gets a little bit more vulnerable with him.
She reveals what her sign would say, which is please handle with care.
She's not as tough as she looks.
You get that impression that that's part of why she was show her by
how this fight has come with John and how he's handled trying to work
it out is because she finally did let her guard down and was tried
to be honest about how she felt with someone and he didn't he just
didn't react well to her being so vulnerable.
I know and I think that it just brought back a lot of stuff with
her dad that luckily Lauren gives her a little bit of tough love of
like you also need to communicate with him.
You can't put it all on him.
You're blaming him for dad stuff, which is a lot of you know, what
people do were hurt most by what happened to us both sisters gave
some tough love in this.
Yeah, but they were both such a great scenes and yeah, they were
really just the one speaking reason to them like no one else will I
know they need those people in their lives because they don't have
many people who will tell them the truth.
I mean, especially John he doesn't have many people who will tell
it to him straight like Caroline would so yeah and John even tells
Caroline that he'll be there for her that she's the most important
thing and you're like finally what she wanted to hear are such beautiful
moments, but you know, there's a bit of it.
That's like, you know, the clip show the like play the hit because
you just know this isn't going to work out.
I will say though.
I'm glad that they gave us these moments.
I would rather have them than have them play just like clips from
the past or what could have been or the show had them still not
talking or not on good terms because they kind of did a switcheroo
with us a little bit from because we saw them going to the plane
in the very first episode of the show and it seemed like the
relationship was really done at that point and whatnot and then
when you saw this time you viewed it a little bit differently.
Yeah.
Yeah, I, uh, I looked up the George awards.
I was trying to I did a quick Google trying to find out.
I was like, what was this event?
Like how many awards did they give out?
Was this like a full-on award show and couldn't find a lot about
it said that that year it was him and Paul Newman put on the awards
Newman's own it was the Newman's own George awards and they were
given awards to a company's that treated their employees.
Well, and they were given an award to Kenneth Cole or something,
but I couldn't really find the whole list.
I was curious about this event.
That sounds all anytime you look at the very nice.
If you look up the event, all it is is just what Carolyn wore that
suit thing.
She wore.
I mean, she looked cool.
I was on the coverage.
John just wanted to make an award show so he could have another
event to go to.
That's probably what that was.
We can relate.
Yeah, he's like I need a night out.
Let's just make an award show.
Let's give somebody an award.
Listen to our previously on awards podcast.
We have a similar energy about us who doesn't love an award show,
you know, all right back to our top five heart-wrenching moments
from this episode.
Number three goes to Carolyn saying just breathe in the plane.
This was especially heart-wrenching because we've seen her say just
breathe to him before she has helped him.
She's always helped calm him down help him through panic attacks.
So this was tough.
It really was and like her getting up in the front seat with them.
Yeah, you know because she's feeling this gonna it's just so tough
and everything's red.
Like the lights and stuff and you just know it's so ominous as you
see because you see the sky off like not looking great in the
distance.
It's so brutal and then it seems to get worse and worse.
I was a little bit confused of what all was going on in the plane.
Yeah.
Well, I did read about this when we did the fact-checked episode
and apparently they do explain it a little bit in the episode
later on, but it really was like John called about what you see
here is he calls about the weather they give him to go ahead, but
they leave at a later time and the weather has changed slightly and
it just seems like such such awful luck because in a lot of the area
around that visibility was fine, but on their particular route, they
hit just this crazy haze and just couldn't see there was just
no visibility.
And so when you're over water and you've just got the dark sky and
the dark ocean and it's all just you need some kind of guide as to
where up and down.
It's like you need a horizon.
You need to see the ground to know that that's the sky like or you
really can get twisted and not not know which way's up.
It's so sad and they had talked about how earlier he still needed
his instrument training.
They hit that a few times in the show of that.
Like he had a little bit of training on instruments, but he needed
like a lot more training to get certified to be able to fly by
instruments.
So he was only allowed to fly by like visibility and it was just
and then he had no visibility.
Yes, then it was the bad luck.
He had no visibility.
So he's trying to fly by instruments, but it's not trained to do
that and you can't see and like they said, it's an illusion like
your brain will tell you the wrong thing to do when you can't see
the ground that is so crazy.
