Chris Trwoga - Shamanism and the Sacred Landscape - Megalithomania Lecture 2006 (Audio)

Artifact Archives
9 followers
3 Video ViewsยทMar 31, 2026
Shamanism and the Sacred Landscape
Presented by Chris Stroger
In this lecture, Chris looks at
ancestor worship, chambered tombs,
stone circles, alignments,
and how they mark the line
between world and spirit.
Mainly studying Avebury, Dartmoor,
and Kilmartin Glen.
Recorded live at
Megalithomania Conference 2006.
Applause
We live
in a scientific age.
That sounds
like a rather banal
and obvious statement.
But I think we actually need
to think back
and consider
what the impact is
of living in a scientific age
in the way that we think
about our entire world
and indeed our entire experiences.
Before I
launch into my attack
on the scientific method,
I think I should say that
I am also appreciative
of what science has delivered.
Scientists
arguably
are the shamans
of our age.
They are the ones who have
performed all the great tricks
that would have dazzled
us a thousand years ago.
When it comes
to archaeology,
I was astonished,
for instance, when I read in 2002
when they discovered the
so-called Amesbury Archer
near Stonehenge.
That not only could they
carbon date those remains,
but they were able
to take unbelievably
microscopic samples from the tooth
and check
the oxygen isotopes
and not only tell us
how old those remains were,
but indeed
tell us where that man
has been. Tell us
he had once lived in a
mountainous area of central Europe
and had migrated
to the region where Stonehenge
was built.
But science
has also delivered many other things.
In the last century,
it delivered
the greatest shamanic trick
of all, the nuclear bomb
and delivered to the
human race the means
by which we might
destroy ourselves.
And from this scientific world
view, I feel
that we need,
certainly within our own field,
to take a little bit
of a step back.
What got me
concerned
about whether, in fact,
the scientific method,
the use
of astronomical instruments,
theodolites,
computers
and all the rest of it,
instruments to test
the acoustics of tombs,
instruments to test the acoustics of Stonehenge,
what made me think
that maybe we were perhaps
straying away from the point
was when I
re-read Stonehenge
Decoded
in a rather
significant passage
in which the work was
describing the
positioning of the Aubrey holes
and how by repositioning
stones in them, you would in fact
have a wonderful computer
for predicting
the phases
of the Moon and the various positions
of the Moon, that we
ended up describing something that
was built 4,000 years ago
as a computer
and in fact
what we had done
or what we are doing
I feel
is remaking our ancestors
in the image
and likeness of ourselves.
My
central contention
in a sense
is that they were not
scientists
and when they built
those megaliths
they were not there
on the ground
worrying that much
about the solar and the lunar
alignments and getting it right
they were responding to something
far more primal
far deeper
and I believe that
this thing
that they were responding to
is something that we
in a scientific age
are in danger of losing.
If any of you
are
artists or students
of art
at a first glance you might
think this picture is a very famous
painting by Mantegna
of the dead Christ
and when Rembrandt
painted this painting
he had
Mantegna's dead Christ
in mind. The original
is a painting
of a god
who came down to earth and became
man. Who lived
his life and sacrificed
himself for the
sake of mankind.
In death
it is still human
in death it is still
noble. In death
it is a symbol of
suffering mankind.
This is
science. When we
look closely we notice
that the stomach
the intestines
the cavity is empty.
The gentleman at the
back is busy
moving the brains.
This is
an anatomy lesson.
Rembrandt
is saying something very different
about what science
is saying about humanity.
I like to think of this
almost as an image
of our megaliths.
We can anatomise
the human form.
We can take the corpse, we can take out the
brains, we can take out the intestines,
we can take out the heart, we can tear
the whole thing to bits
and yet somehow in
all of that I
believe we will have missed
the point of
what it was all about.
And so it is
I feel with
the scientific method
and the megaliths.
