Work-Life Balance: Myth or Real?

Serenity Space
31 followers
October 10, 2025 — Asia Society India hosts a panel discussion on aspects of India's work culture that contribute to its toxicity, including emotions in the workplace and their impact on mental health, as well as recurring patterns among Indian professionals dealing with long work hours and stress. The speakers include Aparna Piramal Raje, author and long-time columnist on mental health; and Krish Shankar, author and former group head of HR at Infosys. This conversation is moderated by Urvita Bhatia, psychologist and clinical researcher at Sangath. (39 min., 51 sec.)
#WorkLifeBalance #WorkLife #business
AI Generated·May contain errors
But I also feel like today is going to be a rare occurrence where a mental health professional
doesn't speak on World Mental Health Day, but we get to hear from experts from other sectors
to talk about mental health and well-being, which is how it should be.
I just wanted to say good evening to everyone or good morning,
depending on which time zone you're joining in from.
And thank you for having us, for joining us over here today.
And a warm welcome to this discussion on work-life balance.
Is it myth?
Is it a myth or is it real?
For me, I think work-life balance is a phrase that we hear often,
and yet it seems to remain so stubbornly out of reach for most individuals and organizations.
Across India, our cultures are very, very deeply shaped by hierarchy,
long hours, and also a sense of duty that often blurs the line between
professional and personal life.
And I think you would agree with me as well that the digital era has only intensified this
with the always-on culture that really makes it hard for us to switch off.
But it's not only so grim.
There has also been a shift.
The pandemic redefined what we expect from our jobs.
Flexibility, empathy, and meaning have become part of the vocabulary at the workplace.
And what I really like is that younger generations are asking tougher questions,
not just how much we work, but why and at what cost.
So as we dive into today's conversation,
I invite us to reflect on a few things as you also hear our panelists speak.
One, which is what makes India's culture uniquely stressful and what might be changing?
And two, most importantly, what can organizations and individuals
realistically do to make work-life balance a lived reality?
So I'm really looking forward to unpacking these questions with our panelists today.
I'm very excited for that.
And to hear all of your insights.
And we can perhaps just dive in directly now.
What I'd like to do is start off with some very broad questions to set the scene.
And you can decide which order you would like to go in
because it's directed at both of you, these initial questions.
So the first question I have is what would you say specific about India's culture
that makes it so stressful?
If you could reflect on problems that have been age-old,
but also new challenges whilst you are answering this question.
Let me start with a little bit of data
because I just like to say I write about mental health.
I live with a mental health condition also.
And I guess that's the reason that qualifies me to talk about it a little bit.
I am not an experienced HR professional like Krish.
But I do also work with companies and do workshops with them
around the whole area of workplace mental health.
So I'll just share some data.
And McKinsey had done some study about three years ago
looking at mental health in Asia.
And they felt that they looked at causes of stress, anxiety, depression, burnout.
And India actually topped the list even in Asia, right?
So where we always assume that many Asian countries are similar
in terms of being hierarchical.
But India was actually very high on that.
About 40% of the people surveyed were suffering from something like this.
And they attributed it really to a very toxic workplaces,
especially work cultures, which are very toxic.
And to answer your question, I think, Urvita, you said it yourself
that we are a very deeply hierarchical country.
We are a deeply patriarchal country.
So obviously, all the ramifications and results of that
will be seen in the workplace.
The workplace is not insulated from the rest of our society and culture,
which is not to say that we're a terrible country.
Of course, we're not.
But I think that some of these aspects of our society get reflected
when it comes to extremely competitive, fast-paced, market-facing realities
probably bring out the worst of us in many cases.
So that was the data that I wanted to share just to set the context.
Of course, McKinsey is not the only authority on this.
And there have been other reports by various other people.
But this one was particularly looking at Asia.
So I thought it was interesting to see how we compared with
so we're not comparing ourselves necessarily to Scandinavia
or other countries that are seen as perhaps more progressive on this front.
But what we're doing compared with our neighbors also.
