Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio vs BMW M3 | Who makes the better performance car?

Cars Arena
18 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 22, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
This is the new Alfa Romeo Giulia Quadrifoglio and honestly not much has changed since we first saw
this car in 2016 but then it didn't really need to. Alfa Romeo knew they were on to a winner so
apart from a bit more power, a few cosmetic changes and
a new limited-slip differential it's pretty much the same.
Trouble is between the 2016 launch of the Giulia QV and now this updated model,
rivals BMW have been very busy creating this, the BMW M3.
And as you might expect it's brilliant. So far in car magazine tests it's seen off the Audi RS4,
the hybrid Mercedes-AMG C63 S and the Audi RS6 but this is the first time
we've pitted Italy against Germany in a battle of the best super saloons.
Just on that point about saloons you might have noticed that the M3 definitely is not a saloon,
it's the M3 Touring and the reason for that is because car magazine has been running this very
car for the last few months on its long-term fleet but I can confirm that having driven the
M3 Touring and the M3 Saloon extensively there's no significant difference driving-wise between
the two. Anyway back to the video. We'll start behind the wheel of the Giulia Quadrifoglio as
it is technically speaking the newest car here. You can spot the latest version of the QV thanks
to its new 3x3 headlights with very effective adaptive LED matrix tech, standard fit dark
5-hole 19-inch alloys and a revised rear light cluster. Plus on the inside a new 12.3-inch
digital dashboard display with the delightful heritage dial mode also debuts. Honestly though
that's not what this car is about. What it is about is the feeling you get when you're driving
it and the first thing that strikes me when I get in one of these is that you can drive off in town
and on the motorway and it doesn't feel like a serious performance car. It doesn't feel like a
Quadrifoglio and I mean that in a good way because it plays the whole dual personality thing very
well indeed. You've got your drive modes down here so advanced efficiency, normal, dynamic
and race and there's no kind of customization apart from switching the damper setting if you
want to soften it off when you're in the sportier modes. But if you just leave it in normal it's a
nice quite comfortable thing to drive around in. It's also quiet apart from some wind noise around
the wing mirror. The ride is good for something this performance focused and you just get the
feeling that this car glides or flits along the road. It doesn't feel like a 500 brake horsepower
super saloon that's saying I must crush the very tarmac that sits beneath me. There's none of that
going on at all. What the Giulia Quadrifoglio does exceptionally well is make driving at five or six
or seven tenths a hugely enjoyable experience. Part of this is down to the weight because at the time
of filming the Giulia QV's 1660 kilogram curb weight is around 150 kilograms less than the
equivalent rear wheel drive M3 saloon. However with the M4 becoming xDrive only it's not hard to see
the M3 following suit at some point and this would add an extra 50 kilograms or so. As such the Giulia
QV's adaptive dampers have to do less work and that's apparent in its wonderfully flowing field.
I'm also a big fan of the steering. I mean the wheel itself is one of the
nicest in any normal car that's on sale today. It feels nice in your hands, the materials are good,
it's a nice size, there's a nice engine start button down there, it's got proper buttons and
the paddles are, I mean they're fantastic. But also the rack is super quick and accurate. It is
really quite something. I mean if you just wiggle the wheel like that the whole car moves around.
It's so, so fast in this thing. I remember when it came out a few years ago it almost felt a bit
too quick but I don't think it is. It's not nervous so that if you so much as sneeze you end up in a
bush. It doesn't do that. It quietens down on the motorway but it is incredibly accurate and every
time you make a move the car shifts with it. It pivots around it and what's really impressive is
that there are other cars with quick steering. Perhaps not as quick as this but it's not something
that's unique to the Giulia Quadrifoglio but what this does is the rear end can keep up with the
quick steering. You often find that the rear end can't cash the checks that the steering is writing
but in this it does. The rear of the car follows the front and it feels so cohesive.
And speaking of the rear end, Alfa's new diff is probably the most significant mechanical
alteration on the new Giulia QV. Previously it was an electronic limited slip diff that
often felt inconsistent when powering away from tight corners and didn't stand up well
under hard use. Now however it's mechanical and far more consistent in its actions.
I don't think it loses anything becoming a mechanical diff from an electronic setup but
what you do gain especially in the slower corners is consistency. You want to know that you can
rotate it with the throttle and just help the car around and with the old setup it didn't always do
that. Now though it just does exactly what you expect it to. Also notice how smooth this 2.9 litre
turbocharged V6 engine is. It is absolutely silky. You could say it's a cut down Ferrari
488 engine which is pretty high praise when this is a four-door saloon car and power is now up
to 513 brake horsepower up from 503. I can't really tell a difference if I'm
being brutally honest. It's still very quick but it doesn't feel any quicker than before.
There's not a huge amount of noise from the engine. Instead it seems to come
almost entirely from the exhaust pipes but it's a nice noise if a little muted.
443 pounds foot of torque comes in from 2500 rpm and does so smoothly while the
run to the red line now higher than before is both incredibly brisk and satisfying.
