Iran wanted to talk, and President Trump is willing to listen. That’s what the White House is saying today as U.S. Central Command announces fresh results from Operation Epic Fury. Almost a month into the war in Iran, the United States and Israel continue launching strikes against the Iranian regime. This comes as Turkey says it is now mediating talks between the U.S. and Iran to help bring an end to the war.
The TSA says it is experiencing the highest wait times “in TSA history” at some airports. Meanwhile, in the DHS funding stalemate, Senate Democrats presented a counteroffer today, but Majority Leader John Thune rejected the proposal as an “unserious” attempt that repeats previously dismissed demands. That’s after Democratic leadership yesterday rejected Republicans’ latest proposal.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome to NTD Evening News. Our top story tonight, a new date for President Trump's China trip and
fresh results from Operation Epic Fury. The latest from the White House as Iran reportedly responds
to President Trump's 15-point peace plan. Iris Tao standing by. The U.S. and Israel launching
more strikes on Iran as the military operation approaches the one-month mark. Now Turkey says
they're mediating talks between the U.S. and Iran to end the conflict. Jason Perry with the war
update. Up to 50 percent call-out rates by TSA agents at some airports are leading to the longest
airport wait times in TSA history. Jason Blair has more from the TSA administrator's testimony
on Capitol Hill. In a bombshell verdict in Los Angeles, a jury finds social media giants liable
in a case accusing them of addicting children. After days of deliberations, the decision could
shake the tech industry. Christina Corona reports. This is NTD Evening News live from our global
headquarters in New York City. Here's Tiffany Meyer. Good evening and thank you for joining us tonight.
Iran wanted to talk and President Trump is willing to listen. That's what the White House is saying
today as the Central Command announces fresh results from Operation Epic Fury. Joining us now
live is NTD's White House correspondent Iris Tao. Good evening, Iris. What is the latest from the
White House? Good evening to you as well, Tiff. So as the Trump administration has reportedly presented
a 15-point peace plan to Iran, the White House today is pushing back on reports saying that
Tehran has rejected that peace plan while also saying that talks remain ongoing and productive.
The White House is also making clear that the U.S. will step up attacks if Tehran rejects peace,
also warning that the president does not bluff. Watch. The president's preference is always peace.
There does not need to be any more death and destruction, but if Iran fails to accept the
reality of the current moment, if they fail to understand that they have been defeated militarily
and will continue to be, President Trump will ensure they are hit harder than they have ever
been hit before. President Trump does not bluff and he is prepared to unleash hell. Iran should
not miscalculate again. And President Trump now says that Iran wants to talk after he threatened
last weekend to obliterate their power plants. And while the president is holding off attacks
on their power plants specifically for now, other attacks continue. The U.S. Central Command today
announcing fresh results from Operation Epic Fury, saying that the U.S. has now had over 10,000
targets actually just reaching that new milestone hours ago. The U.S. has also destroyed roughly
two-thirds of their naval production capabilities as well as sites for producing missiles and drones.
And here's the commander of CENTCOM announcing the results today. Watch.
We are on a path to completely eliminate Iran's wider military manufacturing apparatus,
which is why my operational assessment continues to be Iran's combat capability is declining as U.S.
combat capability continues to increase. I just could not be prouder of our troops,
and I know the American people share that same pride.
And Tiff, the White House today also announcing that President Trump's meeting with China's Xi Jinping
will take place in Beijing now on May 14th and 15th. Of course, that meeting was previously
postponed amid the war in Iran. And when asked today if the new timeline means that the war
will also wrap up before then, the White House reiterates that the original timeline for the
And Iris, on the domestic front, we are now on day 40 of the shutdown of the Department
of Homeland Security. What is the White House saying about it today?
Sure. So we are entering day 40 of the Department of Homeland Security shutdown,
and TSA agents remain unpaid. The White House today blaming that on Democrats in Congress,
while also citing a quote by a TSA agent who is also a father of three. Watch.
I think the hardest thing is seeing the struggle that my wife was going through and not being,
not trying to bring more stress to her, the father of three said. But seeing her cry every night,
how am I going to feed my family? How am I going to survive? For the Democrats in Congress,
the cruelty of this shutdown is the point. Nearly 500 TSA officers have quit
since the Democrat shutdown began. And the president today also praising ICE
agents for stepping in at the airports to help to move lines along for these travelers. And
also tonight, president will be speaking to Republicans at an annual fundraising dinner
here in DC. And tomorrow he will hold his second cabinet meeting of this year, also the 11th
of his second term. Back to you. All right, Iris, thanks for those updates.
Almost a month into the war in Iran and the United States and Israel continue launching
strikes against the Iranian regime. This as Turkey says it's now mediating talks between
the U.S. and Iran to help bring an end to the war. NTD's Jason Perry has the latest war update.