In a sense in adopting
the philosophy, the values
and the beliefs of science
and indeed we are part of
the scientific age and it is hard to unravel
that. Maybe
we are losing sight
of something much richer
and much deeper.
A long time ago
I read a book
by a man called Rudolf Otto.
The book was called
The Idea
of the Holy.
And what Rudolf Otto was trying to do
in that particular work
was to make
sense of
what it was
that had stimulated human beings
in all of these different contexts
to do
amazing, unbelievable
and impossible things
in the cause
of some kind
of a raw emotion.
If for instance we take
the Giza plateau
and the pyramids of Giza.
Now maybe we can look
at them as some
way by which the pharaoh asserted
control over Egypt.
We may look at it as an
exercise in massive egotism.
We may apply all of our
scientific instruments
and work out the different alignments
the celestial alignments,
the alignments with Orion and all of the rest of it.
But I feel
that in a sense we are missing
the point. The phrase
that Otto uses
is the numinous.
That certain
pre-rational
response. This isn't a
scientific response. This is
an innate response
to that which
is holy. He
talks about the
mysterium tremendum.
That strange
overwhelming feeling, and I'm sure you're
all aware of it, that maybe when we
go to our sacred sites
we put aside our
scientific instruments. We
put aside our
interest in getting everything
absolutely right in understanding
how the different stones are related to each
other and working out the different
alignments with the landscape.
And instead we allow that
which is innate to all humanity
to come to the fore.
Our sense of awe.
Our sense of dread.
Our sense
of wonder. Our sense
that there is something
in this landscape
which is deeper
and more powerful
and more meaningful
than anything
that the scientists
can come up with.
This is the idea
of the holy.
The idea that we all have another
way of reading
and seeing the world.
And my fear is
having worked with
children, now in fact it's for 30
years, is that what
science is doing to
our world is actually
deadening that response.
Deadening
our innate
sensibilities to
the divine and to the
holy. And indeed
over time as Gareth mentioned
I have carried out
experiments with our youth
to see if in fact I
can awaken something
of that raw response.
And we have been to
Orkney. If any of you know Orkney well
there are two particularly fine well
preserved tombs. One on Kewing Hill
one on Whittiford Hill.
And when you go into these
tombs you have to go
through very dark
very narrow constricting
passages. When I've
been in there myself
it's taken all
of my sort of strength if you like to get around
the various narrow bends and get into these tiny
chambers. And
then you find yourself
in the darkness
you find yourself
in the silence.
And as is often the case
with these tombs
there's this strange
evenness of temperature.
And what you start to
experience is that
which society, the removal of that
which society as it stands has done
to us. Sensory overlord.
The battering of the senses.
The senses are free.
And in that kind
of area, in that kind
of experience
something
else starts to emerge.
To use the old Christian
phrase, it's the still
small voice.
How do we express
that holy
other? That sense
of the numinous?
That sense of this
presence? By the very
nature of what Otto said and what
I believe that it's a pre-rational
response. We want
to put it into words.
We want to try and make sense
of the experience.
But invariably, I
believe because it's an innate response
words tend to fail.
In our great religious
traditions, whichever one you choose
it is in ritual
it is in song
it is in poetry
that we try and manifest
if you like to evoke
to share the Mysterium
Tremendum. And what is central
to my argument
we try to evoke
it in the building
of great megaliths.
To quote
Rudolf Otto
the motive underlying
the erection of these gigantic blocks
of stone, hewn or unworked
single monoliths or
titanic rings of stone
as at Stonehenge
may have well been originally
to localize and preserve
and as it were
to store up the Newman
in solid presence by magic
the Newmaness throbbing
in the soul almost like
a mechanical reflex
must themselves have been conscious
of this effect
and intended it.
My book actually
spends some
time going into
Jungian psychology
and the length of the talk
does not permit me to develop this
too much further. But when
I've discussed my ideas with people
they've often said well hang on a minute
what is it? What is
this world that you are contacting?
