COMBATING EMERGING THREATS IN TRANSNATIONAL ORGANIZED CRIME AFFECTING (...)-Mr Joseph Humire

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 28, 2026
24th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, Panama🇵🇦- February 23 – 24, 2023
Topic: COMBATING EMERGING THREATS IN TRANSNATIONAL ORGANIZED CRIME AFFECTING THE
CARIBBEAN AND THE AMERICAS
-Mr. Joseph Humire
Executive Director, Center for a Secure Free Society
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning, how are everyone?
I know the lunch is almost ready.
I promise you I won't bore them.
Look, first of all, I cannot begin without thanking my
Dear friend, Congressman Robert Pittenger.
I have participated in several of these forums.
Many of you have already had the chance to meet them, if not in 2021,
when we were right here at the Latin Strike in Panama,
or other forums, in Argentina, in Guatemala, in Hungary,
in Romania.
Many of you I can call friends thanks to the
Congressman Pittenger's efforts.
I also want to thank a very special man.
I believe this forum would not have been possible without your support.
without our dear friend Alejo Campos and everything they are
doing it through Crime Stoppers.
It is truly an innovation in the world,
in the fight against organized crime.
So thank you for everything you do, Alejo.
Look, before I start mixing things up and making mistakes in my Spanish,
And I know I have a Bolivian face.
My parents are from Bolivia, but I was born in the United States.
So, I have a Spanish that's in a boligringo style.
So, before I start making mistakes,
I am going to change to English.
And I'm sorry for those who have to use the translation,
but this is the moment they have to possess because I'm going
to change to English
So I'm going to give my presentation in English.
And I think, from what Celina was saying,
I'm going to try basically taking over the conversation a bit
toward the strategic level.
Transnational organized crime is
often thought of as a transactional issue.
It is considered a problem that is primarily about
in the realm of justice, but also, obviously,
In many cases, it is also the army.
But I believe that in today's global security environment,
And Celina was touching on many of these points,
like other speakers over the past day and a half,
We are beginning to see transnational organized crime
being operationalized in ways we never thought possible
as unimaginable in past years.
Part of that is due to technology,
but most of that is due to new methods of warfare
What are, in reality, ancient forms of warfare?
that are being used by adversarial states.
But let me begin by giving you, I believe, a key question
to encapsulate much of what we have been
discussing over the past two days.
And this is a question I ask many individuals.
much like yourselves, parliamentarians,
politicians, ministers, officials of the FLAGRA
Yes, what makes an illicit activity illegal?
I say it in Spanish as well,
What makes an activity illegal?
So, when you start to think about it,
I'm sorry, I'm going to speak in English,
when you start to think
what makes an illicit activity illicit
The number one answer I get is the law.
But then you enter a hole where it's unclear what makes the law the law.
And it's not really the answer I'm looking for.
The answer to what makes an illicit activity illicit
It is on the map.
They are the borders.
Because more than lines on a map,
Borders do not only provide a legal framework
from one country to another
but rather provide an identity
of a national state
what manages their culture.
And thus, when we speak of transnational organized crime,
The operative word there is transnational.
Tends to hurt across borders
and along the length,
to begin changing the culture of multiple societies.
So let me take you to, perhaps,
on the most dangerous border
in the Western Hemisphere.
Here, in the United States,
in particular in Washington,
We have many conversations about border security.
due to the crisis that is taking place
on the southern border of the United States.
It often reminds me of my experts and politicians.
in Washington
what we are experiencing at the southern border of the United States
It is an extension, if not a symptom,
the multiple border crisis
what we are facing throughout Latin America.
So let me take you to what I would describe
probably the most dangerous border
in the Western Hemisphere.
And that is the border between Colombia and Venezuela.
So, for some context,
I am sure that many of you in the audience
You already know, but just for a bit of context.
Venezuela is the most severe humanitarian crisis
what we have seen in the history of Latin America.
We have never had a humanitarian crisis in the region.
natural disasters
We haven't even had wars,
but we have never seen anything of such magnitude
about what is happening today in Venezuela.
It has catalyzed
the largest migrant and refugee flows in the world,
surpassing Syria last year,
It is larger than Ukraine.
Two活得的战区。
We are talking about approximately 7.2 million Venezuelans
who have left that country since 2014.
Approximately 10% of its population
He is no longer in Venezuela.
