TRANSNATIONAL CRIMIN- Mr. John Walsh

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 25, 2026
26th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 7-8, 2023
-Mr. John Walsh
President and Chief Executive Officer, SightSpan Inc., Washington, D.C
Thank you Robert and thank you everybody for your attendance today for these very very important
topics. This is our 26th event and it's a pleasure to be working with Robert and putting these
together and meeting all of you and sharing ideas and thoughts. We have a very capable group here
and I'm honored to speak with these gentlemen. One of the things I'll start with is when you look
at this topic of the convergence of financial crime and terrorism, I want to break it into
two segments. Counter-terrorist financing really came into the world in a very very big way after
9-11 in the United States, followed up by the attacks in India in 2002, Russia and Spain in
2004 and then the UK multiple times in 2005. There was a global reaction from a government
perspective against terrorist financing. The global response as normal was sanctions,
attacking various areas, going after certain types of business and in some situations war-like
activities and actually direct war. This approach ended the angel investor type investing into
Hezbollah, Hamas and others where rich individuals and very wealthy organizations would donate
specifically to the terrorist organizations. Through following the money approach,
these angel investors were identified and eliminated and that changed the approach
and that changed the way terrorist financing took place. The new approach started from
targeting state actors and looking at various methodologies to take criminal activity and fund
which was very very different than anything prior. One of the things that I found interesting is
in order to solve problems you have to look at the history of the problem.
Terrorism didn't start on 9-11 or 2005. Terrorism actually goes back all the way to the Roman
Empire. The first terrorist activities that were were documented were actually in Judea
going against the Roman Empire. So they have a history here. This is a long time. Criminal
activity has been going on since Cain and Abel. Both of these things have started with different
ideology based on greed on one side and based on change and dissatisfaction on the other side.
When you have those things come together, that's what we're dealing with in the world right now.
The reality of it is, as far as crime and criminal activity, there's thousands and
thousands of organizations, there's thousands and thousands of actors. It's estimated in 2019
that there were 250 terrorist organizations around the world working in six continents in 70
countries. That's a big problem. That's 250 well-known organizations classified
terrorists. Now that's thousands and thousands of cells, that's thousands and thousands of people.
So this is not a small problem as we all know. One of the things that we're always talking about
and we calculate very differently the cost of this problem. Terrorists, the cost is x.
Criminality, the cost is y. We need to start thinking differently about that and I think
the gentleman is going to follow up with how we need to think differently. Basically a transnational
organization is very very undefined. Basically the global definition of a transnational organized
crime unit is three people working in a cross-border situation. So that's what we,
the world, call us. This is way bigger than that. We need to kind of start classifying a three-person
organization with a 30,000 person organization with trade channels around the world going from
Latin America, the Middle East, into Eastern Europe, into the main countries. I mean this is
a very big thing. What I always found interesting, like most problems of the world,
it's communication and definitions. When you're writing and policy makers are working and
law enforcement is working and everything, we always have problems with definitions and
languages. So one of the definitions for terrorism is x in one country, y in another, and someplace
else is called something different. Same thing with criminality. What's legal in one country
is illegal someplace else. The words are very different. So it's very confusing. So there's not
one answer that we could all just walk out of here and fix. But I do find that when you look at
political scientists, they're looking at things from one perspective. Economists are looking at
it from another and have different definitions. And then a criminologist has different definitions
yet again. So what we do is we create different different silos of thought. Not just silos of
databases and various things like that. We have different silos of thought. So when I'm speaking
to a criminologist and I'm on the board of a university that specializes in criminology,
it's very interesting because they're not looking at it from a terrorist perspective or an economic
perspective. They're looking at it from a law enforcement perspective. When I look at this,
and I think my colleagues, when we look at this, we look at what is the detriment to society?
What is the detriment to the country? What is the detriment to some of these communities that
this takes place with? And I'll get into that a little bit later. But like terrorism, transnational
organized crime affects the community down to the little bodega, the little store at the corner. It
affects everybody in the community. And what happens is the same as terrorism, when you have
transnational criminal activity and you look along the trade routes, nobody wants to invest in those
areas because their people are afraid. There's corruption. And then what's happening is people
are not investing in those areas. And then all of a sudden the neighborhood starts to collapse,
which makes it open for terrorist activity. So this is unified. When you go into a region or an
area or a neighborhood or even a block or a street, when you attack that street from a psychological
perspective using either criminality or terrorism, the same results happen. That street becomes
isolated. Now as that becomes bigger and bigger and spreads out to the community and sometimes
out to a country, what happens is the rest of the world, instead of looking at this pragmatically,
they start to boycott that area. They don't make investments. They put them on a sanctions list,
which actually just makes the problem worse and worse and worse. And that's something that I
really feel strongly about. Crime can lead to a safe haven country status for some people. Crime
could lead to so many different things. And then the terrorists come in because it's easy to
manipulate the society. Years ago, I remember speaking with people, there was an admiral from
the US Navy and he was showing me these pictures. It was so fascinating. When you look at a map of
the world and you look at the lights of the world in some of the countries and the darkness in the
world in other countries, it's very simple. The darkness wants the light and the light is afraid
of the dark. So then what happens is nobody's communicating and everybody starts building
walls and fences from people perspective and a personality perspective. There's ways to deal
with this versus isolating countries that are doing it. It's rather work with them, work together,
work in a partnership, sharing information, sharing ideas, not just about terrorism,
because I think we've done a much better job on a global basis of doing that, but on a criminal
basis. I don't think we're doing a very good job of sharing information on a criminal basis because
of corruption and other reasons. But the same approach and the same thinking that we use for
needs to be applied to global organized crime activities. Now when you get these two things
working and they're two very detrimental things, basically you're dealing with greed versus a
grievance. And when I could have this debate for 15 or 20 hours, we're not going to go down that.
