Rep. Coffey Questions University Presidents Over Spending

IL House GOP
33 followers
Mar 27, 2026
State Representative Mike Coffey questioned University Presidents over their increased spending plan during a committee meeting. Coffey wants to ensure that their new funding formula will not be used on Starbucks or President salaries.
Website: https://repcoffey.com/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/RepCoffey
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just a couple questions. What guarantee do you have that this money is
going to go to students? Because we're talking about students, we're talking about how these
students have got to go to work, to go to school, but how is there any guarantees that they're,
no offense, going to go to university presidents, you know, going to go to a new Starbucks
in these buildings? How do we guarantee that it's going to go to the students?
Yeah, I'll start. One of the things that we've talked about within, and there's a group that
will look at it, is looking at accountability measures and looking at, A, how we're spending
the money, what impact those things are having. Our intention would be to support students. Now,
going to students means a variety of things. Sometimes it's lowering costs. Sometimes it's
putting in programs that improve student success and increase their chances towards graduation. So
that would certainly be how we'd be spending a bulk of the money is focusing on those things.
But we would constantly monitor. That's one of the things I push for, frankly,
was to make sure we're looking at the model and is it doing what we wanted to do every year,
even as we're not quite reaching adequacy. And we have to be realistic. Again, you know,
we talked about if you're at 40 percent, you're not going to often see a huge jump in a short
period of time. But we want to see that we're actually doing the things that you all intended
to do. So that should be something that's constantly monitored. And I've been supportive
of that the whole way through. So explain to me why the model doesn't have any performance
metrics in there, because as you're saying, because earlier you said, you know, some of
these schools, we need to get the graduation rates up. Yeah. All right. Because when I look at this,
you know, I look at this, these graduation rates, 85 percent, 47 percent, 59 percent,
54 percent, 62, 67, 22, 49, 50, 54, 23, 48. The university system has the highest graduation
rate. They have a 95 percent retention rate, far superior to all other schools combined.
So if we are going to do this, and you're saying that we're going to spend more money for you guys
to improve, why do we not have any metrics to make sure that when we spend that money,
you do improve? And we do. And that's what I'm saying is it's not necessarily you have to hit
this trigger or that trigger, which I wouldn't suggest, because again, it takes time to put in
the programs that will actually. And I'll talk about that in my testimony and in just a little
bit later this morning. It's not going to take several years, but we should be monitoring those
things. And I should point out when you're looking at those differences across institutions, we don't
all have the same students coming in. And that is a basis for this model to start with. So if you
have students who come from high income, who have the resources, who are higher high school GPA,
you're going to see a higher graduation rate. When you have students who don't have that,
you tend to see lower graduation rates, which means you need to put more programs to support
them, whether it's more financial support, whether it's more student support programs outside,
that's what this model is intended to do, is to help push up those other institutions. And I will
say, having done this for many, many years, that is something we look at all of the time. Are the
programs we're doing actually supporting our goals of improving retention? I was telling the story
the other day, we had a living learning community at one of my previous institutions when I was a
dean, and we actually saw a lower retention rate with those students. So I said, I'm not funding
anything anymore that doesn't actually improve it. And so we actually first changed it to see if we
did, but if we couldn't, we were going to take those resources and put them someplace that they
would be more effective. That's what we all do as university presidents. When you looked at this
formula, you know, I come from the business community. So if I have a product that I'm
selling, and I'm profiting $100 on, and I have a product that I am losing money on, I would never
spend more money to promote the product that I'm losing money on, I would quit selling that product,
I would do something different and promote the successful product. At any point in this formula,
did you look at these universities? Because as you look at all these universities across the state
of Illinois, some are growing, and some are not. Did we ever look at a formula that says, you know
what, maybe we need to consolidate our universities, maybe we need to shut down universities, put more
into the university system, which we know, the University of Illinois system, which we know,
has a very successful rate. You know, one of the problems is I talk to a lot of the educators,
and I'm disappointed when I say, have you thought about shutting down any schools and
rewarding the schools that prosper? And not one time do I hear anybody even consider that.
But in business, you would definitely consider it, you know, why would we not expand the systems that
are doing well? Why would we not increase the scholarships to the universities that are doing
well to make sure that, you know, students have the best chance to prosper? That was not something
that was discussed, but it also wasn't something we were charged to discuss. We were charged to
develop a model that would be adequate and equitable, and that's what we did. So, okay,
so we don't, we're not looking at it as a bit, we're just looking to throw money, and sometimes
throwing money and problems doesn't solve it. So, thank you very much. I think the only thing I would
just encourage you to consider, when you look at the results that you want, which is all shared,
there's nothing you're saying that everybody here would not agree with, that you would, you want to
put investments, and you want to make sure you're getting the returns. We have now a way of
understanding that some of the universities that, my guess is, you are looking at saying, I'd like
to see that graduation rate or persistence rate improved, we're funding them at half of what they
need. And so, are you making an informed decision? Have you, in other words, they serve very particular
needs, regionals do, that will not be served elsewhere. There's a whole lot of line of data
about how far students will travel to go to schools. You lose those opportunities. We have
not invested in those institutions to allow them to be as successful as it is that you would like,
and I would like them to be. That's fine. So then, are you saying that after you spend this money,
and you get that money, if those rates don't change, you're willing to change the formula
and go back to the successful schools? Accountability is built into there for exactly
that reason, that when you hit a certain funding level, you start looking at those results saying,
are they improving? Are we seeing that? You look immediately, but you absolutely have the ability
to have a different conversation once you've hit a reasonable level. For the money you spent,
what kind of improvement are you looking like? How much money will it cost to bring up
graduation rates 10 percent? Do we have any idea? I would let the institution, my guess is that it's
not my guess, that will differ institution to institution based on who they serve,
what their programs are, and where they're starting from. And I can say from the perspective of
Eastern, the proposed framework will allow us to expand institutional aid to our students. The
number one reason for students who stop out, it isn't academic quality, it isn't academic success,
it is cost. It is the number one driver of retention issues at regional comprehensives,
and I think all institutions, if you look at the overall surveys across the nation,
are cost. Cost of attendance, out-of-pocket expenses. While we do everything we can to
keep the net cost down, and I'll talk about that in my testimony a little bit later,
it is a great investment in our students by expanding institutional aid. Any increases
in terms of adequacy gap inherently involves expanding institutional aid, as well as student
support. And another byproduct is it will control the rate of growth of tuition. And so that's,
I mean, those sort of go together and are sort of a two-pronged approach to controlling the
affordability costs going forward. Thank you.
