Premiered 6 hours ago 2 products Adam Taggart | Thoughtful Money® tagged products below. Learn more
Men's Non-Iron Dress Shirt - Trim Fit Pinpoint Solid - In Light Blue, Cotton | The Tie Bar Limited shipping areas thetiebar.com/product/shr-2952-0201?variant=S10-1753637-TF&srsltid=AfmBOoo8i_SGLcwLUxCGyOeAV6eubATbchBGoL9-MZZzcU6tVI_8DQf-IU8
Saks Fifth Avenue Men's Délavé Solid Linen Suit Jacket - Teal - Size 48 Limited shipping areas saksfifthavenue.com/product/Saks-Fifth-Avenue-D%C3%A9lav%C3%A9-Solid-Linen-Suit-Jacket-0400021742510.html?dwvar_0400021742510_size=48+R&dwvar_0400021742510_color=TEAL&site_refer=NPLA_GGL_Shopping&country=US¤cy=USD REQUEST A FREE CONSULTATION WITH OXBOW at https://www.thoughtfulmoney.com/oxbow
For years now, corporate stock prices have been growing substantially faster than their free cash flows.
In theory, this shouldn't be sustainable.
Will 2026 prove to be the year that the math starts to matter?
Today's guest, Chance Finucane, Chief Investment Officer of high net worth advisory firm Oxbow Advisors, thinks it may be.
0:00 - Latest Outlook on Stock Prices vs Free Cash Flows 1:47 - High-Level Assessment of Financial Markets 2:38 - S&P 500 Rangebound Since October 3:05 - Consolidation vs Topping Process 3:54 - 2026 as a Year of Rotation 4:19 - Anticipated Volatility in 2026 5:14 - Midterm Elections Impact on Markets 5:59 - Default Market Estimate for 2026 7:11 - Conservative Positioning Strategy 8:26 - Historically Stretched Valuations 9:15 - Price to Free Cash Flow Analysis 9:50 - When the Math Starts to Matter in 2026 12:03 - Optimism on Commodity Complex 12:26 - Explaining the 30-30-30-10 Allocation 13:41 - Current Commodity Allocation 14:46 - Current Thinking on Precious Metals 15:25 - Long-Term Bullish on Precious Metals 16:44 - Trimming Exposure to Precious Metals 18:33 - Opportunities in Commodities Beyond Precious Metals 18:49 - Moving into Energy Sector 22:48 - Making Money from Bear Markets 26:42 - Opinion on Kevin Warsh as New Fed Chair 28:49 - Outlook on Longer-Term Rates 30:55 - Other Parts of Commodity Complex 32:57 - Expectations for Dollar Weakness 33:49 - Other Areas for Moving Capital 35:55 - Risky Parts of the Market to Avoid 37:19 - Other Topics on Oxbow's Radar 40:08 - Investment Discipline and Stop-Losses 43:36 - How to Contact Oxbow Advisors 43:47 - Thoughtful Money Spring Conference _____________________________________________ Thoughtful Money LLC is a Registered Investment Advisor Promoter.
We produce educational content geared for the individual investor. It’s important to note that this content is NOT investment advice, individual or otherwise, nor should be construed as such.
We recommend that most investors, especially if inexperienced, should consider benefiting from the direction and guidance of a qualified financial advisor registered with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) or state securities regulators who can develop & implement a personalized financial plan based on a customer’s unique goals, needs & risk tolerance.
IMPORTANT NOTE: There are risks associated with investing in securities.
Investing in stocks, bonds, exchange traded funds, mutual funds, money market funds, and other types of securities involve risk of loss. Loss of principal is possible. Some high risk investments may use leverage, which will accentuate gains & losses. Foreign investing involves special risks, including a greater volatility and political, economic and currency risks and differences in accounting methods.
A security’s or a firm’s past investment performance is not a guarantee or predictor of future investment performance.
Thoughtful Money and the Thoughtful Money logo are trademarks of Thoughtful Money LLC.
531 episodes Thoughtful Money (with Adam Taggart) Adam Taggart | Thoughtful Money®
I think you are seeing a broadening or a consolidation where some of the big
winners that were driving the gains in the index in the last few years are
starting to top out. And there's starting to be some more questions about those.
And you're seeing other sectors,
other industries in the market that are showing more strength.
And so for anybody who had a more diversified portfolio that might've lagged in
the last year or two,
they're now outperforming because those other areas are starting to act the way
that you would have liked.
Welcome to Found4Money. I'm its founder and your host, Adam Taggart.
For years now,
corporate stock prices have been growing substantially faster than their free
cash flows. In theory, this shouldn't be sustainable.
So will 2026 prove to be the year that the math starts to matter?
Today's guest, Chance Finucane,
Chief Investment Officer of high net worth advisory firm Oxbow Advisors,
thinks it may be. Chance, thanks so much for joining us today.
Hey, Adam, thanks a lot for having me back on your show.
Hey, it's always a pleasure to have you on,
as is having your partner in crime there, Ted Oakley.
You guys do a fantastic job there at Oxbow Advisors.
You guys just put out your kind of your latest outlook.
And one of the things that focused on, as I just mentioned there in the,
in the intro is how stock prices have been growing, you know,
substantially faster than free cash flows really for the past bunch of years.
So I want to talk to you about, you know,
whether or not you think that can sustain, and if not, what that means. But,
but before we start, if I can, just at a very high level,
what is your current assessment of the financial markets right now?
