YOUNG vs OLD Fishing Challenge River Wilder Catch Monster Pike Walleye
6 Video Views·Mar 29, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Comments are disabled for this video.
Join us on a fishing adventure that's out of your wildest dreams.
Welcome to the Best Fisherman Ever Challenge.
Where elite fishermen, Dad, Papa, River, and of course me, Wilder, are headed deep into the Canadian wilderness.
To spend a week fishing, morning.
He's alive.
I got a trophy, bye!
So he's having a nice little nap.
And none.
The competition is intense.
This is the fish cleaning competition.
And the stakes are high.
What the heck is this?
As we go to extremes.
Whoa.
To find out who is the best fisherman ever.
We have to go where the fish are.
So, we're catching a float plane.
I got to go in the front.
Our adventure begins so far north.
That there are no roads.
So we're flying in to Esnagami Lake.
We are here.
Welcome to Esnagami Wilderness Lodge.
And our host, Dean.
We're so excited to have the boys here for the Best Fisherman Ever Challenge.
Time to get off the plane.
We'll spend our nights in a private cabin.
Hi!
And we'll be taking our meals at the main lodge.
But most importantly, we'll be gearing up and spending six full days out on the lake fishing.
We're up!
This competition has four fearsome competitors.
First we have Wilder, a.k.a. Skookie.
He uses his giant eyelashes to charm the fish.
And he was the winner of the Bro vs. Bro episode.
Then we have River, also known as The Moose.
The YouTube short of his Esnagami Giant has over 24 million views.
Then there's Dad, also known as Captain Know-It-All.
He's probably caught more trophies than anyone in the group.
I've been fishing at Esnagami Lake for 25 years.
Sorry to interrupt your bragging, Dad, but River has a fish on.
I got one!
Papa's netting the fish, and River is on the board.
Numero uno!
This beauty is a northern pike, and at 27 inches, it is just shy of the 30 needed for a trophy.
Points for me!
And there he goes.
Okay folks, it looks like we have some points on the board.
And finally we have Papa, a.k.a. Sir Snags-A-Lot.
How many snags has Papa got?
One!
That's not really a snag.
But he does have the largest fish ever caught in the family.
A 42-inch pike caught right here at Esnagami Lodge.
Bring it on, you whippersnappers!
So let the games begin. I can't wait to see who comes out on top.
Papa, you got one?
Okay, you want to flop him back?
This is a great spot. I've got one, and Papa has one.
Bonus points for farthest cast. I think I can hit their boat.
Ouch! That is one nasty bird's nest. That's going to cost Wilder some points.
Bird! I'm going to monster!
Nice! Wilder has bounced right back.
I'm on the board!
About 26 inches. Not bad.
We want to make sure he swims another day.
Yes! Let's go! Fish on five!
So, me and Papa caught two fish, and Wilder caught one fish, so I think it's time to move spots.
Everyone has a fish but me, but I've got to fly the drone and work the camera, so that's my excuse.
Yeah, yeah. Excuses, excuses. All you have to do is press a button.
Esnagami is a massive lake, so the boys will be moving around a lot.
This is what I'm dealing with in my boat.
What's the matter, Spooky?
We have one wasp somewhere in the boat, and it's Panic City.
Oh, it's right here by me.
Okay, it's windy, but Papa and I are making a go of it.
My fish are much bigger than Dad's.
Another catch and release for me.
More points.
River has an early lead, but I think Dad is about to close the gap.
Look at that boy!
This beauty is a walleye, and they are great eating.
In the boat, in the boat!
We like to fish barbless so that the hooks come out quick.
Yes, Wilder and Dad are absolutely on fire.
All these guys are good practice. You'll see later in the video, I will catch a big one.
I had a good one on, but it scraped itself off on the bottom of the boat.
The answer, in case you're wondering, is I am leading. Captain know-it-all.
Oh, wouldn't you look at that. Dad has me driving when we're going into the wind.
Oh yeah, I got one.
Oh, good one!
Mom, we're going to hit shore.
17 inches are the perfect size for taking a walleye.