So yeah, I attribute that to really this whole culture of having to do the FaceTime
and stay late and equating work productivity with visibility,
those kinds of things that have been enshrined in the way we work for a long time.
Thanks, Aparna, for that.
I think that's an unfortunate reality.
We also think that the data that you speak about is what we know
from the National Mental Health Survey in India.
Although we do not have specifics around work and mental health data there,
I think it more or less speaks to the high burden of disease
and specifically mental health and mental health problems in the adult population.
But Krish, I'm curious to hear from your perspective as well,
what do you feel about the same?
No, I think Aparna has covered it.
The thing about India is a very competitive, fast-growing country.
And when I've been around, I've seen the same in China.
So it's like there's lots of energy, there's high competition,
and therefore people tend to work hard and work late and all of those things.
And that's there.
On top of that, I think India has this enormous diversity,
not only the generational, but the diversity of backgrounds that people come from.
You know, that really is the other one.
And the different types of people that are there, that adds more to the mix.
And you mentioned about this digital culture.
I think that's really the other one,
which is really putting lots more pressures all across.
Yeah, so I think these are all the factors playing in.
While things have, you know, I wouldn't say that it's really,
you know, many companies have understood
and there are lots of good things happening across in corporate India.
But yes, this highly competitive nature,
a strong hierarchy or still hierarchical, you know, not still there.
A very strong, what do you call,
digital kind of pressure to really respond quickly.
And of course, a very big diversity across all paths,
I think really add to the mix there.
But yes, I think if I look back and say,
and I've seen, let's say, compared to Asian countries,
let's say Japan or something, you know, there again, same culture exists,
you know, stay late, work late, socialize late and all kinds of things.
India is a little better compared to some of those countries.
I think some of corporate India has learned and they're trying to do it.
But still, these are areas that we still need to really focus and work on, yeah.
Right, right, right.
So I think the tougher question over here that I have in response to that,
because both of you speak about challenges and a culture
that is very pervasive, longstanding,
and seems to be having a lot of negative consequences.
So can you tell us a bit more about what your personal perspectives
on whether work-life balance is a myth in India or is it a reality?
And also, if you could tell us a bit more about why do you feel that way?
You go ahead now, Krish.
Yeah, well, I think this whole concept of work-life balance
I mean, this is something elusive, right?
I mean, everybody's searching for it.
It's like that Nirvana state that everyone wants and you'll never achieve it.
Yeah, I think that's something we've got to realize.
Now, and the point that I personally feel that is work-life balance
is different thresholds for different people, yeah.
And I think some people like to work hard, work late, and they're happy doing it.
Some may not be.
And sometimes working hard late continuously for some time may lead to burnout,
but they find different ways to really manage things across.
Yeah, but therefore, work-life balance is really,
I think the issue comes when it is lack of autonomy, lack of control over it, yeah.
That's where I think the challenges come.
And the second thing is when this whole work-life balance
leads to more toxicity in the workplace.
As long as there is work-life balance,
but there is also an enabling workplace,
then I think people manage, they have different ways to do it.
But if you, therefore, just to summarize,
I think this is very individual-oriented, yeah, it's not a thing.
Well, everybody wants it.
I mean, each one has their own particular needs,
and I think we've got to respect that.
I think the thing that I see is where there is lack of autonomy,
lack of control over your own kind of thing,
and there is toxicity in the workplace,
then this work-life balance really becomes an issue.
And it kind of leads to dysfunctional kind of behaviors and mental health.
But there are some people who work late,
some people who enjoy it, and they kind of thrive on it.
I don't want to blanket by saying we should not work late,
work hard and work late, but it's how do you manage that?
The other thing, there are two, three other things
that I think in India, it really is tough.
One is the commute.
I mean, if you look at a place like Bangalore,
everybody commutes.
It's about an hour, an hour and a half,
and that kind of puts extra pressure on people.
Lack of infra in terms of managing the other things,
for women working, the kind of times that they've got to do.
So I think all those add up.
I think it's just that it's a whole ecosystem about infra,
about the commute, about the other challenges that are there.
