In 1883, the Anglican Diocese of Toronto had an extraordinary vision: a massive Gothic Revival cathedral that would rival the great churches of England, right in the heart of the city. Work began in 1885. Only a quarter of it was ever built. In 1936, the whole dream was officially abandoned.
This is the full story of the Cathedral of St. Alban the Martyr — Toronto's greatest architectural "what if."
We cover the original ambitious design by architect Richard Cunningham Windeyer, inspired by St. Albans Cathedral in Hertfordshire, England. The plan called for a 135-foot tower, a cruciform floorplan, and a building that would have dominated the Toronto skyline. Then came the funding crises, the depression of the 1890s, two different architects, Sir Henry Pellatt's last-ditch revival attempt, World War I, a fire in 1929, and finally — Bishop Derwyn Owen's formal cancellation in 1936.
Today, only the chancel survives at 100 Howland Avenue in Toronto's Annex neighbourhood, now used as a school chapel for Royal St. George's College — built on the very foundations that were meant for the nave of a cathedral that never was.
📍 Location: 100 Howland Avenue, Toronto, ON (The Annex / Seaton Village)
For almost a century, Toronto planned to build one of the most spectacular Anglican cathedrals
in the world.
Twin towers, massive stone walls, a structure meant to rival the great cathedrals of Europe.
But today, almost none of it exists.
Instead, hidden in the annex, there's a strange fragment of what was supposed to be
Toronto's Grand Cathedral.
Stone walls, half-finished foundations, a cathedral that was never completed.
This is the story of St. Alban's Cathedral, Toronto's greatest church that was never built.
In 1843, Toronto's first Anglican bishop, John Strawn, created a cathedral establishment
fund for a new dedicated cathedral in the city.
At the time, St. James' Cathedral was already serving as the principal church of the Anglican
Diocese of Toronto.
Its spire dominated the skyline and remained the tallest structure in the city until 1929,
when the Royal York Hotel was built.
St. James' had been founded in 1839 as a parish church, and its parishioners were initially
happy to allow their building to function as the city's cathedral.
But that arrangement began to break down when Bishop Strawn wanted ultimate control over
the building.
The parish pushed back.
And out of that conflict emerged a bold idea to build a brand new cathedral for Toronto.
One that, at least on paper, would have been one of the most impressive cathedrals in the
world.
This was the vision for St. Alban's Cathedral.
What makes the story even stranger is that today, you can still see part of it.
At the corner of Howland Avenue and Albany Avenue in the Annex, fragments of the cathedral
still stand.
The eastern section of the choir remains intact.
And if you look closely, you can still see the massive stone foundations that were meant
to support the rest of the building.
So what happened to Toronto's dream cathedral?
Even though the cathedral fund was created in 1843, it took another 40 years before the
project truly began to take shape.
Finally, in 1883, under Toronto's third Anglican bishop, Arthur Sweatman, the provincial government
passed a special act authorizing the construction of a new cathedral, the Cathedral of St. Alban
the Martyr.
The following year, a site was selected.
A new subdivision in Seton Village was chosen for the cathedral grounds.
At the time, this location sat outside Toronto's city limits, and in many ways, the project
was doomed from the very beginning.
The cathedral was designed by Toronto architect Richard Windeyer Sr.
His plans called for a massive Victorian Gothic structure with two towers rising on the western
facade.
The southern tower would even feature a large clock, but the design immediately drew criticism.
The journal Canadian Architect and Builder was particularly harsh, calling it a design
Despite the criticism, construction began in August 1885, but another problem quickly
emerged.
Money.
From the very beginning, funding was limited and construction slowed dramatically.
In fact, progress was so slow that it took three full years just to lay the foundations.
Then things got worse.
In the 1890s, Canada entered a major economic depression.
At the same time, the Anglican church needed to build new parish churches across the growing
city.
Funds that might have supported the cathedral were instead spread across dozens of smaller
projects.
And there was another issue.
St. James' Cathedral downtown was still functioning perfectly well as Toronto's cathedral.