Sure. When we look at it, we think the, the market cap indices,
such as the S&P 500 look expensive to us,
especially given the concentration in seven or 10 big stocks that,
that I'm sure we'll get into the free cashflow production of those really large
tech companies has gone down as they try to invest in AI,
which then creates more risk. If it doesn't pan out,
we think there's a little bit more opportunity and more of an equal weighted,
diversified approach to your stock portfolio.
And then the other thing we're monitoring is as much as it's been a little bit
of a slow steady start for the indices to the first month of the year,
there's been a lot of movement under the surface,
whether that's in commodity prices,
specifically precious metals that we've been taking a lot of activity within our
portfolios, try to make sure we risk manage that well.
And then also through certain sectors within the stock market.
So it's been a lot happening in the first month of the year,
even though it seems like a bit of a normal start.
Okay. Yeah. And if you look at the S&P,
even though it has recently hit a new all time highs,
it finally cracked 7,000.
It's been pretty range bound since what say October or so of last year.
Do you see that as more consolidation or do you see that more as a topping
process?
We would expect at least we thought the first three,
four or five months of this year was going to be more of a continuation of the,
the up move, just because a comparison to the first quarter of last year,
when you had slow GDP growth was going to make it look like the economy was
accelerating in the United States to be a decent backdrop for stocks.
So we weren't expecting a break in the market in the first quarter,
but to your point,
I think you are seeing a broadening or a consolidation where some of the big
winners that were driving the gains in the index in the last few years are
starting to top out.
And there's starting to be some more questions about those and you're seeing
other sectors, other industries, the market that are showing more strength.
And so for anybody who had a more diversified portfolio that might've lagged in
the last year or two,
they're now outperforming because those other areas are starting to act the way
that you would have liked.
Okay.
So does that mean you guys see 2026 is more of a year of
rotation where money finally starts leaving the,
the hyperscaler trade,
which has kind of been hoovering up all the capital over the past couple of
years.
And it's more of a broadening out where that money is starting to find new parts
of the market.
Yeah, I would say we would expect a rotation.
As you're describing,
but we would also anticipate more volatility specifically sort of around the
middle to back half of this year.
We think that if you look at past midterm election years,
we were just going through this in the office.
You can go all the way back to 1990 and pretty much see volatility being higher
than normal in every midterm election year for the U S whether that's
2022, 2018, 2014, 2010,
you start working your way backwards.
There was something that hit in the middle to the latter half of each of those
years that created a little bit more chaos than investors would have liked.
So we would anticipate that there will be volatility later in the year.
And we see that as a chance to try to be a little bit more opportunistic and
maybe add to the portfolio. But right now we're diversified,
make sure we've risk managed things well.
So we can participate a little bit if this upside continues,
but we're very ready for any volatility later in the year.
Okay.
And I want to talk about, you know, where you think that capital is going to rotate.
So as you diversify, what areas you're diversifying into. Um,
but first the midterms, you know,
the second year of a presidential administration tends to be the worst year
stock market performance wise, um,
probably in some part due to the midterm chaos. Um, uh,
also as I've been noting a lot in this channel, it's,
it's quite rare statistically to get three, um,
years of double digit,
let alone kind of 20% average back-to-back-to-back returns in the market.
Very rare to get four years of such a performance.
So as you look to 2026 with your expected additional volatility,
and maybe just the statistics that I mentioned, and then of course,
anything else you're seeing fundamentally, technically, otherwise, what is your,
what is your default estimate for the year for the markets? Um, up year,
down year, up by a lot, up by a little, down by a little, down by a lot.
We really don't try to set price targets and I'm not trying to avoid your
question. I don't find it that helpful. I think,
I think we try to think more broadly where you just look at this and just ask
yourself, do you think things are,
are pretty expensive right now or pretty cheap after to your point?
Cause we talk about the same things.
You just had three straight years where the market was up at least 15%.
Uh, all three years,
you'd have to go back to that 1994 to 1999 stretch where you had more than three
years in a row that went at that pace. Uh,
and so you don't know if we're gonna have a fourth year like that,
but we do know that when it ends,
you're going to see significant weakness in the market because you're going to
have to pull things back in after prices outrun the fundamentals, uh,
for this longer period of time. So we're just not trying to chase it.
And, uh, we'll be ready when there is a 15, 20, 30% pullback in the market.
Um, but there's really just kind of preparing, uh, for that in the meantime.
Okay. So it sounds like, and don't me put words in your mouth,
but you guys are a little bit more conservatively positioned because things
seem expensive to you and you expect more volatility.
And the reason for that is, is, Hey, we want to be able to,
if there is indeed a material market pullback,
we want to be able to be in a position to deploy funds into that and then ride
the recovery.
Exactly.
I think during a move like we had in the past three years and really just
looking at the past few months at our own activity,
we've been trimming or selling some of our biggest winners to try and lock in
some of those gains,
especially if they're more cyclical industries rather than secular growth
stocks. Uh,
we want to make sure that we take some of those gains that might've run ahead of
the fundamentals. Uh,
and then you end up being able to manage a decline or volatility in the future a
lot more easily so that rather than scrambling thinking, Oh,
we still had too much invested in this area. Now, what are we going to do?
It's down 20 or 30%. You've already made the adjustments.
And so you can start thinking a step ahead as to how much further do I need it
to fall before maybe I increase that position again.
And we can get into it whenever you want.
But the example with gold and silver over the past week, uh,
is a perfect case study for that.
