China’s rise to the world’s second-largest economy is often credited entirely to the Communist Party’s wise leadership. But historically, total GDP ranking second—or even first—has been China’s normal state for centuries, not an achievement worth bragging about. From 1000 to 1870, China led the world; even after missing the Industrial Revolution and enduring wars and chaos, it held second place until the 1930s.
Mao’s era was catastrophic, dropping China to seventh globally—an unprecedented low. Reform and opening-up wasn’t Deng Xiaoping’s invention; it emerged spontaneously from the people, with the Party merely stepping aside rather than leading. East Asian rapid industrialization shows that any reasonable dictator can deliver 9–10% growth—China’s performance under Deng, Jiang, and Hu was standard, not exceptional.
Under Xi, growth has slumped to 5–6%, lagging far behind Korea and Taiwan’s sprint to developed status. China’s economic success stems from its hardworking people, not the Party—which has mostly hindered progress and claimed credit for others’ efforts.
Help me grow the channel by donating any amount through the link below—your support makes a difference! https://paypal.me/DonXiang
Hi, I'm Dong Xiong. Welcome to Digging into China, where we take a deep dive into what's
really happening in China and share some unique insights. China has seen massive economic growth
in recent times, jumping to become the world's second largest economy by total GDP. In the
Communist Party's propaganda, they always credit this entirely to the wise leadership of the
Chinese Communist Party. This rapid rise has even become the main source of legitimacy for their
rule these days. Without the Communist Party, there would be no new China. That's been their
slogan for a long time. But is China's development really thanks to the Communist Party? Before we
talk about any credit the Party might deserve, we need to address another question first.
Is being number two in world GDP actually something positive? Is it even worth bragging
about? Some people say, hey, second in the world isn't impressive enough. Our GDP is only a bit
behind the United States. What more do you want? Do we have to be number one? Well, you are right
about one thing. Even becoming number one wouldn't be worth much bragging. Looking back at China's
own history, ranking second in world GDP has never been a compliment. It's actually kind of
humiliating. There is solid research on historical GDP totals for different countries and eras,
the most authoritative being the Madison Project. It attracts GDP in purchasing power
terms all the way back to the first century AD. According to that data, China was the world's
number one economy in total GDP from around the year 1000 right up to 1870. After that,
because China missed the Industrial Revolution and then had the chaos of the Taiping Rebellion,
China's GDP started dropping and got overtaken by the United States. But even so, up until 1934,
under the Republic of China government, despite constant internal turmoil, China still held
second place in world GDP, right behind the United States. It was only in 1934 that the Soviet Union's
rapid industrialization pushed China to third. Then in 1938, with Nazi Germany's expansion,
China dropped to fourth, and stayed there until 1949. So what this shows is that for more than
half of China's recorded history, China has been in absolute first place. Even by 1934,
after centuries of closed-door policies under the Qing Dynasty, the Taiping Uprising, Japanese
invasion and warlord fighting, China was still second in the world, only behind the United States.
