TRANSNATIONAL CRIMINAL CONVERGENCY- Mr. Michael Braun

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 25, 2026
26th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Washington, D.C🇺🇸- December 7-8, 2023
-Mr. Michael Braun
President, SAVA Workforce Solutions - Former Chief of Operations, U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration (Retired)
So my name is Mike Braun.
As Congressman Pittenger said earlier, I retired from the DEA as the Chief of Operations
where I had responsibility for DEA's 230 domestic and 91 foreign offices.
I'm not blowing my own horn, folks.
I spent 35 years in law enforcement.
Before that, the Marine Corps.
While I was in law enforcement, I was in a number of tough assignments
around the United States, Houston, Detroit, St. Louis,
a number of tough assignments both domestically as well as abroad.
Seven years in and out of Latin America, the Caribbean, excuse me,
seven years in Latin America, the Andean region,
the northern tiered countries of Central America.
A lot of time as Chief of Operations in and out of Afghanistan as DEA plus up its presence
in that country from seven FTEs or full-time employees initially after the invasion
in early or late 2001 up to roughly 125 personnel which included contractors.
And also a detailed assignment to the Department of Defense in Iraq six weeks
after the end of major hostilities as the Interim Chief of Staff or the Chief of Staff
for the Interim Ministry of Interior.
Okay. So I'm telling you this because you're getting a practitioner's perspective, okay,
when you hear from me, a practitioner that also had several years
of senior policy level experience.
So I'm going to tell you the way that I see it based on now 50 years of experience because I've been
in the private sector for 15 years leading companies that supply or provide intelligence
and operational support to three and four-letter agencies in our country.
So I'm going to build, I think, I'm very much going to compliment
with what John and Alejo have already told you.
And probably first and foremost is everything that they've talked about and everything
that I'll be talking about is nothing new.
This stuff has been going on for a long, long time.
We're here to talk about the convergence of transnational organized crime
with terrorist organizations and the gray area, the shadow facilitators
that support both groups.
That's what we're talking about.
But let me give you some examples.
I'm not just talking about the Western Hemisphere's usual suspects, okay.
I'm not just talking about the Colombian cartels
and designated terrorist organizations based in Latin America.
I'm also talking about Middle Eastern terrorist organizations
and others and how they've come together.
So some examples, unequivocal connections between Sinaloa and Hezbollah,
Sinaloa cartel and Hezbollah.
Hezbollah is now and have been for several years now involved in the global cocaine trade, okay.
How do they do that?
They've established relationships with cartels in Colombia as well as groups
in Mexico like the Sinaloa cartel.
I'm also talking about the connection between the Sinaloa cartel
and Chinese organized crime groups as well as the private sector
in China and other parts of the world.
That's an important point to make here is that when we talk about corruption,
it's not just in the sense of corrupting political officials, okay.
It's not just, we're not just talking about members of security organizations,
law enforcement, the judicial sector, the defense sector and others having been corrupted.
We're also talking about corruption in the private sector
because without that none of this could happen, okay.
We're talking about links between the Sinaloa cartel
and the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, okay, and a spinoff after they came
to the peace table and disarmed now the FARC people's army.
Our country has designated about 60 terrorist organizations that pose a threat to our country
and other democracies around the world.
Of those 60, virtually every single one is involved in one
or more aspects of transnational organized crime.
More importantly, drug trafficking and let's talk about why.
Why has transnational organized crime groups, excuse me,
why have terrorist organizations shifted, if you will,
in many ways to transnational organized crime?
State sponsorship for terrorism, it's alive and well,
but it was significantly disrupted after 9-11.
But we're beginning to see now kind of a reemergence, if you will,
but it's still been significantly disrupted.
As John said in Alejo, private powerful donors, they've never gone away,
but we've forced them deeper underground, right.
We scared them a bit, but we've significantly disrupted that funding stream.
So if you're going to keep your terrorist organization
and your movement alive, you need to fund it.
So they have turned to transnational organized crime to accomplish that.
They've got lots of opportunities there to do just that, to fund their operations
through transnational organized crime activity.
Everything from private fundraising, kidnapping for ransom, bank robberies,
counterfeiting, wildlife and environmental crimes, the list goes on and on.
Myriad ways to do just that.
It's important to understand that the cost of an actual terrorist attack is minimal.
The Madrid train bombings a few years ago only cost about $75,000
to basically execute.
The 9-11 attacks on our nation only cost Al-Qaeda about $250,000 upwards
to maybe $500,000 maximum to pull that off.
That is a drop in the bucket, but what you do, what those organizations do have to have,
just like transnational organized crime, okay, it takes a lot of money
to fund your operations and keep your movement alive.
You've got to recruit, train, equip, corrupt officials, et cetera.
I keep going back to corruption, and I will throughout this presentation,
because if these organizations cannot corrupt, they cannot operate.
That's a vulnerability, and I'm going to try to point some more
out as we move through or as I move through this.
So what it comes down to is it's all about the money.
There's a lot of money involved in transnational organized crime.
Retail theft groups, a recent threat that's emerged.