I was just reading a Gallup report.
Gallup did a state-of-the-workplace study.
And one of the things they found in India
was that India was very high on workplace anger.
Well, stress was quite across the thing.
India was not that bad,
but daily instances of workplace anger and sadness,
India was very high.
So it's just this, you know,
so therefore, I think we ought to take it all in that thing.
So just to summarize, work-life balance is,
I mean, I would say it's an elusive thing.
Everyone finds their balance and does it,
but when it is under pressure, when it seems coercive,
when there is toxicity in the environment,
then that really becomes an issue.
And I think that's where we've got to say,
how do we really ensure that that is not there
and provide the supporting infrastructure
to make people make the best out of their lives?
Sure, sure.
Thanks, Trish.
And Aparna, if I could come, before I come to you,
if I could just stay with that thought
about how it seems to be an elusive concept, Krish,
could you reflect a bit about whether you feel
there has been changes over the decades
about the narrative of work-life balance or whatever,
whether it's possible or not,
do you feel like it's increasingly becoming more difficult,
for instance, to maintain that, or it's becoming,
what do you think are changes over time
that we have seen as well in the workplace?
Do you feel like these challenges have remained
for a long time and they're just getting worse over time,
or there was a time when we used to be better at work balance?
You know, I'm just reflecting back on my own experience.
And, you know, early in my career, I used to work late.
I mean, we used to take pride that we'd be leaving office
at 8 p.m. and catching a train back or whatever it is,
you know, that's what it was as young people.
So I don't think it was, you know,
it was, at those days, we used to also work on Saturdays.
I mean, some half a day on Saturday,
we used to go to office all the way,
you know, trudge along and then do something, you know.
Partly it was the enjoyment of work.
Partly it was we wanted to make a contribution.
But partly, yes, sometimes it is also due to that,
listen, peer pressure that you have to do it, yeah.
But I think what has now happened, I see is,
I think the generation is different, yeah.
I think their needs and things are different,
and we've got to understand that.
I think they've realized they've got other things to do,
number one.
Number two, I think the challenges across the country
and then the pressures on people's time have increased.
And therefore, you know, and the work has stayed as competitive
and work has become, you know, even tougher.
And the digital thing has increased.
So I personally feel that the pressures on work-life balance
have increased over time from where I've seen.
And therefore, people working now are under pressure
because of many of these things,
the digital pressure of responding quickly.
You've got to be at call 24 hours,
you're supposed to get back.
The businesses are moving at a fast pace,
so you've got to keep up with it.
Your own needs have increased
and you want to do different things,
so that's also there.
So I think, I personally feel that the pressure,
and then from challenges have not completely gone away
and sometimes increased.
So therefore, I think it's increased in my view over time.
So thanks Kirish.
And I'm really glad that you're bringing up these perspectives
which move beyond the individual and the workplace,
but also to looking at environmental
and structural issues that contribute
to the idea of work-life balance as well.
I think the audience is also resonating a lot
with what you're saying,
because there seems to be a lot of questions
around what are the solutions to this
and what are the practices we can adopt.
So if I could just tell everyone
that we're going to definitely come to that.
Before that, if I could go to Appanna,
your thoughts about whether work-life balance
is a myth or reality,
and if you feel like there are any generational shifts
as well.
Thanks, yeah.
I mean, I would agree with a lot of what Kirish said.
I would also add that this whole issue
of the global aspects.
So you're doing calls with the US late into the night,
you might then wake up and do calls
with other parts of Asia early in the morning.
So I think that global side of it
also adds to the always-on culture.
To your fact about whether it's a myth or reality,
I mean, definitely in a country of our size,
both stories will exist.
But certainly the stories we hear much more
of it being a myth than being a reality.
And anecdotally, I would say for myself also,
as somebody who's living with bipolar disorder,
just the ability of having the autonomy
of being able to choose.
So I don't even look at it now for me
as work-life balance.
I look at it as work-life boundaries.
And do I have the boundaries?