Yes sir, first catch at this new spot. Got a fish.
Small and slippery, but it's a fish. Let's let him go.
Another keeper, I think. Let's see.
17! I have nine.
I know I have more than him, whatever that is.
18-inch walleye. Let's let him go.
Dad's catch.
17.
It's like the fifth fish in the bottom of the boat.
That is my little guy, but it counts.
We are definitely winning this challenge.
Dinner for me!
That's a lot of rain! Go faster!
I can't! Dad started to get in the rain here, but now he's way behind us.
River and Popper are out in that storm. We're headed into the sun.
This is it, rainy!
Okay, so Dad has a commanding lead. But keep in mind, this is only day one.
To be the best fisherman ever, you have to know how to clean fish.
So I'm going to get some tips from the pros before the competition.
Now folks, if you come to Esnagemi, you don't actually have to clean your own fish.
They will clean them, bring them to the lodge, and cook them for you any way you like.
I found a rabbit. That has to count for bonus points, right?
Dad has fallen asleep on the couch, so we're going walleye fishing without him.
With Captain Nodal down for the count, me, River, and Popper are sneaking out onto the lake
for what is sure to be some Esnagemi walleye magic.
Look at that sunset.
I got a fish!
Oh, this guy's a big guy.
While Dad's asleep, we're trying to rack up as many points as we can.
Esnagemi leaf!
That is a teeny weeny little fish, but it counts. One point.
Fish number two!
Hey, little guy!
Popper just caught a fish, and I thought it was really small, but it turns out he was using his pike rod.
Oh, Popper got another one!
Popper was just waiting until the evening, because now he's catching back-to-back-to-back fish.
And meanwhile, back at the cabin.
I made a friend, so I get bonus points.
Didn't hurt, but I was a little startled.
Yeah! Fish number three!
Oh, this guy's a fighter.
Number three walleye for the night.
Watch this. A triple header.
Oh, yes, sir. Popper got one.
Oh, I got one, too!
All three of us!
Here we go!
Look at all those fish!
Okay, that is an epic conclusion to day one. I'll see you tomorrow.
Okay, so Dad's power nap has really cost him, as Popper and the boys are now hot on his tail.
It's a new day, so it's time to grab a killer breakfast at the lodge and then get back out there.
Father, what would you like for breakfast?
Please have a one-egg-everything omelette, one piece of French toast, one piece of white bread, one chocolate pancake, with some extra hot chocolate on the side, please.
Yeah, we can do that, sure.
Last, as always, to leave the cabin, because I have all the important stuff.
I have food, drink, clothes, dry clothes, sunglasses, suntan. Oh, my gosh, too much stuff.
But we are ready for an awesome day of fishing. We're going to the far side of the lake, Monster Pike.
Here we come.
We're mostly going for pike this morning, but hopefully we'll catch a few walleyes by accident, and that will set us up well for the fish cleaning challenge.
It's the fishing cleaning challenge!
Okay, I think Dad's in first place, so one of us needs to catch a big one.
River's trying to steal our fish, so let's steal theirs.
Fish wars are on.
Twenty-six to start the day. I will take it.
Captain Know-It-All is on the board for the day.
That's Dad for two.
Hey, Papa and River, I've already caught two fish. Would you like some advice?
Yep, he's going down.
All right, three fish in the bag already this morning. I am definitely in the lead.
I hate to say it, but Dad is right. He is our leader.
Father's going to feed me a jellybean.
Oh, look, some actual fishing.
Finally, I got one!
Yay, River!
I'm sure that it's Dad's lure because he's caught two in a row, so I think it's time to switch lures because he's such a nice person.
Bring him over, bring him over.
Oh, I can't, he's pulling.
Woo-hoo!
Yeah!
Twenty-eight. Chunky, too.
Beauty.
Twenty-eight, and so close to that 30-inch trophy.
Hey, Skookie, I just caught the biggest fish of the day on your lure, buddy.
That's nice.
Everyone's caught a fish so far except Skookie. It's time to talk about one of the P's of our family's fishing motto, Perseverance.