Yeah. Well, we're going to get into that. Um, but,
but to your point about expensive, you know, I've,
I've mentioned with many of the experts on this channel over the past several
years about how valuations have gotten to just very historically
stretched levels. In some cases, the most extreme we've, we've ever seen them.
Uh, and we've generally talked about, you know, common multiples,
whether it's CAPE ratios, whether it's price to sales, whether it's, you know,
at a high level, the Buffett ratio, et cetera,
haven't really talked that much about it from a price to cashflow standpoint,
but I've got to imagine from the data that you've, you've surfaced here,
um, that, uh,
a price to cash flows have also got to be at very stretched levels.
If stock prices have been growing, you know,
much faster than cash flows have free cash flows have over the past bunch of
years. Um, you know, a, is that true? And,
and kind of to my question in the intro, I mean,
nobody knows for sure what's going to happen in the future, but do you,
are you suspecting that 2026 might be the year where
the mass might start to matter?
And that's going to have to be pulled back down into maybe more historical
norms.
We're definitely in the range where it, this could be the year that matters.
And the way to frame it is it's dependent on when investors
decide to be more skeptical about all the investment going into AI.
So this may not be the year for that.
It may be that everyone's still very optimistic and bullish.
And you saw the reaction to various tech company earnings releases last week,
whether it was down on Microsoft,
but very happy with the investment being done by Meta or Tesla. Uh,
you need more skepticism on the part of investors that would punish all this
additional CapEx that these companies are spending, uh,
with uncertain future returns. But if you just look historically, uh,
going back to the start of the financial crisis in 2008, 2009,
on average, uh, the S and P 500,
whether it was the cap weighted index or the equal weighted index trades at
about 20 times free cashflow, would it be about the average?
So be about saying like a 5% free cashflow yield, uh,
when you're looking at the next 12 months expected free cashflow,
which seems pretty reasonable to us.
What's changed is the largest companies in the index that drive more weight
there.
They're now spending so much on CapEx that their free cash flows have come down
by a lot.
And now the S and P 500 is trading at nearly 30 times free cashflow.
So one of two things needs to happen. Either, uh,
price needs to come down where investors become skeptical about that, uh,
excess CapEx spending,
or the companies may decide that we're not getting the return that we'd like on
all that CapEx and they try to rein it in.
But one of the two has to occur where something's got to catch up because right
now things have gotten so extended.
We think you're better off diversifying across more quality companies.
If you look at the equal weighted, uh, S and P 500 price to free cashflow,
that's still trading just above 20 times, pretty close to its average.
You can find other good businesses that aren't cheap,
but at least are trading in a more reasonable valuation compared to their
history and feel like you're not going to get crushed if the sentiment turns on
that whole AI story.
Okay. Um, and so, you know, all right.
So take your money out of the big dominant trade, um,
or take some capital out of that big dominant trade,
put it into other areas that don't appear as overvalued.
Now you guys at Oxbow from my previous conversations with you, um,
have been fairly optimistic about the prospects for the commodity complex.
Um, you guys have talked about the 30, 30, 30, 10 allocation.
If I'm getting that right. Um,
and maybe it might be worth just spending a second on defining that for folks.
Um, chance. Um, well,
I don't let you do that first and then I'll get into the meat of my question.
Sure. And to be clear, it's not as if it's a set formula,
but our managing partner,
Ted Oakley has talked about the era of the 60,
40 portfolio, 60% stocks, 40% bonds, uh,
may not deliver the same quality returns that we just had over the last 40 years
where we were in a declining, uh, interest rate environment. Uh,
now we're in an era where inflation we expect to be higher, more volatile.
That can mean higher interest rates,
which is more of a headwind for long-term bonds.
So our focus is more on a portfolio that's split between, uh,
say 30% stocks, 30% more short-term, uh,
fixed income, uh, maturity is five years or less.
And then 30% in commodities.
The remaining 10 is more just trading opportunities, uh,
idiosyncratic opportunities that you find, uh,
that you want to put in your portfolio.
And we don't try to stick exactly to 30, 30, 30,
but the idea is that commodity piece we think is of increasing importance.
And in the high income strategy that Ted's run for 25 years of that
commodity piece, I'm just doing the math in my head.
We're over 30% uh, of, of that portfolio right now.
That's allocated across various companies, uh,
or metals in the commodity space.
Oh, okay. All right. Um, so, uh,
I'm going to imagine that again,
the capital that you're removing from the big trade, uh,
probably a good amount of that's going into the commodity space.
I want to know where you, you, uh, see opportunity there,
but I think the right path to take to that question is let's go to the precious
metals. Um,
cause I know that you guys have had a good outlook on the precious metals. Um,
you actually warned in your,
your piece that you guys put out just last week that the price action,
especially in silver was getting too hot for your comfort.
And as I've been saying on this channel, uh,
for a couple of weeks leading up to this as well, um,
as a huge general bull of the precious metals, um,
you know,
vertical price moves in any asset don't last forever and they tend to not
correct by going sideways. They tend to have a, you know,
fairly violent pullback. Um, obviously that's what just happened here.
So I guess question for you on the precious metals is,
is what is your current, um, thinking on them? Um,
and I'll let me cram a couple of questions and you can answer it any way you
like. Uh, we've had two big price blow off spikes, you know,
in the past 50 years with the precious metals,
this was the third big one. The first two, their corrections were brutal.
