Another Dawn (1937) is a sweeping romantic drama set against the vast deserts of North Africa, where love, friendship, and military duty become deeply intertwined. Starring Errol Flynn, Kay Francis, and Ian Hunter, the film explores the difficult choices that arise when personal happiness conflicts with honor and responsibility.
Filled with striking cinematography and emotional performances, Another Dawn examines themes of sacrifice, loyalty, and courage. Rather than relying solely on romance, the film asks what true devotion requires when duty calls.
A forgotten gem from Hollywood's Golden Age, Another Dawn combines epic adventure with heartfelt drama, reminding us that some of life's greatest victories come through selflessness rather than triumph.
AI Generated·May contain errors
What's wrong, Julia?
I think I'm going to leave Dickett, for a while at least.
I have to get away from here.
You know, of course, how that will hurt John.
Oh, he won't mind. He'll be alright.
You know that's not true, nor is your reason for leaving.
You love Denny, and you want to escape it.
Then you know.
Yes, I know now.
Then you know why I can't stay here.
Seeing him day after day, pretending I don't love him.
It's impossible. No one could stand it.
Oh, yes they can.
That's easy for you to say.
But harder for me to do.
Yet, I do it.
I've loved John for seven of the longest years of my life.
You?
That must have been awful for you.
Why did you stay here?
Because I've learned a different kind of love than wanting and having.
A quiet kind that watches and shares in someone's life without that someone knowing.
I've shared in every part of John's life.
Even your marriage.
Because I know he can never love me any more than you can love him.
You can learn to love that way, too.
I can't.
I don't know any other way to love than with my whole heart.
Don't you see? There's nothing for me here.
Nothing but another dawn.
I'm Tiffany Brannan.
I'm Rebecca Brannan.
Welcome to Real Thoughts on Cinema.
A while ago, I went on sort of a binge of watching Errol Flynn movies.
I saw a lot of them that I liked, and a few that I didn't.
But one really stood out to me as being a very special and unique film.
This movie is unusual because it's not a swashbuckling film.
And although it has an exotic locale and adventure theme, it's set in modern times.
Although it is, at its heart, a romantic melodrama,
typical of Flynn's other films, it has quite a bit of combat in it as well.
The film we're discussing is Another Dawn from 1937.
This film follows the commander of a British outpost in the Arabian desert called Dickett
who goes on a holiday to England and falls in love with a young American woman
who doesn't think she can love again after the pilot that she loved so dearly has died.
However, John, the commander, tells her how much he loves her
and she ultimately decides to marry him and go back to Dickett with him
with the understanding that, although she's very fond of him, she's not in love with him.
However, upon returning to the outpost, she meets his second-in-command, Denny,
and finds herself being attracted to him because he reminds her so much of the man she loved.
As combat and the unrest in this outpost builds,
so does the unrest between the three members of this love triangle.
This movie was produced by Warner Brothers.
It was directed by William Dieterle.
It stars Errol Flynn, Kay Francis, Ian Hunter, and Frida Innescourt.
No producer was credited on this film,
but Jack Warner and Hal B. Wallace were two of the uncredited producers.
I think the most famous Warner Brothers film from this genre, if you will,
it's not really a war film, not entirely swashbuckling,
but it includes elements of combat and melodrama,
is Casablanca from 1932, produced by Hal B. Wallace.
That really is definitely the best known,
but the epitome of that self-sacrificing melodrama
in the middle of an exotic military conflict kind of film.
Yes, and I think that really is the style,
which was so unique in a way to Warner Brothers during this period.
I feel like that was the new style that they found
after, in the early 30s, they were so well-known for their gangster films.
Yes, it was all very violent, very modern,
but in the late 30s, during the beginning of the production code era,
they went back and forth between extremely historical works,
like their swashbuckling films,
and more modern works that explored sensitive emotional topics,
sometimes called women's weepies or melodramas.
Casablanca is the best known or remembered,
but it certainly isn't the only film that was of this type,
and I think Another Dawn is an earlier example of the same type of film.
Perhaps one of the first examples of such a film.
Absolutely.
It includes similar themes of a love triangle,
a woman who marries a man she doesn't really love
because she thinks the man she does love has died,
she doesn't think she can ever find love again.
You're right, it's sort of like Casablanca is such a similar story,
but the focus has shifted.
It's shifted, it's switched a little.
The order in which it happens, yes.
But there's a similar theme and this conflict
of what could turn into an adulterous situation
being right at the core of it, this temptation,
but also the nobility of the husband,
rather than being jealous or outraged,
to love his wife so much that he's willing to step aside
in one way or another to make her be happy.
I think what really stands out in this film
is the sense of honor amongst the three of them.
That's what struck me.