Can I choose where the work begins
and where life ends or where life ends and work begins?
Can I choose those boundaries?
And so I don't really think of,
I'm trying to achieve a balance
between these two things.
I think of my day as having boundaries
and do I have the flexibility to choose them
based on what's happening in the day,
what the workload is,
pursuing the projects that I want.
And I mean, I would say that I'm very lucky
that I have that flexibility.
But most people who are working,
because I pretty much work for myself,
but most people who are not working for themselves
or working in a company may not have that.
The other thing that I have seen though
is I have one particular startup founder
comes to mind.
They have different ways of working,
which they're able to accommodate
different work styles of their leadership team
when they are working.
So let's say the CEO might wake up early
and start working
and then go and do some yoga and walk around
and actually end up getting to the office
only by 11 or 12.
But they've been working in the morning already
for two or three hours,
done some calls with people,
but they're coming into the office when it suits them.
Or some of the other colleagues,
if they need to start their day earlier
and then they can leave by about six o'clock
because they need to go and attend a show
at a cultural center or something like that.
They have the flexibility.
So I think a lot of this,
and I'm sure when we discuss solutions,
we could go into that,
depends on the leadership culture
and really the mindset of the manager
who's managing them.
So the stories where I see
it being more of a reality
then depends on these kinds of situations
rather than people who are totally constrained
by the things that Krish talked about earlier
in terms of the commute,
the always-on culture, the technology,
the fast pace, the growth,
and knowing that your job can be,
you can be replaced by somebody else very soon
in the job market that we have.
So, yeah.
Right, right.
Thanks, Aparna.
It seems to be that there's unanimous agreement
that we are looking at something
which is very elusive
and almost like a unicorn.
But we'll, of course,
there has to be some silver lining
which we'll get to.
Before we speak about another aspect
which you brought up, Aparna,
which is mental health,
I just had one more question for Krish
around what does work-life balance look like
in the informal sector?
We know that from data,
that economic data,
majority of the people employed in India
are employed in the informal sector,
as a result of which they're lacking protections,
they might have increased stress levels,
and that will have knock-on effects
as well on work-life balance.
So, could you comment a bit more
about the state of the informal sector?
Do these conversations exist?
And what do you feel about it?
Yeah, I know sometimes I feel
that this work-life balance
is a very elitist concept,
people talking about.
But when you look at so many of these people
in the informal sector,
the way they manage it,
and partly because they're forced to do it,
yeah, partly because of their livelihood
and various other things,
they're forced to do it.
You know, the delivery boys,
I mean, during rain, late hours,
I mean, they've got to work so long
to make things happen.
The vegetable vendors sitting with their families
and doing many things.
So, I think what I'm saying is,
while work-life balance
in the corporate sector
is much talked about,
there is something
that we also have to look for.
You know, look at this unorganized sector
and the challenges that they have.
And I think sometimes
we shouldn't really forget that
because they have even bigger challenges.
They have even bigger challenges
than I think much more.
And there's hardly any infra
to really support them
other than their own family and ecosystem.
And they've got to manage through that.
And they're doing it
because they need to make that livelihood.
And I think somewhere
we've got to broaden that and say,
how do we really make life even better
for that large group
of unorganized people also?
Right, right.
Thanks, Krishan.
If I could just, again,
diversify this question a bit.
And this is for both you and Aparna.
What do you think are the challenges
that people are presenting with?
I think both of you have alluded to data
around anxiety and depression
and stress and burnout.
But could you tell us a bit more about,
are there any recurrent themes
that you're seeing
or patterns amongst
Indian professionals
or Indian workers working
both in the unorganized
as well as the formal sector,
which we really need to think
a lot more about?
Okay, if I can say one thing,
I think we've talked about,
you know, this always on culture.
We've talked about the whole idea
of toxic workplaces
and working for managers
or cultures where, you know,
you're not respected
and your views are undermined
and it's very demanding.
So I want to talk about
the emotional overload
that people carry, you know,
that I think that
this sort of emotional labor
that comes with all of this,
which is really unseen.