Most of the Anglican elite continued to worship there, while St. Albans remained an unfinished
construction site.
By 1891, most of what we see today had finally been built.
But the grand vision for the rest of the cathedral remained unfinished.
Then in 1905, a new proposal emerged to finally complete the building.
Architect Vau Chadwick introduced a revised design.
The original twin towers had proven unpopular, so Chadwick proposed a single tower on the
southern façade instead.
This completely shifted the visual focus of the cathedral.
Rather than facing west along Albany Avenue, the building would now present its main face
toward St. Albans Square to the south.
But once again, the same problem returned.
Funding.
The financial situation became so strained that by 1908 the church was forced to sell
part of its own land, just to keep the project alive.
Then in 1910, Toronto's new Anglican bishop, James Sweeney, attended the Great Anglican
Congress in Halifax.
The event was held in Halifax's brand new cathedral, designed by a Boston firm called
Cram, Goodhue, and Ferguson.
They were famous for their dramatic Gothic designs.
And Bishop Sweeney must have been impressed, because that same year the firm was hired
to take over the St. Albans project.
This decision was extremely controversial.
Toronto had recently hired an American firm to design buildings at Queen's Park, which
had already upset many architects in Ontario.
Now the city's future cathedral was also being handed to an American firm.
But Bishop Sweeney pushed ahead.
His goal was ambitious.
He wanted the cathedral completed by 1914, in time for the 75th anniversary of the Diocese
of Toronto.
When architect Ralph Adams Cram reviewed the project, he quickly decided something radical.
The entire design needed to change.
Cram believed the original two-tower design was far too grand for Albany Avenue, a relatively
narrow street where the building's scale would be lost.
He also believed the design was not British in any respect.
So he proposed an entirely new vision.
His plans drew inspiration from the great cathedrals of Britain and Ireland.
At the center of the design was a massive central tower rising above the structure.
We even see a perspective drawing of this new cathedral appear in a letter dated 1913.
But this vision would never be built.
Construction resumed briefly.
In 1912, the first stone was ceremonially laid by the Duke of Connaught.
He even used the same trowel Bishop Sweatman had used 25 years earlier.
But problems appeared almost immediately.
Construction tenders came in roughly $200,000 higher than expected.
Then another disaster arrived.
The First World War.
Across Canada, construction projects slowed or stopped entirely.
Although Bishop Sweeney remained committed to finishing the cathedral, the diocese eventually
voted to halt construction.
And another concern had started to grow.
Church leaders worried that parishioners were leaving St. James' Cathedral downtown.
So in 1918, the official role of cathedral was moved back to St. James'.
St. Albans was no longer the center of the diocese.
Then came another blow.
The Great Depression in 1929 made completing the cathedral virtually impossible.
From that point on, the project was no longer a priority.
The final chapter came in 1932.
Toronto's new bishop, Bishop Owen, chose to not take his oath at St. Albans.
That decision forced the church to finally resolve a long-standing question.
Where should Toronto's cathedral actually be?
In 1936, the decision was finalized.
St. Albans lost its cathedral status.
And St. James' became Toronto's only Anglican cathedral.
The dream of St. Albans Cathedral was officially over.
But the story didn't disappear completely.
You can still see the remains today.
The partially completed cathedral still stands in the annex,
along with the massive foundations that were meant to support the rest of the building.
Today, the structure serves as the chapel for Royal St. George's College,
a reminder of Toronto's grand cathedral that never quite came to be.
If you enjoy Toronto history and stories,
I run a private group where I share content just like this.
There is currently a waiting list,
but if you click the first link below,
you can sign up and I'll reach out when a spot opens.
I'm also hosting a limited history event in May
looking at proposed streets and landmarks that were never built in Toronto.
It will be hosted over Zoom, and I'm limiting it to just 100 people.
You can sign up for that through the second link in the description below.
And if you enjoyed this story, don't forget to like the video
and subscribe to the Insider Toronto channel for more free content like this.
And until next time, take care.