What is it that you are reaching out towards?
And I quite like
the Jungian idea
that we do live in two worlds
we have the conscious world
which dominates
predominates, has given
us the scientific method
we also have
our subconscious sensibilities
which speak through our dreams
speak through our imaginations
central to
my argument is that our remote ancestors
did not, did not
regard our imaginations
as something that was
unreal or a fantasy
they did not regard
dreams as unreal
or a fantasy. They did not
regard ghosts and spirits
as unreal or a fantasy.
The world in which they live
and this is what we have lost sight of
was a world
where everything was animated
where everything
had a spirit
where the stones
the rivers, the trees
humans, animals
everything
had this dual nature
this is the essence of their
world view and stones
are not
rocks chosen
at random and set up
they themselves
in the view of our remote ancestors
were living things
things with
spirit, things with life
and that is what we have
to take in
and absorb
in order to see our megaliths
as our remote ancestors
did. What I'm working
towards is
we'll get rid of the corpse
a shamanic
view of the world
to start
to see
as they see
the world. Now I know this is
a popular bandwagon and quite a lot of
people say well it's just one theory
amongst many
but as my book develops
the argument
the shamanic world view is
universal to indigenous
cultures. Wherever
we go, where indigenous
cultures survive, shamanism
is the world view
and through
ancestral spirits
through the spirits of animals, through the spirits
of stones, the spirits within plants
this is how
we move through the world
and make ourselves safe
within the world. It is a
universal world view
what I have to demonstrate
today is
that that same world view which
is present in indigenous cultures today
was present in
our own landscape
4,000, 5,000
6,000 years ago
this is
drawing
of a standing stone
in Kilmartin Glen
as you can see
it is a carved stone
Kilmartin Glen, and thank you for
asking because I normally like to spell
these things out, it is in
the west of Scotland
the north west of Scotland
and since you've asked I'll also say that the main
reason in fact why I've themed on Kilmartin
Glen is because I feel it's a neglected
landscape. We here
in the south actually don't know much
about it, and as you'll see at the end, the major bulk
of my presentation will be about an
interpretation of Kilmartin Glen
these are called, as I'm sure you're aware
cup and ring marks
and it is so
universal a symbol
in western Europe
that I like to see it almost like
the cross is to Christianity
or the crescent and the star
is to Islam
it is the universal
religious symbol
of the megalithic
era, the neolithic
and the bronze age
but what does
it mean?
Here's another example which shows
a series of concentric circles
this in fact is
on living rock, we find them
mainly on living rock
where the rock emerges
out of the ground
and this begins to introduce
one of the fundamental
ideas of shamanism
that of
liminality
liminality meaning
a place, a point
a nexus
within the landscape that we
occupy, where the
other world is close
this is what
living rock, the
earth if you like, the bones of the
earth coming out of the surface
means to many indigenous cultures
and you've only got to go to Australia
and the aboriginal cultures in Australia
and look at their regard for rocks
to see that this is in fact the case
but we've still got to interpret
these particular symbols
and in Spain
I think we begin to see
something of the answer
in a sense
what we are looking at
is a kind of tunnel
a kind of pathway
that penetrates
pierces the rock
and what we see in this
particular illustration
a little bit of
representational rock art
is animals actually
entering
and leaving
through these
tunnels
these pathways
into the rock
and there are other examples
from around the world that show
very very similar things
now we have to
think about how
to relate this
particular central symbol
with the architecture
of the neolithic
and the bronze age
if you fly over a church
you will see that the church
is in the shape of a cross
the church
is in the shape of the universal
Christian symbol
if you fly
over
a passage grave or rather if you look at the plan
of a passage grave
you look at the plan of a hinge
what you see is
a clear similarity
between the architecture
of the bronze age
and the neolithic
and the fundamental basic design
of the cup
and ring mark
it remains
is the great
single
universal symbol
of that particular period of time
Newgrange
if you look
at a plan
of Newgrange
what you see is a broadly circular
design perhaps it is somewhat more