And I think Krish,
that point you made about the rage,
you know, just suggests
that people are carrying
a lot in them.
Of course, as a woman,
I would say that, yes,
women have a huge brunt of this
because they've got another
full set of responsibilities,
but it's not that men are immune
from those responsibilities either.
But I think we really don't talk
about the sort of emotional labor
that people are doing
as a result of all of this.
Just the other day,
I was in the gym
with my personal trainer
who's about 30 years old,
you know, but he just told me,
Madam, you know,
it's just so difficult commuting,
you know,
you know, he's a 30 year old man,
you know, and he's a fit guy
and he's struggling
with that commute, right?
So all these kinds of things
that how they weigh on people
and how they're supposed to,
you know, perform.
I think that we don't
have that perspective
or we just expect people,
let's say, for example, to show up,
not knowing what else
they have going on with them.
So that was one thing
I'd love us to be sensitive to.
No, I think if you look at it,
what is this work-life balance?
Let's say dysfunctional
work-life balance.
What does it lead to?
Yeah, I think it probably leads
to burnout in one instance,
maybe, you know,
various mental health issues,
et cetera, et cetera.
And to the company,
maybe a lack of engagement
and productivity, et cetera.
I think that's what really
this whole thing is.
Now, how do you manage it?
Clearly, I think it is partly,
if you look at it,
the role of the manager,
how it is.
And if that person,
even in any company,
whatever the culture,
the manager can play a role
making a difference.
I think that's a big role
that they play.
Yeah, I think the role of manager
and the team is very important.
If the team is toxic
or the manager is toxic,
then this is like unbearable.
They just can't stand that.
So I think that's the first thing
that we ought to really manage.
The second is,
what does the organization do
to really enable many other things?
You know, therefore,
is there some flexibility
that people can do
in terms of times, et cetera, et cetera.
And most companies allow
a couple of hours here and there,
and et cetera.
And then they also allow
two days a week to work
and three days from home.
But now many want people to come back.
But yes, that's the other thing.
But is there a culture
within the organization
where people can voice these issues?
And I think the point is,
if there is little more control
and autonomy that people have
over their jobs
and how they do and what they do,
that goes a long way.
And how do we really do that?
I think that's something
that many companies
are trying in different ways.
But I think the role of the manager,
I think is primary.
The company,
if it creates a culture
where there is a little bit of discussion,
people can raise their views,
have some flexibility,
have some autonomy of control
over how they work.
Those two will be very, very important,
I think, as we,
how do we solve this?
I think the larger question is,
we're all in this world
where for many people,
you know, commuting, working,
managing family, managing,
it's tough.
So I think that's another thing
that one has to look at
and say what does,
what support system can be there
to really make people,
you know, manage their lives better.
So I'd stop there.
Yeah.
Can I just add to that, Urvita?
You talked about roles, Krish.
Yeah, this is something
that I do in my workshops
where we ask this question
on who is responsible
for emotional and mental well-being.
And I actually outline
five stakeholders in this,
which is me as an individual,
manager, as you said,
the team,
and then the organization as a whole,
and then the leadership, you know?
So, and each of these
have a specific role to play
when it comes to mental health.
And it's not a situation
when it just is like,
oh, somebody is stressed,
let's look at it as an individual issue
of saying that so-and-so is stressed
or so-and-so is burned out.
But actually,
this is like a collective way
of looking at it, you know?
So the purpose of these sessions
is really for companies to identify
and to understand what those roles are.
I think I pasted a link
to one of my pieces
which talks about this.
Maybe y'all can post it
on one of the chats.
Yeah.
I think just to add on,
the default thing could be that,
listen, here's a person
who's not resilient enough, you know?
And I think it's about,
and is that default about the individual
or the default thing about the system?
Yeah, I think that's where we've got to do.
I think in the past,
we would say, yeah,
many people are managing,
here's one or two people
are not able to manage it.
I think that's the,
as they say,
the fundamental attribution error
kind of plays in
and the bias saying that's the thing.
