Human Trafficking- Mary Vigil

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
1 Video View·Mar 26, 2026
26th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 7-8, 2023
-Hon. Mary Vigil
Subcommittee Staff Director, House Foreign Affairs Committee, Global Health, Global Human Rights, and International Organizations, Chairman Michael McCaul
Hi everyone, good afternoon. My name is Mary Vigil and could we reduce the lights just a little bit?
Thank you. Well it's a pleasure and honor to be here today with all of you and really a huge
thank you to Congressman Pittenger for the invitation. I've been working on this topic
of human trafficking since 1995, which I'm dating myself, which a woman never wants to do,
but it's the truth. A lot one-on-one with victims, but then also through advocacy organizations,
health care, housing, healing, recovering, empowerment, and building these programs
alongside survivors. And then I started working on the government side, both in the executive
and legislative branch. I had the honor of being asked by Congressman Chris Smith, who's the author
of the U.S. Trafficking Victims Protection Act, to help draft his reauthorization two years ago,
and that's how I ended up working in Congress. And so now I'm in the House Foreign Affairs
Committee, still working with Congressman Smith and for Michael McCaul. So it's perfect that
human trafficking is falling under the topic of democracy, human rights, and religious freedom,
because all of those topics intersect with human trafficking, as well as the previous topics that
were discussed earlier, including on supply chain, illicit financing, all of those topics.
So some of the items that I really want to press upon for the presentation is really those items
of who, what, where, why, and then also end with what do we see as the future, at least for the U.S.,
and how we want to tackle human trafficking. And if there's anything I want to leave you with,
though, at the end, and I'll reiterate this at the end, is that the key point I hope everyone
leaves with is that human trafficking, which I know all of you have heard about at some point
and probably even work with on a regular basis, the key issue with human trafficking is opportunity.
Where there is opportunity, that's where it will occur. So remaining vigilant is really
key and important for that. And then I'll emphasize some other very key linked pieces
to that, to how to address that. So what is human trafficking? So we define it in the U.S. through
the Trafficking Victims Protection Act, which we've had since year 2000, and then also around that
same time we also have the Palermo Protocol by the U.N. Both of them are very similar, but there are
some key areas in which they are different, just a couple of areas. But the U.S. is also moving
towards the direction to include some areas of Palermo Protocol that it hadn't previously
addressed, such as organ trafficking. So we are actually, in the reauthorization that we have
right now in the House, we are including removal of organs, as it's stated for the U.N. We're
including that as something that's reportable now in our annual Trafficking in Persons Report.
It's not defined yet as part of severe forms of human trafficking, but it is now going to be,
hopefully, if it passes into law. We are hoping that it will be part of the reporting piece.
Then, of course, the two areas they have in common, which I think are really important,
is that children are defined as being under the age of 18. And this is particularly critical
because when we look at the law in the U.S. and how we apply it with all the other countries that
we engage with around the world, because we rank all the countries through our annual
Trafficking in Persons Report, when we talk about child trafficking, particularly child
sex trafficking, it's for anyone under the age of 18 would fall under that. And so that would mean
even if other countries' laws might have age of consent, as they call it, age of sexual consent,
being younger than that, if they are under the age of 18 and are engaging in a commercial sex act,
we do in the U.S. define that as child sex trafficking and then would grade the countries
accordingly in the annual TIP Report, whereby there are these tier rankings that we rank each
country from Tier 1, 2, Tier 2 watch list, and then Tier 3, which then Tier 3 is then considered
sanctionable or is under consideration for sanctions. So the other area, so there's a bit
of a questionable piece about also early child marriage, which I'm not going to go into too
much detail because that does deserve its own conversation. So where does it occur? So all
of you know this can occur anywhere. It occurs in every social class. It occurs in every race
and ethnicity, religion, et cetera. It occurs in most, if not all, countries as well. And
what's important to note, though, is that those two areas that are growing and that really around
the world, but even more so in the United States, we've had challenges in being able to address the
online exploitation, particularly of children and of women, as we've seen that explosion occur,
particularly during the beginning parts and throughout with Ukraine, but also
during COVID, for example. But that's something that's a huge challenge to address the online
piece in which we have seen our EU partners lead a lot of those efforts. The other piece that's
also growing is the, well, has always been present, is when there are unstable democracies,
as you all know, then it's harder to implement the rule of law. It's harder to prosecute. It's
harder to provide safety in these kinds of circumstances. And so that said, that's also
where we see a lot of issues. I mean, earlier Bob was talking about the Uyghur forced labor camps,
and we see this in other parts of the world as well. We see this with extremist groups. We see
it with other authoritarian regimes where they do use human trafficking as a way to fuel their
efforts everywhere else. And we see this Africa, Latin America, a lot of other places.
