Premiered 7 hours ago 2 products Adam Taggart | Thoughtful Money® tagged products below. Learn more
Men's Non-Iron Dress Shirt - Standard Fit Pinpoint Solid - Standard Fit Point Collar - In Light Blue, Cotton | The Tie Bar A$97.90 thetiebar.com/product/shr-2955-0201?variant=S30-3435175-SF&srsltid=AfmBOoqrTea6GHcoBXVwpefmFxR2dqr2uP9GCe38qqfSaFqQLYLM_dOY8Eo
Men's Haggar Smart Wash Repreve Slim-Fit Suit Jacket, Size: 42 LONG, Ink Limited shipping areas kohls.com/product/prd-4960878/mens-haggar-smart-wash-repreve-slim-fit-suit-jacket.jsp?skuid=20368191&CID=seo_offers&utm_campaign=SAG&utm_medium=organic&utm_source=google&utm_product=20368191 HAVE QUESTIONS? SCHEDULE YOUR FREE PORTFOLIO REVIEW with Thoughtful Money's endorsed financial advisors at https://www.thoughtfulmoney.com
Smart retirement planning is key to living well after you've stopped working.
Sadly many Americans find themselves falling behind.
According to the Federal Reserve’s “Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households” report, 65% of Americans either believe their retirement savings are off track or aren’t sure. For those who do have retirement accounts, the median savings balance stands at $87,000 -- far too little to retire on.
Today's guest is going to tell us how to increase your odds of not only being able to afford to retire, but doing so with ample excess to live your golden years the way you want.
Ed Slott, CPA, is a renowned IRA distribution expert, author, and professional speaker known as "America’s IRA Expert." He is the founder of Ed Slott and Company, creator of the Elite IRA Advisor Group, and a Professor of Practice at The American College of Financial Services. He focuses on advanced tax strategies for retirement savings.
0:00 Retirement Savings Crisis 2:53#1 Mistake in Retirement Planning 3:46 Always Pay Taxes at the Lowest Rates 6:42 Why Roth IRAs Are Great For Tax-Free Wealth 9:36 The Real Risk of Doing Nothing 15:09 Widow's Penalty Explained 19:21 The Secret to Lifetime Tax Savings 32:43 Roth Conversions Explained 39:39 Creative Strategy: Gift Up the Family Tree 49:06 Using Annuities For Tax-Free Income In Retirement _____________________________________________ Thoughtful Money LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor Promoter.
We produce educational content geared for the individual investor. It’s important to note that this content is NOT investment advice, individual or otherwise, nor should be construed as such.
We recommend that most investors, especially if inexperienced, should consider benefiting from the direction and guidance of a qualified financial advisor registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or state securities regulators who can develop & implement a personalized financial plan based on a customer’s unique goals, needs & risk tolerance.
IMPORTANT NOTE: There are risks associated with investing in securities.
Investing in stocks, bonds, exchange traded funds, mutual funds, money market funds, and other types of securities involve risk of loss. Loss of principal is possible. Some high risk investments may use leverage, which will accentuate gains & losses. Foreign investing involves special risks, including a greater volatility and political, economic and currency risks and differences in accounting methods.
A security’s or a firm’s past investment performance is not a guarantee or predictor of future investment performance.
Thoughtful Money and the Thoughtful Money logo are trademarks of Thoughtful Money LLC.
The key to saving taxes, not today or tomorrow or this year, but over a lifetime and beyond
to your beneficiaries, is my number one always rule.
Always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
Welcome to Thoughtful Money.
I'm its founder and your host, Adam Taggart.
Smart retirement planning is key to living well after you've stopped working.
But sadly, many Americans find themselves falling behind.
According to the Federal Reserve's Economic Wellbeing of U.S.
Households Report, 65% of Americans either believe their retirement savings are off track or they aren't sure.
And for those who do have retirement accounts, the median savings balance stands at just $87,000, far too little to retire on.
Today's guest is going to tell you how to increase your odds of not only being able to afford to retire, but doing so with ample
access to live your golden years the way you want.
Ed Slott, CPA, is a renowned IRA distribution expert, author and professional speaker known as America's IRA expert.
He's the founder of Ed Slott and Company, creator of the Elite IRA Advisor Group and a professor of practice at the American
College of Financial Services.
He focuses on advanced tax strategies and retirement savings.
Ed, thanks so much for joining us today.
Thank you. Great to be here.
You know, when you mentioned that median retirement balance, $80,000, I wonder, is that skewed to like all ages?
Because I would think somebody like in their 50s or 60s would have a much higher median.
You would hope. I don't have the distribution in front of me.
I think that is probably median of all working adults.
So maybe that sounds pretty weak.
Yeah, but I have seen data that shows it's not all that much better for people who are in the 54 to 64 year old cohort.
You know, maybe they've got $175,000, maybe $200,000.
But again, that's not enough to fund the next 20 plus years of your life.
Yeah. All right, Ed, so look, as far as thanks go, thank you again for coming on.
But I want to extend my gratitude to the team at Lance Roberts Teams at Real Investment Advice.
They had me out at their conference in January where you were the keynote speaker and really enjoyed your presentation.
And I thought I wanted to get this in front of my audience.
So that's what we're going to try to do today.
OK, now you remind me what I said, because it's different every time.
Yeah. As you saw with me, I never use PowerPoint or slides or anything.
It's whatever, you know, whatever happens organically with the audience.
Good. Well, we'll build into this nicely, Ed.
So to start, let me ask you this.
What are the most common mistakes or acts of self-sabotage that people make when it comes to retirement planning?
Oh, the number one mistake, short-sightedness.
That's easy, especially when it comes to a Roth IRA or, more particularly, a Roth conversion.
A Roth conversion requires you to pay tax up front.
And one of my always rules, the reason I created all these always rules I have of mine, because I saw for years people on TV talking heads and everything, not me.
They could never give you a straight answer.
You'd be on CNBC.
They said, well, probably could be maybe, I don't know, wishy-washy, you know, have to run the numbers.
And to me, that didn't help anybody.
So I came up with my own.
There's not many of them because there's not many rules that are always.
But when I tell you I have an always rule, you can take it to the bank.
It's non-negotiable.