I've never really thought about that before that.
It's like kind of like a black hole type of thing and that you
wouldn't even know if you're upside down.
Yeah, it's very scary.
That's very sad.
Yeah.
All right.
Well now we're really in the sad heart-wrenching moment part of the
list.
Yeah, we're in the real dark part of the list.
So number two heart-wrenching moment.
That's what I was hoping to find the George Awards.
I was like, I could just read another George Award after each one
on the list, but couldn't find it.
That would have been fun.
Yeah, I tried.
All right, number two.
We do have some fun things planned for later on in the we just have
to talk about this this crier of an episode this brutal episode and
this might be one of the more brutal ones number two goes to Caroline
and Anne grieving.
Yes.
Oh, this was real tough to watch.
I mean it starts with Caroline and you feel so bad for her when she
just starts to break down saying I'm not doing this again.
It's just like it's so painful.
It's so hard to watch you you feel for her.
I mean that is her last immediate family member.
It's just so sad like she's already been through so much tragedy and
now she just lost her brother to under very tragic circumstances and
then you see Anne's perspective when she goes to talk to Ed who
immediately brings up where the Kennedys want John to be buried which
was just not the right move here.
You really see the other side of the coin of like I did feel so bad for
Caroline when of what she's going through and rightfully so she's a
person like she's dealing with a major loss the shocking loss of losing
your brother at such a young age, but then for Anne to just be so outside
of this family and like yeah be completely ignored what her wishes are
and what she's going through and the fact that she lost two daughters
which she has to explain that to Ed Ed just gives condolences and kind
of like moves on is not even mentioning Lauren and any of the burial
stuff and when she has to explain that she lost two daughters.
It is really really sad them saying that her choices were to bury her
daughter in DC or Massachusetts and she was like my daughter has no
attachment to either of these places.
I don't even think DC was offered.
I think that you're right.
That's what it was off.
He was going to be he was going to be in DC by himself.
You're right.
That's what yeah, which is so insensitive to say that to and to like
so we're gonna bury him in DC and you know, you can see whatever it's
like they are married and died in this very tragic circumstance like
and brings that up to Caroline to how this is all being treated in the
press where John is on the cover of every magazine Carolyn's featured
on the inside and Lauren is barely a footnote in it.
Yeah, and I cannot imagine that of seeing John's face just plastered
everywhere because everyone's comparing it to the tragic loss of his
dad.
So everyone's being like father and son like there was there's so much
of that.
Yeah, you can understand and anger.
Yes is it's just it's so awful because you know, she had foreshadowed
this with her speech like at the wedding and then for to lose both
daughters just unimaginable pain and then everyone's talking about the
Kennedy curse as if like, you know, he didn't have some, you know
responsibility and flying the plane that instead the press is completely
blaming Carolyn and like if you look this up in real life, you can see
all sorts of just awful stories and headlines that like attack like
Carolyn blaming her for like delaying the flight and you know, because
she was getting her nails done which is just making her sound like a
very vain person that she had to get her nails done before going to this
Kennedy wedding and that's why this happened, which that is not the
truth at all.
No, and you know, they ruled it, you know pilot error like yeah wasn't
equipped to be doing what he was doing.
It's very very sad.
I think it's one of those things to where it's just such a tragedy.
We don't need to be like throwing around like blame on people who are
gone.
Don't have to blame.
Neither of these people wanted to die, right, you know, exactly.
So those are just some really tough scenes.
I did love the scene though where and and Caroline more so come together
seem to read some common ground.
You really see how grief can bring people together like these two.
I feel like barely spoke had no kind of relationship.
And in this moment, they really rely on each other.
Yeah, because no one else understands really.
Yeah, I mean it's tough.
Whatever Caroline walks in the apartment and they make eye contact
with each other and you're like what's about to go down right now.
Yeah, I'm like, oh my God, please don't like scream at each other.
It's just so awkward.
It's awkward.
It's nice and talking it out and seeing each other's sadness and knowing
that like, you know, you don't have to blame each other.
You can understand that both people both sides are hurting a lot.
Right now, but yeah, I'm not sure if in real life.
It was quite as yeah, I don't think it was.
But once again, we're not talking about the real life people.
We're talking about Ann and Caroline from this show.