U.S. forces on Wednesday report striking Iranian military infrastructure that has
threatened American troops and regional partners for decades. The U.S. military also addressing
claims that the Iranian regime shot down a U.S. fighter jet, saying in a post on X that the claim
is false, adding that no U.S. fighter aircraft have been shot down by Iran. Fighting alongside
the U.S., the Israeli Air Force saying they completed another wave of overnight attacks in
Iran. This went on weapons production sites in and near Tehran, including a strike on a facility
used for developing submarines. An Israeli general saying this the day before.
The Iranians plan to launch hundreds of missiles towards Israel on the first day of the operation.
They fired fewer than 100 on the first day and half that amount on the second day.
The number of launches decreased very quickly. The average is roughly about 10 missiles per day.
An Iranian missile was seen falling from the sky in Israel on Wednesday,
and workers cleaning up the aftermath from an Iranian missile that struck Israel's largest city,
Tel Aviv. Also in the region, a Turkish official telling Reuters on Wednesday that Turkey is now
mediating talks between the U.S. and Iran in an effort to help bring an end to the war.
The Turkish official did not elaborate on what messages were being passed between the U.S. and
Iran, but he did say that messages were also being passed on to Gulf countries who have been caught
up in the war. This as Iranian attack drones reportedly struck a fuel tank at Kuwait
International Airport the same day. Kuwait's ambassador to the United Nations in Geneva
saying this about the situation. What we are witnessing today is a persistent aggressive
approach that disregards all the efforts and initiatives undertaken by the state of Kuwait
and other countries in the region over many years to establish the principles of good
neighborliness and build trust. And in another development, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin
Netanyahu saying Israel is determined to quote fundamentally change the situation in Lebanon
and the Israel Defense Forces said they'll continue to operate against Hezbollah,
accusing the terrorist group of attacking Israel on behalf of the Iranian regime. Jason Perry, NTD
News. The stalemate which has led to a more than six-week partial shutdown of the Department of
Homeland Security is leaving lawmakers scrambling for solutions. The latest in the back and forth,
Senate Democrats presenting a counteroffer today for Majority Leader John Thune rejected the
proposal as an unserious attempt that repeats previously dismissed demands. Following the
breakdown in negotiations, a test vote to advance the DHS funding bill failed in the chamber with
neither side showing signs of movement. NTD's Melina Weiskopf has the details. This week on
Capitol Hill, lawmakers are largely focused around negotiating a deal to end the DHS shutdown as TSA
workers and airports are feeling the brunt of the shutdown pain. Abandoned, unvalued, forgotten,
unimportant. It feels horrible. Democrats have so far rejected the White House's proposals which
met most of Democrats' demands on changes to ICE policy. We have made some progress and the White
Sticking points remain over mask removal and judicial warrants. Republicans say that masks
protect from doxing and judicial warrants would bog down immigration operations. After talks between
the White House and senators have so far failed to make a breakthrough, Senate Republicans are
looking to change strategy. On Tuesday, unveiling a new proposal to separate ICE funding from the DHS
bill, a move that would allow Republicans to effectively bypass Democrats' reform demands.
If they want reforms, then they ought to figure out how to help fully fund ICE. ICE will be
partially funded. CBP will be funded under this proposal. Under this plan, Republicans would later
fund ICE through a process that would allow passage on a simple majority without any votes
from Democrats. Democrat leadership yesterday rejecting Republicans' latest proposal, though
it could pass if just seven Democrats break ranks. The latest GOP proposal meeting with skepticism
from House leadership. That is not my preference. I can tell you the House has funded DHS twice.
We're prepared to do it again, completely fund the entire department. That is a responsible way
to do this thing. So we've been very resistant to any idea to break it apart. President Trump
expressing openness but falling short of a total endorsement. Well, I'm going to look at it and
we're going to take a good hard look at it. I want to support Republicans. And, you know,
sometimes it's awfully hard to get. The president previously insisted that any DHS funding deal
include the Save America Act, a bill to mandate photo ID for voting and proof of citizenship to
register to vote. Reporting from Washington, D.C., Melina Weiskopf, NTD News. The TSA says
some airports are experiencing the longest wait times in TSA history. NTD's Jason Blair has more
from a hearing on Capitol Hill as today marks the 40th day of a partial shutdown of the Department
of Homeland Security. The shutdown has caused massive disruptions across our airports and travel
system nationwide, weakened our nation's cybersecurity posture and left states unsupported.
