Russia s spring offensive in Ukraine expected to focus on Fortress Belt in Donetsk region

Soldier’s Legacy
4 followers
Russia's spring offensive in Ukraine is expected to focus on the so-called "Fortress Belt" of heavily defended cities in Ukraine's eastern Donetsk region, which Moscow has repeatedly demanded Kyiv relinquish in return for peace. Speaking on FRANCE 24, retired Vice Admiral of the US Navy Robert B Murrett, says that the region is "a veritable highway for any army that wanted to conduct operations further into Ukraine and beyond".
#Ukraine #Russia #war
Now, Russia has begun an early spring offensive in Ukraine, intensifying fighting along the
eastern front after a winter pause.
Russian forces are focusing on the Donbas so-called Fortress Belt, using drones, missiles
and mechanised assaults to test Ukrainian defences.
Along the 1,250-kilometre front line, both sides are stepping up strikes, including major
drone exchanges.
For now, Russia has made only limited gains, but is attempting to expand footholds in eastern
and southern regions.
Ukraine says it's holding its positions under heavy pressure.
Monty Francis gives us the latest.
The people who live in this apartment building in the Ukrainian city of Dnipro got the shock
of their lives when a Russian drone struck early Thursday morning as most of them slept,
setting fire to the first two floors.
I was in bed when I heard the sound of the incoming drone.
I couldn't believe it at first until the very moment it struck.
All of our windows were blown out.
I was in shock and didn't know what to do.
It was just one of almost 1,000 drones launched by Moscow at Ukraine since Tuesday, along
with 34 missiles, in one of the largest aerial attacks of the war.
Kyiv responded with almost 400 drones of its own, targeting Russia and occupied Crimea
in what's believed to be the largest overnight attack by Kyiv since the war began more than
four years ago.
Meanwhile, the Ukrainian president told Reuters that the Trump administration is pressuring
Ukraine to cede the rest of the eastern Donbass region to Russia to end the war, a land area
that covers about 5,000 square kilometers.
But Zelensky says giving up the territory would just play into Putin's hands.
Therefore I believe that withdrawing from the east of our country poses a high risk
to Ukraine and to Europe.
At a gathering of G7 diplomats outside of Paris, the EU's foreign policy chief said
she agrees.
It is, of course, the Russian playbook of negotiations, that they are demanding something
that has never been theirs.
And that's why we are also flagging that this is the trap that we should not walk into.
With the world's attention on the war in the Middle East, Zelensky made a surprise visit
to Saudi Arabia Thursday, hoping to leverage Ukraine's expertise in defending itself against
drone attacks, swapping drone interceptors for air defense missiles it needs to fend
off Russian missile attacks.
Joining us now for more analysis is retired Vice Admiral of the U.S. Navy Robert B. Murrett.
Thanks to you so much for joining us, Robert.
In terms of the spring offensive, we are about to see more aggression.
What would convince you that this offensive is strategically successful, both on the side
of Russia and on the side of Ukraine?
Certainly a great question.
I think, you know, as we enter the fighting season, as we call it, from the standpoint
of the Ukrainians, I think it would be successful if they're able to continue to enforce the
pretty tough stance they have had in the eastern and southern parts of their own country.
Along those lines, I would mention that Russia has only gained about 1.5 percent of Ukrainian
territory in the last three years.
In fact, they've suffered some fairly significant losses, as you know, just in the last two
to three weeks.
That could shift.
I mean, from the Russian standpoint, I think, you know, they certainly are key on that additional
territory in the Donbas, as you were just mentioning, specifically in Donetsk, which
is part of the negotiations that the United States is trying to broker right now.
But unless there are very, very strong security guarantees, I just don't see any way that
the leadership in Kyiv is going to be willing to accept that.
Well, those security guarantees is something that Volodymyr Zelensky touched on in an interview
with Reuters yesterday, an exclusive.
He basically said that security guarantees from the United States were contingent on
giving up the Donbas territory, which Ukraine has still six thousand square kilometers under
their control.
If we can just remind ourselves and remind our viewers exactly what Zelensky said on
that regard.
Yes, certainly what he said, and it was interesting, he also mentioned, and this is important,
that the actual territory which Russia is asking to get as part of negotiated settlement
is a major security guarantee for the Ukrainians.
From a tactical battlefield standpoint, again, I defer to my army colleagues on that, it's
my understanding that part of the Donetsk province is strategically important and also
is kind of a major pathway, not just into the rest of Ukraine, but really throughout
Western Europe because of the territory that it comprises.
So I mean, the territory itself is a security guarantee.
And the other thing is, any situation where the Ukrainians would be willing to give this
up, I think have to be predicated upon assurances that Russia will ask for more.
And I don't see any evidence of that at all.
You know, when you listen to what President Putin is saying and his tight-knit group in
the Kremlin there, they have not backed off their maximalist gains, you know, the underlying
causes, assurances that they want from Ukraine to, you know, completely reduce the size of
their military, reject any future NATO membership and even potentially membership in the European
Union.