I'm just saying what I'm just I'm making the point that they did try
to end us on a more hopeful note, which I mean, I have no idea if
Ann and Caroline Kennedy in real life had bad blood for each other.
I just know about, you know, the lawsuits and stuff.
And so I'm just, but I'm glad that, you know, in the show, what
they're trying to show is that people are really hurting and you
need to have a lot of sympathy for what everyone is going through
in both sides.
Yeah, I think it was nice that they were both able to say their
perspective on it.
And then in the end we see and ask Caroline, you know, how how do
you get up the next day?
Like, how do you get through this?
I thought that that was such a great moment of them kind of finding
some common ground together in this and reaching out for each other
with support.
Yeah, for sure.
So thank you for the show for bringing us some some kind of hope
in that moment.
They were trying.
They were trying to find their moments.
Yeah, they were.
But brutal to watch them get there.
Yeah, and I think you feel for both of them too.
Oh, of course.
How can you not just everybody in this situation?
Which that brings me to the number one most heart-wrenching moment
in this episode goes to everyone grieving.
We see Caroline walk through the crowd outside the apartment for
the first time.
It was eerily silent.
Everybody just let her walk by walk on through you see also how
much these people meant to other people.
Yes, which I think that puts it all in perspective like we're
watching this as a love story.
And yes, we're seeing the paparazzi and the photos and all that
and whatnot.
But these people did mean a lot to people.
It's a good boy.
And like, you know, it's not like they were going through all of
this fame in vain because they did mean a lot to people's lives
people like, you know, follow them and I gauge their lives by
what's going on with their lives.
They've they watch John grow up.
This is a whole lot, you know, right?
Yeah, so I think just seeing the memorial outside of the apartment
like that really got me that that was really like it more put it
into perspective that this is real too.
And that is what really happened and the show is continuing on
in these moments without our main characters.
We're not seeing them anymore.
It feels so eerie to see, you know, Calvin there and to see the
family there to just see all these characters.
You've seen all season, but they're not there the stars of the
show are gone and you miss them.
Oh, absolutely.
You miss them in those moments.
I mean when we went to Calvin, I was like, oh my God Calvin.
It was sad.
It was sad and then it ends on those just, you know, and gives
the poems at the end as we're seeing like the flashes of what
she's given.
I looked up what she said and she read the poem death is nothing
at all by Henry Scott Holland and the poem do not stand at my
grave and weep by Mary Elizabeth Frye and I saw some stuff online
that the real Anne Freeman at least read the first one.
I'm not 100% on that but it was a nice moment of talking it because
both are very much about trying to put a different spin on their
death and remembering what they meant to you and how much you love
them how much they loved each other.
Yeah, and then the moments where they are spreading the ashes on
the boat, which that is real.
That is what they did.
Yeah, that was very sad too.
Lots of very sad moments.
I just feel like I keep saying that was very sad and that was very
sad too and that was sad and I cried during that moment too and
that was not uplifting either but I was happy that they spread the
ashes all their ashes together.
I thought that that was nice.
Not just sad nice as well.
Nice and sad.
All right.
Do you have any Tyler's takes for us?
I do you want something lighter?
This is funny, but is it going to be funny?
Oh, I've always got something lighter.
That makes me nervous.
While you're crying your eyes out.
I was joking around here in my notes app.
Oh God.
Oh, I did want to open with there were a few stories about how the
KFC thing which we thought was almost completely product placement
last week was apparently real that multiple people had written about
Carolyn eating KFC.
Wow.
All right, she did love it.
The author of the book said that Carolyn only had one recipe in her
home.
She mostly ordered out every meal which we love that.
We love that.
That's a New York girl.
My kind of gal.
We love that.
Yeah, but that isn't to say KFC didn't still pay him a little.
Well, feel like they had to have I mean, they must have gotten some money
from that, but that's when it works out.
Great when it's like kind of real too.
I mean it worked.
I want KFC.
I thought her telling the mayor the marriage counselor that she dreams
of wearing the Jackie pink suit like that was haunting that was like, well
when she talked about the Jackie suit, it reminded me of when Ethel Kennedy
said, you know that Jackie had to wear that and it's about being a Kennedy
is about like, you know, standing there and taking it up.