But if you say, listen,
the default is,
where is the system?
What can we do where?
I think that's the thing.
I think many organizations
are looking at it.
I'm not, you know,
I've seen many companies
have done phenomenal jobs
in building it.
But I think it's a culture
that is not very easy
to change in India.
I think there is a bit of a taboo.
There's a little bit of,
there's a little bit about
this thing about
you've got to have that resilience
and the thing to fight
through all of this,
which I think sometimes
is a little bit of
a little bit of a tough ask.
And I think we've got to temper that
and say, listen,
it's not about,
you know,
while there is a bit about it,
it's not about the individual,
it's about what the system is also.
So I think that perspective
also is very important.
Thanks. Thanks, Krishan Appanna
for a very balanced perspective.
Because again,
you find conversations
leaning towards
what do we do at an individual level
when there is a severe type
of a mental health problem,
for example,
at the workplace.
And these are not typically looked at
as what are the contributors
to it in the workplace?
What are the systemic,
structural, environmental
contributors to it
that need to be addressed as well?
So I think that was a very useful
and insightful unpacking
of how emotions,
culture,
as well as generational shifts
all shape our mental health and work.
I think that also segues well
into the segment
where I want us to talk
a bit more about solutions.
And I really appreciate
that both of you
have started responding to that.
So just if I could pick on a bit more
about the responses
that you gave earlier.
Krish, you spoke about the importance
of what do organizations do,
targeting managers,
the role of the leadership team, etc.
Do you feel like there are good models
of workplace standards
that exist in India?
Appanna speaks about workshops
that she does.
So just curious about
what has your experience been
about models that have worked.
Appanna, the question is about
what is the responsibility
when you try to target
so many people in the system
and really give them
the reality check
that if you want to change,
multiple types of people
also have to change.
Well, I think India is a large country,
many, many different companies,
very diverse.
I think there are a set of companies
which have really looked at this,
you know, large employers,
you know, multinational companies
and companies which have really been
at the forefront of thinking.
I think most companies
now have an employee survey
where they really track this,
and they kind of track engagement
and they track many of these things.
There's also a thing about
how does the leadership
set the tone at the top?
I think that's the other thing
many companies are doing,
increasingly talking about that.
Maybe still a long way to go,
but that's the other thing
that many companies are doing.
The third one is really
creating greater awareness
of these issues.
And again, here again,
I've seen many companies,
especially in the IT services sector,
people are doing it.
They're talking about these issues
and what it is, etc., etc.,
and creating greater awareness.
And I think, as you mentioned,
post-pandemic, this has increased a lot
and you see a lot of this.
Companies also have
what they call as a EAP,
you know, where they provide a hook
and people can reach out
to their issues.
So these are all the things
that companies have done.
I think they're all in the right direction
and many companies are doing it.
But I think there are still pockets
because of very strong,
deep-rooted cultural factors
that I think still play
very strongly in this.
I think that's where companies
have to do a lot more,
continue to do a lot more
to really look at
setting the tone at the top
because that's, I think,
is a very big determinant
of what really happens
down the organization
and the culture.
So I think that's very important.
And I think this whole set of,
because the big player in this
is the manager.
How do we really incentivize?
And if I were a manager,
I'm also under pressure.
I've got to deliver work,
and as they say,
the middle manager
is a bit in the puddle
because there's so much there.
And we've got to realize that
and also look at their role
and see how we can
make it easier for them.
And I'm just talking about
a middle manager,
let's say in IT services.
They have all their employees
working remotely.
They don't even know
what they're doing.
How do you do it?
How do they get work out of it?
And there's a pressure
from the client or the customer.
So you've got to understand
that part also.
And how do we really manage?
If you can get the manager
aware, trained,
empathetic,
then I think the job is done.
Yeah, I think setting
the tone at the top,
building that culture,
ensuring that the manager
will understand and see what it is,
and creating various other forums.
And I think that's where
support groups,
groups that employees
can reach out to other things.