You pretty much gave up all the gains, um,
of the vertical move and the metals didn't really go anywhere for the next 10 to
15 plus years. Are we seeing, do you see something similar like that here,
or do you still remain bullish on them and think that after some period of
correction here, they could maybe even get back to new all-time highs.
We think that we're still bullish. So if you looked out,
we try to take a five-year view.
We're still bullish on precious metals for the next five years.
But the crescendo that you saw there in recent months,
it's pretty wild to say that silver after the decline that we just experienced,
uh, last Friday,
silver was still up 20% for the month of January and up 60% in the last three
months. So it kind of turned into a meme stock, started trading like Bitcoin.
Uh, that's, that's not the norm, uh, for that metal.
So you need things to kind of calm down a little bit.
We wouldn't expect much, uh, from that metal in the next several months,
but we still like it for the next handful of years.
I think what I pointed out in the video that we published when we had this,
just looking at the last 15 years,
when you had this sort of extreme interest and a ton of volume at right around a
peak for the silver price in 2011 and in 2021,
you had essentially a 40% decline in the price over the ensuing 18 months.
This was a lot more drastic where you just went down 30 or 40% in a day or two,
but it's still the same idea that you almost need something akin to a 50%
washout. Uh,
and then I think we would be more interested in building that position back up
and increasing our exposure to the miners again.
But over the course of the last few months, uh,
I would say our exposure to precious metals and the high income strategy, uh,
that's really trying to preserve purchasing power for our clients.
It got up to about 15% of the portfolio that was in gold,
silver and then miners related to those metals.
We had trimmed that back down to about 7% over the course of the last few months,
but really picked up the pace of the trims, uh, in the last few weeks,
just as we saw that behavior start to get extreme.
Okay. So, um, I guess just on the precious metals going forward,
are you kind of like, um, you're not adding, I think I just heard you say,
but are you kind of just, you trim down,
you kind of keeping what you had here and you're just going to wait for that to
show signs of life again. And whenever that, however long that takes weeks,
months, years, then you'll start increasing it again.
Yeah. So we're, we're keeping what we have. Uh,
we've got a couple of percent in gold, 1% in silver, uh,
a few percent across a few different miners that we've owned for years. Um,
so I think the way we view this is if we still like the longterm,
we did not want to sell everything because then it's very difficult
psychologically to know when to flip the switch and jump back in when you kind
of time that as difficult. So we wanted to keep some exposure. Uh,
but I think we're going to wait for things to calm down,
wait until we start seeing prices again.
We'd been saying for a good part of last year that we expected gold to correct
back down to 3,500 silver could easily correct back down to $50 an ounce.
Um, and maybe those, uh,
short to midterm lows that it makes off these highs are a little bit above those
levels. Maybe it's 4,000 for gold and $60 an ounce for silver,
but you've got further to go, uh, before we would think that, you know,
these are prices and valuations that we might want to start increasing our
exposure again.
Okay. All right. So, um, you are bullish on, uh,
commodities, precious metals, part of that complex. You're like, well,
you know, we're just going to let that cool for a while. Um,
where do you see the opportunity that attracts you enough to start moving more
capital in there?
We've been moving into energy for the last several months and you had a huge move
in energy from sort of the middle of 2020 up through the summer of 2022.
And then, uh,
hasn't done a whole lot in the last couple of years and it's become the most
hated sector again. Uh, and we actually see that as an opportunity. Uh,
and so we've been accumulating energy positions in both the high income
strategy and our, uh, long-term growth stock strategy, uh,
and specifically looking within oil field services, uh,
most recently where we think there could be a pickup in activity, uh,
both in offshore drilling and in certain parts of the world,
or maybe there'd been a little bit of a slowdown in drilling activity.
Okay. And when you say energy, do you mean the whole complex evenly,
or are you looking more at oil oil and gas?
Yeah, it's a good coal. Yeah, it's a good distinction. Uh, yeah.
So to be clear, crude oil and natural gas are the main focuses. Um,
we don't have anything right now with coal or with uranium. Um,
not that you can't play along those same themes with those two areas,
but at this time it's just been a focus on, on oil and that gas.
Okay. Um, I'm going to disclose something.
And so I just want to put a big disclaimer in front of it. Um, you know,
I generally don't like to, um, tell people exactly what I'm doing.
Not, not cause I'm not trying to be helpful.
I just don't want them to blindly copy what I'm doing. Um,
but, uh, I, I, I have disclosed this in the past that, uh,
Oxbow is one of the firms that I personally work with to manage part of my,
my personal, um, portfolio. Um,
and so folks I think highly of that says,
I think highly of Oxbow doesn't mean you need to rush out and become an Oxbow
client yourself. Although maybe that's something you might want to look into.
But I, I mentioned that, um, a, just to be transparent, but also, uh,
you were kind enough, uh, chance, uh, like a month or two ago, um,
because you're,
you're not the only guest I've had that has been starting to ring the bell on,
on the energy complex. And I've, I've told my audience here,
it's something that I'm personally beginning to invest more in. Um,
you're one of the people I reached out to, to say, Hey,
can you share with me some of the list of some of the stocks that you are watching
most closely right now? Um, and at a,
a week ago I was at the Vancouver resource investment conference and I had a
keynote there and I started the keynote by serving the dessert first. I said,
look,
I'm sure you're here to get a list of companies to go research everybody.
And I had just interviewed Rick rule as well about the oil and gas industry.