And the key to saving taxes, not today or tomorrow or this year, but over a lifetime and beyond to your beneficiaries, is my number one always rule.
Always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
Now, that sounds simple.
It makes sense, too.
If you're always paying at the lowest rates, you'll save the most in taxes over a lifetime.
But there's a second part to my always rule, which catches people.
Always pay taxes at the lowest rates, even if that means paying taxes before they're required.
And that's the one that nobody likes because nobody likes paying taxes before they're dragged, kicking and screaming.
I'll give you an example.
Let's say you're a 60 year old now, a 60 year old.
You're building a nice retirement account, maybe.
And under today's law, you don't have to take RMDs until age 75.
It's actually 73 now, but for 60 year old changes later on.
But for a 60 year old, it's age 75.
Should that 60 year old, that's 15 years.
Should that 60 year old do nothing for 15 years?
Just watch this account grow.
It's growing tax deferred, your IRA, 401k, while there were low tax rates each of those years where some of those funds could have been pulled out, had historically low rates.
And I'm not talking about pulling it out to spend on a vacation or something.
I'm talking about like a Roth conversion, getting money out while rates are low.
Taxes are historically low.
And the Roth conversion is really just a big bet on future tax rates.
So I may have asked the audience this, how many people think tax rates will go up?
And almost all the hands went up.
But then I asked a different question, which is actually the same question.
And no hands went up.
I said, how many of you think taxes will go down?
And nobody thinks that.
And it's the same question.
So I think the Roth is a good bet.
But back to your question, what's the number one mistake people make that affects them long term?
Shortsightedness, not seeing the big picture, where you want to end up.
That may require you paying some taxes if you can get it now while rates are low.
Not using the 12 percent, 22, even 24 percent.
If you don't maximize or optimize those brackets each year, they're gone forever.
You never get them back.
So back to that 60 year old, can you imagine wasting 15 years of low brackets?
All right, so let's let's define a couple of things here for people, Ed.
So you're clearly a really big fan of Roth instruments.
I'm a fan of keeping more money and more of it tax free.
And any way to do that, which the best way, I mean, let's face it, the Roth IRA is the best account ever created.
It grows tax free for the rest of your life and 10 years beyond.
It would be even better if you didn't have to pay the tax to get in there.
Right. That's that's the price of admission.
OK, let me just again clarify here.
So it grows tax free, which is why I love it.
But I think you love it even more because you withdraw tax free on the back end, unlike a traditional IRA where you're putting it in tax deferred.
It's growing tax free, but then you're actually getting taxed on it when you're taking those distributions.
Correct. Right.
And every year you watch this IRA grow, it looks nice on your statement, but it's also looking nice on Uncle Sam's statement, too, because he's a partner in that growth.
All right. So you said don't never waste a low tax, never waste a low tax bracket.
So I want to I want to use your 60 year old.
Yeah. So you're right.
Most people think in general, the tax code is going to go up over time.
Right. That's the assumption.
Tax rates. Yeah. Yeah.
The tax rates. But let's say that 60 year old still employed and let's say he's doing really well.
Yeah. So let's say his income tax bracket, he's in the highest tax bracket right now.
The question here is, is what's better for me?
Is it is it better for me to do a Roth conversion?
And we'll we'll define what that is in just a second and take the tax hit on that today, even though I'm in the maximum tax bracket and I might be in a lower tax bracket later on when I start doing my distributions.
But but, hey, that still might make sense to take it today if I've got enough years of growth ahead of me, that if I'm taking it out tax free.
Yeah, it's worth the hit today.
So how does somebody do that math?
That's a tough one, because if you're in the top bracket, you're probably thinking, oh, I'll be in a lower bracket in retirement.
But in reality, the math isn't proving that out.
Now, there could be a situation we've seen situations where there was a gap, a lag where somebody in their 60s, they're doing well at their top earnings, your top bracket, like you said.
But they retire maybe at 67 or 68.
So you have those few years where income will be lower before RMDs kick in.
Those would be the years to fill up those low brackets.
Also, I might still do the conversion if you look at where he may be, this person, when RMDs are required, are required minimum distributions.
Because one of the real benefits of converting to a Roth IRA is known tax rates.
We know what the rates are today.
We don't know what they'll be when the 60 year old retires.
Plus, if he does nothing, to me, doing nothing is not really an option unless you honestly believe you'll be in a lower bracket in retirement.
There's a lot of people who will, then the Roth conversion probably doesn't pay.
Going back to my rule, always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
If you think you'll be at low rates in retirement, then fine, then you'll be fine, and the beneficiaries too.
But many people, when they do whatever analysis they do, whether they use computers or however they do it,
they fail to take into account that when they do nothing, if they say,
well, I'll be in a lower bracket in retirement, so I'm not going to do anything.
And now you have this 60 year old growing for 15 years, a gigantic tax bill.
If you have large balances, that's another factor too.
If you have too much in your IRA, what do I mean by that?
Many people have an imbalance today, especially people with large balances.
Not everybody has that, unfortunately, but if you have 500,000 or a million more in an IRA,
you have too much money in your IRA as compared to tax free money.
There's an imbalance because most people, the Roth came later.
So most people filled up the tax deferred.
So they have tax, what I call tax risk diversification.
They have a tax, they don't have tax risk diversification is what I'm saying.
They have too much that will be taxed later.
So if this continues to grow, you may only be looking in retirement when you say,
what will my bracket be?
You have to figure out the cumulative effect or the accruing of RMDs,
what they will be based on 15 more years of growth when you didn't touch that money.
So now what we see in the real world when we,
I've seen it with clients when I was a practitioner and we would see people come in.
And I remember this one guy, I was having this exact conversation with him,
a tax client right at this desk, same desk I've been at for over 40 years.
And I was talking to him about Roth IRAs.
And he says, no, everything you said, I'm in a high bracket making a big W2.
I'll be at a lower bracket in retirement.
All right.
And there's almost a joke already all the years of these
little talks while we were doing the tax return.
So he comes in this one year and he's a lick of his chops almost.
He says, Ed, no W2 this year, totally retired.
I give him the return.
How could this be?
My income's higher than my best earnings years.
How could this be?
Because you never listen to me.
Now your IRA is so high, your RMDs exceed the income you used to have.
And you didn't figure on that.