And many companies
have really started
a lot of kind of
activity clubs
and various other things
so that people can really
participate in the workplace,
build a stronger team.
So they do all of that.
So I think creating those
kind of structures
within an organization
where people can really
kind of, you know,
relax, do something,
you know, break out rules,
break out time,
all that really helps.
So I think those are
all the things we've got to do.
But while companies are doing it,
I think very strong
cultural factors at times,
which we have to really overcome
and then continue to do that
with greater momentum.
Thanks, Krish.
I think these seem to be
very concrete tools
that you're speaking about.
Also, it seems like Aparna,
you've tried these
in the workshops that you build,
where you're aiming to build
capacities of individuals.
So what has your experience been
in terms of the response
that you're getting from people?
OK, Chalo Krish,
I'm going to argue with you.
It's no fun if we're always agreeing.
So the point is, you know,
telling a person to go
for a meet up in a yoga class
is like saying that,
you know, I'm drowning
and you give me swimming lessons,
you know, it's like
what I'm saying is that to say that,
you know, I'm going to expect
the work out of you
and then you have to figure out
a way of coping with the work.
That I don't agree with at all, you know.
And I really think that
from a system point of view,
the companies that I've interviewed,
because I've also been
before getting into this
mental health space,
I used to be interviewing
a lot of CEOs and companies.
I've seen some companies
really make an effort to say
that we will block certain time out,
no meetings on, let's say,
on a Wednesday from 9 to 12,
which will just, you know,
give people a little bit of time
to catch up on whatever
they need to catch up.
Or somebody saying, CEOs saying that
let's try not to make calls
over the weekend, you know, to my team.
Or let's try not to schedule meetings
after like seven o'clock.
So I've seen a few of these
moves by some companies.
I agree market realities
are very different
and, you know, there are times,
but I think that
those are the kind of work practices
and processes that I want to hear
more from leaders, right?
What are they doing to give people
more autonomy to their time
as what you said, Krish.
You know, these EAPs
and all that have been there.
They are important.
No doubt about it.
There are some very good companies
that are now offering
all these services and clients.
But typically the, you know,
usage rates are like 10% or 5%
or they're pretty low.
Even lesser, even lesser.
Yeah, they're very,
they're very low, right?
So nobody wants to talk necessarily
to a company sponsored therapist, right?
Now, not especially
when you have AI nowadays.
So what I'm trying to say
is that the recognition
really is the question
we ask ourselves.
Who is responsible
for emotional and mental wellbeing?
Am I the only person
as an employee who's responsible?
I am obviously responsible for that.
The manager plays a very critical role.
I'm so glad, Krish,
you've emphasized that repeatedly,
but they also have, you know,
their targets to deliver.
So I think that it's,
when I do these workshops,
I see companies have aha moments
when they realize like,
oh wow, it's up to all of us, you know,
that we want to be high performing,
but we also want to be people oriented.
And the data really shows
that only like 10% of companies
are actually high performance
and people oriented both.
You know, sadly,
I would say half the companies
don't are neither of them,
but there, you know,
the pressure for companies
to be performance oriented
is so high that for them
to actually believe
that being performance oriented
and people oriented in the long run,
investing in the kind of
HR initiatives, Krish,
that, you know,
you would have sort of sponsored
your entire life and career.
Like not everyone is doing that, right?
So, so just seeing that
as a strategic space
that they want to occupy,
that not that it's something
that's good to do,
but it's something that we must do.
That I think is going to be
the real driver of getting
to a place of workplace well-being.
Thanks Aparna.
Before I go on,
Krish, any reflections
on the disagreement?
Because it seemed.
No, I think that's fair.
I mean, it's not,
I think the point is,
you got to have everything,
you got to have the leader
and the culture in the company,
but you got to also have other things
that really help people
cope with things and, you know,
ensure that there are areas
that they can manage.
So you got to keep all of that.
They are not,
they're not the only solutions there.
But yeah, as I said,
the work itself is a bit of a thing,
you know, some enjoy it,
some don't, yeah,
and some have different things.