And I basically read them through a list of companies that Rick had mentioned and
that you had mentioned. And that, uh, uh,
I'd also gotten a similar list from David Hay. And I just sort of went through,
you know,
probably two dozen companies for folks who were interested in the space to go
research. So I mentioned that to say,
if someone's watching this and you're looking for, you know,
a list of oil and gas companies to research,
you may want to reach out to the folks at Oxbow and see if, um, you know,
if it's appropriate, if they might be willing to, to let you know,
which ones they're, they're watching most closely,
that list has done well for me so far chance.
Glad to hear it. Uh, and I think there's also, uh,
another point to make within energy. Uh, my,
my previous firm that I worked for early in my career,
the best analyst we had was our director of research,
who was also the specialist in the energy sector and all of his outperformance as
an analyst for our firm came from being overweight or underweight at the right
times in the sector relative to the index.
So as much as it's the right call to try and identify the correct companies on
quality businesses,
just being overweight this sector when nobody wants to own it.
And it's such a small percentage of the index that can generate a lot of return
for you, uh, just on its own.
And then if you're able to pick out a few big winners within that,
then it's just a little bit extra.
Okay. And you know, your, your, your partner, um, Ted Oakley, you know,
has always told me that the firm has made the most money coming out of
bear markets. Um, and I think that's a general comment,
like when the market falls into a bear market and nobody wants to touch a stock,
you know, if you're buying in then and you time it right, you know,
you ride the up cycle, you make a ton of money. Um,
but I think it's also true sector wise. And as you've said,
kind of oil and gas sectors been in a bear market now for a good number of
years. And I think you use the term,
it's been the most hated sector until recently. Right.
So it seems like you're trying to ride that same phenomenon here,
just in that specific sector, correct?
That's correct. And I think sometimes people might think that it's incredibly
complex variables that are being used,
but sometimes it's pretty simple where, uh,
if the comparisons that a company has to work against from the previous year
are really easy,
where it's going to make it look like their growth's accelerating and things
are improving, it can be just that simple where, uh,
they have a series of quarters where their year over year growth in a revenue
or cashflow accelerates. Uh,
that's all you need to start seeing some real outperformance.
And on the flip side, uh, when you've got businesses like, uh,
in the tech sector and the magnificent seven that were reporting huge increases
in revenue and earnings per share in 2023,
but now you're seeing those growth rates decelerate back towards the rest of the
S and P 500,
then it makes it more difficult for those stocks to outperform because they're
no longer such standouts.
And those difficult comparisons start to act as a headwind.
Right. Right. Um, all right. And then one other thing about, um,
the oil and gas sector, um, is, uh,
oftentimes when you're building a position in anticipation of an
upswing, um, or a secular change in, in, in a sector,
um, there's an opportunity cost to that capital, right? So if, if,
if the market is not moving, um,
you're not getting any return on that capital, basically, if you're, you're,
the sector you're putting your money or the stocks you're putting money in or
languishing, um, the oil and gas sector right now,
at least the larger companies there, uh,
they're still paying pretty attractive dividends here, right?
So one of the,
the pleasant differences in this sector is,
is you can get paid while you wait and that payment can largely cover your
opportunity cost of capital.
Yeah, absolutely. And I think that opportunity costs now,
if you're comparing it to whatever the short-term treasury rate is,
that funds rate, uh, and that appears to be continuing to come down slowly,
but steadily, um, uh, will be below 4%. Maybe it goes down to 3%.
If we're able to find a quality company where a business is stable to growing,
uh, that pays a dividend yield of above 4%, uh,
that starts to look more and more attractive in a environment with lower
short-term rates. Uh,
and that's something that we've been seeking out across a number of sectors, uh,
and you know,
something that's been working for us and we're going to continue to try to
identify those opportunities for the rest of the year.
Okay. And you know, just speaking of, of, of short-term rates, uh,
you know, the precious metals just got destroyed on Friday. Um,
the market sort of swooned and the narrative over the weekend was,
well,
the market didn't like the fact that Kevin Warsh was picked as the new fed
governor. And that's sort of why everything took it on the chin.
The day we're talking here, stocks are actually up a fair amount.
So it doesn't really seem that the worst factor was that big of a deal.
Um, they're probably just, we're looking for reasons for why, you know,
some assets like the precious metals just hit their dog whistle moment where all
of a sudden sellers outnumbered buyers.
But do you guys at Oxbow have any particular opinion on the selection of,
of Kevin Warsh as the new fed chair?
Ted and I haven't talked to him. I feel a little differently than I do,
but from what I've been reading,
and we read a lot of the same research sources, uh,
my takeaway is that it seems like he's going to be okay with lowering the fed
funds rate, which is in line with what president Trump wants.
But if you look at Warsh's history, especially when he was on the,
was a fed governor there from 2006, 2011, uh,
he's not a big fan of increasing the balance sheet at the fed. Uh,
and so he might try to use lower interest rates as a way to stimulate, uh,
things rather than increasing the balance sheet. Uh,
like what we saw with QE at various points in time over the last 15 years.
So less, less QE, but more interest rate cuts. Yeah. Yeah. Uh,
and I will say, you know, it's,
it's something that is very easy to say for anybody in any role,
uh, you know, whatever you're doing for work,
it's easy to be the person to the side,
assessing the person in that chair, uh,
as to what they would do in that situation.