Also these gearshift paddles. Did I mention how much I like them? There's so many cars now that
get them wrong. They're too small, they're plasticky. In this they're big metal units
and they feel fantastic when you use them. I'm not entirely convinced the box they're
attached to is perfect. It can be a bit clunky at low speeds, a little bit too aggressive and
then when you want to quickly down change it's not bad but sometimes especially if
you go for a double change quickly you can catch it out a bit and it is starting to feel
a little bit older than some rivals. I mean I can see why Alfa Romeo has barely changed this car
several years on from when it first came out. It is still phenomenal. My only lingering thought
about the driving experience is is it a bit of a 7 tenths or an 8 tenths car because with some cars
you can really really push them and the more you push them the more that you get out of them. In
this it feels like you get to a point and then afterwards there's quite significant diminishing
returns. It's like the body control starts to feel a little bit wobblier and you really do feel
like you've hit this car's potential. That's the only slight criticism I'm feeling at the moment
but other than that it is awesome. So Alfa Romeo has taken an already very good car and made it
even better. Not by much but is it enough to hold off the M3? At the time of filming the saloon
versions of both cars cost from around £80,000. Both deliver around 500 brake horsepower and both
are at the top of their game. But which is better? Well you know what I've just got in the M3 from
the Giulia Quadrifoglio and the first thing that strikes me is the seating position. Now these are
the optional £4,000 carbon seats so they are expensive but I can sit so low in the car it feels
fantastic from where I'm sitting. It's a proper performance car driving position. I mean I know
these seats they won't be for everyone. I've heard from some people that they are very uncomfortable
so I guess it just depends on your body type but for me I'm really comfortable in them and I can
sit so fantastically low. I think I can even go a little bit lower which is just incredible.
Really love the seating position. I've also got way more adjustment for the drive mode. I've got
M1 and M2 shortcut buttons. I can shortcut to the different setup options so I can change the
chassis, I can change the steering, the brake feel. You can't do any of those things or only
the chassis with the Giulia Quadrifoglio. I mean the cabin it feels a hell of a lot more expensive,
the materials are nicer and also the infotainment system is just in a completely
different league to the Alfa's. It's so far ahead.
Advantage BMW then. But it doesn't take long for the Alfa to claw its way back into contention
because the M3 is pretty much the opposite of the Giulia Quadrifoglio when driven normally.
It's very firm and bold and meaty feeling even at 30 miles an hour. I mean the ride
is definitely stiffer. There's more road noise in here as well and it doesn't feel like a
particularly delicate thing. It just means that the BMW sometimes feels a bit over the top at low
to medium speeds. It's less tactile and feels more desperate to show off what it can really do
when you switch the engine, chassis, steering, exhaust and brakes up to 11.
Yes, this is more like it. It is loud, it's shouty. Some might say it's too aggressive but
there's a very, very good reason for this. It torques a big game but it can also deliver
base figures of 503 brake horsepower and 479 pounds foot of torque,
0-62mph takes just 3.5 seconds with xDrive. And while it might be a little bit less powerful
and heavier than the Alfa Romeo, it honestly feels, I think, a little bit quicker.
I don't think the engine is as smooth or as sonorous as the Alfa Romeo's. The sound
is just a little bit more fake but it does come into its own right at the top end. It feels more
exciting. It's got more of a fizz to it. I mean between 4,000 and 7,000 rpm it's a proper rocket
ship. Where the M3 does feel more similar to the Giulia is in its steering. The wheel itself isn't
as nice in your hands but the M1 and M2 shortcut buttons are very useful and the responses on the
front wheels are equally as sharp, if not even more so. We really are at a point where today's
super saloon steers sharper than yesterday's supercars. Nice feel on the brakes. I think a
little bit more intuitive than the Alfa Romeo's, which is interesting because these are carbons
and the Giulias are not. What's honestly so impressive with this is the faster you go,
the lighter this car feels. It almost wipes out that weight disadvantage to the Giulia.
And then there's the steering. It's a very quick rack, just like the Giulia's, but then once you
get past the initial turn-in, so should we say about 9 till 11 and 1 till 3 on the clock face,
that's where the BMW steering feels more alive, it feels more positive. You have a better idea
of what's going on, which I wasn't expecting. As you send this thing into a corner you've just
got a better idea of what the car is doing more of the time than you do in the Alfa Romeo. It's
got better body control and it's got a better front end as well. I mean honestly how, how,
how have they done this? It's just incredible. And then of course you've got that flexibility
with the xDrive that if you want the all-wheel drive traction, fine you've got it. If you want
a little bit more push to the rear you can put it in four-wheel drive sport and if you want it
entirely in two-wheel drive, just like the Giulia, then yeah you can do that as well.
You know the range of ability that this thing offers is honestly breathtaking.
I know it's boring to say that BMW's M division has nailed it again, but they have. This thing is
so impressive. Picking a winner from this test was difficult, not because one car doesn't
convincingly edge ahead, but because both are so incredibly likeable for different reasons.
I really do think that each will appeal to a surprisingly different customer base. However,
the BMW's breadth of ability and, when it comes down to it, sharper dynamics,
superior body control and more up-to-date cabin give it the win. Despite how you might feel about
the looks, the car underneath is stunningly talented and goes to show just what BMW's M
division is still capable of. The M3 is the winner, but honestly if you're in a position
to be choosing between these two cars then you cannot lose because they are both utterly brilliant.
Thank you for watching.