It's like showing that, you know, you can handle the pain and which was
eerily similar to what Ethel says at the end of this to Caroline, but I
thought just Carolyn thinking about wearing Jackie's outfit was just that
truly was carrying the burden of all of this of what bad things were to come.
It also shows how many ghosts are just in this relationship.
This is not an easy relationship to be in with all this history all this
tragedy and all these just like surrounding ghosts that you can't get
away from I do think this show is hopeful that these two might have made
it, you know that they might have been able to stay together because when
you think they were dealing with a lot of obstacles like this wasn't just
normal like marriage troubles.
This was like insane like world like just putting so much pressure on and
they were still fighting through it.
So I think they would have lasted I think they showed them working on the
problems when they came up.
So I think they would have lasted based on the show based on what we know on
the show together forever.
I love that dive that empty dive bar getting a drink during the work day,
you know, that's my kind of vibe.
You and I took a day off where we went to like a like a Upper East Side bar
and like got them to open we did had a drink and did something like that one
day.
It's just like New York to have a weird day like that.
Yeah, you know, it's fun getting drunk in the afternoon in New York.
Just having a drink.
It is fun.
Did you see that that was right by their apartment too?
Oh, it's the bar that's like right by their apartment because then I thought
that makes sense.
Like they probably know this bartender more.
It's probably much easier for them to go to a dive bar during the work day
too.
They don't have to worry about a crowd.
That's probably where you meet famous people's just midday like that.
That's the one time they can go.
That's a good point.
We'll try it.
Yeah, try it again.
I felt the running down to catch the elevator move.
What a move wasn't even out of breath.
This guy this guy loved it.
That's not the kind of kiss.
I was talking about.
I think I just said thank you for giving us this.
This is what I needed in this episode.
I needed a good elevator kiss.
I needed a good running to stop it.
Put the hand in there.
Do you think they got through with the script and we're like we just need
One more like punch it up.
Happy moment for the girl.
He's watching and they were like, what if they talk about what their best
kiss was and I do think that's exactly what they did.
I was thinking do people really remember a kiss that well, they seem to they
could have a spreadsheet on them.
They remember every single one.
Yeah.
Well, they're dramatic.
But how like it was just good.
I just keep thinking back to it now.
I'm like that was a good moment.
And yes, I do think they wrote it for that and I don't care.
It's still do the top five on this episode.
We should have just done their top five kisses in the show.
Maybe we'll do that in another app.
Yeah, I liked the next morning of when Carolyn says should we talk about last
night?
John goes, yeah, that is so just the guy's response.
He's like, were we even having problems?
Like we had sex.
We're good, right?
He was like, let's meet for lunch.
You want to talk about that's not what I'm talking about.
She was like, no, this this wasn't great.
Like maybe we should tell our counselor about it.
And he's like, we're not telling the counselor about this.
Are you crazy?
Give us a bad grade.
That again, they do such a good job of showing these very real-life couple
dynamics for any any form of couple.
Yeah, and having John and Carolyn have those kind of arguments and those
kinds of dynamics.
It's really fun to watch.
Lauren when she agreed to go on the plane when she said, of course, I want
a plane ride on those summer Friday.
It's like pretty relatable.
I get I know I know I was like, I would never turn down a plane ride on a
summer Friday.
Yeah, it takes so long to get out of the city on a Sunday.
Friday.
I mean, I can imagine in the 90s.
It was probably way worse.
Now.
Everybody leaves Thursday night.
So Thursday night is a new summer Friday.
Yes.
Yeah, the hell's going on.
Yeah.
I'm telling you Friday now, not bad.
We have been stuck in some traffic on the highway trying to get out of New
York on Friday before.
Poor Ed, honestly, she really I gotta say Cara like Caroline really threw
him to the wolves right there.
I don't know if that was the best job for Ed.
Oh, like Ethel could have done it.
I don't know.
Ed for that.
That was rough.
Well, and it's Ed talking about the Kennedys.
It's Ed talking about like Kennedy business and he married into it.
So he should not have to do that.
She said if the Kennedy family what felt strongly they wouldn't have sent
you.
I know and calls it out and is not afraid to call it the Kennedys from
day one.