But I would imagine somewhere in the next four years,
when Warsh is there as the fed chairman, uh, there is going to be an event,
whether it's like we have a 2023 with the banking crisis or 2020 with
COVID, uh, there's going to be something where his, uh,
saying that he's not going to increase the balance sheet at the fed is going to
be tested, uh, because in the past,
whoever's in that seat ends up having to do what it takes to try and keep
financial markets propped up. Uh, and maybe he'll do things differently,
but that would lead to more pain, uh, for risk assets. Uh,
if he just let things play out, however, the market decided. So, uh,
we'll see, um, a, the best example of that currently is, uh,
treasury secretary Besson, uh, was very clear that he wanted to stop, uh,
what Yellen was doing as the head of the treasury of issuing all these short
term treasury bills. He was going to start issuing longer term treasury notes.
Well, he got in there and it wasn't really possible.
And he's doing the exact same thing, issuing short term bills,
and just hoping that the longterm treasury yield comes down at some point in
the future. So we'll see what happens when he gets in there. Um, but yeah,
my take is lower rates, but maybe less activity on the balance sheet. Okay.
What is Oxbow's opinion on longer term rates? Um, you know,
as you just said,
the administration would love nothing more than to get them down, uh,
to reduce its borrowing, uh, costs there. Um,
and that's been pretty stubborn. So, um, you know,
we'll have a new fed chair that maybe we'll continue to try to hammer down the,
the, the lower end. Do you think the longer end will follow it down?
Or do you think we're just going to end up with this ever steepening yield curve
here?
It could, the long-term rates could come down in the short to intermediate term.
Um, but, uh, I think from our standpoint,
things change starting in 2020 where that seemed like a generational low.
You had a nearly 40 year run. Uh,
these interest rate moves tend to last three or four decades,
either moving steadily higher or steadily lower.
And we think since 2020 that you're now in a phase where this could go for a
long time where interest rates are slowly,
but steadily moving higher over time. Uh,
and that really doesn't make it appealing to try to own long-term treasury notes
or bonds, uh, unless you're trying to play some really short-term move.
And that's not really our style. Uh,
we'd rather try to take advantage of the volatility and the rising inflation
rate in other ways. Uh,
and that's also goes back to why we've been so much more focused on building out
commodity related positions,
because those tend to be the biggest beneficiaries of an era where the inflation
rate is rising, but also inflation is getting more volatile. Uh,
I'd seen this from 1995 to 2020,
there was a 25 year period where the core CPI was about 2%,
but more importantly, the standard deviation or the, uh,
the movement from year to year was only about half of 1%. It was very stable.
And so far in the 2020s,
we're at nearly a 4% average core CPI and the standard deviation is one and a
half points in either direction from year to year triple or quadruple the
volatility of what we'd all experienced there for a couple of decades.
So that makes it difficult to try and be a long-term treasury bond owner. Uh,
when you have that sort of environment as a backdrop.
Okay. Which explains in your 30, 30, 30, 10,
the 30 is bonds that are five years or, or, uh, shorter. Correct.
Correct. And really mostly two years or shorter, um, is,
has really been the focus. Yeah.
Okay. All right. So back to commodities, um, precious metals,
you're kind of leaving, leaving them lie. Uh,
definitely very excited about oil and gas. You're,
you're expanding your, um, exposure there.
Any other parts of the commodity complex right now that you are actively moving
capital into?
Yeah, it's not to the same extent, but, um,
buying miners or players, whether that's in, uh, iron ore, copper,
agriculture, um, things of that nature. So, I mean, not the,
the super soft commodities, uh,
but anything in sort of like the base metals area,
we've been trying to get some exposure to as well.
And one benefit of that is it's led us to some companies that are based
overseas, which, uh,
we think there's a increasing possibility that you might see more us dollar
weakness in the years to come relative to other currencies, uh,
similar to what we saw in the two thousands,
where you saw a little bit more outperformance by emerging markets and,
and international businesses. So adding, uh,
miners in Australia or Brazil, uh, places like that,
I think adds a little bit more diversity and an opportunity for our
performance. If a trend like that with the U S dollar continues.
All right. And I was actually just going to ask you about that. So, um,
uh, emerging, well, the rest of the world,
international stocks actually outperformed the S and P last year, uh,
and have continued to do well so far this year. Um,
the dollar has been weakening and, uh,
believe you showed this in your presentation from the other week.
It's actually just broken down through, um, a long-term, uh,
trend line, right? So it's sort of a breakout to the downside.
So true that you, you expect more dollar weakness, uh,
in the future versus other currencies.
Yeah, we would think so. And we're not betting the entire portfolio on it,
but it is something that we've made incremental decisions to have more things
in the portfolio that would benefit from that.
And that could be international businesses.
It could be more exposure to commodities where there's companies that are in
emerging markets or overseas that play more in the commodity space because it's
a bigger part of their economy.
And then sometimes it's just a business that has a lot of international
exposure. Um, so for instance, we've owned booking holdings, uh,
which is one of the big, uh,
online travel agency stocks for the last several years.
And people may not realize that their biggest market is Europe. Uh,
and so if you start seeing, uh,
increasing strength in the Euro relative to the U S dollar,
that's positive for their business results.
And so trying to find different unique ways to play that, um, you know,
across sectors and different themes.
Okay. All right. Um, okay.
Any other areas besides the ones that we've talked about that you guys are moving
capital into right now? Just want to make sure I'm not missing anything important.
Yeah. I think we're trying to just pick off things. It's,
it's been difficult to find things that are truly cheap.