Representatives from four Department of Homeland Security agencies testified before Congress while
the department is in its sixth week of a shutdown. The TSA administrator says some airports are
seeing record wait times at security checkpoints. Now, multiple major airports are experiencing days
where 40 to 50 percent of their staff are calling out. This has led to the highest wait times in TSA
history with some wait times greater than four and a half hours. McNeil says assaults on TSA officers
are also at a record high. Unfortunately, we have seen an over 500 percent increase in the frequency
of assaults on our officers since this shutdown began. This is unacceptable and will not be
tolerated. The DHS shutdown will end once Democrats and Republicans reach a funding agreement for the
department. Democrats are holding out, demanding reforms to ICE. Democrats want to ensure that
before we give even more money to ICE and CBP, which is already flush with cash, by the way,
that we wring in the deadly abuses we saw in Minneapolis. It is unfortunate that Senate
Democrats chose to shut down DHS and weaken our national security posture for their own political
gain, especially at such a critical time and heightened threat environment across the homeland.
At this point, newly hired officers will not be able to work on the checkpoint until well after
the 2026 FIFA World Cup. This is a dire situation. We are facing a potential perfect storm of severe
staffing shortages and an influx of millions of passengers at our airports for the World Cup games
in less than 80 days. Reporting on Capitol Hill, Jason Blair, NTD News. Amid the longest TSA wait
times in history, will Congress pull through and refund the DHS? Panel discussion tonight on Capitol
Report at 7 p.m. Eastern time. Coming up, the Chinese Communist Party is waging war on small
businesses in the U.S. Ariane Ponsdar has the stories from American entrepreneurs exposing
the underhanded tactics the CCP uses to wage economic warfare. Six Chinese citizens and two
China-based pharmaceutical companies are indicted for allegedly selling chemical precursors used to
make fentanyl. The indictments are part of an FBI effort dubbed Operation Box Cutter.
And the U.S. and its allies are waking up to the reality of China's leverage in the rare earth
market. But is it too late to catch up? A new book explores just that. Dave Martin has the
book launch next. Looking to refresh the style in your house? Come to Matheson during the spring
style event and see hundreds of options for your perfect living room. Take a look at this sectional.
We can help you build into the style you want. From sleek and modern to something more eclectic
to an updated traditional look. You can also reconfigure it just by adding or removing pieces.
The sofa version is a great value at just $12.89. Come find the look that's right for you at your
furniture superstore, Matheson. Hi, I'm Susan Lucci. You may know me from my many years on
television. I never thought about heart disease until I had my own heart event. I felt this
slight pressure in my chest, just slight. I thought, oh, it's nothing. It'll go away.
I didn't get it. I did not get it. A few days later, while shopping at a boutique,
that pressure returned much stronger. It felt like an elephant pressing on my chest.
I had a 90% blockage in my main artery and a 75% blockage in the adjacent artery.
I was rushed into surgery where I received two stents in my arteries.
Stents developed through research funded by the American Heart Association.
Those stents saved my life. That's why I'm in front of you today, asking you to join me in
supporting the American Heart Association by becoming a monthly donor. Call now or go to
helpheart.org. For only $19 a month, just 63 cents a day, you can help fund the next medical
breakthrough. Get the next person trained in CPR, the next hospital certified in high-quality
cardiovascular care. I'm so grateful to the American Heart Association. Their research
helped save my life. I can enjoy life with my children, my grandchildren, and my friends.
Heart disease is America's number one killer, and your support now can help save your life
or the life of someone you love. Give $19 a month with your credit card,
and we'll send you this special t-shirt that you can wear to show that you are helping save lives.
Please, listen to your heart. The only reason I'm here today is because I did.
Please call the number on your screen or go to helpheart.org. Become a monthly donor during
February Heart Month, and your first month's gift will be matched. Thank you.
Kids love it. Parents trust it. Obviously. Obviously. Explore GJW Plus Kids Series
and Gone Deal campus courses led by expert educators. This is spectacular. Children
will learn values like respect, responsibility, and knowledge in language, science, and more.
Wow. All while having fun. Perfect. Subscribe today at GJW Plus Kids, where learning meets fun.
Welcome back. I'm Tiffany Meyer. The Chinese Communist Party is waging war on small businesses
in the U.S. Multiple Americans tell their stories at a house hearing today,
exposing the underhanded tactics the CCP uses to wage economic warfare.