kidney shaped
there is a long passage
90 foot long or thereabouts
leading into the heart of the tomb
leading into
a central chamber
this is the architecture
of the cup and ring
and what some commentators have pointed
out is that
on passage graves
you actually rarely see
the cup and ring symbol
drawn or carved
this is because
you don't need it anymore
the cup and ring is the symbolic
manifestation of
penetration to the other world
here
is the reality
here is the nexus
here is the point
in the landscape
at which the worlds meet
the entrance
to Newgrange I'm sure all of you are familiar
with this particular picture
what I find absolutely fascinating
about the whole experience of going into
Newgrange
is that it is a journey
anyone who has been down that passage
and I've been fortunate to go down it three times
will experience it as a journey
it is a journey
from light
to dark
as some of you may know
the passage of Newgrange is on a slope
when you are close to the
entrance a lot of light
comes through the entrance
as you go up the slope
that light becomes
increasingly restricted
until
at the heart of the tomb
there is darkness
there is silence
and you are in the court
of the ancestors
as you can see there are
three chambers
small chambers off the central chamber
and when you walk
into that central space
you are not if you like
in front of or behind
they are all
around you
and the concept
of communicating with the ancestors
of a relationship
with the ancestors
is fundamental
to shamanism
it is the heart
of shamanism
that we don't just live in
this moment we don't just have these
short miserable lives
that we are not
on a linear path
through life
as the symbol of the circle dictates
life is circular
we are one
with our ancestors
we will return to our ancestors
and we will re-emerge
with new life from
our ancestors
that link, that bond
is never broken
and of course what you
find in neolithic tombs
not complete bodies
this is what some people struggle to understand
what you find
are the bones
bone fragments, incomplete
remains
and why is this?
well again if you look at shamanic
belief, what the bones are
are the seeds
the bones are the seeds
of new life
and so that we can be
freed, so that our soul
can move forward, can be released
from this cage of flesh
and move on to its next life
first the bones must be rid
of flesh
and in some shamanic cultures they are very
very careful when they have killed an animal
not to damage the bones
not to break the bones, to try and keep
the skeleton intact
so it can be returned
to the earth for the renewal
of life
the bones therefore are the seeds
of future generations
this is the
famous triple spiral
from Newgrange
and
researchers such as Jeremy
Dronfield have also put
a different interpretation
on how we might interpret them
I'm a little bit hesitant here
because I am, as you probably
gathered, resistant somewhat
of the scientific method and resistant
somewhat of scientific research
but what Jeremy
Dronfield and other commentators
have focused on
is the way in which
both the monument and
indeed these spirals
may represent or
symbolize altered
states of
consciousness, the so called
tunnels or vortices
that people experience
when they
are dying, and what I found
absolutely fascinating when I was reading his
work and the work of other people
is that
when we are dying
if you like, when our hearts give up, should I
fall down now and start having my
heart attack
that a common experience
is this
not only this state of ecstasy
people who have gone through
this experience describe
not misery, not pain
but a kind of ecstasy
and being pulled down
this tunnel of light
towards some beautiful
destination, this is
an extremely
common experience, particularly
in the modern world where people are being revived
and are able to talk
about this particular experience
and his argument and the
argument of others is that the
spiral, the multiple
ringed
cup and ring mark
is a symbol of that
tunnel of light, that journey
that experience
there's also
again in his work and the work of others
the interpretation
of so called navicular
markings
which are common to a number
of sites in Britain, I'm thinking particularly
of, I'll promote his book
David Lewis Williams, Cosmos in Stone
the advantage of his
particular work, because I wish to defend
my argument
his work is based in
South Africa and
the South African researchers have the
advantage that there is living
memory, there is a record
of people who did
these carvings and what
it meant to them and indeed
what the research has revealed
is that there is a correct shamanic
interpretation
this is a navicular
carving at Nouth