So I don't see...
My own sense is, looking at this, that even if they were to give up that territory and
provide it to the Kremlin, that would not be the end of the discussion.
The Kremlin would actually continue to ask for a lot more.
We'll touch on that exact point just after we hear from Zelensky yesterday.
Americans are ready to finalise these guarantees at a high level once Ukraine is ready to withdraw
from Donbass.
In my view, the Russian side is shaping the atmosphere in its dialogue with the Americans
around this very idea, that Ukraine should withdraw from the Donbass, the United States
will then provide the security guarantees Ukraine is seeking, and Russians will certainly
end this war.
More or less, this is the triangle we find ourselves in.
Robert, Zelensky was referring there to that fortified belt in Donetsk and in the Donbass
region at large.
If you can just tell us about that belt and why it is so crucial, and what that actually
would mean for Europe if those Ukrainian defences were no longer there.
It would certainly make it far easier for Russia to conduct offensive operations against
Ukraine and potentially beyond Ukraine into Eastern Europe and beyond.
It is very much a pathway.
We always used to study the Folda Gap during the Cold War in terms of the point of entry
from the then Soviet forces into Western Europe.
There's some parallels between the Folda Gap, which we studied so carefully during the Cold
War, and that region, those parts of what I'll describe as Northwestern Donetsk province,
which provide a veritable highway for any army that wanted to conduct operations further
into Ukraine and beyond.
And then you mentioned those very small gains that Russia has only been able to make.
It took them forever to make inroads into Pokrovsk, for instance.
What is actually there for Ukraine to say, OK, well, we should actually listen to this?
I mean, it doesn't seem like they would be inclined in any iota to give, to cede any
territorial possession.
I think it's directly related, as you were mentioning earlier, to the level of confidence
they would have in whatever security guarantees can be provided.
And to be frank, I think there's justifiable skepticism in Kiev right now in terms of any
security guarantees that might be provided by the current leadership in the United States.
I say that reluctantly.
On the other hand, if there were to be more extensive, real and strategic planning, we
tend to draw the distinction between peacekeeping operations and peace enforcement operations.
But just for example, if we were to have peace enforcement operations along the forward line
that exists right now between Russian occupied territory and Ukrainian territory, comprised
of many Western European nations and others from, I'm just making this up, Japan, India
and so forth, a large international footprint of ground forces that Russia would have to
contend with if they renewed offensive operations in the future.
I think that would give the Ukrainians a lot more confidence.
How many casualties, though, are we looking at from the Russian side if they actually
decide, you know what, we're going to try and take Donbass?
It would be catastrophic.
I mean, I've seen different estimates.
They're well into the tens of thousands.
And the real backdrop is just the horrific level of killed in action that Russia has
continued to take already, just in the operations they have conducted, especially in the last
three years, and the disregard that the Kremlin leadership seems to have for the high levels
of killed and wounded in action that are being inflicted upon the Russian army.
And what do you think it's going to take for the Donald Trump administration to actually
start putting the pressure on Moscow?
Because Zelensky in that same interview, he said that it always seems to be Ukraine who
receives the pressure from Washington to make amendments, to cede where they otherwise
would have held strong.
So what is it going to actually take to twist Donald Trump's arm and get the pressure back
on Putin?
I think a very much increased level of pressure of all sorts, including increased sanctions,
increased arms provision to Ukraine, and assistant, you know, continued diplomatic pressure on
Moscow and isolation, and working very closely with our partners in Western Europe and North
America, the Canadians, certainly.
And I'd like to say that I see the administration doing that in the near future, but it doesn't
seem to be in the cards.
And the projection, the bottom line that that kind of delivers for you is a continued stalemate
and one that could continue for some time.
And do you think that the current war in the Middle East has basically exacerbated that
and actually provided Russia the necessary breathing space on the battlefield?
Provided them a certain amount of breathing space, and certainly a distraction in terms
of the international press.
However, you know, the two main factors for the war so far, as we go beyond four years,
is that people continue to underestimate two things, I would say.
The first thing they underestimate is the capability of the Ukrainian armed forces and
just how good they are at defending their territory.
The second thing that people continue to underestimate is how hard-nosed and dug in the position
of the Kremlin, that insular group of people in the Kremlin right now, including Putin
and his deputies, have in their maximalist domains.
They don't want just that territory in the Donbas.
They want assurances that a peacekeeping force will not be that strong.
They want assurances that there'll be a decline in the capability of the Ukrainian military,
rejection of future NATO membership, and even potentially, as I was saying, even European
Union membership for NATO.
And they want a new administration.
They don't want to have to deal with the existing leadership that exists in Kiev, which has
been so capable.
And this also comes as NATO says that all US weapons for Ukraine, funded by Kiev's allies
through a special NATO program, have been delivered or continue to be delivered to the
country.
Robert B. Murray, thank you so much for just providing all of that fascinating insights
and analysis there on the current situation on the ground.
And after those comments by Volodymyr Zelensky as well.