NTD's Arian Pozdar has the story. People's Republic of China is America's foremost
strategic competitor. The House Committee on Small Businesses on Wednesday probing the Chinese
Communist Party's threat to American entrepreneurs. Ranking member Nydia Velazquez laying out the main
problems the CCP creates. The practices it has employed to bolster its state-controlled firms,
corner markets, and undermine free competition around the world are hurting America's
technological leadership and small businesses. One of the witnesses at Wednesday's hearing was
Rush Doshi. He's the director of the China Strategy Initiative at the Council on Foreign
Relations. He laid out one of the aspects of China's unrestricted economic warfare,
the so-called Little Giants program. Once firms get in, once they get that Little Giants designation,
they get access to an incredible package of loans, subsidies, state equity investments,
expedited patent processing, university research support, streamlined stock market listings,
and even offtake from SOEs and the government. Today, more than 17,000 Chinese firms have been
designated Little Giants. Ninety percent are in high-tech manufacturing, and some have grown
into global titans, like Unitree Robotics. Like other CCP tactics, it goes beyond simple
competition between free-market businesses. Another example of China's war on American
businesses is the story of witness Sean Murphy. A businessman from Singapore invested in Murphy's
Bitcoin mining company. However, it later turned out that the investors weren't from Singapore,
but from Beijing, with ties to the CCP. Just before Bitcoin mining began,
they brought in personnel from China to replace us as operators. We sued for breach of contract
and interference, and then they counter-sued us, a small local business, for $110 million.
It was unfair. It was hugely inflated, and it was lawfare. Effectively, they were mocking us
and our judicial system. China experts often point out that the CCP uses America's free and
open legal system to advance its own unethical goals by hiring multiple law firms and using
funding from the Chinese regime, as was the case with Murphy. The witnesses at Wednesday's hearing
saying the stories show that China is waging war against American entrepreneurs. They're calling
on Congress to take legislative action to counter the CCP. Arianne Pasdar, NTD News.
Six Chinese citizens and two China-based pharmaceutical companies have been indicted
for allegedly selling chemical precursors used to make fentanyl. FBI Director Kash Patel announced
the indictments on X. In a post on social media platform, Patel added that the group had also
formed an alliance with a Mexican drug cartel. The FBI director called the indictments historic.
According to Patel, the investigation involved cooperation with Chinese authorities following
an FBI trip to China in November. The indictments were part of the Operation Box Cutter, the
bureau's effort to disrupt the global supply chain of fentanyl precursors. Coming up, a verdict has
been reached in a landmark Los Angeles trial over claims social media platforms are dangerously
addictive for children. A jury has found them liable with major consequences for the tech
industry. Christina Corona reports next. Are you sitting at home living in pain? Maybe it's
in your hands, maybe your back or your hips. The good news is you don't need to live in pain. Why?
Because there is Omega XL, a one of a kind, natural, powerful joint relief supplement
created from the green lip muscles of New Zealand. Drug free, non-habit forming. It's small,
easy to swallow and it's backed by more than 40 years of clinical research. If you're experiencing
daily aches and pains due to aging and overuse, try Omega XL. Just ask anybody who uses it. The
results are undeniable. I had a lot of joint pain and that slowed me down. I had considerable pain
in my back. Really, really felt the pain. I mean in my ankles and in my my heels. I'm telling you
about something that's gonna change your life. It has revived me. This works. I'm not a prisoner
anymore to my pain. As I was getting older, my joints started to feel that wear and tear,
but then I tried Omega XL and it changed my life. Today I'm here at my ranch exercising some of my
polo ponies. So as you get older, it gets tougher. I was starting to suffer some of that business
and then I ran into somebody who said, look, you should try Omega XL and look what it's done. I feel
better than I felt in the last 30 years. Omega XL gave me the ability to get back in the saddle.
It works great. If you're in pain, I want you to know that there is real hope out there. I'm living
proof. See the difference it can make in your life just like it did in mine. Call now or order
online to receive our special TV offer. Buy one bottle of Omega XL and get a second free. Plus,
we'll also include a free bottle of Vitamin XL D3. Two free bottles for the price of one bottle
of Omega XL. A total value of $115. You pay only $49.95 and it ships free. Plus, you get a money
back guarantee. Buy one, get two free. Call or go online right now. There are real consequences
to controlled media and NTD's founders know that firsthand. Our freedom of thought is the price.
This is the lesson that guides us in everything we do. We know the value of a free society
and we take seriously the responsibility to preserve it. We are NTD.
Welcome back. I'm Tiffany Meyer. Investors gathered in Manhattan yesterday to discuss
the global supply of critical minerals or rather how one country has controlled it
and what we can do to correct that. NTD's Dave Martin and I were there.
China has cornered the market on rare earth minerals. But was this by accident or was this
a strategic move by the Chinese Communist Party? In Thomas Nerdowski's new book,
Mineral War, he makes a very compelling argument. The obsession with steel and metals is typical for
totalitarian regimes. It's typical. It's Magnitogorsk, right? In Soviet Union. It's
massive centers. Without that, without those massive factories, with those massive metallurgical
complexes, you don't have a huge army, which is so important for these regimes to feel secure.
Nerdowski identifies 17 rare earth minerals and says in some cases China controls 99%
of global production. And weaponization of this control is something that China
has prepared with its own national legislation in 2020 called export control law.