So when people say China ranking second in GDP is something to celebrate,
is it really? No, it's not worth celebrating, and it's hardly an achievement. Historically,
it's just China's normal state. Even if China becomes number one again someday, that wouldn't
be some huge breakthrough. The real unprecedented feat, the one truly worth praising across the ages,
would be when China's per capita GDP reaches the top ranks of the world. Since being number one or
in total GDP has been China's default for so long, why does getting back to second now spark so much
pride? Well, that brings us to one person we have to mention, Mao Zedong. There was a period when
China's world GDP ranking plummeted dramatically. Besides World War II, that drop happened mainly
during Mao's time in power. After 1949, because of all those bizarre policies like the Great
Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, China's economic size fell hard in global rankings,
at its worst, down to seventh place. That's something China had never seen since the first
century AD. In all of Chinese history before, even when things got really bad, the GDP never dropped
as far as it did under Mao. Getting knocked down to seventh was unprecedented. You could say Mao's
damage to China surpassed even the Qing's dynasty's close-the-door era. Plus Japan's invasion,
plus the warlord chaos of the Republic period. As the founding emperor of the Communist Party,
why don't we hear about the Party's economic contributions during that time? Yet now,
rebuilding on the ruins the Party itself helped create and getting back to second place,
using that to boast about the Party's great achievements. It's like someone burning down
their own house, then spending 40 years rebuilding it, and afterward bragging about what a great
builder they are. Isn't that just modern day credit stealing? Of course, after talking about Mao,
we naturally have to move on to Deng Xiaoping. Some will say, from Deng, to Jiang Zemin, to Hu Jintao
during the reform and opening up era, China's economy grew at high speed. You can't say the
Party had zero credit in that period, right? True enough, compared to Mao, Deng, Jiang, and Hu all
look a lot more reasonable. Under those three leaders, China did finally climb back to second
in world GDP. But does that mean these leaders made huge positive contributions worth our
eternal gratitude? Actually, no, they don't deserve that level of thanks. First big question,
whose achievement was reform and opening up really? In the Party's story, it's all Deng
Xiaoping's doing. He had great foresight, saw the importance of opening up, made the bold decision,
and that's why China reformed. But the drive for reform was already there spontaneously among the
people. As long as the Party didn't block it, reform was going to happen anyway. You could even
say Deng was able to come to power because he went along with the tide of reform. It wasn't Deng
who created reform and opening up. Reform and opening up made Deng possible. Before Deng took
over, the Chinese people had already erupted in large-scale protests against economic model.
Take the famous April 5th movement in 1976. On the surface, millions took to the streets to
mourn Zhou Enlai's death. And because the Gang of Four wouldn't allow proper mourning,
they stormed Tiananmen Square. But why were people really mourning Zhou?
It was a way of carrying the red flag to oppose the red flag. At the root, people were fed up
with Mao-era economic policies and the cultural revolution. It's the same logic as people today
gathering to mourn former Premier Li Keqiang, using his name to oppose Xi Jinping. And economically,
even in 1976, ordinary people were already doing reform on their own. In Wenzhou, even as the
cultural revolution raged, family workshops never stopped. Despite the risk of being struggled
against, or worse, for doing handcrafts. Then in 1978 came household responsibility for land,
basically land privatization reform, which the party propaganda calls the Trumpet Blast for
Reform and Opening. But that household responsibility system wasn't Deng's decision
first. It started spontaneously from below. On October 24, 1978, 18 farmers in Xiaogang Village,
Fengyang County, Anhui Province, secretly signed a life-and-death contract to divide the land
among households, risking prison or execution. That's often called the starting point of household
contracting. But actually, from 1977 to 1978, over a thousand production teams nationwide
had already quietly gone back to household contracting on their own. Many people unable
to eat just started doing it themselves. Xiaogang Village became famous because it was the first
one semi-legalized. Deng's role was basically not punishing those farmers and, at the central level,
shifting household contracting from illegal to semi-legal. Things like that. There are
countless examples. So on reform and opening up, it's a classic chicken or egg question.
The party narrative says Deng led it, so China reformed. But in reality, even without Deng
pushing reform, ordinary people had already started their own version. Some market activities
happened way before Deng ever talked about the reform. In plain terms, reform and opening up
was the party compromising with what the people were already doing, a political decision to stop
messing things up. Today, that not messing things up gets glorified as the party leading China to
reform. If simply not tormenting the people counts as virtuous rule or achievement, then the party
really is unbeatable. Of course, some will say, OK, reform happened, but implementing it, executing
it well, that still tests leaders' ability, right? Without the party's great leadership and the
excellent governing skills of party leaders, even with reform, the economy couldn't have grown so
fast. To that, I can only say you are overestimating how much leaders matter in a big trend like this.
For East Asian countries in general, I'd go so far as to say even the dog could lead
one of them and still get decent growth. Just look at Chiang Kai-shek for comparison.