So and the RMDs, remember the R stands for required.
Then it's out of your control while you're converting to a Roth.
I'm not saying convert everything.
You're in control.
You can manage the brackets.
But once RMDs kick in, those funds have to be taken at whatever the future rate is.
And we don't know.
That's another unknown.
If you know the rates now, and they're super low now, historically low for most people,
even people like that in a high bracket, the highest bracket is 37%.
Compare that to what it was in the 70s and 80s of 50%, 70%.
I'm hoping we don't go back to those days.
But I also have to look at the math.
Not that Congress does, but I look at it and you see the debt level.
I don't know what the debt levels are.
37, 38, 39 trillion.
All I know is if they have to round up to the nearest trillion, that's a problem.
That's a financial problem.
And the things I'm saying where I believe tax rates will go up, I've been saying that
for years and I've been wrong.
But I have to believe at some point the math has got to hit the fan.
So if you can lock in these rates, it might be a great deal.
But it's not for everybody.
So if you truly think you'll be in a lower bracket in retirement, then it's not for you.
Or you do partial.
One way to go into the midway of this whole situation is to do a series of smaller conversions
each year for that 60-year-old for maybe 15 years, using up some part of the bracket just
to hedge your bets.
At least get something in the Roth at low rates just to manage the imbalance of IRAs
to Roth IRAs.
All right.
So again, I want to dig into your advice about managing your brackets and helping people
understand that.
But before that, so again, you're a big fan of anything that lets you reduce your taxes
and you love tax-free more than anything.
Reduce lifetime taxes, not today's taxes, because we're in tax season today.
And I guarantee there's somebody listening, either they're doing their taxes or sitting
with their accountant.
They say, should I convert to a Roth?
And the accountant, my own peers, will say, oh, no, that's going to raise the tax bill.
That's going to raise the tax on Social Security.
That could knock out the new senior deduction.
Oh, that's going to raise your ERMA charge.
All right.
I heard enough.
I'm not going to go near a Roth.
But that's one year.
You're not thinking long-term, big picture.
OK, so minimizing lifetime tax payments.
And for beneficiaries.
Remember, another thing, when people say they'll be in a lower bracket in retirement.
I've had people tell me that.
I'll be in a lower bracket in retirement.
I always answer, there's no I in team.
Maybe you think you'll be in a lower bracket.
But let's say you're the husband and you die.
And now you leave your IRA to your wife.
You never did the Roth conversion because you figured you'd be in a lower bracket.
Well, now something I call the widow's penalty that people just don't plan for.
And what happens is most couples, which is fine.
Most couples leave everything to each other, and that's fine.
But when the husband dies, let's say in this example, he leaves everything to his wife.
So she's going to have the same income, roughly, maybe a little less due to the Social Security
adjustment.
She's going to have the same income that they both had together.
But she will be paying tax at a much higher rate because now she's filing at single rates.
I'll give you an example.
If you want to look up the tax rates for 2026, in a married couple filing joint, let's say
they had $400,000 of income.
They'd be in the 24% bracket.
A single person would be in the 35% bracket.
That's a 46% tax increase on that widow now.
And that's going to hit her for the rest of her life.
On the other side, let's say he converted everything.
Maybe he thought he'd be in a lower bracket, but he wanted to make sure his wife wouldn't
get hammered with taxes at single rates to avoid the widow's penalty.
And let's say just extremely converted everything.
Well, now he dies.
She has a Roth IRA.
Her income will be low for the rest of her life and 10 years beyond to beneficiaries.
Plus, she won't be required to take any money out of that Roth because Roth IRAs have no
lifetime required minimum distributions.
Plus, if she wants to take money, she can.
Total freedom.
It won't increase her income.
It won't increase the tax on her Social Security or the Medicare IRMA charges or the 3.8% tax
on that investment income.
She can just take the money tax-free.
If she doesn't take it because she doesn't need it or for whatever reason, she can leave
it to the beneficiaries who, even after the SECURE Act changes, can hold on to that money,
growing, building, and accumulating 10 more years all income tax-free for the investment,
say, the husband made when he decided to convert.
So you get the bang for your buck.
It's just the buck has to come out up front.
And that's a tough, that's a major psychological hurdle for most people.
Yeah.
And we're going to get to how to deal with that in a little bit.
You just said something I want to confirm.
So Roths do not have RMDs?
No.
Lifetime RMDs.
For beneficiaries, there are.
They, for most non-spouse beneficiaries, they have to empty the inherited Roth by the end
of the 10th year after death.
But they don't have to touch it for 10 years if they don't want.
So it grows and accumulates, snowballs, like I said, income tax-free for her life and beyond
to the children or grandchildren.
OK.
So just to be clear, though, I put my money into this Roth while I'm alive.
I don't have any RMDs.
If I die and give it to my, and I die and my spouse gets it, she doesn't have any RMDs.
No.
It's only when it then, the estate then passes to heirs.
They've got 10 years to take those RMDs.
Right.
But look at the amount of time given most people's average life expectancy.
The accumulation period could be decades.
Right.
You really benefit from all that compounding.
And appreciation.
OK.
So that's a huge advantage there.
Even I wasn't super clear on.
OK.
But again, just getting down to brass tacks, I'm going to build up a little bit here.
All right.
OK.
So first off, you love minimizing lifetime taxes.
The Roth is a great-
Everybody loves minimizing lifetime taxes.
The difference is I don't mind paying for it up front.
And that's the secret to it.
Yeah.
So I'm going to give you the secret to this.
You know what Benjamin Franklin said about secrets?
Three people can keep a secret if two of them are dead.
Here's the secret.
And I use this in a lot of my consumer programs.
Three words to paying the least amount of taxes over your lifetime on your retirement savings.
Three words, pay taxes now.
Now when I say that, most audiences say, Ed, what kind of accountant are you?
Pay taxes now.
If I pay taxes now, I'll immediately have less, not more.
I'm here to tell you, if you get it out at the low rates,
the exact opposite is true mathematically.
OK.
And I understand the sense of that.
And I think a lot of my audience probably rationally does.
Maybe they're still working through the emotional challenge of-
It's a psychological- I said, it's a major hurdle to pay a tax,
especially when your accountant is there.
And I'm an accountant too.
But you know what?
I'm a little different than most.