Nouth in case you don't know is
the great burial mound
that's about a kilometre and a half
away from Newgrange
it's part of the great Neolithic
cemetery at the bend in the Boyne
and in South
Africa we have examples
of where that navicular response
in fact that navicular appearance
I should say it's, and I'm sure you may have heard this
yesterday, an entoptic phenomenon
it's something if you like
that our brains produce
under certain states
is here being fleshed out
and interpreted
and again this is a key
to my argument
I said at the very beginning
that the shamanic response
the religious response
the numinous is a pre-rational
one, it doesn't actually make
sense to our rational brains
it's something that overcomes us
overpowers us, reduces us to tears
we don't know why it's happening
we can't necessarily make sense of it
and it's just there
but what the shaman's role is
is to try and make sense
of those experiences
to give shape to them
to interpret those
raw emotional responses
for his audience
and that is where in fact
shamanic landscapes
start to appear
in my argument
we live in landscapes
we move
through a landscape
if you like when we talk
about our journeys
we see ourselves at certain
places in the world
if we were a neolithic society
we would also know
those liminal places
we don't go there because
there is something strange
happening there, this is
where we go to speak to the ancestors
this is the liminal space
and they would see
the world not just as a physical
environment but as an
environment which is spiritualised
too, what the shaman
needs as a means of interpreting
these raw emotional experiences
for his people
and very often we find what
they do is to translate
those experiences
into
a real physical
landscape
they have to tune in if you like
bed in with the landscape
and they can talk about their specific
shamanic experiences
relative to a world
that their people would understand
and one of the arguments
that I present in my book
that part of our own
mental ill health
if you like the disease
of modern western society
is that we are now
divorced from our
landscape, we buy it
and sell it as if it belongs to us
which it doesn't
we rape the landscape
for short term material greed
something which is anathema to indigenous
cultures, it doesn't
matter, we also move
from place to place as
suits our careers and suits our needs
and every time we become
dislocated, we don't belong
part of the
shamanic vision is to
belong, to be rooted in the
landscape, it is where
our ancestors bones lie
it is where
we have had our roots
for countless generations
and I'm sure many years ago when
it was a teacher who lived
in the Mendips
discovered that he
had genetic traces
within
his makeup that were
the same as those
of human bones found in the
caves in the Mendips
and therefore that he was still linked
intimately, physically
with someone who had lived in the
Mendips 10,000 years ago
that must have been one of the
highlights of his life
to feel, to know
that we belong
just a couple more examples
that are often shown
in this case from Gavrini
to express this sort of
idea that it is this kind
of raw, emotional, bizarre
if you like
pre-rational experience
that our ancestors were trying to communicate
in stone, here
both a sense
of movement into a space
and a sense of visual
chaos, because of course
part of the shamanic
method is
to enter into an altered state
of consciousness and if you like
to do what it takes indeed to get there
I like this one
particularly because if you stare
at it long enough it actually starts to sort of
do peculiar things to your eyes
I just wonder what state
the guy was in when he was carving it
and of course
a lot of people who talk about
what our shamans were doing
no doubt in order to go to
that other place and I have no particular
problem with this
they would have been using
substances to help them
along the way, but of course again that's a feature
of indigenous cultures around the world
too. And once again
just another example
here you have
a passage grave at Loch Rue
if you go to Newgrange
it is very worthwhile
taking a little trip to Loch Rue, it's not far away
and there is a hillside
which you'll usually have to yourself
certainly that was the case when I was there a few years ago
where there are
dozens of beautiful
megalithic tombs
the only problem you may have
there is a guy, this was the case anyway a few years ago
again things might have changed, who has the key
you have to find him to get the key
and then you can let yourself into these tombs
and yes you can have the
darkness and you can have the silence
and just to the left of course you can see
one of these carved stones