And one thing that we've noticed, uh,
we track about 500 companies that meet our quality criteria, uh,
for the stock portfolio. And I would say about 60 of them right now,
which is surprising to have a number this high when the market's at record
highs, but about 60 of the 500, uh, look really cheap on the surface,
but I would consider them value traps because they're going through disruption
or, or some sort of real significant headwinds that it's been the right move to
just stay away, continue to watch and see if they ever stabilize. Uh,
but there are businesses like that,
that it's almost been as much about dodging those sorts of bullets and then try
to figure out, um, you know, where there's opportunities. So Ted,
for instance, has found two or three, uh,
pharmaceutical stocks that pay high dividend yields for the high income
strategy that, uh,
appear to have made a turnaround and they're not the most exciting businesses
like Bristol Myers Squibb or GSK or Pfizer,
but they've been going down for so long and then have stabilized, uh,
and appear to have good solid cash flows to pay a dividend yield and could be a
good way for us to be able to generate some additional return in that strategy,
but not be exposed to some of the key themes that could break down later this
year. If investors sentiment towards something like the AI trade turns negative.
Okay. All right. Um, well, let me ask you this.
So I've been asking you about where are you seeing opportunity and where are you
moving capital? Um, you know,
we've talked about a few things weakening us dollar. Um,
you're not a huge fan of, of, uh, long-term bonds or whatever.
Beyond those two things, are there,
are there any parts of the market where you're just feeling like there's a lot
of risk and we definitely want to stay away from that right now?
Yeah, I would say semiconductors and that memory and storage space. So, uh,
one screen or thing that we look for, it's a simple metric,
but just looking at what stocks are in the market that are the prices trading at
more than double the stocks, 200 day moving average,
which just tells you that things have gotten so extreme.
And the optimism is so high that it's been bid up to a level that's probably not
sustainable. And there's a turnaround and a decline coming. Uh,
and it was interesting because last week,
one of those areas was silver and silver miners,
and that's already started to recede.
So the one area left where you still see,
and it's even a sub-industry within semiconductors,
it's the semi-cap equipment makers like LAM Research and KLA,
which are very excellent businesses,
but I've really taken off and gone to levels that are kind of unforeseen for its
history. Um, and then the memory and storage players like, uh, Micron,
SanDisk, Western Digital, uh,
those are levels now that we would expect, uh,
some sort of a pullback just because the,
the optimism is such an extreme that, you know, it's not sustainable.
Okay. Um, thank you, uh, for not just answering it,
but giving such an actionable answer and mentioning, you know,
specific companies and the warning signs you look out for. Um,
last major question, uh,
is there anything else that's burning brightly on Oxbow's radar right now that I
just haven't thought to ask you about yet?
I think it's, it's a good example. I think just to tell people, you know, it's,
it's great to talk about the examples where things have worked out really,
really well and how to trim and manage that.
I think it's important for us to also point out, um,
we've been invested in a space in, uh,
software that we thought there'd be a bounce back going into the year and it's
just accelerated down and it's important to know how to manage positions that
aren't working as well. Um, so normally there's two or three positions a year
that just don't work out for whatever reason. If we take a 20% loss,
we have to decide whether we're going to double down and invest further for a
turnaround or more likely you just end up needing to just take it out of your
portfolio and walk away.
And we've looked at past examples like this where you have a 20% loser in your
portfolio. Uh, when we have sold it, uh, in the couple of years since then,
the average return is flat.
You're not missing out if you just kind of walk away and take a step back.
So this movement in software lately has caught a few of our positions that we've
ended up selling in January, uh, just cause it hit our stop loss limits.
But we consider that good risk management and we'll be able to reallocate
elsewhere. And it's just been a move that's been more extreme than we
anticipated. We do think there will be some winners from that space eventually,
but you need to see more stabilization in the share prices and a little bit of a
turnaround, uh, before you really want to move back in. On the flip side,
within the semiconductor move has gotten really extreme. Uh,
and we would expect that, you know, those have been the winners within tech.
We would expect that to turn around the other way.
So that's been the space within tech that we've been watching very closely
along with all the movement we've been trying to keep our eyes on within
precious metals.
All right. Um, I very much appreciate that answer.
And you do a really good job of demonstrating the discipline that I
try to tell people about. Um,
just one of the big benefits of working with a financial advisor, um, is,
you know, you guys have a framework, you have a set of rules,
which you use to kind of get all the emotion out of the trade, right. You know,
a lot of real regular retail investors,
they're in a trade that's not working the way they thought it's now down 20%.
You know, that's where you're starting, you know, you're bargaining with God,
right? Okay. Just please let it go back a little bit higher.
I promise I'll sell out if you get me back even right where you guys have just
learned over time, the discipline of, Hey, look,
if it's not working the way you need it to. And it's, it's, you know, and,
and importantly, it sounds like when you enter a position,
not only do you have expectations that say, okay,
if it starts failing to meet these expectations,
we want to think about selling it. But it sounds like you use the term stop loss,
but it sounds like you, you kind of have a price that says, Hey, look,
no matter what happens,
if it drops to this price in a relatively quick period of time,
it's a signal to us that something's wrong here and we need to pull the rip
cord.
Yeah, that's correct. So when we enter into a position,
we're buying at a price that we think the expected downside is less than 20%.
So we don't anticipate that to happen. Um,
and sometimes we'll leave ourselves some wiggle room or we'll buy half of the
ultimate position size we want.
