Raising Retirement Age: Warren Warns "Americans Aren't Buying It and We will Keep Fighting Back"

Elizabeth Warren's News
3 followers
Mar 27, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. So, when he ran for president in 2024,
Donald Trump repeatedly promised that he, quote, wouldn't touch Social Security.
And as soon as he took office, he immediately directed Elon Musk, who thinks that Social
Security is a Ponzi scheme, to doge his way through the Social Security administration.
He slashed staff. He created new administrative hurdles that make it harder for Americans to
get their checks, money that they earned. That is effectively a benefits cut.
Now, Senate Democrats have fought back, and we have forced the Trump administration to
reverse course on some of their most harmful policies. But this fight is not over. Social
Security administration is still facing a customer service crisis. And the Trump
administration and the Republicans are still looking for ways to cut Social Security.
So, their current approach is make Americans work until they drop dead.
So, just listen to what Trump's appointees are saying. When asked about raising the
retirement age, Social Security Administrator Frank Bisognano said, quote, everything is being
considered and will be considered. Mr. Adcock, you are a Social Security expert. How would
raising the retirement age affect Americans' benefits?
Well, simply put, it's a benefit cut. It doesn't matter whether you claim Social Security benefits
at 62 or 70 or how long you live. It's a benefit cut in any way you slice it.
And so, for every year you decide that you're going to raise the retirement age, you're taking
about, well, you're losing $24,000 of income for every year. But then in your future benefits,
for every year that it's increased, you're losing about 7% of your benefits.
So, raising the retirement age on Social Security by one year costs $24,000. And over your lifetime
is about a 7% benefit cut. Is that?
For each year.
Yeah, that's right.
For each year.
So, because some of the proposals that are being discussed would raise it from 67 to 69 or 67 to 70.
So, if you go to 70, you do the math, how big is the cut?
Well, the math ends up being, it's a 20% future cut.
A 20% future cut. Okay. So, Frank Bisognano is not alone in this. After the Republicans blew
trillions of dollars on a tax cut for their rich buddies in their big, beautiful bill,
Dr. Oz said the way we dig out of a deficit is having, quote, the average American work
a year later and not retire. Mr. Adcock, how many Americans without a college degree
work in physically demanding jobs?
In that category of people who don't have college education, it's about 41% of them.
So, what does it mean to work an extra year?
Well, it means an extra year that you don't have benefits in it. And especially when we're
talking about this particular group of people who need to retire early, generally their longevity
isn't as long. I mean, I think I've seen studies where when you take the bottom half of the income
scale, they live about five years less than the people at the top end of the income scale.
And so, and especially the other part of this is that if you do have a physically demanding job,
and you're likely also to be from a community of color, in these situations, it means that you're
going to need to claim benefits early. And so, today, under current law, if you claim early at
62, you're taking about a 30% cut to your benefits had you not waited until your full retirement age
currently at 67. But if you were to raise the retirement age to 70, we're talking about a 50%
cut. Wow. Wow. And I just want to add in this, there are obviously also people who have college
degrees who also have physically demanding jobs. Am I right on that? Oh, absolutely. Yeah.
Right. My favorite example are kindergarten teachers. Try it sometime. But unsurprisingly,
Dr. Oz is not thinking about the millions of Americans who work in manual labor,
who have physically demanding jobs, many of whom have ground their bodies for decades
at construction sites, hauling boxes in warehouses, scrubbing bathroom floors,
and literally may not be capable of adding work. Indeed, as you say, these are often the people
who have to retire early because they're just physically spent. And look, I'm all for older
Americans working longer if they want to work longer. But let's not confuse wanting to work
with being forced to work because the Trump administration is taking a sledgehammer
to Social Security. Instead of hanging those workers out to dry, we should be expanding
and protecting Social Security, especially when tariffs and war are now driving up prices
for our seniors, for everybody in this country. So, Mr. Adcock,
how could we pay for bigger Social Security benefits? Our preferred solution would be making
the wealthy pay their fair share. Yeah, that seems right to me. But we've got to make sure
that the wealthiest Americans pay their fair share and not force seniors to work until they drop
dead. Right now, a billionaire, Jeff Bezos, Bill Gates, Elon Musk, pays as much in Social Security
taxes as someone who makes $175,000 a year. I've got a bill to fix that, and it would raise enough
money to increase benefits by $200 a month for every senior and help stabilize Social Security
and make sure it is round for the long haul. Social Security is not charity. It is a promise,
and it is a promise that people have earned. And the Trump administration is trying to strip away
that promise, trying to chisel it, trying to shrink it up, and then rebrand it as an opportunity to
work. Americans aren't buying it, and we're going to keep fighting back. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