Perseverance means never giving up. Yay!
Got one!
Get the net!
Skookie is on the board!
Perseverance!
Papa always fishes with the most ridiculously oversized lures. Spoiler, this will come up later.
Ladies and gentlemen, this just in, we have our first trophy pike.
Okay, River, what do you have there?
I got a trophy pike!
Wow, look at that.
How big is it?
Look at this guy, this guy's 35.
35 inches is indeed a trophy and the biggest fish of the competition so far.
We catch the big ones, not the small little ones. But that's a lot more points than Dad has now.
I'm in the lead now!
River now has the biggest fish in the tournament. That's got to be a lot of points.
And with that fish, River has catapulted into the lead.
Bonus points for spotting a baby lure.
Part of being a master fisherman is how you help the people around you catch fish.
And Skookie is the most reliable, incredible netman.
Yeah! Super netman, Skookie!
He is just as excited about your fish as you are. And I think that deserves some mega bonus points.
Okay, we got fish number one for the fillet contest. We need three more.
I'm going to bring it in the other side.
In the boat, in the boat!
That's a trophy.
He is 30.
30 exactly.
And just like that, Dad is on the board with a trophy also.
I got my trophy. Wilder's next, buddy.
Oh, sorry Wilder, but this is another trophy for Dad.
In the boat, in the boat!
Oh my gosh, that almost pulled Skookie in.
Oh, he's another 30 right on the nose.
Nice.
Nice. That looks like another trophy for Dad.
With that, Dad has closed the gap and is back on top.
Hold on, folks. River has another trophy.
Wow, look at that, River.
A beautiful 32.
Wow, look at that.
Great work. River's second trophy is an absolute unit of a fish.
Gorgeous.
Okay, let's let him go.
Splash me, splash me.
Slimy.
Trophy number two.
Now that I've caught two trophies, I'm definitely in first place.
That's right, River. First place.
Papa taught me everything I know.
My secret to catching trophies is just to kick back, relax, eat a cookie, and have fun.
You getting frustrated, buddy?
Wilder has the tired teddies.
How have I not caught a fish?
Wilder has a bad case of tired teddies, so we popped into Papa's Sugar Shop.
Papa's Sugar Shop.
A few moments later.
This place is incredible.
I literally have been jigging for two minutes outside of the weed bed, and look at that beauty.
Fish cleaning challenge is on.
Okay, ladies and gentlemen, it's time for the fish cleaning challenge.
This is the fish cleaning competition.
We are going to clean the fish and then present it to Papa, but he won't know whose is whose,
because he will definitely give favoritism to his Captain Admitment.
I don't know what you're talking about.
You boys ready?
Oh my gosh, get started already.
Let's go.
How do you do this again?
That is not a good sign.
How's it going, River?
You guys almost done over here?
I forgot how to do this.
We want to honor the fish we caught, and we want to do the best job possible.
This is not cooking.
I missed like half of the meat.
This is the final product the boys are aiming for.
I'm doing a really hard double fillet, but you keep the fillet connected until you get one in here.
How's it going, boys?
You might taste some bones.
I took out both sets of bones, including the set of bones you can eat.
Dad's fillets look pretty good.
I'm happy I gave some respect to the fish.
Inspection time.
Well, look at these fillets.
No bones.
A rookie, but you know, the rookie's tried his best.
He got a nice six.
This one here does look the nicest.
The lettuce dads, obviously.
This one has lost a lot of meat.
And this one is totally clean.
A tie for second.
I tied for second place.
Dad is cleaning up here, folks, literally.
And he has taken a commanding first place lead.
All right, good fun was had by all.
So now it's time to eat.
Everything we need to cook a good short lunch is in here.
Fish batter.
All of the spices.
We got the beans.
Plates.
Very thick, very heavy pans.
Make little home fries.
It only took two matches.
Not bad, not bad.
Only ten more to go.
The potatoes are underweight.
So now it's time to fish.
Okay, fish is ready.
Grab a plate.
We'll let Papa, our judge, go first.
Thank you very much.
That's excellent.