It is hidden throughout Latin America and the world.
So when I went to visit the border between Colombia and Venezuela,
I have visited many parts of the border.
I started seeing a lot of what everyone has seen on the news,
What is a humanitarian crisis?
Obviously, I saw the massive migration.
I also saw the conflict between the illicit actors,
primarily transnational criminal organizations,
most notably the dissidences of the FARC and the ELN.
In fact, in April 2021,
This truly reached a calm.
when these different transnational criminal groups
They began fighting against each other.
to gain territorial control
on drug trafficking transshipments.
It became very violent and very delicate.
In fact, that is a photo of me at the Arauca River.
The Arauca River is the river located on the border.
from the province of Arauca in Colombia
and in the state of Apure in Venezuela.
In fact, we had to cancel that patrol.
I was accompanying the Colombian sailors.
why did they find a dead body
hidden underwater, sealed with explosives.
This is a daily occurrence
about what is happening on the Colombian-Venezuelan border.
But what I actually saw,
And I was able to visit this two or three times
In recent years,
My last visit was in April 2022.
And what I truly saw
when I went to the Colombian-Venezuelan border
It was that I saw Russian radar systems,
the mobile radar P-18 in particular,
succumbing to communications
of the Colombian army.
Iranian surveillance drones
carrying out survival at a low level
over Colombian airspace.
Our Chinese satellites
being managed through a PLA satellite radar installation
at a military base in the center of Venezuela.
What I saw was a great struggle for power.
manifesting within a warm bed
transnational organized crimes
on the Colombian-Venezuelan border.
What may seem
commit random acts of violence
spontaneous outbreaks of conflict,
a series of illicit activities,
what could just be very random occurrences,
You can start to see a process
in which the humanitarian crisis
leads to mass migration,
leads to conflicts among illicit actors,
what leads to a great power struggle
in your border.
When it reaches that point,
when your border reaches that point
in the ability of border security officers,
whether military or police
responsible for protecting
your state of sovereignty,
You begin to lose your boundary
And as you do so, you begin to go mad.
your democracy.
This is deliberate,
It's not by accident,
It's by design.
Now let me move on to a case study
what I want to present to you.
I think this is an actor who has not been
an actor of threat who has not been mentioned
up to this point
but I think, being here in Latin America,
It takes great courage to mention it.
Another border that is often heard about
when talking about boundary value problems
in the Western Hemisphere
It is the border court area.
in the southern part of South America.
This is the intersection of Brazil,
Argentina and Paraguay.
And, unfortunately,
It is a very good area.
as a tourist destination with Iguazú Falls,
but, unfortunately,
It is also commonly heard
about the presence of a barrage
transnational criminal organizations,
among them, Hezbollah.
In the United States,
and I believe in the world,
We recognize Hezbollah for many things.
They are a political faction in Lebanon.
They also have a midstation in Lebanon.
It is also recognized
as a foreign terrorist organization
in over 60 countries worldwide,
including the United States since 1997
and since 2019
at least five countries in Latin America
But Hezbollah has also been seen
as a transnational criminal organization.
In fact, in 2018,
The Department of Justice published a list
of what was considered at that moment
the five transnational criminal organizations
in the world
Now, some of the people who were expected,
some of the groups expected
They were on that list,
like Mexican drug trafficking organizations,
the famous bargain or super-bargain
from El Salvador, MS-13
He was also on that list.
But Hezbollah also appeared on that list.
why Hezbollah,
beyond his work
and about what they have done within Lebanon
and beyond their terrorist actions
what they have done around the world,
including in Latin America in the 1990s
They are also very involved.
in drug trafficking and in theft of money.
In fact, a colleague of mine in Washington
Once he called it
The Federal Express or the Western Union
for large drug trafficking billboards
In Latin America
because they have a large network of banks
that extends throughout the world.
When we go to the tributary zone,
What we see is a model
which is now being replicated
in other parts of the region.
What we see is a model.
where there are three different cities
with three different languages
using three different coins,
but in a very narrow geographical space.
And what we see is the ability
of using the corresponding corporate records.
So, you have corporate records in a city,
Another company is being built in the other city,
in a different jurisdiction,
but it has a corresponding corporate record.
We see multiple nationalities,
often dual nationalities,
The same individual with multiple passports.
And we see a free exchange zone.