Honor is so important.
Even though Denny and Julia find that they are just
very deeply in love with each other,
they really know that they could never be happy together
because not only is John her husband,
but he's Denny's friend and that would be such a betrayal.
That's one way that it's a level,
in a way, more complicated than Casablanca
because there's no relationship between Rick and Victor.
Perhaps some kind of respect, but they don't know each other
as opposed to these two men are good friends
before this woman even enters the picture.
So now, are they going to let their friendship be torn apart?
But honor is such an important theme
and it really is very poignant
coming from a studio like Warner Brothers.
In the pre-code era, which is the early talkies,
so after the transition to sound in the late 20s,
those first four years of the 1930s,
the height of the Great Depression,
were noted by extremely scandalous, daring films.
And nobody was more scandalous and daring than Warner Brothers.
They in particular were noted for making very vulgar,
violent films that were just dirty for the sake of being dirty
and just trying to make a profit.
So they did such an about face in the late 30s
going into the 40s, making it all about honor
and they still made more dramatic films,
I would say, in general than MGM, for instance.
Right, because the head of that studio, Louis B. Mayer,
really loved happy endings.
Right, whereas Warner Brothers, even during the pre-code era,
not only Jack Warner, but his brother Harry,
wanted to be a pioneer for social justice, civil rights.
And sort of making films for the people,
more about more everyday people
and common struggles of the common man.
Now this film at first might not seem like a modern picture
because of this exotic setting.
We see a lot of soldiers in these very classic British uniforms
that don't necessarily look like modern uniforms
and many of the enemy are in traditional Arab garb.
But they're riding around and using machine guns.
True.
The women's fashion is what really tells us
that this is set very much in modern times
because it's an excellent example of 1930s style.
My outfit is inspired by one which Julia wears
in a very dramatic part of the film during a sandstorm
when she goes to visit Denny.
It is a turtleneck blouse
with some very unusual swags around the neck,
a loose skirt reaching to mid-calf
as was standard in the 30s,
open-toed shoes, and when she first arrives,
a fashionable fedora.
My outfit is based on the first costume worn by Grace,
who's played by Frida Inniscourt.
It's a very standard 1930s style dress
with the puffy sleeves, belt at the waist,
buttons up the front, and mid-calf length.
She's wearing black and white spectator shoes
and a more structured hat as well as little gloves.
Another added detail that I think further complicates
this love triangle is it's almost more of a love square
because you also have Denny's sister, Grace,
who has been in love with John for years.
They very cleverly show us that in the opening scene
when they're saying goodbye to him at the train station.
You can see, shows film form,
and she's quite devastated when he comes back with a wife.
But her character,
although she's not one of the main trio,
really, I think, is such a beautifully written character
and the scene that she has with Denny
when she tells him about this quiet kind of love
she's discovered was so moving to me.
The first time I watched the movie,
I actually immediately went back and watched that scene again.
I just loved it so much.
I think this film is really a testament particularly
to a woman's love.
You see the counterpoint of these two women,
the one who has just learned to share in this man's life
without receiving love from him in return.
Julia has had this experience of she loves someone so deeply
she doesn't believe she can ever love again.
When she does find love again,
it's sort of like the song, I Love You for Sentimental Reasons,
a lot of the reason that she is attracted to Denny
is because she finds,
it's almost like she finds that man she loved again in someone else.
It's like he lives again.
It's not how he looks necessarily
because she doesn't have that feeling about him at first.
It's when he laughs.
I love that detail because when I read the synopsis of the film,
I imagine it'd be like, he reminds her of love
so she's going to see him in the movie like,
he looks like this man I love.
That would be very obvious.
It's not that.
Their first meeting, he doesn't realize she's Joan's wife.
He just sees her. There aren't many women around.
He kind of tries to pick her up and she's just not interested at all.
And then they're just friends.
You know, this is my husband's friend.
But then, yes, the first time she hears him laugh,
she's just stricken.
It's like a ghost has come after her.
She says, I used to know a man who laughed just like that.
And then talking to him, it's his spirit.
He begins to see his spirit and how similar that is.
And that's very real.
You can find the same spirit in a lot of people.
I think that this film
was intended to be kind of a
not an answer to but a continuation
of The Charge of the Light Brigade
which was
one of Errol Flynn's early successes.
It also was set in
the desert with this British outpost.
And I found it to have some similar themes.
There's a similarly
complicated love triangle in that film.
But this one is definitely shorter, lighter
and easier to watch.
And then they incorporated other things.
I wouldn't say The Charge of the Light Brigade
has those same themes we were discussing
like with Casablanca.
It's much less modern because it's a more historical piece
based on real events.
This has that exotic locale but more of a modern flavor.