So that if it does go down by 10 or 20% initially,
then we've got that room to double the position size.
And that's worked out well for us on a number of occasions.
But if we have a full position that we thought we bought in at a reasonable
price, and it still goes down 20% from our cost basis,
that tells us that there's just something we missed,
or it could have been something unexpected that happened in the company's
business that just bad luck,
but it's time to move on and reallocate somewhere else.
And usually you end up feeling relieved that you got out of the portfolio.
Cause I can give a number of examples where it just kept going down and it was
the right call not to just try to hang on.
Okay. All right. Well, Chance, thank you.
We're at the part of the conversation where I ask you, um, you know,
where can people go to, to follow you in your work? Um,
it's a little bit different in the case here of, of Oxbow,
cause I'm going to drive folks to a very specific URL if they want to talk to
you guys. But first, uh,
just give a quick reminder to folks of the type of clients that you serve. Um,
cause you are, I think I mentioned in the intro,
you're a high net worth advisory firm. Um, so you're, you're not for everybody,
but I know you try to help as many people as possible, but,
but if someone's watching this and they're like, Oh yeah,
I think I might like to learn a little bit more about Oxbow.
What's the type of client that fits well for who you're looking for?
Yeah, we, we work with high net worth individuals. Uh,
the original starting point of Oxbow was working with, uh,
founders and entrepreneurs after they sold their companies. Um, but you know,
we've, we've brought that out a bit more to just anyone who really is a fit with
our style of investing.
We know it's not for everybody to take more of a cautious approach that's more
focused on the downside and preventing a really significant losses.
But we seem to identify very well with a lot of people that like this approach
to investing and trying to maintain and grow purchasing power through an
investment cycle. Uh, so that's really who we try to click with most.
And typically we're,
we're looking for two to 5 million minimum to be able to manage our strategies
in the way that we think is the best way to run money.
All right. I appreciate that. I just wanted to get those,
those filters out or those thresholds out just because I don't want people to be
disappointed if they reach out and you tell them, Hey, sorry,
you're just too small for us to work for with. Uh, that being said though,
one thing that,
that Oxbow very commendably does is it publishes a lot of educational materials
that are available to everybody.
I know Ted has written a bunch of books and a lot of those,
I think you guys give out to people for free.
So technically if people want to get one of those free books,
if they don't have millions of dollars,
they can still reach out to you guys and get the books, correct?
Yeah. You can order the books for free off oxbowadvisors.com.
You fill out a form there and let us know which books you'd like to have shipped
to you. Uh, and then to your point about just sort of other content, you know,
we have our own YouTube channel.
If you search for us at Oxbow Advisors and we're usually putting something up
there several times a month just to give you a sense of what we're seeing and
what we think is most relevant.
All right. Um, okay. So with all that background out of the way, um, if,
if, uh,
you perhaps fit the criteria of a client of theirs and you're interested in
talking to the Oxbow folks about working with them, um,
go to thoughtfulmoney.com slash oxbow fill out the very
short form there. It should only take you a couple of seconds. Uh,
and then the Oxbow team will be in touch with you right away after you do that.
All right. And finally, one last thing and wrapping up, um,
the thoughtful money spring online conference, uh,
is now officially launched. Uh, it's going to be Saturday, March 21st.
Don't worry if you can't watch live on an actual date,
because everybody who buys a ticket will also be sent replay videos of the entire
event, all the presentations, all the live Q and a, uh, right after the event,
we're getting pretty good at sending those replay videos out just within a
couple of hours after the end of the event. Um, as usual, it is our,
it's the best faculty that we've ever assembled. Um,
we've got a Lacey Hunt starting off with as usual, a tremendous keynote.
We've got, uh, let's see Luke Groman. We've got Ed Dowd.
We've got Matt Taibbi. Uh, both Ed and Matt are new this year.
We've got, uh, uh, in addition to Luke Roman, we've got Brent Johnson.
We've got, uh, Mr. Liquidity, Michael Howell. We've got Darius Dale. Uh,
we've got Rick rule. We've got, uh, Andy Sheckman.
We've got, uh, Judy Shelton, Daniel D Martino booth, Grant Williams,
Stephanie Pombo. As you can see, this is just a list of like the greats of the
greats. Uh, I've got a male melody, right? Talking about housing. Uh,
I think we've got one or two more as well. I'm not remembering at the moment,
but you can get all the details, uh,
over at thoughtful money.com slash conference. And if you go there now,
you can buy your ticket at the early bird price,
which is the lowest price we're able to offer it at.
I want to make sure that everybody possible gets that lowest price.
So go there now and buy your ticket.
And if you are a premium subscriber to the thoughtful money sub stack,
you can get an additional $50 off of that early bird price to do that.
Just look at the email I've sent you.
It's got the discount code that you should use in their chance. Uh, as usual,
it's just a, it's always a wonderful time interviewing you.
You've got a steel trap mind. I ask you a question.
I get a very specific, concise answers. Uh, it's just a joy,
not to just interview you, but also work with you and your colleague in crime.
They're, um, Ted Oakley, as well as the entire team there at Oxbow.
I just very much appreciate it. Look forward to having you back on soon.
Yeah. And thanks so much for, for always having us on. It's always really 10.
I really look forward to these conversations with you.
All right. Well, thanks so much, buddy. Really appreciate it.
Hope to have you and Ted on again soon. Absolutely. Thanks. All right.
And everybody else. Thanks so much for watching.