Nerdowski explains that China used their export control law to limit exports based on conflicts
or disputes with other nations, of which they have many. Profits weren't their concern.
People weren't paying attention when China was doing all these things. We think in terms of
sales and profit. They think in terms of market share. They don't care if they, quote, make a
profit. That's an accounting thing they aren't even interested in. Now that the rest of the
world has woken up to the fact that China owns a near monopoly on this market, Western investors
are starting to take notice. Nerdowski, who's a portfolio manager for Amvest Capital, is leading
the way. When he first conceived of this idea for a critical metals fund that avoided Chinese
investments, I worked with him on the concept. I advised him on the concept. I tried to convince
investors to put money into the fund. But five, 10 years ago, no one was interested. Now it's
the hot topic du jour in the financial markets. There is a much greater interest in metals now
than there was 12 months ago, 24, or any time prior in my career. There's probably a lot of
minerals that are sitting in our backyard that we haven't really been looking for, knowing that we
could never bring them up anyway. Now I think we have a different attitude. It's about national
security. It's about making sure that we're self-sufficient. Although countries like the
United States still lag well behind China in terms of their rare earth minerals production,
awareness and investment into domestic mining is on the rise. I'm Dave Martin for NTD News.
A Los Angeles jury has found Meta and YouTube liable in a landmark case over claims their
platforms harmed children. The ruling could reshape how social media companies are held
accountable. NTD's Christina Corona reports from the courthouse. A verdict was made in the
landmark social media addiction trial accusing big tech companies Instagram and YouTube of designing
platforms that are addictive and harmful to children. The decision was made Wednesday morning
after nine days of jury deliberations. At the center of the case is 20-year-old Kaylee GM,
who testified she began using YouTube at age six and Instagram at nine, often spending hours on the
apps. After five weeks of testimony from experts, executives and whistleblowers, jurors weighed
whether Kaylee's mental health struggles were driven by social media or other factors like
family history and environment. Her attorneys argued the app's features like endless scrolling,
autoplay and notifications were designed to keep young users hooked, contributing to depression,
anxiety, suicidal thoughts and body dysmorphia. Jurors agreed, finding both companies negligent
in how their platforms were designed and operated, and saying that negligence was a substantial
factor in Kaylee's mental health struggles. The verdict was a finding of liability on all counts
against both Meta and YouTube. They found that Meta was negligent in the way they designed and
operated their platform. They found that Meta failed to give what a reasonable company should
give as warnings. Jurors awarded Kaylee three million dollars in damages and also decided how
responsibility should be split between the two companies. They put 70 percent on Meta. They put
30 percent on YouTube. Then they gave findings that both of them acted in ways that constitute
conduct that should be punished. Jurors also found both companies acted with malice,
meaning they will now consider additional punitive damages that could significantly
increase the total amount owed. Meta and Google say they disagree with the verdict.
Meta says it is weighing its legal options, while Google says it plans to appeal. Parents who say
their children were harmed by social media platforms call the decision a major step
toward accountability. Stop blaming the parents. It's on you. And this is what this is showing
today. And for parents, we now know that they were manipulating our children for profits while
we were watching and trying to keep our families safe. This comes just one day after a jury ruled
Meta must pay $375 million for violating New Mexico law in a child exploitation case.
Reporting from downtown Los Angeles, Christina Corona, NTD News.
Joining us now to discuss the verdict are Andrew Selapek, social media professor at the University
of Florida, and Gerard Fillady, senior counsel of the Lawfare Project. Thank you both so much
for joining us. Andrew, starting with you after the verdict, parents showing their support for
the plaintiff, held a gaggle, and here's something one of them said. Let's listen in.
If social media was the gateway drug, AI is like the crack in heroin, and it moves fast,
and tech moves very fast, and government does not. So they need to catch up. This is a victory,
and we all feel vindicated. But until it has to be coupled with legislation,
because this could just be like, okay, this is just the cost of doing business,
and then they go back to doing it. And we hope that that's not the case.
And Andrew, do you expect this case's outcome to trigger serious substantial change to the
way social media operates? Well, I think what we're seeing is that part of this is already
happening, and you've had the social media companies looking at ways to maybe create
kids' accounts. They're looking at ways to maybe, with the New Mexico case and the end-to-end
encryption that we would see at direct messaging, they're trying to find ways to remove ads.
They're trying to do anything that they can to prevent bad PR or lawsuits. So yes, I think
they're going to be trying to do different things, but at the end of the day, they recognize the
just substantial profits that they make, and $3 million lawsuit here, $375 million lawsuit there,
it's going to hurt a little, but not necessarily enough that it's going to drive these businesses
to make vast changes to how they operate. And Gerard, here's some of what the plaintiff's
attorney said after the verdict. Let's listen to that now.