I'm a recovering account.
Because most accountants are just there to help people.
They just look at, how do I save you taxes this minute?
Yes, you could save a boatload of taxes and just kick the can down the road like Congress does.
Yeah.
And one of the reasons why I brought you on is I've learned of some instruments like this,
where I'm like, why didn't my accountant tell me about this?
Because it's going to save me a lot of money in the long run.
And usually it's because in the short run, it's costly.
And they have that short-term focus, like you're saying.
But OK.
So the goal is to minimize lifetime taxes spent.
The Roths are a great vehicle for that.
Now, Roth IRAs, first off, there's just a minimum-
I'm sorry, there's a maximum that you can generally put in each year.
And there are income limitations on it, correct?
Yeah, that's not what I'm talking about.
That's the small potatoes.
I'm talking big picture.
There's two flavors of Roth.
Contributions and conversions.
I'm talking about the big number, the conversion.
I know.
I just want to make sure people sort of understand the options that are out there.
Contributions are limited by income.
For example, for 2026, the most you can put in is 7,500.
If you're 50 or over, another 1,100.
So that gets you to 8,600.
And that's assuming you're under the Roth income limits.
And if you are over that, there's something called the backdoor Roth.
But that's 7, 8, 9, whatever it's going to come to with the inflation increases.
That's small potatoes.
Again, I always plan in the big picture.
Where do you want to end up?
That's great doing that if you can.
But the big picture is bringing down this IRA.
You have to start reducing these heavily weighted IRA balances while rates are low.
Yeah.
So I agree with that.
And I'm just building here.
So first off-
I can't wait till the finale comes.
No worries.
And we're just in the introduction right here.
But if you qualify to be able to put those contributions in, I assume you would say do it.
Yeah, because all you're doing is moving money from one pocket to another.
It's your own money.
You're moving money from a taxable pocket to a tax-free pocket.
OK, great.
So we're doing that now.
Now, we're going to talk about the Roth conversions in just a second.
But above and beyond contributing to my Roths, if I can then put money into something like a
traditional RIA or whatnot, I should do that, correct?
Well, it depends.
Again, I'm a little controversial in this area.
I think some people are heavily overweighted.
Like I said, no balance.
They don't have any tax.
The tax rate, with investments, they tell you don't put all your eggs in one basket,
everything in one stock.
But people are doing that with their IRAs.
They have all their IRA money in one tax basket.
And that basket is too full.
So if you think you're too full and you want to build up in the tax-free, why would you
add anything to that problem if you're already at a problem phase?
OK.
And just so you know, I'm coming at this from the perspective of somebody kind of growing
into their career, right?
So I would assume you would say put your money into your Roths first, then put your money
into your traditional IRAs up until the point where you start having too much.
Well, even before that, I might stop.
I would look at your tax rates.
Again, tax rates are historically low.
From a tax planning perspective, you want to take deductions when rates are high, not
when rates are low.
So getting a deduction for an IRA or 401k contribution, it's not worth it when rates
are low.
You take income when rates are low.
You take deductions when rates are high.
OK.
All right.
That does make sense to me.
And maybe somewhere in here, too, I should probably just say getting a good financial
partner, a good accountant, a good financial advisor can kind of help you do the math to
judge when it's too high or when it's not will be helpful.
All right.
So let's talk about a Roth conversion now, which essentially is a way to take tax deferred
retirement income and put it into a Roth.
But then the challenge is you have to pay the price of that up front.
You have to pay the taxes of that.
It's essentially a distribution, right?
You have to pay that up front, right?
Right.
Don't think of it as a payment in tax.
Think of it as an investment in your future financial security because it goes right back.
Yes, but it goes right back to you because this is tax that will have to be paid anyway.
It's not if but when.
It's not like if you don't do it, you've escaped it.
The problem just gets worse and worse.
Like, you know, not seeing a doctor for a while.
It doesn't mean you're getting better just because you didn't see the doctor and he
didn't give you the bad news.
Right, right.
And so here's the way I think of it.
And I'm going to take my high earner example.
Let's say I'm 50, right?
And I'm successful.
I'm in the highest tax bracket, but I hope to live another 40 plus years, right?
So I've got just round numbers.
I've got a million dollars in a traditional IRA or amongst my traditional tax deferred
retirement accounts.
Well, let's say it's in one just for simplicity.
I've got a million dollars in there and I say I want to do a Roth conversion.
First question is, can I convert all one million in one year?
Sure.
If you have the money to do it, you know, that's really ripping the bandaid off.
I might do a series of smaller conversions to use up the low brackets each year.
OK.
And so, all right, but you can't.
First question is, you can, in theory, take an unlimited amount that's in a retirement
as long as you can have the ability to pay the tax that year.
I'm going to come back to your brackets in just a second.
But in my example, I'm 50.
I've just paid, what's the top bracket?
37%, you said?
OK.
And I guess it's gradated.
So I'm not paying $370,000.
No, not everything's at 37%.
You know, remember, I'm looking at the brackets now.
The 35% tops out.
It's a very high number.
The brackets are so wide.
You don't get to 37% married joint until your taxable income after deductions exceeds $768,700.
So that's not most people.
OK, got it.
All right.
But I'm paying my hefty fee.
Let's just, for ease of calculations, let's say it's $300,000.
Might be less, but let's just say it's $300,000.
So I'm paying that today on a million dollars.
Why would I do that?
Well, in my mind, it's because, all right, fast forward 20, 30 years or more,
that million will have grown to, I don't know, what do you want to say?
$3 million?
It doesn't matter what it grows to, because now you're getting to an area which some,
even my accounting colleagues, my CPA colleagues sometimes,
use what you're talking about as an argument against the Roth.
Here's what they're talking about.
You're talking about the time value of money or what some people call the opportunity cost.
So some people say to me, Ed, again, short-term thinkers, say,
Ed, why would I convert and pay all that tax when I could have used that money to invest
and it would have grown in the market?
So I lose the opportunity.
It's an opportunity cost.
So for anybody thinking that, and that's something like what you're talking about,
there is no opportunity cost, because you can't go about how much you make,
because you have to compare apples to apples.
If you're doing the comparison, you have to compare,
you have to assume the same tax rate and the same earnings rate.