The pigeon is hot.
Oh, my God.
Uh-oh.
Papa's got the snorlaxes again.
Thankfully, I have our new book, Life Hacks for Kids.
It's 276 pages of hilarious short stories for kids.
I'm reading the chapter on how to catch a bigger fish than your dad.
Get your copy today at Amazon.com.
You can't call yourself a master fisherman if you can't start a motor.
This one's very cool.
Uh-oh.
All it takes is a big jerk.
It was a tough day yesterday, but today is my day.
Today is cooking our gorshkin.
And we are here.
I get bonus points for going first
and taking out all the spiderwebs with my face.
I do have a slight concern of bears.
This is perseverance if I've ever seen it.
Ah!
Normally, we have to bail the boat out,
but Skookie, because he's using his persnickety,
has figured out the boat's so high,
he can just pull the plug.
There's a ton of pike in there,
and there's a few monsters.
Ew.
Oh, yeah, those are some serious fart bubbles.
They're called fart water
because all the dead stuff dies and then ferments.
Then when you agitate it,
the fart bubbles come out.
No!
Okay, out to Betty Lake
to catch Wilder his trophy.
There's a giant hump out there in the center
that goes to about a foot deep.
We're just going to stay off the deeper side of that
in about five or six feet of water.
We didn't film every fish,
but trust me, I was racking them up.
Go bring me your big brother.
Another one for Dad.
Oh, yeah, easy barbless.
I caught about four walleyes in a row on that one drift.
We just hit a school.
Bang, bang, bang, bang.
That's the way it goes up here.
The fish are very angry.
They broke my favorite lure.
A good fisherman knows
when their batteries need a recharge.
Now, let's go to the big lake
where River and Papa are reeling them in.
Oh, yeah, Papa.
Pike number three.
Look at that.
This is awesome.
Papa just had one on,
and now I got one.
Okay, look at that one, eh?
Woo-hoo!
That is awesome.
You can literally see the pike.
Okay, I think the lens on the GoPro
is broken,
but trust me,
there are shadows lurking down there.
And at almost exactly the same time,
while I was sleeping,
Dad stole my monster pike.
We got a big one on.
I haven't even seen him.
Are you ready?
Get him in.
Yes, he's out, he's out, he's out.
He's off the hook.
Woo-hoo!
And wow, that is yet another trophy for Dad.
That's the game we launched, baby.
Woo-hoo!
Slimy high five.
Oh, wait, River's got one, too.
Look at this fish.
Oh, my.
I think you're taking a lesson from Papa.
That is a big monster.
That is a huge fish.
That guy is a 36.
36.
Woo-hoo!
He's too happy.
Okay, let's get him in the water.
Let's get him in the water, yeah.
Woo-hoo!
High five.
The day closes with Dad in the lead,
and River hot on his tail.
Amazing place.
We climbed over a beaver dam
and switched to a canoe
because we're headed upstream.
It is beautiful back here.
It's like we've stepped back in time
a thousand years.
My son is a Nintendo Switch expert.
Let's see if he can figure out the word.
Cheekers.
We have a motor,
but the real motor is my dad.
Yeah!
Okay, we've hit our first beaver dam.
Who's getting out?
I nominate the guy with the sandals.
Oh, gross.
I'm not actually touching the bottom.
We've made it back to Wonderland,
which are a series of spring-fed lakes
that are an amazing emerald green color.
But to get to the good spot,
we have to drag our boat through all this.
River's going to do all the hard work.
There's a leech.
Here's the leech.
Uh, yeah, yeah.
Pretty nasty.
Ugh!
That did not go well.
Oh, yeah.
It's a nice-looking shoe, buddy.
Did you actually think you could make that?
Part of my brain thought I could.
I can't get purchase.
When I step, my foot just sinks.
I'd like to thank my sponsor, Dad,
for pulling the boat through the gluck
so I can catch a brook trout.
Okay, we made it.
Look at how clear it is.
You can see down like 30 feet.
Brook trout are super rare.
If I can catch one, that's mega bonus points for me.