with all of these intense spiral
carvings
sorry, closing them
oh right, yeah
so you've been there fairly recently
five minutes
finally, and I didn't realise
I'd spoken for so long
it brings me to Kilmartin Glen
one of my favourite
sacred landscapes
it is a natural landscape
the reason why it is so flat
is because several thousand years ago
the glaciers made it that way
it is also the home
of a huge range of monuments
what I want to quickly stress
is the unity of
Kilmartin Glen
because what it has running down
if you've just about seen these pictures
first it is a linear cemetery
it is a cemetery of cairns
of burial places for the ancestors
that are placed along the valley bottom
in order to get this kind of
unity, this sort of liminal
experience, the oldest
monument there, the Netherlagi Cairn
was in fact
itself made into
a cairn
to resemble the cairns
that were built in the later
Bronze Age
the valley has around it
several routes in
and each of those routes
is clearly marked
and defined, either with
cup and ring stones
or indeed with
standing stones
here's just another of the cairns
that if you like march
down this incredibly flat
valley floor
and here are the cup and ring marks
there are 640
Neolithic
or Bronze Age monuments
most of them small and insignificant in this landscape
and this
makes me think about the state of mind
the sort of spiritual state
if you like of the people who did this
there are often hundreds of cup and ring marks
on stones, this isn't producing
if you like a work of art
this is an icon
making process
where you do what has been done for countless
generations, you do it in the same
repetitive way in order to
take you to that other place
and there's the association
the piece of land in front
of this stone, when it gets wet
fills with water
there is a sacred pool if you like
that appears at certain times
of year
this is one of the ways in
this is the way
to the sea
and of course we should bear in mind that this
shamanic tradition is a tradition of
the western Atlantic seaboard
most of these monuments are close
to the sea, this tradition
this belief, this culture
passed by boat from country to country
and guarding
this particular entrance
if you like
defining the sacred space
into which people enter is this
cup and ring decorated stones
in fact two of them are all made
when you see it, there's a huge
towering cliff above it
it is on a platform which gives you a view
to the sea, very sadly
if you go there now
you will not see this view
a plantation has been planted there
and in fact you have to fight your way through
a fir forest
to locate it, so
unfortunately that's an experience we can't have at this moment
and then of course
we have
monuments that have been sacred
through time
monuments that have manifested the presence of
the ancestors since time immemorial
this is Temple Wood
also at Kilmartin Glen
where we start off with a Neolithic
we have a stone circle
a kist is built into that stone circle
it changes shape, it is always
sacred, it is sacred not for
100 years but for 2000 years
and this is another one
of those circles at Kilmartin Glen
the beauty of it
and I'm trying to encourage you to visit it
is that there is an ancient
coach road
which enables you to walk from one
monument to the other without
having to use the car
it is literally a shamanic journey
and if you go there, do it in the morning
8, 9 o'clock, you'll have it to
yourself and as the mists are rising
off the valley, it is an absolutely
magical experience
you also have
wonderful stone alignments
now there are so many of them
that people who have written about Kilmartin
Glen don't themselves
fully understand what those alignments mean
and maybe it doesn't matter
maybe for me if you like
I see them as gun sights on eternity
to stand before them, yes
and watch the moon rise and feel that
sense of being drawn
drawn along the axis
the shamanic axis that links
one world with the next
coming to the close of my talk
I began
by being critical
or fearful rather than critical
of the scientific method
fearful that
somehow, something in us
is dying
when we turn to science
to understand things of the
soul, things of the spirit
we have something
in us which needs
to be reawakened
and we can leave our theodolites at home
we can leave all our measuring instruments
we can put our telescopes away
and make the journey
that really matters
the journey
that is inwards
into our own souls and our own
subconscious
and the journey outwards through our
imaginations that enables
us in flesh and
spirit to journey
to the stars
thank you
this has been a megalithomania audio
production
for more information visit
megalithomania.co.uk