Another thing that really struck me
about this film is the fact that it stars
some noteworthy actors who
aren't the best known classic actors
today.
That's very true.
Errol Flynn's name is still recognizable.
And I would say he's sort of
the star of this picture.
But he doesn't get top billing.
That's right. Kay Francis gets it over him.
Because Kay Francis was the top
paid actress at Warner Brothers at this point.
She made so much more money than Bette Davis.
And she was
very successful. She made
comparatively few films
like when you look at her filmography versus
Bette Davis. She got started
first on the stage and then in the early 30s
in Talkies, first at Paramount
then Warner Brothers. But she just made
some really big films in the pre-code era
and then the early code era.
It's kind of funny. I'm pretty sure this is the first movie
I've seen with her. I'm the only
one. But when I saw
the name Kay Francis, I was like, I know
that name. I feel like she was a really big deal.
I know I've seen her in
Four Gels and a Jeep. It's almost a
cameo appearance in that.
But this was kind of the
end of her filmmaking.
She continued for a few more years
but after the end of the 30s she
stopped making as many movies.
She's a bit older
than Errol Flynn's average leading lady
at the time, wouldn't you say? Yes, I'd say she is.
Because she was an established
actress on the stage and then in the pre-code
films. Certainly not old by any means.
There's a maturity about her. Partly just she has a low voice.
She has a mature way about it. And then Ian
Hunter and Freda Innescourt are
an actor and actress you will see a lot
in supporting roles if you watch
many movies from this time period. Ian Hunter
would go back and forth between being
basically just a sidekick and sometimes
being a very strong
second man. I think
of him as being that man
the other man. The one who's
not the only man who usually doesn't get the girl.
And Freda Innescourt is kind of
the other woman. She's often what I would
call the duchess role. She's that woman
who is the fiance that the guy doesn't really
like or the mean sister.
She's in Pride and Prejudice
from 1940. That's what I always think.
She's Bingley's sister.
She's not a nice sister in that.
I thought it was a really
great part for her because although she
was technically that other woman, she was so
sympathetic, almost more so than the Leaning Lady.
You really really feel for her because
she is very self-sacrificing. That's what's
so sad about it. She and John are the same
kind of person. And you really wish that
they could have gotten together
because she
appreciated him more. One of the most interesting
trivia things about this movie I do have to mention
although, spoiler alert, it does
kind of ruin the ending, is
that the original ending that was written
for this film was
for Denny to make the
ultimate sacrifice and to die at the end
in order to
rectify this love triangle.
But within the story
to destroy this dam
to save the lives of 500 people
and that way, it was a much
longer ending so I think the film was a bit longer.
They actually filmed this. I think they filmed this
longer ending. He died and then the husband and wife
were able to reconcile. But I'm pretty sure
the release of The Prince and the Pauper in
1937 was what made the difference.
Errol Flynn was
very quickly moving
his way up but I think really that
film that was the last film released before
this one, he had become such a huge
star. They were like
he needs to end up
with the girl at the end so they reshot the
ending and flipped it so that
John makes the ultimate sacrifice and
Julia and Denny
end up having another dawn together.
And you can see how they could have done that pretty
easily because you see
the plane flying away. I don't
think you see who's in it. That could have been...
They did do a close shot. You see John in it.
But then you see the shot and then you don't
really see anything that happens. There's like
a cable that tells them the news so
that definitely is less than showing the
plane with him in it. Yeah, I could see how
that would be a very easy fix. It goes as
far as they're sort of arguing about who's going to
take the plane and they flip a coin and
Denny says heads and it lands
on him so he is going to take it but then John
just goes and jumps in the plane and takes it out.
And going along with what you said about
Charge of the Live Brigade, in that one
Errol Flynn was the one who ended up dying and
the other man in the love triangle
got Olivia de Havilland which was
unusual because he and Olivia de Havilland were
such a couple. Yeah, they were a pair.
But having
read that and then kind of looking at the
film again, I was just thinking I can kind
of see in a way how it was leading to that.
How
she's almost obsessed with the way
the first man she loved died
young and clean and
owing life and so forth and
how Denny has the same spirit.
I remember you said if I hadn't told you the story
before watching it, you
were thinking it seems like it's leading toward
he's going to die. And he actually did
die a lot in his movies for being
the leading man that he was.
But probably after Charge of the Live Brigade
he didn't die and let the other man
have the girl. I was going to say that's a very
good point. He would die
making sure that she'd be miserable for him
for the rest of her life. But not, oh I'm going to
die, you can be with him. That's
just kind of how they began to write the whole scenario
with him. But partly because
of that, this is a remarkably short film.
It's 73 minutes. So that's the biggest
reason why I would recommend this as a good
film to kind of get you started in this genre.