So I think it's not one size fits all,
but how do you really matter?
And that's where the company
has to ensure that
there is a little bit of autonomy
for the man, for the individuals
to really see what works.
And if there are things
that are not working for them,
how can they raise and manage it?
You know, I think that's what is
very important there.
And the role of the manager,
because the manager,
the three key things,
the tone at the top from the leader
that sets the culture,
the role of the managers
and the kind of a supporting team
and things that are there.
I think these three
will really help manage this.
Right.
So it sounds like there's agreement
that when leadership moves
is when you actually see change.
It's not only about people
going into yoga sessions and therapy,
but you need mid-level
and senior level management as well
to go with individuals towards change.
We do have just a few minutes
before we open for Q&A.
So I had one last question
and then we'll open up
and then come back to more questions
if there's time,
which is just to briefly
also speak about the issue of burnout,
because it's often misunderstood
as well as interchangeably
used with stress,
although it's very distinct clinically.
While stress is typically
a short term response
to external pressure,
burnout, on the other hand,
is a very chronic
occupational phenomenon.
So in India's culture,
workplace culture,
that high pressure culture
that you all have been speaking
about for so long,
where long hours
and constant availability
is often seen as commitment.
Burnout can easily be missed
or even normalized.
So just if you could reflect on,
have you seen any changes
around discussions on burnout?
Are there any policies
that you've seen that have worked
and be differently to prevent burnout?
Yeah, I think it's
a very important point
you brought out.
Many people don't even know about it.
And many people don't realize
and sometimes, you know,
it just, yeah,
it's a bit too late for that.
Yeah, as I said,
many companies have tried
different ways to it
in terms of,
as Aparna suggested,
many companies have tried this,
you know, no meetings on this,
but it's very tough
to mandate these things
across companies,
you can put it,
but then very tough to control
and mandate those.
Well, I think
there is this thing about,
you know, if you look
at IT services companies,
many of them really do calls
late in the evening,
but they have time,
they can, they travel,
you know, if you look at it,
they leave,
probably they leave work
by around 4.35,
but they reach home
and then they do calls
till, you know, night, etc.
So that's the kind of thing
that they do.
So I think,
while companies
have tried to do all of this,
I don't think there is,
you know,
we've come to a situation
like in Europe
where you can't send
official mails
after office hours
and stuff like that.
I think that's the kind of thing
that I would say
is the gold standard.
I'm not sure
if you're going to reach there,
but how do we really,
you know,
ensure that there is
a little bit more,
what I call,
more mandate for people
to really not,
you know, work that late?
I think that's something
that we've got to try
and figure out
and come to a right thing.
I don't have an answer
because it's tough
to really mandate
across the organization
and I've seen
those kind of mandates
have never worked,
you know,
but how do you do it
is something
we've got to figure out.
Aparna, any thoughts
you have from this?
I guess,
I guess the thing is Krish,
from what you're saying
is that,
you know,
there can be periodic times
when we are all working
really, really hard.
Like we might put in,
you know,
16, 18 hour days
or something like
there could be emergencies
or things that happen
that require that.
But if you're,
certain professions
require you to work
like that all the time
and the culture,
let's say even abroad,
investment banking
or law firms abroad
have that kind of culture
of working really hard
and there's been pushback
against that abroad also.
But what I'm saying
is if every time
that you're,
you're always expected
to work very, very late,
that's when the issue,
you know,
and that then becomes
a cultural,
like do you always have
so much work and projects
and where is the role
of, you know,
how you're negotiating
with your clients
or whatever environment
you're working with
that that is constantly
necessitating such long days,
you know,
I think that's that question
that needs to be asked clearly.
And the other question
I would say is for burnout
is that it's also comes
from not being visible,
you know,
like overwork
is our definition of burnout,
you know,
prolonged overwork
and then with multiplied by stress,
but also times
when you are not visible
to people,
you're not feeling valued
in the organization.
Those are also things
that can lead to burnout.
So it is more nuanced,
Urvita, as you were saying.