The best estimates are that activity alone globally is generating about somewhere
between $40 and $80 billion a year in contraband revenue for these groups,
or the groups that are involved in that activity.
But a recent RAND study in 2022 valued the illicit global drug trade at $652 billion.
If you look at that in terms of GDP, it would rank 22nd, okay, 22nd.
No other black market generates this kind of revenue.
How do terrorist organizations embark down this path?
I don't care if it's the FARC or it's the Taliban or others, if they are based
in a production area of the world, they usually get their start by taxing farmers,
which is one of the oldest forms of extortion.
They move into providing security services to the cartels.
Transportation, taxing the movement of drugs and precursor chemicals over borders.
That's how they get involved, folks, one step at a time, until they find themselves
in the position of the Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, okay, when they disarmed in 2016.
They have become the single largest manufacturer and wholesale distributor
of cocaine in the world, in the world.
Those aren't my words.
Those are former Colombian President Santos' words.
But yet, they're a terrorist organization designated by our country, the EU,
and several other countries around the world.
So, we have the advent, okay, of the hybrid terrorist organization.
One part terrorist organization, one part transnational organized crime enterprise.
I don't have time.
We're going to blow past that real quick.
Quickly, what are the commonalities between these two very powerful global threats,
terrorist organizations, and transnational organized crime groups?
On the left, we have the commonalities.
There again, we see they rely heavily on corruption, intimidation, and violence.
Those are the long-standing hallmarks of organized crime.
That's where it all started, okay.
If they can't corrupt you with cash, they'll turn to intimidation.
Here's a photo of your family.
Here's a photo of where you work.
Here's a family of your car.
If you don't cooperate, we're going to slaughter them and you.
And if intimidation doesn't work, they'll do just that.
They'll follow through with their promise, okay.
They rely on the same shadow facilitators, another vulnerability.
Those other illicit networks that are in the center of both of these groups,
terrorist organizations and transnational organized crime groups, as one example,
typically rely on the world's most nefarious money launderers
to move their money around the world.
That's a threat that you can also focus on because the money launderers,
if you are following the money, you can take your investigations
and your operations in any direction you want, okay.
Another vulnerability, those folks in the gray area are on the periphery.
They're not hardened like hardened criminals and terrorists.
They are far more willing to cooperate with law enforcement and security agencies
when you've got them, yeah, well, when you have them.
Let's just say that.
They rely on the latest in technology, communications and navigation.
Drop all the way down to the bottom.
They both create permissive environments around the world in which to operate, okay.
I say permissive, I use that term permissive environments.
Many in our government would refer to that as ungoverned space or undergoverned space.
What are the differences?
Terrorist organizations have always been motivated by the most part, by ideology,
whether it's religious or political.
But once the executive secretary gets a taste for the money, it all changes.
They become more involved and more focused on the criminal side of things
because that's where the discretionary funding for these groups come from.
When Iran is providing, as an example, Hezbollah or Hamas, you know,
with their annual tranche of state-sponsored money, okay,
they're going to tell them how to spend that money.
The money that these groups generate from transnational organized crime is discretionary.
They can use it however they want.
They don't let go of ideology, folks, because they use ideology to recruit
and basically control the young combatants that they need
within their organizations to do the dirty work.
But it's all blue smoke and mirrors.
So let me just, look, I'm not going to read all these things to you.
I'm not going to hit on all of them.
We're almost out of time.
But there are some things that I do believe that we need to point out here.
Some things that I don't think have been analyzed appropriately, if at all.
Shoot down to the center there, okay, roughly just above the center.
Both rely on the hallmarks of organized crime.
I've mentioned that, okay.
This results in mutually beneficial outcomes, if you will, for both groups
that are occupying the same space at the same time
in under-governed spaces around the world.
And I'll go back to Colombia for just a minute.
Anytime the FARC attacked and further disabled the country of the government of Colombia
through attacks or through corruption, the old Medellin and Cali cartels benefited equally.
Anytime those two organizations were successful in their attacks to the government,
are further corrupting officials and destabilizing the government, the FARC benefited.
It's a, it gives new meaning, really, to, well,
it just turns into a very harmonious, very nasty outcome.
This is extremely important.
Both, the leaders of both of these types of organizations, folks,
send their toughest young sergeants and lieutenants to these under-governed spaces
to establish and manage their operations.
Ruthless, tough, young sergeants and lieutenants.
And when you compress them in ungoverned space, it really results in a very,
very dangerous outcome because these guys are staying in the same shady hotels.
They're hanging out in the same smoke-filled bars.
And I don't want to sound too crude, but they're sharing the same sweaty prostitutes.
And when you bond in areas of the world under those kinds of conditions,
you build ultimately some lifelong personal relations.
Here's what keeps me awake after all these years.
Okay? What keeps me awake all these years later is those personal relationships
that were made under those conditions can and will develop
into strong interorganizational relationships because those young sergeants
and lieutenants are going to naturally percolate to the top of their respective organizations
and they're going to collaborate.
Congressman, I think I've said enough.
I've covered it all.
You were great.
Thank you.