So who's involved? Well, anyone can be involved. Very sadly, we are seeing more and more parents
being involved in the U.S., and this is something that hasn't really been, it's been harder to talk
about, but it is something that's coming more to the surface, at least in the U.S., to talk about
familial trafficking, as they call it. But also this could be strangers as well, but it could
be people people know, like teachers. It could be church leaders. It could be trusted relatives
and friends. It could also even be peers. You know, I work with survivors who tell me that
they were trafficked because their teenage peers during high school are the ones that recruited
them. So this is, it can occur anywhere. Again, that goes back to that word I used earlier that
if there's anything I can leave you with, there's that piece about opportunity. Where there is
opportunity, it can happen. So that goes back to that point, why does it happen? Because there is
an opportunity. So how can we fight this? So, you know, when we talk about opportunity, how do you
counter that? How do you reduce the opportunity? The real big three ways to do this is going to be
having a national action plan, having laws, and then implementing and enforcing, both implementing
the national action plan and then enforcing those laws. Now, I listed some of the three, the four
key pieces that we emphasize in our U.S. law, which is the prosecution, prevention, and protection.
And then we had added a fourth in conversation, which is partnerships, because you can't do it alone.
And so a lot of what we emphasize is a whole-of-government approach, but also partnering
with other allies outside that. So that also means, for example, in our reauthorization bill,
we have this prevention education grant, which focuses on children from kindergarten, so ages like
five, all the way to age 18, where we provide prevention education in the school systems,
but also ask them to partner with law enforcement, like Internet Crimes Against Children, but also
other law enforcement agents, and also ask them to partner with local NGOs that specialize in this
area, and also partner with other people in the community, which also can include parents, for
parents to learn about this, as well as other interested parties. So the other piece that I
want to make sure I also don't forget is the piece on, as I mentioned, the national action plan, I
also mentioned the need for laws, but also having a survivor advisory council. And so in the U.S.,
we have a U.S. advisory council, which actually makes policy recommendations, and they come up
with this policy recommendation every year that they all brainstorm on, and they research on, and
they work really hard to put this together. And actually, the draft of our reauthorization bill
that we have for trafficking, a lot of that was actually based upon their recommendations,
and also continuing conversations with those members, as well as other survivor groups as well.
You know, we know that they themselves are the experts. Those with lived experience are the ones
that know how they got there, know what had happened, and also know a lot of the gaps that
exist in the laws, as well as in other communities, to be able to effectively address it. So we can't
forget them as being a key expert in all of this. I guess that was it. So the last thing that I will,
the other thing that I want to leave you with, though, is that, you know, again, opportunity,
how do we reduce opportunity, national action plan, laws, implementing the plan, and enforcing
the laws? But I also want to talk about and leave you with the way forward. What are some of the
issue areas that the U.S. government, at least of the U.S. here in Congress, that we're looking at,
and that we still have work to address? Because this is a never-ending, unfortunately, feels like
a never-ending kind of pursuit, but hopefully we will find some day where this is much better
controlled. But what we're looking at right now, we've got a whole laundry list of issues that we're
working on, which includes online exploitation, as I mentioned, which all over the world, right,
that this occurs. But we need to strengthen our laws in the U.S. to ensure that we can
provide safeguards for that here. But also the organ trafficking piece, right, where we are
hoping to get a start and having it be reported, and then eventually being as part of the severe
forms of human trafficking. And then also, we actually don't really have a solid definition
of what child labor is either. Also illicit financing, where there's also some bills out there
on that as well, where we're trying to be better about understanding where we actually have
sanctioned individuals and companies, but also what do we know about this from the U.S. perspective,
from within our own banking systems and whatnot. What are we doing to provide these safeguards?
And also to sanction, and then also looking more closely at supply chain,
and also looking at hotels. Hotels are a huge avenue for this to occur.
And then I would also add monitoring convicted child sex offenders. We already have a law on that,
but this is something that we could also do more globally to be able to see where these child sex
offenders are traveling for child sex tourism and being able to provide a way to protect these
children. And then again, training law enforcement at all levels, as well as judges. And then as we
continue on countering authoritative regimes and extremist groups, which also helps with national
security. And then again, going back to sanctions, making sure that we're actually implementing those
sanctions so that it could have the effect that it was intended to have to reduce trafficking
and to deter traffickers as well. Thank you.