Maybe introduce you to Errol Flynn
because it's really short. A lot of movies like this
are close to two hours and that's a
lot of black and white melodrama if you're not used to it.
But this, it's a little over an hour.
You might find that you're very
intrigued by it. And the scenes are very short.
It's almost episodic.
One conversation, quick fade out.
Now they did do faster fade outs in general in the 30s.
That was more the style. And there is
the back and forth. There's also this military conflict
going on. The most prominent
sequence of that, interestingly, most of it happens
off screen. Combat. And you see John
Macdonald hearing about, oh the Arabs are still
attacking. So
there is discussion of combat.
You see some of it but not a whole lot of
I'd say on screen violence.
Or even as much as in a lot of
Errol Flynn's more swashbuckling films.
The sword fighting. You see
some of them shooting the machine guns.
Arabs getting shot at horses.
And some of the soldiers.
In a way that's actually kind of startling because
they make a point of a character
having a line right before getting
killed. A lot of times the ones you see
getting killed in combat scenes will be, you don't
know them, they're extras. So that
even though they don't show a lot of combat, it really
is focused on the human element. And I think
that's Warner Brothers. They weren't afraid to shoot
people who were characters to whom you were
attached. And very quickly too.
He's dead. And you weren't expecting it.
It is startling. And
speaking about the cinematography
and the way it's filmed, I think it's very
unique because William Dieterle
directed it. And he was
very much a German impressionist, right? Yes he
was. Which is sort of considered
a predecessor to film noir.
To open up that can of worms.
But the use of shadow
work for dramatic effect.
Particularly a shot used a couple of times
of Denny and Julia looking through these window
shades. So they're like these lines on their faces.
And in the very
last scene,
it's probably a matte painting, which was
the technique they used to give those beautiful backdrops
they're up on the roof, seeing the sunrise.
And right before he actually says
the title of the film, Another Dawn, there's a shot
which was in all the cover art for this film
of just their profiles
lined up beautifully. First time I watched it
I thought, what a beautiful shot.
Genuinely gorgeous cinematography.
The shots of the sand dunes and riding
out on the horses. Interestingly you
see the horses really struggling in this
deep sand because horses aren't really meant to be
in that terrain.
Another thing which adds to the
German drama of this is
the dramatic score by Erich Korngold.
Right. And this is before
Robin Hood. Which kind of
surprised me because I thought of Robin Hood as being
the first movie he did. But that actually isn't true.
Because he did
he scored A Midsummer Night's Dream
back in 1935 for Warner Brothers.
He orchestrated Mendelssohn. I think Robin Hood was
the beginning of his living in America
and writing for films as the main part of his career.
He was coming back and forth.
I think he did Another Dawn and then he went back to Germany
but then because of the Nazi
rise to power increasing and because
he was Jewish, then he came
they called him for
Robin Hood. So he came back and then he stayed.
He would say later in life that
Robin Hood saved his life.
So the theme, the main love
theme which he wrote for this film, he would
later incorporate into his violin
concerto. Yes, that was so fascinating to me
because I knew the violin concerto first
and then I watched
this movie and I said, wow, there's that theme.
Wasn't the other theme in The Prince and the Pauper?
Yes, the third movement of the violin concerto is
the main theme music to The Prince and the Pauper.
That was something
that the composers for films would
do often times. That was a really great
theme and it was just kind of background music. I think it needs to be
a symphony or a concerto.
And it's such a beautiful
theme, that love theme and just
excellent scoring overall.
Gordon Gould's music really takes on a character of
its own. Some
scores do that more than others and this one is
very distinct and you don't forget that
love theme when you hear it.
As we said, this film being very short
it's really very approachable
but I think it gives you
a little taste of several different
elements you'll see in a lot of classic films
and especially Warner films. I'm a
real Warner buff. I really love the style
of their films and I think this movie is a great introduction
to that. Or if you've seen Casablanca
I think you'll, here's another
one, it's in a very similar vein. So if you loved Casablanca
I think you'll really like this movie as well
and the exotic locale gives it sort of
a different flavor. So I
would highly recommend this for
people wanting
to move into the classic
genre or who are somewhat
acquainted with some of the big classics.
This film is available
in many beautifully remastered
black and white copies. You can rent
or buy it on Amazon Prime Video
buy it on a DVD from
the Warner Archive and
you can also find it for
streaming for purchase on YouTube
and some other streaming platforms.
While changing times in Hollywood
led Warners to swashbucklers
and melodramas, it led other studios
most notably MGM to the
classical arts. Join us next
time as we discuss a musical comedy
starring two real life opera singers
which also centers on a love triangle
albeit a most unusual
one. Thank you for watching!
Goodbye!