In mainland Chinese eyes, Chiang Kai-shek usually has a terrible reputation, seen as hopeless at
governing and hopeless at war, which let Mao take the mainland while he fled to Taiwan.
But actually, if you look at Taiwan and Chiang Kai-shek from 1950 until his death in 1975,
those 25 years, Taiwan's average GDP growth rate was 9.5%. Now compare the three East Asian
authoritarian states during their rapid industrialization phases, China, South Korea,
Taiwan. That's 7 leaders total, Deng Xiaoping, Jiang Zemin, Hu Jintao, Park Chun-hee,
Chuan Douhuan, Chiang Ching-kuo, and Chiang Kai-shek. Their overall performance? Pretty
similar across the board. Chiang Kai-shek's growth rate under Taiwan wasn't even the lowest in that
group. It was higher than Jiang Zemin's China, and only 1 tenth percentage point below Deng's.
So do Taiwanese people today thank Chiang Kai-shek for bringing them high-speed growth?
Even looking closely, the people in that seat were all roughly on the same level.
Besides Chiang Kai-shek with his bad reputation, East Asia has another leader famous for low
education and low quality, Chuan Douhuan. Yet his growth rate was 9.2%, only 1 tenth percent
below Jiang Zemin. Do Koreans thank Chuan Douhuan today? In short, for East Asian countries in a
industrialization phase, as long as the dictator isn't completely outrageous, they can easily lead
the country into high growth. Even a monkey could do it. The hard-working, endure hardship spirit
bred in East Asian culture, that workhorse mentality is perfectly suited for fast
industrialization. Every time we talk about development, someone brings up India or some
African countries for comparison. If China didn't have the Communist Party, it'd be like India or
Africa. That argument doesn't hold water. China has almost nothing in common with those places
beyond population size. India has tons of factors against development, a culture that doesn't value
striving, bad geography with few good ports to the world. More importantly, India's ethnic
divisions are extreme. The largest group, Indo-Aryans, make up only 46% of the population,
not even half. Hindi is spoken by less than 50%. Then huge religious issues, Islam nearly 20%,
and so on. In that context, the fact India doesn't descend into civil war is already
a blessing. Economic development? Forget it. African countries are even less comparable.
Taiwan and Korea, though smaller in size, are otherwise very similar to China. And on size,
a big country is never a disadvantage. It's an advantage. Look at the United States compared to
other Western democracies. Its huge population and land area give it a massive edge. If the US
had only one-tenth the people and land, could its economy be this strong? Its influence this big?
No way. So for a country like China, if a leader can't manage the economy well under reform and
opening, that's the abnormal thing. If China had kept a 20% average annual growth way above
Park Chung-hee, Chun Do-hwan, Chang Kai-shek, Chang Qing-kuo, or South Korea and Taiwan,
then you could say the party did outstanding work. But holding 9% to 10% average? That's
standard for an East Asian dictator plus rapid industrialization. You can't treat any positive
growth as proof of brilliant party leadership. That would be insulting to the Chinese people.
China's high-speed growth during rapid industrialization wasn't the party's achievement.
It was what hard-working Chinese people deserved and earned. And among party leaders, besides Deng,
Jiang, and Hu, they also picked Xi Jinping. Under Xi, China's average GDP growth is only 6%,
far below all those other East Asian leaders. A cliff-like drop. And it's sure to keep falling.
In 2025, growth was only 5%, and this year's target is just 4.5%. Knowing how the party works,
set 4.5% and hit exactly 4.5%. At 4.5%, that's even worse, lower than Taiwan's 8.6% last year.
Of course, such low growth isn't all Xi's fault. China has indeed left the rapid industrialization
phase and entered a sprint to develop the nation's status. Slowing down is normal at this stage.
But slowing this much? Not normal. Compare to Korea and Taiwan. By World Bank standard,
China started its developed nation sprint around 2021. Korea started in 1992, Taiwan in 1988,
both finished by 1997. During their sprints, growth slowed to average of 7.8% for Korea and
7.2% for Taiwan. That slowdown was far milder than China's under Xi, where it's dropped to 5.4%
average. Don't underestimate that 2% gap. At under 5% and falling, trying to cross the middle
income trap and become developed, it might mean China never makes it. Under Xi's leadership,
the economy could get stuck in the middle income trap, trapped forever.