Yeah, it was a tough job at you were going to fail no matter what but you
did a pretty poor job pretty piss poor job at I don't think he could have
done worse in that moment.
I mean and probably heard about that humiliating doc getting canceled.
So like she already is like this guy.
I wish she would have brought up the doc in that moment.
Just hit him where it hurts and come on.
Yeah.
The coverage was torture of just because it's honestly even worse than
the coverage of the Diana stuff of just that.
They're missing lost like you don't know the results like you're just
watching the end.
The newscasters don't know anything.
So they're just talking and talking about nothing while you have no news.
I was happy the show though did not lean too much into the coverage.
They kind of quickly, you know went with the route of they're gone.
We didn't have to watch people in agony and trying to figure this out or
watch a bunch of new cast for like 20 minutes.
And my last one was just I know what they were going for with Ethel's
speech there at the end to Caroline, but I was like, I think Ethel needs
therapy like I know have had some tough stuff in your life and you're just
whole like suck it up.
Like I don't know.
I don't know if you're doing okay.
I can't you are like torturing everyone around the table quizzing them
into oblivion like maybe talk to somebody well now that we know what
she's been through.
I'm like, okay, I get the quizzing a little bit, you know,
she's been through a lot.
Let her get her kicks where she can get them.
She needs her humiliation people.
Then she needs her humiliation ritual.
Yeah.
Yeah, right.
But how many times has she given that speech of like, oh my God, we're
at Kennedy.
This is what we do.
Yeah, you know how many people have heard that it's like it's a lot.
I I would also agree.
I think some therapy could have been good.
I mean, you can't go through that much.
I mean the tragedy that woman has been through is too much for anybody.
You got to talk about it.
Talk to somebody Apple Mrs.
Kennedy.
Yeah, please call her Mrs.
Kennedy.
You're not getting invited to the table.
All right.
Well since that was a tough episode to watch, I don't know if we've
mentioned that let's make it a little bit more fun.
That's where some fun Tyler's takes though.
Thank you for that.
I tried.
Let's look back at some of the some of our favorite things from the season
because as John said in his note to Carolyn just because we can't go back
to what once was I would say the Calvin Klein days doesn't mean we can't
have what we've always wanted.
Yeah, meet me back at the beginning.
Yeah, and that's what we're going to do here right now.
We're going back to the fun stuff.
Yeah, we're going back to the vibes for a second to the vibes when I was
like, it's a hangout show.
That was a cute note that note would get me.
I would no longer be mad about him not wanting to talk about the sacks.
I'd be like, all right.
This is a good now.
Yeah.
All right, rapid-fire.
Let's do it.
Okay.
Yes, best music moment.
Best music moment for me is name by the Good Good Oz because that's right
after their fight in Battery Park and then she like accepts his proposal
and it's been like all these meanings because it's like the press can't
get her name, right?
Oh, and then like it's also been the weight of what this name means to
add Kennedy to the end of her name.
And then it's like she's so happy when she accepts the proposal, but
you're hearing that song and you're just like there's a lot going on.
There's a lot of meaning but it's great.
I love that moment.
That's a good one and a great song.
I love that song very 90s.
All right.
Mine is linger by the cranberries.
How can you beat linger?
It's great.
I love linger and it's a good moment.
It's when she finds out she's in the tabloids and the Calvin Klein
office and it's kind of where things really start to change.
You're like, oh no, what's going to happen next?
Everybody knows she's dating him.
No, that's a great moment when she's marching in Calvin Klein there.
I gotta say there were so many great music moments in this one.
Like I picked one off the top of my head, but like there's so many like
them dance into that common people.
Yeah, all the times I had like no ordinary love.
I'm just playing the playlist the Spotify playlist for this show kind
of on loop right now.
I'm listening to that Jeff Buckley song all the time.
Oh, yeah, the playlist is very good.
People should listen to that on Spotify.
It's the official playlist for love story.
I mean Lenny Kravitz.
It ain't over till it's over great song.
Yeah lover.
You should have come over.
That's the Jeff Buckley song.
I was thinking of that was I've been playing that on loop.
Oh my God.
There's so many good ones on here.
I've been hearing that and I'm like, what is he listening to?
And then I think I was the love story soundtrack.
Oh my gosh.
