Dream Combo? D700 & 58mm 1.4

Fantastic behind the scenes
10 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 28, 2026
Dream Combo? D700 & 58mm 1.4 vs z mount 50mm 1.8 vs 50mm f1.4 D
AI Generated·May contain errors
Does this camera, the D700, coupled with the 58mm f1.4 create the dream combination,
the most magical combination of camera and lens combined? What happens when you use these two
together? And I've done a video on the D700 before and Hypo Magic, and for me it is magic because I
love the experience of using it. Also the files straight out of camera, which have a rendition
and colour which I can't match with anything else. And then I've got the lens, I've just got this
lens, the 58mm f1.4 G, which was designed to be character full. So this is the second time I
bought this 58mm lens. I bought it a few years ago and I did find it had a character even on
that it did have rendering and colours. But I found the focus too slow. And also the colours
and rendering didn't fit when I was using other cameras. So I just got rid of it because I didn't
have DSLRs then. Now I have DSLR, it's a whole new world. Or is it the camera that overrides
the character and everything else going on with your photography? One of my favourite things about
this lens is that the autofocus areas in the background swirl in towards the centre,
almost like a vortex effect. And some other lenses do this as well. But it's very profound and
beautiful with this lens. The 58mm f1.4 G was designed to be unique. Nikon designers wanted
to make something different from the rest. And that made this, I'm not thinking about sharpness
so much, although at f1.4 it is sharp enough for me, especially for portraits. It's designed to
have character and a certain 3D nature. So yes, I've looked into it, it has field curvature.
So the centre is sharp and then the middle parts are less sharp, and then it goes sharper again
and that creates like a wave. And it does create, I think it does create a swirling effect.
And when it comes to sharpness, yeah f1.4 is sharp enough, not razor sharp or clinical like
you'd expect from lenses of its time even, especially mirrorless lenses now. But f2.8
it's like using a different lens, the sharpness goes skyrocketing high. And Photography Life has
done this sharpness chart, which I actually find the same conclusions as well. And you notice that
the middle parts and the sides of the frame don't really get much sharper, which again might add to
this 3D nature. So other characteristics of this lens that I found, the colours do have that FML
kind of retro design that was trying to emulate film photography at that time. But the bokeh is
really interesting. So I've compared it to other lenses, I've compared it to my 50, compared it to
my 50 f1.4 D lens, that's with the FTZ adapter. And also compared it to the, yeah, 50 f1.4 S lens
for Z mount. Let's see the lights, so you can see it. Nice. Okay, 50mm f1.8 Z mount. You can
get really close with this. Does it have a more sharper contrast? Realistic colours? Focus is
certainly faster. Okay, this is a 50mm f1.4 D. Manual focus, of course.
There's a bit of softness. Bad thing for portraits or something like this.
So yeah, the bokeh on the 58mm f1.4 G is very smooth. There's no hard edges to the bokeh,
which you might find with the mirrorless and of course the old D lens. It couldn't deal with
harsh lights so much. And that adds to the rendering is so smooth and buttery, especially
as it fades out to the fully out of focus areas to the in focus areas. Because a criticism of
the mirrorless lenses is that the bokeh can be really harsh looking, kind of that nervous look,
which I do find with the mirrorless lenses. But that character is clean and clinical,
and that's the way they designed it to be. So when you use any lens with the FDZ,
it's a very strange handling experience. It kind of adds a weird cavity in the middle.
It's a bit really awkward for holding, I think, and quite ugly to use, but it works effectively
for sure. And when you put it on, this is the Z8, it looks fine, it looks weird. But you know,
let's put that closer. So it does look a bit weird. So I found that, yes, F mount lenses,
especially ones with heavy character like this 58, do enhance the mirrorless experience for that
character line. So if you want the characteristics of F mount with the retro colours, it is slightly
there. Sometimes you can't tell. It depends on the lighting conditions and the bokeh and the
field and so many considerations. But there is times when F mount lenses like this 58 can stand
out with its colour rendering and the field curvature with the 51.2 was amazing. It was
just a completely straight line, which is amazing because I utilise that for group photos. I could
have people all lined up and they'll all be in focus, which is fantastic. This is completely
the opposite lens to that. This is the 51.4D lens. This is even softer, more retro film looking,
but it can't deal with harsh lights. I've seen this a few times now with photography and video.
It just almost destroys the image quality, unusable. And that's where a better designed
newer lens like this 58 can pull it together and use harsh lights because it has better coatings
on. When it comes to autofocus with this lens and the D700, it can miss sometimes. So even if I've
used the optical viewfinder and focused, it might not be in focus when I take the photo because
sometimes it back focuses with this lens in certain conditions. I have found that a few times,
but it's something to get used to. With mirrorless technology, this lens is better. This is for
autofocus because of the mirrorless technology. So I use this 58 with my D700 on a few weddings
and just as a side, so I'll get the photos I need with my mirrorless technology to make sure I've
got them. Then I'll, I've used my D700 with this lens on my side. I'll take a few frames
and I found, I don't know if I was just rushing it, but about 40% of them were out of focus on that
session, one particular wedding. I think it was just because I was switching systems and this was
just a rush to use it. But yeah, about 40% of the photos were out of focus, but ones that were in
focus, I loved. I love the texture and the colours and the rendering and that 3d effect. So I used
this combination as a reference file for the rest of my album of that wedding. And that's something
really impressive, isn't it? And that shows that the combination of the D700 and the lens
created something that my mirrorless combination couldn't do. Distortion. So yes, this lens,
this 58 does have distortion and I'd leave it on. I don't always recommend that of course.
So when you put the files into Lightroom, it automatically puts the profile of this lens and
the camera in, and it kind of tries to sort it out. You don't want that with this lens.
It's designed to have some distortion to make that different look. So yeah, overall,
I would say that the camera and the D700 is the main magical component of this combination.
I've used this camera for a year and a half now with all different lenses. I keep on trying
because they're so cheap to buy sometimes. And they've all been had a look that I've really
loved straight out of camera from even the cheap ones, the 24-120mm F4, to prime lenses,
to D lenses, everything I've put on it. The D700 has made something that I really enjoy looking at
straight out of camera and the experience of it as well. You don't want to disregard the
rapport and the experience of photography. It's meant to be fun. And I think DSLRs with the F
and more optical viewfinder and the clacky clunk of the noise of the camera,
you want to have fun with it. And it's a great experience. Something different from mirrorless.
Does this combination of most characterful lens and most characterful camera body come together
and creates the dream team, the most magical combination? I think it does for me. I think
it's the closest you can get to having straight out of camera files with something different.
We're rendering and the field curvature and all the lens design of Nikon that are put into this
lens. It has shortcomings for sure, but they add to the character and the rendition and the D700
with its own character rendition combined with it. It is something really special, I think.
But that doesn't mean every photo you're going to take is going to be a masterpiece. You can't
just buy this combination and everything's going to be golden. It doesn't really work like that.
And it's not just colour that looks really good with this lens. It's black and white because of
the rendering. You're always going to have that field curvature and rendering and the D700 with
the noise that looks a bit like film noise. OK, so there's a lot to take in there. And this is
all very subjective and personal taste. I even used it on a corporate shoot because the clients
wanted a retro feel, like early film, early digital style. Well, this is perfect then,
isn't it? So it's perfect. It was nice, really refreshing to use DSLRs again and something of
this combination for actual work, client work, which is in vogue now, I suppose. OK, right. A
lot to take in there, but I hope you enjoyed the video. And right. I'll see you next time.