I'll give you, you may want to write this down.
I'll give you a little example to prove this point.
Let's say you're debating whether to convert $100,000 or not, and we'll put on our parameters.
So where you started going with that, but I would earn all this money,
you have to assume even if it was in the IRA, you would earn all that money
and it would be tax deferred.
You would actually earn on a higher balance
because you didn't use that money to convert to a Roth.
So you can't assume because you went into a Roth, you'd earn more
because you paid tax upfront.
So let's say you're debating, should I convert $100,000?
All right, let's assume a 30% tax rate.
It doesn't matter as long as you're comparing apples to apples,
assuming 30% now and 30% later.
And let's assume it doesn't even matter what your investment return rate is,
as long as you're assuming it would have been the same in the IRA
as it would have been in the Roth IRA.
So let's say instead of an investment return over many years,
it would have doubled.
All right, make it easy.
All right, so if I don't convert, let's take the first scenario.
If I don't convert, I have $100,000.
I said the money doubles over time till you take it out, let's say.
So now it'll be worth $200,000.
And then I'll pay tax at the 30%.
30% times $200,000 is $60,000.
So what does that leave you from the $200,000?
If you're writing that up.
Well, that would be $140,000, right?
All right, good.
I wanted to hear you say it, okay?
Okay.
Now, all right, so that's one scenario.
So I'd net $140,000, right?
Let's say I converted now.
I have the same $100,000.
I convert.
So now I pay 30% tax on the $100,000 right off the top.
So now I'm only left with $70,000 to invest, but it doubles over time.
What am I left with?
All right, $140,000.
The same thing.
So you can't assume where you started going,
say all this money will grow in the Roth like if it wouldn't in the IRA.
The only difference is the tax,
that 30% will apply to a higher balance in the IRA eventually.
Right, that's actually where it was going,
which was assuming they both grow at the same rate.
My point was that the tax burden that I'm paying on day one,
if this thing over time continues to grow,
and like I said, 30 years, it's probably going to more than double.
And therefore, my tax deferred taxes that I will pay
when I finally get to the distributions that I have to take
will likely be far greater, even inflation adjusted,
than what the hit I'm taking today is.
Yeah, they will be far greater,
even though we're using the same rate and rate of return,
because the difference is,
and this is where I think the Roth tips the scales,
you're forced to take that money out whether you want to or not at age 73 now.
Right.
With the Roth, it just keeps growing until you die,
the spouse dies, and the kids 10 years later.
Right.
And to your earlier point too,
there's just a lot of uncertainty about the future, right?
We might have President Mundami by the time I retire,
and tax rates could be in the 70th percentile for whatever.
Whereas in the Roth, you do have certainty,
which is, hey, when or even if I take these distributions out,
I know I'm getting it tax free.
Right, you have known rates.
You know, it's really, like I said,
a big bet on where you think future tax rates are.
So when I say the word bet, it reminds me of a casino,
which by the way, I don't know if you've noticed this,
I know you speak at a lot of financial conferences, me too,
and they always teach you,
have good speakers on how to be prudent with money,
and most of those conferences are in a casino in Las Vegas or somewhere.
So I never understood, a little ironic,
but anyway, so the Roth is a big bet.
Now, let's say you were in a casino,
and I'm not a big, I don't gamble at all,
but I've walked through, I know the games, let's say.
And let's say you're playing blackjack.
In other words, on the Roth bet,
you're betting, which I think is a real good bet,
that future high, to do the Roth,
it would work if you believe future,
your future higher tax rates,
the rates and your marginal rates will be higher.
I think that's probably, for most people,
it could be 70, 80% probability that it'll be higher.
It's a good bet.
So in Las Vegas, you don't get those kind of odds.
But what if you did?
What if you're at the blackjack table,
and you know the way the works,
and they have the two cards,
what if the dealer turned over both of his cards
before you decide to hit?
Would you increase that bet?
Absolutely.
Right, that's the same thing with the Roth.
I think the odds go in your favor
on whether tax rates will be higher in the future.
All right, and I like that analogy,
because the Roth gives you greater clarity,
and that's just like being able to see
both of the dealer's cards.
Right.
Okay, so earlier you said you want to manage the brackets.
So let's use my 50-year-old again,
so somebody with some life ahead of them still.
How do you manage the brackets?
Well, right now you gave an example
of somebody already in the top bracket.
Well, it may not be the best thing for them
unless they're so overweighted.
I think in your example,
the guys that already had a million,
that might be too much.
Again, there's no disparity.
There's no too much in tax.
Instead of calling it tax deferred,
to be taxed money is growing.
You're growing a bill.
You know, I always say at conferences,
your IRA is an IOU to the IRS.
It's a growing building tax bill
where the compounding is working against you.
In the Roth, it's working for you.
So when I say the tax brackets,
you look at the brackets,
and I would say at a minimum,
given today's 12%, 22 and 24,
those are historically low.
I know I've said it a few times,
but most people don't realize how good they have it.
And each year, the brackets,
these low brackets expand due to inflation increases.
So more money can come out at 12% or 22%.
I remember at an accounting conference I was speaking at,
one of the accountants came up to me proudly.
He was waiting for me to give him a pat on the back.
He says, Ed, you're gonna love this.
I kept my client in the 12% bracket.
I said, I'm sorry to hear that.
You mean the guy has a large IRA
and you didn't use the 22 or 24% bracket?
Now it's lost forever.
So you look at brackets, you wanna optimize.
If you don't optimize these low brackets,
and they are historically low.
I know everybody complains about taxes
and nobody wants to pay them before you have to.
But I mean, this is like Christmas.
It's on sale.
Taxes are on sale.
Look what they do on Black Friday.
Everybody tramples over everyone
to get a TV for $10 less because they like a sale.
Taxes are on sale.
And these are taxes.
The difference with the TV in the store on Black Friday,
you don't actually have to buy it.
With the taxes, you do.
So with the taxes, you know you have to pay it at some point.
So may as well get it on sale.
That's another way of saying,
my always will always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
All right.
And maybe this is really defined by the individual.
But let's say somebody is in the 12% bracket,
but they have money in a to-be-taxed retirement vehicle.
An IRA, yeah.
Is it just getting the next bracket?
Is that what you wanna do?
Or might you wanna get the next two brackets?