I love it.
Great music throughout the show.
Definitely.
All right, best fashion moment.
I'll be John's backwards hats that backwards straight cap thing.
Yeah, all his goofy clothes are great.
There were some goofy clothes by John.
Yeah.
Well, I saw an article.
I think it was GQ or someone was saying that they weren't going
goofy enough in this show.
They were like they're being they're scared.
They're like they were scared to get too wacky and they're like
the real John just would get so wacky with the clothes and would
just be feeling himself.
It was a vibe.
I believe it.
It's kind of fun that he could really rock like a suit or a tux
and look so good in that and then also look really good in these
wacky clothes.
I know, you know, who knows what he was wearing big t-shirts
hats, sunglasses, a lot of accessories.
He seemed to be an accessory guy.
He did.
He looked like a 90s punk Keith Richards.
Sometimes he'd have like crazy like bandana things and like all
these accessories.
I appreciate a guy who goes for it.
So I like that.
All right.
Mine is Carolyn's black dress and scarf that she wore to Ethel's
dinner.
That just really stuck out with me.
That scarf was so good with it.
She looks chic, classic black.
Mrs. Kennedy didn't like the scarf though.
I know and I'm still mad at Mrs.
Kennedy about it.
So I'm praising it here.
She shouldn't have had to take that off.
I mean, yeah, Carolyn looks incredible throughout the show.
I mean anything she wore.
Yeah, every time she's walking through Calvin Klein.
It's like damn.
I know she has once again changed fashion.
We're all wearing what she was wearing.
We're all wearing that minimalist look now.
So good for her.
The legacy continues.
It continues.
And that coat that she was wearing too when she was in the
Ralph Lauren office.
That was good.
She had some really good office looks.
All right, next up best 90s nostalgia moment.
A lot of 90s nostalgia in this.
I mean, I guess it's not really nostalgia for us, but just,
you know.
Probably just like people going to these parties, all the
parties they go to.
It's fun that everyone's like looking around and talking to
people and like, like even if you're sitting in a booth,
everyone's like looking around that who's there and seeing
who they can talk to because no one's on their phones.
Like no one has their phones to just be scrolling up.
So just that kind of like phone at all.
Act of social energy is fun.
It is fun in a TV show like this, a period piece, if you
will, when people are waiting for somebody for dinner and
we don't see them scroll on their phone.
They're just kind of looking around or like a waiter goes
to talk to them or you know, they're just they're not killing
time as much.
You made it.
You made it work.
What about you?
Mine goes to John talking to Carolyn through the answering
machine.
Oh, that's a good one.
Her screening his calls on the answer machine old school.
Yeah, I mean you can still screen a voicemail but now we
don't even leave voicemails and those were fun messages.
He was leaving so we should bring that back back to answer
machine.
It's awesome when he's like, I'm outside.
Yeah, I know that was a really romantic moment to we should
break down all the most romantic moments that we got maybe
another time.
All right last up most New York moment from the show.
Most New York moment.
I would say Carolyn walking to work and him biking to work
like that's you know, very New York not a lot of people live
in places that they do that but lots of people do that here.
You know, I'm always walking home from work.
Yeah, I know they just walked so cool.
I was like, I don't think I look like that walking to work.
Yeah, they just read about like is cool.
Yeah, I have two one of mine is John playing football in
Central Park.
Yes shirts off very much a thing that felt like a very New
York thing timeless meeting up with people after work to go
the park and then my second one is from this episode.
It's when John and Carolyn are at the reservoir in Central
Park.
Oh, yeah, that was great.
Yeah, we love the reservoir.
We go there all the time all the time.
So that was fun to see.
Yeah, that was great that a bridge there sitting by I looked
into proposing to you on that bridge.
Yeah, we take that bridge a lot when we go to the reservoir
but they were doing construction on it at the time, but I
don't know how we didn't know this was shooting right through
there.
I know we're there all the time.
They must have done it early in the morning or something, but
it's a very pretty spot in New York.
We love it.
It's great.
Love the reservoir.
All right.
Anything else?
Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis reservoir.
Is that what it's called?
Yeah, that is what it is.
You know, I just call her Jackie Kennedy.
I'm not putting on that O on the end.
Okay, we want to forget about those years.