When you combine those three things,
and neither of them is bad in itself,
but when you combine those three things,
They can be exploited by illicit actors.
And this is how Hezbollah has been able to
to create a money laundering scheme
in the free exchange zone.
That has shifted to other parts of Latin America,
most notably Venezuela.
That is an image of a 2020 report.
what I wrote for the Atlantic Consul
and the Think Tank in Washington, D.C.,
where did we put the data
on how Hezbollah operates in Venezuela.
Now, the most interesting thing here is,
Some of those individuals seen in the slide,
Are they Hezbollah or not?
So it has been a great discussion
within the intelligence community
Unfortunately, Hezbollah does not handle business letters.
so it's hard to tell
Who exactly is an operational member of Hezbollah?
But what we know
They are prominent members of their communities.
and there are individuals who are supporters
yes, and supporters of Hezbollah.
That is, the term we are using now
the Hezbollah support networks or Hezbollah sympathizers.
And what we have seen is that in Venezuela,
They have begun targeting certain industries
and get involved in money laundering based on solid businesses.
But there is one aspect of this that needs to be added.
why the tribal frontier that we see
among these three cities in South America
It extends throughout Central America through here.
The new maritime tribal frontier,
It is not a physical tribal border,
It is a tribal border of water,
it is located between the city of Punto Hijo, Venezuela,
Maicao, Colombia and Colón, Panama.
Now, my friend Michael Chen was here earlier today
and I told him he must not remain like this,
And I agree with him.
There are many honest and hardworking entrepreneurs,
especially in Lebanese communities
and in all these cities, especially in Colón, Panama.
But Hezbollah has a tendency and a habit
to penetrate Lebanese communities
just as any mafia has done in the past.
Like the Irish mafia in its day,
the Italian mafia we have seen in The Sopranos,
in the movies.
Well, mafiosi tend to operate through the diaspora.
What they have done is replicate the model.
what they use in South America south of the equator,
in the tribal frontier area,
and they have taken him to a new tribal frontier,
a tribal maritime border
with a different advantage.
He still holds dual nationalities.
multiple nationalities.
He still has the three different coins,
so it has the ability to make exchanges,
manipulate currency exchanges,
but it has two additional advantages.
One is obvious—it's in the water.
but the second one is that it now has a hub
in a dollarized country.
And that, for monetary reasons,
Y Selena could give a whole lecture on this.
It is highly advantageous for transnational organized crime.
Now let me move on to what this is working on,
because of this convergence of terrorist organizations,
criminal organizations
and then operational spaces within countries
not only are they stopping this,
such as Venezuela, while incentivizing it
It is experiencing problems we have not seen in the past.
It is making transnational organized crime
It is much greater.
So I am going to start talking to you
on an emerging threat
within transnational organized crime,
and one that is specific to an industry
which is very vulnerable at this moment,
the agricultural industry.
I don't know if you're involved
in the agricultural industry,
But as politicians, I'm sure they're surpassing it.
This is a video, I'm going to play the video.
I hope it works.
And listen to what they are saying.
This is a program that was launched in 2020 in Venezuela.
within that country's agricultural industry.
The last export that was made from Venezuela
It was 120 years ago,
and it became two ranches of the state Huárico
for the sister Republic of Cuba at that time, 1900.
I would like Doctor Wilmer Arcaza to give us this.
because it is part of the export vertex activation
from the Great Mission Agriculture Venezuela.
I am getting back to translation.
what he was saying
for those who do not speak Spanish
What he was saying is,
essentially,
They're talking about this new international exchange program.
that were launched in Venezuela in 2020
to send livestock,
Venezuelan livestock to the Middle East
to export livestock to the Middle East,
and obviously in exchange for foreign investments.
Then, we are all in favor of free exchange,
There's nothing wrong with that.
However, let's put this into some context.
Venezuela is, in reality,
As we mentioned earlier,
It is one of the two countries that,
according to the Food and Agriculture Organization
of the United States,
It is one of the two countries suffering from famine.
What is severe food insecurity?
Haiti is the other.
It is a country with 9.3 million of its people.
considered severely malformed.
Then, in a country that is struggling
for food security,
They are sending livestock to the Middle East.
Well, let's see how that program was made.
This is a chart.
This is a slide that I will show you
seven ships from different countries
which were part of this program
What did Venezuela's livestock industry export?
to different countries in the Middle East,
In this case, four countries,
Iraq, Egypt, Spain, in reality,
and I'm losing a third country,
but anyway, Lebanon.