Finally, let's look at the party's overall contribution to China. By results, China ranking
second in total GDP under communist rule isn't something to exaggerate. Claiming that proves
brilliant leadership is a joke. If that's brilliant, then Empress Dowager Cixi was
brilliant too. She started the regency in 1861 when Qing GDP was still number one,
better than the party. Does that mean Cixi was a better leader? Total GDP being second or even
first isn't worth the party bragging about. Breaking it into phases under communist rule,
Mao's era, the rapid industrialization from Deng through early Xi, and now the developed
nation sprint. In those three, two phases, the party failed, one barely passed.
Mao's era was a massive fail, shouldn't have happened at all. Precisely because of those 30
years of weird rule, China's per capita GDP got left far behind Taiwan's for the first time.
Why did Korea and Taiwan start their developed sprint in 1988 and 1992 while China only in 2021,
30 years late? Because Mao ruled for 30 years after 1949. Those wasted 30 years delayed China's
rapid industrialization by 30 years compared to those countries. In that time, the party gave
zero positive help to the economy, only negative. Then in the rapid growth phase, how much positive
contribution did the party make? Not much, just barely met the Korea-Taiwan benchmark,
did what any dictator should in that setup. If you insist on picking one leader to praise in the
party's lineup, it has to be Hu Jintao. His average growth was even higher than Park Chun-hee's,
so a slight positive contribution there. And if you look beyond the GDP speed, development under
the party is actually worse than Taiwan's. China has a bigger population and a size,
inherent advantages the party didn't fully use. Meanwhile, typical East Asian development
flaws, low fertility and high housing price from over-squeezing the workforce, got amplified
worse under the party. Korea during its developed sprint had fertility at 1.76, Taiwan 1.82,
China's in 2021 was already 1.12, not even developed yet and fertility near zero.
Housing price to income ratio were far higher in China too. Same development model,
same cultural base, yet the party didn't grow faster than others and left more hidden dangers.
If Korea and Taiwan's leaders get 80 points, the party barely scraps 60, just passing.
And now Xi Jinping in power, can't even call it neutral like a Deng, Jiang, Hu at 60 points. His
contribution to the economy is fully negative, same as Mao's era. When Korea and Taiwan sprinted
to develop the status in 1988 and 1992, their dictators stepped down, willingly or not,
through democratization, crossing the middle-income trap to become developed.
Under Xi, China went the opposite way. The party clings to power, refuse to let go,
causing all sorts of economic problems and heading towards big deflation.
So in summary, the Communist Party has never given positive help to China's development.
Most of the time it's been negative. Their boast of the reform and opening up was at best
neutral, not messing things up. Why is China's economy still growing so fast today? Because we
have a group of people who work incredibly hard. How could it not grow fast? Any country where
people work 9-9-6 from adulthood, kids start school at 6am and finish at 11pm, that GDP should
grow fast. When I hear people say China still has 5% growth so we should thank the party, come on.
With Chinese people this hard-working, why shouldn't China have 5%? By Korea-Taiwan standards,
at this stage, hard-working Chinese should be doing 7% or more. All of China's past development
is what hard-working Chinese people earned and deserved, not something the party gifted. Most
of the time, the party wasn't helping, it was holding back. Sometimes it didn't just hold China
back, it shamelessly stole the fruits of the people's hard work, claiming the development
from our efforts as the party's great contribution. The party calls capitalists thieves who steal
workers' value. Well, isn't the party itself a thief? It steals the value Chinese people create
and turns the economic miracle we built into their own miracle. Thank you so much for watching.
If you find this video helpful, please like it, drop a comment below and hit the subscribe button
right here. It really helps YouTube suggest my video to others.
I'll be back with more content soon. Until then, be well.