It depends on how much you have.
If somebody has, I'd say, two, three, 400,000,
I'm not saying that's not a lot.
But it's more likely more of that money will be spent
over a given life expectancy or through RMDs.
And maybe a Roth is not a big deal.
You may always be in a low bracket,
just in lifetime spending and always getting it out.
So this wouldn't apply.
But as the accounts grow, the larger the account balance,
it's not only a bigger tax bill
that again will be forced on you at 73,
but a bigger tax bill for your beneficiaries
over that shortened 10-year window,
because they may at that point
be in their own highest earnings years.
And all of that money, think about this,
all of the buildup in your lifetime plus 10 years
has to come out at the end of the 10th year after death
to your beneficiaries.
In other words, in year 10, it's a 100% RMD.
That could be a big hit of taxes at that point.
Okay, so help me understand here.
So I get all the advantages of doing this.
Now, the older you are,
you may have less time to recoup
between the time you pay the tax
and the time you have to start taking this stuff out.
So a lot of people who are watching this video
are close to retirement age
or perhaps already retired.
How should they be thinking about this?
Because you can still kind of play these brackets
even if you're retired before you're RMD.
First of all, another one of my general rules,
nobody should go broke converting.
If you're 70 or 80 years old, I get this question,
am I too old to convert?
Well, it should never impact your current lifestyle.
You shouldn't be converting
and then keeping yourself paying all this tax.
I'm trying to say it in a nicer way,
but given the cost versus the benefit
in your limited life expectancy is just not worth it,
especially if it impacts your lifestyle.
Nobody should go broke converting.
You should be thinking about yourself first.
However, if you could be 80 years old and say,
look, I don't even need that money.
I'm converting for my children and grandchildren.
Well, that's another whole story.
Then you might wanna convert
and maybe take advantage of the tax brackets
because it doesn't impact your financial security.
That's rule one.
You have to take care of yourself first.
It cannot impact your financial security during lifetime.
People worry too much about the kids.
And I even said this would be a great gift to the kids,
but not if it impacts your lifestyle.
Got it, all right.
All right, totally makes sense there as well.
So let me ask you this.
You wanna hear a nice little strategy I've used for people.
It doesn't apply to everybody
because we started talking about older people.
Let's say you're watching this now
and you have followers or viewers that may be in their 50s
and they may be that person
that's doing well in a high bracket.
I got plenty of those watching right now.
Right, all right.
But their mom's around and their mom has an IRA,
but she's in a low bracket,
taking her RMDs and all that.
Here's an idea.
Give your mom money to convert her IRA to a Roth IRA
because she'll do it at her bracket.
She has to still take her RMDs.
RMDs can't be converted.
But after her RMDs are taken, make her a gift
and the gift limits are very high.
You can gift up to $15 million a year,
30 million per couple under the new rules.
And you can do 19,000 a year
just in the annual gift tax exclusion.
Doesn't even count against the 15 million.
So that's not even an issue.
There's no gift tax or anything.
So you could give mom money
to convert her to a $300,000 IRA, convert it all.
She'll still probably be in a low bracket.
The only trick here is make sure she names you
as the beneficiary.
Because then you're going to inherit her Roth
at some point, but it was paid for at her rates.
Correct.
And then you've got 10 years to basically
do whatever you want with that money.
But hopefully mom lives a long time.
So you're not seeing that long in the future
when hopefully maybe it's actually appreciated
a fair amount.
And I'm curious if she converts at all,
like you said in that example,
she doesn't have any more RMDs, does she?
Right, right.
Then she has a Roth.
Not only that, her income is lower
because of no RMDs for the rest of her life.
It may even lower her IRMA charges,
her social security taxation,
and everything based on income.
Man, that makes total sense.
That's a great idea.
You know what I call it?
I call it estate planning up the family tree,
reverse estate planning.
Everybody that does estate planning
looks how to get money down
to their children and grandchildren.
But nobody thinks about the parents.
And this could be one situation
where it pays to gift up the family tree.
Yeah, absolutely.
I mean, that just makes total sense to me.
So you're giving us lots of great jewels here, Ed.
Thank you.
So question for this.
I asked you and you said,
yes, if I've got a big tax-deferred account,
I can convert all of that
in any given year if I want to.
Can I do that every year?
Can I put money into a regular IRA,
make a contribution for the year,
and then at the end of the year,
convert that over and just do that year after year?
Yeah, what you're describing
is basically the backdoor Roth.
You would only do it that way
if you're making too much money
to contribute to a Roth IRA.
But if you have a very large IRA,
you can bite off bits,
then you don't have to do the backdoor Roth.
Then you can just do,
I'm gonna do 200,000 a year or something.
I was just speaking to somebody
who's doing exactly that,
doing say 200,000 a year
to knock down a $2 million account,
too much money in their IRA.
Right, so that's taking your bites
of an existing IRA.
I'm saying, let's say I've already done that.
So I'm this successful 50-year-old.
I decided to take all the pain today
and I convert everything I have.
Next year, can I make an additional contribution
to that tax-deferred IRA
and then roll that over again too?
Right, but if you're gonna roll it over,
why not just make a contribution
to the Roth IRA
unless you're over the income limit?
But I'm assuming in this case,
you're over the income.
Yeah, all right.
That's called the backdoor Roth.
You make a non-deductible IRA contribution
to a traditional IRA
and then convert it to a Roth.
Okay, and I can do that year after year after year,
there's no limitations on it?
Yeah, people do it every year.
Wow, it seems like almost cheating the system
to a certain extent,
but I guess the government's getting paid today.
Yeah, the government,
you bring up an excellent point.
One of the biggest objections
to doing Roth convert,
I don't know if it's objections,
but things I get from consumers and programs,
they hear me talk all about the Roth
and I said,
but Ed, somebody always asks us,
can I trust the government to keep their word
that Roth IRAs will always be income tax-free?
And my answer is always,
no, you can't trust them
as far as you can throw them.
We have a saying among CPAs,
tax laws are written in pencil.
I have no problem with that.
I don't see that as a problem.
Why?
Because luckily, as I said before,
Congress is short-sighted.
They're the worst financial planners on earth.
They actually love the Roth
because it brings in money up front
for their budget cycles.