We're looking down in the water
and we see this giant brook trout.
And I think you can guess what happened next.
Get him in the net! Get him in the net!
My dad caught it.
Get him in! Bring him in!
Woo-hoo! Woo-hoo-hoo-hoo-hoo!
Oh, my gosh!
That is a monster brookie.
Whoa, he is a monster.
That is certifiably a big brookie.
He's ready to go.
And that fish puts Dad in an even more commanding lead.
Mwah, mwah, mwah, mwah, mwah.
Thank you to my son for suggesting we come back here.
Remember, kids,
always wear suntan lotion.
Yikes.
Ow, that's hot.
Let's go!
First fish of the day.
Oh, yeah. We found the spot this morning.
We've been here for two minutes.
We caught two.
Oh, they're nice, too.
Yeah.
Wilder's got another one.
That's three.
In between fish, I take the time to learn kid slang.
Sigma.
That's good.
That's double good.
Cheeks, which is kind of bad.
Cheekers, which is very bad.
Bro.
That could be a good thing like bro,
or a bad thing like bro.
Little guy.
Cookies, crushing it.
Yeah.
Wilder wants to go pike fishing,
and I said, as soon as we go ten minutes
without catching a walleye,
we can leave.
But we keep catching walleyes,
so we're not leaving.
We gotta do our part for shore lunch.
Now, I caught way more fish than Dad,
but as always,
Dad had to steal the biggest fish from me.
It's my job to make sure the boys
respect their elders,
so I always catch the biggest fish.
One of the highlights here at Esagami
is our group shore lunch.
This is a weekly shore lunch
that we do with our clients and staff.
It's something that you're going to have
in your life, and it's a highlight
of the client's week.
Shore lunch is the best.
Dad would like me to remind you
that he is in first place.
Wilder just gets bonus points.
He just got a minnow with his bare hands.
I got a minnow too.
I like fishing with Dad,
but he steals a big fish.
Trout Bay is massive,
and the walleyes could be anywhere,
so we are fishing with two boats.
We have walkie-talkies,
so after Wilder and I have caught our fill,
we can let Papa and River
come give it a try.
What about the other way around?
Sure, or they could catch them first,
and then we will go follow them.
A little too much bragging netted Dad
a slimy piece of karma.
Oh, we got a decent one.
What the heck is this?
That's all, that's all.
Get the net, get the net.
This is one of the really rare ones.
This is a burbot.
Okay, this is a burbot?
Yes, that is a burbot.
It's basically a big slimy tube of a fish.
Oh, bonus points,
but I thought that was a trophy walleye.
All right, it's time for those boys
to start playing catch up.
Okay, I'm on the board.
Hey, me and Papa are on the board too.
Look at that fish right there,
21 inches,
the size of his head.
Look at that.
Got him.
But for every fish we catch,
Dad catches a bigger one.
All right, that is an Estagami beauty right there.
21 inch walleye, awesome.
We're going to let him go now.
It's a beast.
21 and a half.
Bigger than Dad's.
Getting closer to my trophy.
Hey River, Wilder wants a reminder
of how big your fish was
because he just caught one that was 21 and a half.
Yeah, mine was 20, over here.
20, okay, so his was bigger.
Yeah.
I feel like they're trying to catch it.
Our success has attracted
some other fishermen.
Yeah!
Dinner tonight.
Papa, we're out of snacks.
Can we borrow some of your snacks?
Of course you can.
Papa always has snacks.
Earlier this afternoon,
we caught three big walleyes in Trout Bay.
So we're headed back
to see if we can get Wilder his trophy.
If you want to know
if someone caught a lot of fish,
just ask to see their hands.
Cut, cut, cut,
cut, cut, cut,
cut, cut.
Mine's like that.
Bit of a tradition in our family,
I have some celebration cookies,
not sponsored,
and I'm going to celebrate
because I just caught a fish.
I am going to catch a fish
and get one of my cookies.
Do, do, do, do,
I get my celebration cookies.
Do, do, do, do,
I got a feeling,
do, do, do, do,
I'm gonna get my celebration cookies.