Lebanon, Iraq, Egypt, and Spain.
Pay attention to two things on this slide.
Actually, I'll highlight them for you.
The first is that there was an inter-agency rate.
developed in Venezuela to implement this program.
Among the various agencies,
In fact, there were six agencies.
who were responsible for overcoming this program.
Among those six agencies,
it was the National Guard of Venezuela
and the Drug Agency.
Well, that makes sense.
You want to protect those shipments.
Then, there was this ship,
this boat with the portfolio of Togo, from Africa
he made some shipments to,
I think it was to Egypt in 2021.
to send some of these ranches
And these herds are going to that country.
Over a month ago,
January 28, 2023
that boat, the Spirit Dom,
and has the same number of IMOs,
the same portfolio of the portfolio,
He was arrested and captured.
in the territorial waters of Spain
for carrying 4,500 kilograms of cocaine.
4,500 kilograms of cocaine.
That takes mules to another level.
If we make the street value, the conversion,
That is from 180 to 3 decorations of dollars
of cocaine.
And that is a boat.
That is a boat.
There were multiple ships,
There were seven ships in the middle of 2021.
You start adding these numbers
And why don't you talk about the millions,
You're talking about trillions.
And when you start talking about trillions,
You're talking about GDP level numbers.
And that is essentially what
We are seeing this here.
That's what happens when convergence occurs
it begins to happen,
not only among the illicit actors,
but rather begins to occur
with malignant authoritarian regimes.
So let's take a brief tour
to finish this
about what is happening inside Venezuela.
And this is the so what.
This is the advice for all of you
what they are looking at throughout the region,
It's not just about Venezuela.
We know that Venezuela's economy
You've signed the contract, haven't you?
The economy has contracted by 60%.
over the past eight years,
that means they have lost 60%
their GDP over the past eight years.
And when we think of Venezuela,
The majority of us think of an oil state,
a gold-producing country
and to a large extent still is,
but not as much as before.
Why when Venezuela's GDP
it's no longer what it used to be
that was over 100 trillion,
and now down to 43 trillion and falling,
Venezuela is no longer just an oil state,
it is more advanced in the direction
of an agricultural state.
Venezuela's GDP today
That's what it was in 1950.
before Venezuela
had begun to produce massive amounts
of oil.
How does this apply?
Why in every aspect
of a transnational organized crime
it operates within an ecosystem,
and that ecosystem is illicit economies.
And in society,
at any moment
in all your countries,
there exists the formal economy,
the informal economy
and throughout that
It is illicit economy.
This always exists
in the United States and in all places.
The key is power
eliminate access barriers
Remove the obstacles
for the formal company to grow,
to clear the informal enterprise
and finally,
to reduce the illicit enterprise.
But when you don't do it,
or when you don't do it,
It does not mean that the completion comes to a halt,
it does not mean that economic scales
They begin to clear up.
The formal economy will decrease,
but illicit economy will grow.
And that is when organized crime
Transnational begins to surpass.
Today, territorial control
define power
more than any other form of democratic government.
And transnational organized crime
It is the best method.
It is the best tool.
It is the best weapon.
for a malignant authoritarian regime
like Venezuela,
like China,
like Russia,
How about Iran,
to gain more power.
Now I have the strong signal
What do I have to stop?
so I'm going to finish with one thing,
because, and I was planning to tell you
A bit more about another element
transnational organized crime
what is emerging in this threat matrix,
what is
irregular, unregulated fishing
and unregulated.
This is something that really
You must pay attention to
in terms of Minister Pino
He was talking,
the maritime domain
It is beginning to be
very popular
due to transnational criminal activities,
And this is among all of them.
And I'll leave you with this one slide.
I won't be able to explain it,
but I wanted to show it to him,
What is it?
Latin America and the Caribbean
they are now entering what
Selena was saying
in this great competition
what we are witnessing among the global powers,
but the difference is
the other global powers
that are throughout the world,
Be Russia, be China,
And I would even include Iran,
considering their alignments,
They are now beginning to assemble
transnational organized crime
as a means of gaining greater territorial control
and reduce that geographical advantage
that the United States and Latin America
You have had over time.
Thank you very much for your time and attention.
And I hope to continue the conversation.
