Was Caligula Insane-

Artifact Archives
9 followers
Mar 25, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
During the summer of 39 AD, one of the strangest construction projects in classical history
took shape along the north shore of the Bay of Naples. From the resort town of Baiae to the
bustling port of Puteoli, a distance of about three miles, hundreds of boats were anchored
in a double line. The spaces between them were bridged with planks. Their decks were
packed with earth and a roadbed was laid on top, complete with fountains and wayside inns.
When the floating highway was ready, a young man appeared on shore. He wore a spectacular
golden breastplate, stolen, it was said, from the tomb of Alexander himself. A cloak of cloth
of gold spilled from his shoulders and over his caparisoned horse. An oak-leaf crown perched on
his balding brow. He paused a moment at the bridgehead, and then, cloak streaming, an army
of Praetorians at his back. The emperor Caligula galloped onto the sea. Ancient authors struggled
to explain why Caligula had constructed his colossal bridge. One speculated that he wished
to demonstrate his power over the sea. Another suggested that he was trying to intimidate the
barbarians beyond the empire's frontiers. But the most popular explanation, then as now,
was simple. The emperor was insane. The brief reign of Caligula, the third Roman emperor,
is one of the most notorious episodes in ancient history. The son of a famous and popular general,
Caligula had been hailed as Rome's savior when he came to the throne at the age of 24. But by the
time he was assassinated, less than four years later, he had carved out a reputation for tyranny
and cruelty that would outlast the Roman Empire itself. Caligula ruled with a dictatorial disdain
for any power or prerogative beside his own. Soon after becoming emperor, he reportedly told
someone who dared to give him advice, remember, I can do whatever I want. He showed special contempt
to the Roman aristocracy, making distinguished senators hold his napkin at banquets, or hitch
their togas and jog beside his chariot. Eventually, he began to present himself as a living god,
receiving the veneration of his subjects from a throne flanked by statues of the divine twins,
Castor and Pollux. His private life was equally unrestrained, as we'll see after a brief word
about this video's sponsor. Established Titles offers certificates to small plots of land in
which, in keeping with a historic Scottish custom, allow recipients to call themselves
lord or lady. If you are so inclined, you can even change your name officially in certain documents.
I can attest to this, since I have a certificate informing all and sundry that I may style myself
Lord Garrett Ryan. Each title pack gives you at least one square foot of land on a private estate
in Eddleston, Scotland, along with an official certificate featuring a unique plot number.
Since Established Titles plants a tree after every purchase and works with global charities
One Tree Planted and Trees for the Future, it's a fun and novel way to preserve the natural
woodlands of Scotland while helping global reforestation efforts. As an additional perk,
the first 200 people who purchase a title pack with my link will be granted plots quite close
to mine and join the Toldenstone Kingdom. Established Titles makes a great last-minute
gift, so take advantage of the massive Black Friday sale going on now. Head to
establishedtitles.com slash toldenstone and use the code toldenstone for an additional 10% off.
Back to the crimes of Caligula. The emperor bathed in perfumed oil, dissolved pearls in his drinks,
and gilded the food served at his banquets. On Lake Nemi, just outside Rome, he ordered the
construction of two magnificent luxury barges. When their remains were uncovered in the early
20th century, archaeologists found traces of heated marble floors, rotating statue platforms,
and pumps for hot and cold water baths. Caligula's casual disregard for human life was legendary.
Once, when the price of meat was high, he fed prisoners to the lions and bears scheduled to
appear in the arena. He executed scores of political opponents, sometimes forcing parents
to witness the deaths of their sons. He burned a man alive for writing a poem that poked fun
at his regime, beat slaves to death with chains, and had prisoners bled dry with dozens of tiny
cuts. The emperor's eccentricities were even more notorious than his cruelty. He especially liked
to dress as one of the gods, and could be seen sauntering about with the trident of Neptune,
the caduceus of Mercury, or the golden beard and thunderbolt of Jupiter. His belief in his own
divinity was so strong that he was said to stand at windows after dark, calling the moon goddess
down to his bed. Once, in the middle of the night, Caligula summoned three senators to the palace.