So anything, that's their golden goose.
If you look at the last few tax bills,
that's what the Roth provisions
were in the revenue provisions
to pay for everything else in the bill.
And if you look at it,
I don't know how far back you go,
but if you remember before 2010,
you couldn't convert to a Roth IRA
if your income exceeded $100,000.
I don't know if you remember those days
when Roth first came out,
you couldn't contribute
if your income exceeded 100,000.
Congress, as usual, needed money.
And somebody say,
why don't we get money from people
who make more than 100,000?
So they eliminated that restriction
and they got a boatload of money,
including people like me.
That year, I converted everything.
The minute they eliminated that restriction,
I converted everything in 2010.
You wanna take a guess
on how much tax I paid in 2010?
I'm gonna say zero.
Zero is the answer.
That was the deal of the century.
If you went to my seminars,
I begged people to take that deal.
The point is Congress was desperate for the money,
but if I paid zero, how'd they get the money?
The deal was we're gonna let everybody,
regardless of income,
no more income limitation convert
because they wanted boatloads of money to come in
and they got it from people like me.
But the deal was if you convert in 2010
as an incentive, no tax in 2010,
you can pay half in 11, half in 12.
In other words, the government gave everyone
an interest-free loan
to build a tax-free savings account.
It was the deal of the century.
I begged people to take that deal.
And even professionals in my audiences
and consumers didn't take that deal.
Why?
They didn't even wanna pay the tax
under those circumstances.
Even then, the short-sightedness took over.
And if you look at it, back in 2010,
I believe the market, the Dow was about 11,000.
Even now, it's four times that.
All of that growth for the people who did that
has all been growing for now 16 years,
income tax-free and compounding income tax-free.
So looking in hindsight, you might say,
it would have paid to pay the tax,
but people are not looking.
Again, short-sighted, nobody wants to pay a tax.
So the reason I bring up that deal
is because once Congress saw the money,
they got in from that deal.
They said, let's expand Roth 401ks.
Let's spend Roth 403Bs.
And then eventually they added SEP Roth IRAs,
simple Roth IRAs, 529s to Roth.
They want everybody to do Roths.
In fact, this year, 2026 is the first year
Congress actually mandated Roth contributions
for catch-up contributions.
People that work at a company
that get catch-up contributions,
they're over 50 or over the 60, 61, 62,
these are the catch-up contributions.
If you made more than 150,000 last year
on a W-2 at this company,
your catch-up contribution must by law go to the Roth.
Not the worst thing in the world,
but people would like a choice.
But this is where I'm saying Congress is tipping their hand.
They love the Roth because they get their money up front.
So I don't think that's a risk
of Congress killing their golden goose.
Okay.
So what I'm taking from you, Ed,
is you're saying, look, we all hate paying taxes,
but obviously it makes sense to pay taxes now
if it's gonna save you more taxes down the road.
And we're in this beneficial moment in time
where tax rates are historically low
and the government is actually leaning
into Roth-based solutions.
That's right.
So basically don't be an idiot, take advantage of it.
Well, everybody's situation is different.
If they truly believe they'll be in a lower bracket,
you go back to my rule,
always pay taxes at the lowest rates.
If those will be your lowest rates,
then the Roth is not a thing for you.
Okay.
All right.
Well, look, this has been great, Ed.
I wanna ask you about annuities,
which is something you also spoke at.
But real quick before I do,
Roths are great vehicles for saving lifetime taxes.
Are there any other strategies
that are worth talking about here
before we move on to your annuity concept?
Well, the annuity I don't sell,
just so people know,
I'm a tax accountant, a tax advisor.
I don't sell stocks, bonds, funds,
insurance, annuities, none of that.
I don't do any investment.
I don't make any money over at any...
We're an education company, essentially, is what we do.
But there is a case to be made to have guaranteed income
with these gyrations in the market.
And it might not be a bad idea
to take some of those gains off the table,
some of those chips off the table
in that casino we were talking about,
where everything is generally up
except the last few weeks, but generally up.
Maybe take some of those chips off the table,
cash them in at today's low rates
and get yourself and speak to your own advisor
if it's right for you,
a guaranteed income through an annuity
where those checks come in.
I mean, they're guaranteed.
My own rule is for your basic monthly living expenses.
Those shouldn't be left to volatility in the market.
Oh, I can't pay the light bill
because the market's down.
Nobody should live like that.
So what I mentioned,
you might've heard me talk about that at that conference,
because my mother, obviously before she passed,
she had these annuities.
I didn't even know what they were,
but my father died much earlier.
My mother lived into her 90s
and she had an advisor that realized
she was like the Energizer Bunny.
She's gonna be going a while.
And he put her in these four or five annuities,
turned out to be the best thing
that ever happened to our family.
Those checks came in every month,
no matter how old she got,
no matter how sick she got,
and no matter how the market performed,
she never worried about money.
And I don't have any data on this,
but from what I see,
people like my mother and others,
people with guaranteed income,
they're just happier people.
They don't worry about anything.
Even at the end, before my mother passed,
I was up at the hospital with her
and I said,
Ma, you only have $600 in your checking account.
She says, what do I care?
I get five new checks every month.
That mentality that you'll never run out of money,
there's something to be said for that.
But one thing I did mention
that I picked up from my mother,
I got annuities myself,
just as a hedge,
you know, to have some guaranteed income.
But the only thing better
than guaranteed income for life
is what I have,
guaranteed tax-free income for life.
How did I do that?
Well, I followed my mother's lead,
but I got the annuities in my Roth IRA.
What does that do?
Well, I'm hoping never to need the income for life.
I hope it goes to my kids.
But let's say I wanted to tap into that.
It would be guaranteed for life.
And because it's coming out of a Roth,
it's guaranteed tax-free.
And it's not for my whole Roth,
a very small portion,
but enough to protect against any downside risk
as a buffer, a guardrail,
whatever you want to call it.
It allows me to be much more aggressive
with the lion's share of my Roth investment.
Right, because you know every month
when those annuities kick in,
you're going to get that check.
Hey, real quick.
So to me, this makes a ton of sense, right?
I love it.
It's your guaranteed income,
but it's tax-free as well,
which is great.
Because I love anything tax-free.
You know me.
Yeah.