Oh my gosh.
Give me the Jackie O story next.
Well, who do you want to see on love story next?
Oh, does it have to be a tragedy?
I guess it does.
Like is that what they do in this show?
No, I think it just needs to be a love story.
That's interesting.
So probably people who you know, fight break up get back together
love each other hard that whole thing.
Let's just stick with the 90s and do Brad Pitt and Jennifer
Aniston.
I mean, that would be good.
What do you think the edit on Angelina Jolie would be on that
one?
You know, Daryl Hannah was bad.
Watch out for the Angelina Jolie edit.
I cannot imagine.
Yeah.
Wow.
What about you?
I'd watch every second of that.
You know that.
Oh, yeah, that I actually lived that I would get a lawsuit from
both of them, but they would fight through it.
I think a letter has already been sent of you are not touching
us.
Yeah, I would watch that.
Oh my God.
I mean, I talk about some more fashion icons when he's that
shirt that he's wearing when they're like crying in Mexico
the last time they were together.
I don't know what you're talking about.
You don't know the last Mexico trip.
The last trip.
Okay, wait, it is.
I'm going to show you those photos.
It's like iconic.
Like, I'm sure and then the divorce is like right after that.
Okay.
Well, so I would keep it to the celebrity couple of our time
similar to Brad Pitt and Jennifer Aniston.
I would go Ben Affleck, Jennifer Lopez.
I mean, come on.
It's like three seasons.
I think you do a season for each time.
That's what I want to see.
Are they currently together?
I don't know.
Weren't they holding hands?
Not that long ago.
They just had a big thing about selling a house.
I actually don't know if we can cover them yet because I don't
think their story is done.
I think we're still in it.
They've got a few more seasons.
Yeah, I mean, but one day I better be 80 years old watching
that love story.
That's what I want.
Bennifer.
Yeah, Bennifer.
Season two could be Bennifer 2.0.
Love story Bennifer is a lot easier to search than the long
name of this show.
Yeah, it's hard for me to put the name of this show in our
podcast title.
It's hard for me to say.
All right.
Well, but what a fun show it was despite, you know, the very
tragic ending it was, you know, you got you got great really
nice moments of reminding you why you love these two and then
you cried your eyes out for about 20 minutes.
I thought it was a really well done show.
I thought that Sarah Pigeon was phenomenal as Carolyn Bassett.
I thought she brought a lot to the role.
I think it was great that we saw more.
She's probably getting nominated for this.
I would assume so.
Yeah, I mean, she was great.
Yeah.
So I even wondered if Constance Simmers getting nominated for
this final thing.
She was great too.
I know her supporting or something.
Yeah, a lot of great performances and I think when I heard
this show was first going to come out, I kind of rolled my
eyes like what is this going to be?
I didn't think it was going to be great.
Yeah, so I eat my words.
I thought it was great.
It was a great show.
We had no idea how big the show would become either when we
first started covering it, but quite a popular show.
Everyone I know is like aware of it or has seen some of it.
I know it's pretty fascinating how big this has really become
especially when I don't think people were really talking about
it much before it came out.
People were more so making fun of it saying it was going to
be a flop.
So it's so fun when it's not like that and then we're all
watching it week to week and enjoying it and I think it'll
get a lot of supporting noms too.
I just could see a lot of these people racking up noms, you
know, even like Naomi Watts as Jackie or I already forgot
about her.
Yeah, I know a lot of great performances.
So I think it will like come back around and discussion around
award season and I think no matter what yes, the show took
liberties and it was a lot of timelines dramatized and everything
like that, but it really did bring two people back into conversation
and the spotlight and what they did and made people fall in love
with them again, which I think is a great thing for their legacy.
So I'll be buying that tortoise headband this weekend.
So catch me in my tortoise headband and my long brown coat
walking to work.
As long as I get to wear the wacky John looks.
Well, we'll see about that.
We'll talk.
We'll talk offline.
All right.
Well, thank you everyone for listening.
Be sure to follow our podcast wherever you get your podcast
rate us five stars on Spotify and Apple.
We would love that you can follow me on social media at previously
on underscore team TV subscribe on YouTube as well.
Like our videos by our merch on Etsy and thanks for listening.
Bye.