If you're 35 years old and you get addicted to YouTube and Instagram, well, same on you.
But to take that preteen, to take that teenager whose mind is still developing,
and to be fully aware of how you can use a casino effect, which is what the YouTube
documents talk about, using a casino effect on a young developing mind, that's outrageous.
And Gerard, break down for us the defense's arguments. What was the crux of them?
The crux of the defense arguments is that there was no negligent design,
that it's very difficult to establish that mental health issues were actually caused
by the social media apps, that there is no scientific proof to that.
And in this case, we did have a plaintiff who had a history of mental
issues, and none of them were documented as relating to either Instagram or YouTube platforms.
So the defense argument essentially was that, first, they should be shielded from liability
by Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, because this is editorial content,
this is conduct, it's a service, not a product, and so there is no defect for product defect.
But the strongest defense that they had going in was the absence of proof
that correlated these injuries to the social media platforms themselves.
And Andrew, there's been growing evidence and studies on the negative impact social
media can have on teens, those still in their developing years, even adults.
Australia has banned it for children under 16.
Is there any significant doubt today about how addictive social media can be?
Well, we're always looking at the difference between correlation and causation,
and that's one of the big things here.
The three of us right now talking, your brain works different than my brain,
works different than his brain, and there's a lot of outside factors that can impact
to what degree we become addicted to anything.
So one of the things that I think we're looking at in this particular case is you just had
the attorney there talking about, if you're 35, that's on you.
One of the other things is that we know that a brain doesn't fully form until about 25
and understand long-term impacts.
So what we're looking at is that these platforms have now been around, look at Facebook, 22 years.
You have an entire generation that we're kind of petri dishing on and seeing like,
what are the long-term effects?
And that's something we really don't know because, again, it's only been 22 years when
you compare us as a species for tens of thousands of years.
So we're not sure what the long-term impact is.
We can look at some correlations to kind of explain that certain people would have
more problems with addiction when it comes to these platforms, but it's something that
is still going to play out for quite some time.
And that goes back to what, again, the attorney was saying is that, or one of the mothers
was saying, we don't have much legislation or regulation on this.
It's sort of the courts that are now the ones who are kind of playing out what changes will
be made or the companies themselves kind of being concerned about bad PR like they have
right now.
And Gerard, there's been comparisons to the legal campaigns against big tobacco in the
1990s.
Your thoughts on that?
I think those comparisons are apt.
And what we have to remember here is that although this was one case with $6 million
ultimately between compensatory and punitive damages, this was one plaintiff.
And this may open the floodgates to additional claims by additional plaintiffs across the
country.
And that adds up.
$6 million, $6 million actually does put a dent even in the budgets, even in the income
of major companies like Meta and Google.
So at the end of the day, there is potential here.
If these cases are sustained on appeal, there is a potential for there to be a substantial
shift in the marketing structure of these apps because companies will be exposed to
significant liability.
So just as with tobacco companies and the cases there that led to settlements, that
led to changes in advertising, changes in manufacturing processes, and increased restrictions,
we may see that happening in the market for social media companies as well.
And Andrew, parents and guardians are the first line of defense when it comes to children.
Do you see this case as part of an awakening, if you will, for parents to the risks of social
media?
Well, hopefully, because specifically with this case, as you just covered a couple minutes
ago, it was talking about how the plaintiff was starting to use, became kind of addicted
to YouTube at the age of six and Instagram at the age of nine.
That's one of those things where you could have the social media companies kind of looking
at the parents and kind of potentially blaming the parents for that and saying, hey, we say
the platform is not supposed to be for anybody under the age of 13.
How did they have access to this?
And that's, again, one of those things, I think, in that sort of back and forth between
the social media companies, the parents, the lawyers, and everything else, I think hopefully,
or I would hope that it will raise awareness for a lot of parents that kind of having technology
babysit your child has some negative consequences to it of just sort of having them sit in front
of a TV, watching YouTube or using your phone and scrolling on TikTok.
There are negative impacts that this has.
And it would be great, to be quite honest, if this was a wake-up call for a lot of parents
to kind of recognize this.
But again, we've kind of known a lot of these things.
You know, the things that we're talking about, this is nothing new.
I've been talking about it with my students for years now.
We've known about it.
Facebook has known about it.
We had Francis Haugen basically as a Facebook whistleblower talk about this years ago.
Just nothing has happened.
And on that note, Gerard, you've also got your pulse in the political realm.
Parents are calling on lawmakers to act to keep kids safe online.
How is this issue doing on the Hill?
Do you expect this to make some waves there?
I think this will make waves and this will drive more pressure for legislation on this.