That is a beaut right there.
They don't get much nicer than that.
I feel the celebration cookie
running through my veins.
19 and a half.
Put that one on the stringer.
Sweet victory.
Fishing is getting pretty good,
so I think it's every man
for themself at this point.
Over here.
25.
Oh, yeah.
A trophy walleye.
Look at the size of that beast.
At 25 inches,
that is indeed a trophy walleye.
Great job, Dad.
Thank you, Essendon Gammy Lodge,
for this absolute monster.
I'm confused on how Dad
always catches a big one.
We're using the exact same thing
and doing the exact same thing.
Though there's some great fish
on the stringer,
it is just beautiful out here.
I think the size of the fish
doesn't matter so much.
It doesn't matter.
I have to stand about with this can.
This is an actual fish this time.
Wake it. Tip up.
It's an actual fish this time.
That is so mean.
Another awesome night
on Essendon Gammy Lake.
Once again, it was an amazing night,
but sadly, again,
Dad had to catch
the biggest and the most fish,
so tomorrow is my day!
Okay, folks,
Dad has a commanding lead here,
and I'm sad to say it,
but it's the last day of the competition.
Why are you guys eating in the cabin?
Because Dad and Papa were nice enough
to let us sleep in
and bring us our breakfast.
I am exhausted,
but the challenge goes on,
so I will get out fishing today.
I like fishing with Dad,
but I hope Papa wins
because he's less likely
to steal the monster fish from me.
It's cherry on top
if Wilder gets a trophy pike.
So we're taking him somewhere secret.
Shh!
It's so secret,
we're having trouble finding the entrance.
I knew where the entrance was,
but Dad said,
oh, I'll go over there.
Wilder and I are at the secret spot.
Papa and River want our bait.
Bonus points for me.
Thanks, Dad.
You're the best.
I made him say that.
Maybe to catch my trophy,
we need a little bit of magic,
so me and Dad are headed back
to a magical little lake.
Going to go
to secret lakes.
There's a giant fish
that comes at the end of all this hard work.
Hopefully.
Skookie is just pushing us out
into this little gem of a lake.
It is blazing hot back here,
and by all fisherman logic,
we should not catch a thing,
but this place is magic.
Wilder, I challenge you
to reach the shore with the cast.
Extra triple bonus points.
Oh, yuck.
That counts.
I caught a fish, guys.
You're literally 15 feet in the trees.
Now catch a fish with that.
From tree to trophy.
Oh, actually, I got one.
Pull me.
Get the net.
Tip up, tip up.
Oh, my gosh.
What the heck?
From tree top to tree bottom.
All right, Wilder just caught another one.
They are here.
We just need to get a trophy.
There we go.
Oh, he's good, he's good.
He's good.
He's fighting.
Yeah.
How big is he, Skookie?
He is 34.
Boom.
At 34 inches,
that is a verifiable trophy pike.
And away he goes.
Yes.
My trophy.
Yeah.
Trophy.
Bonus points for us.
Oh, that is cold.
So the Best Fisherman Ever Challenge,
it's got to be about the type of person you are.
And really, at the end of the day,
who wants you in their boat?
In our family,
the kids want to fish with Papa the most.
And with that,
let's go to the last fish of the competition.
Oh!
Oh, my God!
Well, boys, that's how you do it.
30...
37.
Sea Wilder, Sea River,
that is what you call a fish.
Wow, what a monster.
Papa has absolutely caught
the biggest fish of the week.
Woo-hoo!
Papa, high five.
High five.
High five for Papa.
I nominate Papa to be
the Best Fisherman Ever
because I love hearing his stories
about wilder fishing.
So I've watched all the footage
and this is just too close to call.
Everyone has caught so many fish.
River has multiple trophies
and he's such a great fisherman.
And Wilder has so much heart
and pulled out his trophy on the last day.
So, I'm going to choose
his grandpa.
Yeah!
Hey, folks, if you haven't subscribed,
please do so now.
And don't forget to pick up
your copy of Life Hacks for Kids
on sale at Amazon.com.