Well, and it's like,
why wouldn't you do it in your Roth, right?
So I could get an annuity,
it would pay me,
but then I'd owe taxes on that.
So I'm getting only a percentage of the check
at the end of the day.
Well, if I just have my Roth buy it,
I get the whole thing.
Why wouldn't I do that?
Right.
Yeah.
And you said,
one thing I just want to clarify there
is you said the annuity is guaranteed for life.
So the annuity part of your-
They're all different products.
Again, I'm not a product guy.
It's like every different flavor
and bells and whistles and features.
You can turn some features on or off.
So you have to speak to a professional
or do your own research.
Every one of these products
has different bells and whistles
options to choose from.
Okay.
Let me just get the thought out.
If it were one that was
for the life of the annuitant,
that is something that would not pass on
to your heirs as part of the IRA?
If that's your...
I don't have that kind
because I have a death benefit on mine.
But you pay for that internally.
So you would get a lower lifetime benefit.
It's all the actuarial numbers.
So yeah, if you want it to end in your life,
you'll get a much bigger monthly check.
I didn't choose that.
Okay.
All right.
So obviously be careful about
what you're agreeing to
and the impact it might have on things.
But also the benefit is
there's so many different options there.
You can pretty much
custom create what you want.
Right, right.
Yeah.
All right.
Well, Ed, look, this has been super useful,
very informative.
And I'm going to say this
and you can clarify anything
you want on top of this.
But folks, if this is sounding
of interest to you,
I highly recommend,
especially if this is something
you're not already doing yet,
sit down with a good financial advisor
and or your CPA
and go through the different options
that you think you might want to do.
And of course,
they might be able to come up
with a whole bunch of options
that you haven't even thought of yourself.
But really do have a professional
run the numbers for you,
give you lots of different options
and help you triangulate in
on what's going to be best for you.
But obviously, Ed,
you've given us a lot of fodder for thought here
in terms of ways to basically reduce taxes
we'll pay over the rest of our lives.
And thus increase the amount left over
that we have to actually live our lives
and enjoy our golden years
and pass stuff on to our family.
Yeah. And with the Roth,
I have to add this,
you have to be careful.
Roth conversions are permanent.
There's no backseas,
no do-overs,
no re-characterizations
that we had years ago.
So I would have these conversations
or do your research,
but I would not pull the trigger
on a Roth conversion
until the first week of December
when the capital gain distributions come in,
when you have a better idea
of wages for the year,
income, expenses,
so you can have a better projection
of what it's going to cost you
on what bracket you'll end up in.
Okay. And do you know
with doing the conversion,
can you do it in that window
between January 1st and tax season?
No, no, no.
That's the challenge with Roth.
It's not like an IRA.
You have until April 15th
to put money in an IRA,
a contribution to an IRA,
a Roth for last year.
There is no last year concept for Roth.
So it's a challenge.
If you want a Roth IRA conversion
for 2026,
the funds have to leave the IRA in 2026
when you won't know the exact bracket.
You have an idea,
but not exactly
until you see that tax return.
You say,
where do all these capital gain distributions
come from?
Okay. All right.
Well, look, Ed,
thank you for coming on
and sharing all this with us.
For folks that would like
to follow you and your work,
where should they go?
IRAhelp.com.
It's an amazing site.
I know it's our site,
but there's so much free
and quality information.
www.irahelp.com.
We put out blogs several times a week.
We answer questions.
And when I say we,
I'm talking about experts.
You'll see the question.
You can learn so much
just from going into the mailbag
where people write in questions.
We can say, bring your questions.
But oh, and we also have a part
where other people
can answer your questions.
And usually experts log in there.
So you might say, well,
if anybody can answer,
that's a different section.
The section we answer,
you know, you're getting it right
from the expert.
But the, I forget what we call it,
it's not the mailbag,
something where it's like a bulletin board
where you could just ask a question
and anybody, it's an open forum.
Let the community have it.
Discussion forum.
That's what it's called.
Discussion forum, I think.
So anybody can answer.
So you might say,
well, if I put something in there,
how do I know the answer
is going to be correct?
I'll tell you, it's self-correcting
because we have had such a following
on there for over 20 years.
If you post an answer on there, that's wrong.
You will hear from about 20 people
within about a minute.
And they'll say it's wrong
because you forgot these three things.
And when that happens,
you learn so much from that.
Excellent.
All right.
Well, look, Ed, when I edit this,
I will put up the link to your website there
so folks know exactly where to go.
Folks, the links will be
in the description below this video as well.
All right.
Well, as we wrap up here, folks,
please extend your gratitude for Ed
for being so generous with his expertise
here with us today
by hitting the like button
and then clicking on the subscribe button below,
as well as that little bell icon
right next to it.
And very important, as we mentioned,
if you're planning on acting on this,
I highly recommend that you do so
under the guidance
of a good financial advisor and your CPA.
But if you don't have a good advisor
or CPA advising you,
feel free to talk to one
of the financial advisors
that Thoughtful Money endorses.
These are the firms you see with me
on this channel week in and week out.
To set up one of those free discussions,
just fill out the very short form
at thoughtfulmoney.com.
Tell them you saw this video with Ed
and you want to talk to them
about the strategies
that we mentioned here.
They'll be happy to sit down with you.
And again, these consultations
are totally free.
There's no commitments involved.
It's just a service they offer
to be as helpful to as many people
as possible.
Also a reminder
that we had the Thoughtful Money
Spring Online Conference
this past weekend.
It was absolutely fantastic, folks.
Hands down the best one we've ever done
and couldn't have been more timely
with everything going on in the world,
particularly with the war there in Iran
and all the knock-on effects
that's having on the markets
and the global economy.
If you did not watch,
did not attend that conference
and wish you had, don't worry.
You can purchase the replay
to the whole thing.
To do that, just fill out
the very short form.
Not even the very short form.
Just go to thoughtfulmoney.com
slash conference
and you can quickly buy
the replay video of the whole event,
all the presentations,
all the live Q&A there.
All right, Ed, I can't thank you enough.
This was so informative.
Really look forward to having you
back on the channel again soon.
Yeah, thanks, Adam.
Great show.
Thank you.
Thank you and look forward
to having you back on again
at some point in the future.
All right.
And everybody else,
thanks so much for watching.