We've already seen legislation in Australia, in Europe, that is designed at keeping young
children off of the Internet, off of social media programs, and puts the burden both on
the state and on parents to ensure that that happens.
I think that we are looking, we have been discussing legislation that's very similar
to have more law-based restrictions on access to social media by minors.
And this is something that this case will certainly give impetus to those discussions.
I don't think we are quite there yet.
We're not going to see this in the short run.
I don't expect to see that within this Congress making any progress.
But this is certainly on the agenda for the medium term.
And next year, perhaps, or the year after, this is likely as more cases develop as well
to get more pressure.
The irony, of course, is that a lot of parents themselves are addicted to this product and
may not appreciate the full dangers because they have the same issues that their children
are having.
So that makes it more difficult for them to rally around this cause.
And Andrew, final thoughts for you here.
In terms of ideas to keep children safe from social media risk and harm, what are some
key proposals that people are proposing or that may be gaining traction here in the U.S.?
Well, we see a number of court cases that are going to be coming up from school districts
in the next few months in Georgia, Maryland, Kentucky.
I think a big part of it is when we're talking about kids being safe online, it really kind
of comes down to education and letting people know, hey, these are the dangers.
Even if we can't say one-to-one prove a causation, a lot of times knowledge, maybe as an educator,
knowledge is power.
And for young people to have this knowledge, even at a young age, it's like, hey, maybe
put the phone down, don't spend so much time on it, find other things to do.
That can have tremendous value, not just for a child, but really for all of us as our own
social media addictions kind of continue to grow.
And that's really, I guess, to sum it up, is what this case has been about.
It's not necessarily been about the content, the Section 230 part of it, but the design
of the platforms and the addictive nature of the design, not the content.
And that's something that affects every one of us.
And Gerard, on the other hand, what legal options do these social media companies have
in this case?
Well, I think that right now that they're contemplating appeals.
I think Google is more likely than better to want to pursue a vigorous appeal.
YouTube is a different platform.
It has a different model in its design than Instagram does.
So I think Google does have an impetus to push forward with an appeal.
Ultimately, even if an appeal is granted, these companies will be repeat players.
We will see many other similar issues coming up in litigation.
I think that these companies are already pressuring Congress on their own for an enhancement of
Section 230 protections from liability, much as gun manufacturers have done over the years.
So that is the other pressure.
They're coming from the companies themselves for added legal protections.
Gerard Politi, Andrew Silipek, thank you both so much for joining us.
Thank you.
Coming up, a new documentary examines how Shenyuan Performing Arts faces threats and
intimidation for telling the true story of Chinese culture.
Carly Richards was at the premiere of Unbroken, the untold story of Shenyuan.
The highlights from that event, next.
Absolutely perfection.
Hands down the best show I've ever seen.
I almost cried like eight times.
I don't think anybody realizes how good this show is until you actually get into the theater
and see it.
I feel better about the world.
I feel uplifted.
It fills the cup with joy.
Could not get enough of it.
You have to come see it.
It's a must see, must see.
Returns to David Koch Theater, March 25th through April 12th.
Get your tickets at Shenyuan.com.
Ladder control aisle.
You won't shop here again.
Your private business is your own.
The constant struggle is over.
Now there's a better way.
It's HGIS.
We home deliver bladder control products.
We understand how you feel.
For over 25 years, we've home delivered to many of the 20 million Americans who deal
with incontinence.
We offer all brands.
We pay shipping and use plain, unmarked boxes.
If we can help you or someone you care for, call for your free product sample pack and
$45 in money-saving coupons.
Our counselors will help you choose the right product.
And unlike stores, we're always in stock.
You'll get what you need.
Satisfaction guaranteed.
HGIS, the better way.
For your free sample pack with your free catalog, $45 in money-saving coupons and free product
samples, call 1-800-701-6159.
That's 1-800-701-6159.
We said we'd never give in to a meltdown.
We'd never babysit with a screen.
We said we'd never let the toys take over.
Or leave the house looking, well, out of our sight.
Cars get hot fast, and kids can be at risk.
Always stop, look, lock.
With Select Specs £6 specs, you can get 10 pairs of prescription glasses for just £60.
That includes frames, prescription lenses, and delivery free to your door.
And what makes this really special is each pair can have a different prescription.
So it's glasses for everyone.
Selectspecs.com slash £6, 10 frames, all with prescription lenses and delivery for
just £60.
You don't get that on the high street.
Right now, you can save an extra 5% with offer code CG5OFF.
Welcome back.
I'm Tiffany Meyer.
A newly released documentary follows a world-renowned Chinese classical dance company as it rises
to global acclaim while facing threats and intimidation.
Xinyin Performing Arts telling their side of the story with the film premiere of Unbroken.
Entity's Arlene Richards was there.