As they stood in the audience hall, sure that they were about to be executed, the emperor emerged in a
flowing tunic, performed a dance to the tune of flutes and cymbals, and flitted from the room
without saying a word. Once Caligula was safely dead, historians of his reign agreed that he had
been mad. Some speculated that a fever had been the cause. Others blamed a love potion administered
by his wife. Still others thought that his madness stemmed from innate character flaws.
Representations of the emperor in pop culture, most famously the movie Caligula and the BBC
series iClaudius, have taken their lead from the ancient sources, and presented the emperor as
insane. A surge of interest over the past decade has inspired a mini-series on Netflix, some
impressively bloody comic books, and a progressive metal band called Caligula's Horse, all of which
reference the emperor's supposed madness. As so often, however, the historical truth is less
straightforward. Any assessment of Caligula's mental condition has to begin with his political position.
For the first few centuries of its existence, the Roman Empire was a military autocracy masquerading,
ever less convincingly, as a republic. Emperors were expected to at least gesture toward including
the traditional ruling class in important decisions. That fiction, transparent though it was,
continued to be important. It mattered whether the aristocracy felt respected, not least because
aristocrats tended to write the histories. Caligula, who ignored the compromises underpinning
his power, was never destined to be remembered fondly by senatorial historians. That legacy was
guaranteed by his assassination. His successor Claudius had to distance himself from the murdered
emperor without condemning the imperial power he had inherited. He did this by labeling Caligula
a tyrant. Historians working under his reign followed the court's lead. Their accounts should
Take, for example, the allegation, repeated by several of our sources, that Caligula was involved
in an incestuous relationship with his sister Drusilla. Suetonius's biography lists the evidence,
which boils down to a rumor that the emperor's grandmother had caught him in flagrante,
the favor he showed Drusilla during his reign, and his grief when she died. This is less than
compelling, especially when combined with the fact that several other ancient authors
fail to make any mention of Caligula's relations with his relations. The most notorious instance
of the emperor's supposed madness is equally suspect. That Caligula made his horse consul
is a staple of pop history. Suetonius, however, makes it clear that he never actually did this,
but was only rumored to have considered it. He was certainly fond of racing in general,
and of his horse Incitatus in particular, going so far as to build a palatial stable
with marble stalls and ivory mangers. But the rumor that Caligula planned to appoint
Incitatus consul seems to have originated from nothing more than one of the emperor's sardonic
puns. Explanations can be posited for the most outlandish of Caligula's exploits.
Sometime in the spring of 40 AD, for example, the emperor led a large army to the English Channel.
If we can believe our sources, he drew his forces up in full battle array, then ordered
the troops to gather seashells from the beach as spoils of their victory over the ocean.
This puzzling episode has generated dozens of interpretations. Some, such as the theory
that Caligula wanted his soldiers to use the shells as missiles in their military exercises,
are unlikely, but others are plausible. Since the Latin word for shell can also mean boat or hut,
for example, some commentators see Caligula's command as an order to gather an invasion fleet
or to break camp. Perhaps the most likely explanation is that Caligula really did
order his soldiers to gather shells, not from some megalomaniacal delusion, but as part of
a ceremony centered on the surrender of a British king. Even the colossal floating bridge at Baiae
likely had a symbolic purpose. Caligula crossed it twice, first at the head of an army in full
array, then in a chariot followed by wagons of treasure. Both crossings were pageants,
borrowing motifs from history and ritual to imitate, respectively, a battlefield charge
and a triumph. Although the precise significance is uncertain, the basic meaning of both processions
and the bridge itself is clear. They were nothing more or less than statements of imperial power.
For all their silences and distortions, our sources present a basically coherent portrait
or caricature of Caligula. To the extent that this picture was drawn for life, as we must assume it
was, if only an outline, we can glimpse the historical Caligula. Our sources show, or seem to
show, a strange and unsettling figure, witty, even charming, capable of statesmanship, but untroubled
by the slightest sense of moral responsibility. Caligula was erratic, eccentric, megalomaniacal,
and murderous. But there is no reason to assume that he was insane. For more on Caligula,
follow the link on screen to my tour of Baiae, where one side of the famous floating bridge was
anchored. Follow the link in the upper right-hand corner to visit Tolandstone Footnotes, where
you'll find my podcast, live streams, and much more. Please consider supporting my channels on
Patreon. You might also enjoy my book, Naked Statues, Back Gladiators, and Whorlophants.
Thanks for watching.