There's greed, people just want the money, they don't care about anything. Then there's other
people that have a grievance with a government or an official and they want to change society.
That's crime and terrorism, money versus change, this is all it. But when you look at the ideology,
it's illicit activity. And somebody is going to get hurt, and either one, they're both getting
hurt on a regular basis. The convergence started with ad hoc transactions. So terrorists needed
passports, they didn't know how to get them, they would go to a criminal, they would get the
passport, they would get illegal documents, they would get other things. So basically you had ad
hoc relationships for many, many years between criminals and terrorists. One of the things that
we were speaking about earlier, terrorists don't make good criminals. They're not that good at it,
so they actually need the criminals to go get these things. So that's when you get this
intersection of the two and they start working together. That started with weapons, lodging,
hiding people, and then what happened is it was happening on a regular basis because terrorism
expanded and they kept going back to the criminals where the criminals were like,
this is a regular source of funds, which is more of a criminal attitude. So they started partnering
more freely. Crime organizations didn't want the additional risk of being classified a terrorist
because that would signal them out for law enforcement and other governments would come
after them. So they were very careful to stay away from the terrorists and being branded a
terrorist organization. But as society has grown, particularly in Africa and Latin America, they've
come together and they don't seem to care anymore and that's the dangerous part. So you have criminal
organizations that are acting as terrorists and terrorists acting as criminal organizations.
It's a policy nightmare when you deal with it that way. A very good example of this, and people
don't always look at it this way, but ISIS was a great criminal organization. Started out as a
terrorist organization. They wound up taking approximately 34,000 square miles. That's the
size of the state of Maine. They created their own enterprise. They had the self-supporting
criminal activities in that 34,000 miles. They were generating almost $3 billion a year
in annual revenue in criminal activities. So I mean, this is a real case of what took place.
What enables these things to come together, criminality and terrorism, is basically poverty,
a lack of education, a lack of basic resources. I mean, they pry on poor people. They pry on
the underdeveloped people, people that need us the most. This is where they get hurt the most
on a regular basis. That's not new. But we as a society have to start looking at neighborhoods
and countries and areas that need our help, need our funding, need our assistance in so many
different ways before it gets darker and darker and darker and not wait until there's such bad
activity that they get sanctions, which just speeds up the whole process. What are the next
steps? We need to start looking at illicit financial flows, whether it's terrorism,
doesn't make a difference. Criminality doesn't matter. Policymakers need to look at what is the
illicit activity route, not looking at the meaning behind it. When we start getting into the
definitional arguments of terrorism and criminality, we lose. We lose. What we need to look at is the
illicit funds flow. Regardless of the mentality behind the funds flow, we need to look at that.
Terrorist organizations are less successful on these illicit financial activities if we could
break those funds flows, which is run by criminals. And that'll be a lot easier than dealing with.
What we need to do is go after high profile prosecution cases, make it very public on the
corruption side and on the criminal organization side. Let it be known that this illicit channel
is being broken and disrupt the trafficking routes with strong border controls. I'm going
to repeat that again. Disrupt the trafficking routes with strong border controls. And I think
we also need to disrupt the trafficking with strong border controls. I don't think I need
to say it a fifth time, but without border controls, you will not solve this problem.
So this is not a political issue. If you do not have a strong border, you don't know what's going
across the border, whether it be people, illicit activity, human beings, lumber, gold, gems,
antiquities, artwork, anything. So without a strong border across the world, that does not
close down businesses, protect societies. In closing, I'm going to ask the policymakers,
colleges, academia, law enforcement to come together, share information and ideas like we
do with terrorist financing, because it's a hot topic and nobody wants terrorism. It's the same
thing with corruption. We're not sharing the information properly. We can. We have to get
better at that. And we need to finally have law enforcement and governance understand that for so
many years we worked for globalization. We wanted it. It's here now. We are a global community.
People are going to have cross-border payments, cross-border businesses. We can't stop these
things. What we need to do is design methodologies to make them safer and to protect society by not
limiting globalization, but by embracing globalization, sharing information and doing
it in a way that protects society and particularly the most vulnerable of society, which are the poor,
the uneducated and the people that don't have natural resources. So the way to do this going
forward is really work together, collaborate. And that's not a cliche. We can do this. We did it
very effectively with terrorism. We just need to do that with criminality at this point.
I'll pass it off to my friend, Mr. Kampos.