For 20 years, a Chinese-American dance company has faced intimidation.
From cut bus tires to death threats, to a coordinated campaign linked to the Chinese
Communist Party.
But on Tuesday night, the performers had an opportunity to tell their side of the story
in the film premiere of Unbroken.
Xinyin Performing Arts artists and principals, along with filmmakers and invited guests,
attending the New York red carpet premiere screening of Unbroken, the untold story of
Xinyin.
In 2006, a group of classical Chinese artists came together in New York with a mission to
revive the traditional divinely inspired culture of China from a time before communism and
share it with the world.
Since then, rigorous artistic training and spiritual conviction have shaped both their
craft and their character.
I think everyone sees Xinyin as a perfect show or like a flawless show.
And that's what we try and make it.
But I hope that they can see that behind that it's actually just a lot of human people.
Despite their rise to global acclaim, the group has faced constant intimidation and
threats of violence.
Well, I think what we're seeing now is all coming to a head with the attacks that Xinyin
and Falun Gong more broadly in America are facing the last two, three years.
It's coming at us from the bomb threats, obviously, the spies, obviously, but also
disinformation through the most trusted news sources, supposedly, in quotation marks.
Here, they're trying to do something fantastic, something that's bringing light and hope
to the world.
And you've got a foreign power coming in and trying to sabotage it and silence it.
NTD's Steve Lance investigates performers' accounts of threats and other interference
linked to the Chinese Communist Party.
The New York Times prepared a series of articles against Xinyin over a six-month period.
In one article, it accused the company of denying medical treatment to dancers when
they are injured.
We looked into their reporting, and we saw so many flaws in it.
And we've decided that it's time to give Xinyin a voice and hear their side of the
story, because much of the New York Times reporting failed to include information that
was given to them from Xinyin.
Despite the obstacles along the way, the dance company has thrived.
Xinyin to me personally is a story of hope.
It's a company that brings hope and goodness and optimism to the world.
It's a story of courage.
It's a story of doing what's right.
Xinyin, I feel like I can't separate myself from Xinyin.
It's taught me, it's made me who I am, basically.
It's taught me the traditional characteristics of Chinese culture.
Before, I was someone that didn't really like Chinese culture, even though I am Chinese.
But now I appreciate it, and I spread it to everybody else in the world.
When artists risk everything to preserve truth, faith, and tradition,
the human spirit is unbreakable.
I loved actually hearing the story and seeing how everything unfolded.
I think it's a very powerful documentary.
I highly recommend for people everywhere to go and see it to better understand what's happening.
The film really shows American values.
The family that was depicted in Unbroken really
encaptured the values of courage, grit, and love.
This is a very special film, and it's very relevant to the times.
And I think it'll educate people about what's happening in the world,
in addition to the beautiful dancers of Xinyin.
I'm Arlene Richards reporting from the Lincoln Square AMC in New York City.
And at the film's premiere, dozens of dancers from Xinyin Performing Arts
walked the red carpet, joining the documentary's cast, crew, and audience.
They also showcased a range of traditional Chinese dresses.
Here they are describing their classic attire.
So tell me about your outfit tonight.
Well, tonight this outfit was designed by the artistic director of Xinyin.
So I'm so honored to be able to wear a piece by him.
And this specific dress was actually based on traditional Tang Dynasty attire.
So I'm very proud to share a bit of Chinese culture with everyone here tonight.
This is a Ming Dynasty dress.
The dress I'm wearing tonight, the style was inspired by the period
from the late Qing Dynasty to the early Republican period.
So it has characteristics from that period,
but it's been reimagined to fit a modern day evening dress.
And we're just trying to do our best to bring hope and goodness to people.
So I hope people can feel that.
Each of the dresses was custom made by hand, with every detail carefully designed.
Xinyin, based in New York, is considered the world's leading classical Chinese dance company.
Its goal is to bring back 5,000 years of traditional culture,
what it calls China before communism, and share it with audiences worldwide.
Xinyin's costumes emphasize both beauty and virtue,
with a strong focus on balance and harmony, reflecting the deep cultural heritage of China.
It's actually a story that I feel like a lot of people need to hear,
not just people who like Xinyin, not just people who appreciate dance, but everybody,
because it has to do with every single person.
I hope to understand that, you know, behind the beautiful costumes and dancing,
there's actually much more sinister things going on,
and that Xinyin's been under attacks for many, many years, and hopefully that can end soon.
Every year, Xinyin produces an all-new program with new music,
new choreography, and new outfit designs.
So even if you've watched it before, you'll be seeing a completely new production.
And that's all for today's news.
For around-the-clock coverage, visit us at ntd.com slash live or download our NTD app.
Thanks for tuning in.
I'm Debbie Meyer.
Good night.