ARTH 4007 International Style in France and Lowlands Part 3

ArtEcho: Exploring Art History and Critique
24 followers
1 Video View·Mar 21, 2026
Art Historian Dr. Vida Hull
ETSU Online Programs - http://www.etsu.edu/online
Northern Renaissance
20130820 2 France late 14th ea 15th cen Part 3
AI Generated·May contain errors
There are several panel paintings that are associated with the Chartreuse des Champs-Malls,
and this is another one of them.
It's recorded as being painted by Henri Bellacose, and we believe it may very well have been
started by Jean Malo.
But when Jean Malo died, his successor continued to finish the painting.
And so here we're looking at a painting showing the martyrdom of Saint-Denis.
Saint-Denis is the patron saint of France, and this has, as you see in the center, what
looks like a crucifixion, but if you look closer, it's a trinity.
It has God the Father behind or above the cross, holding the cross of Christ, and the
And then on either side, we see two scenes from the martyrdom of Saint-Denis.
On one side, you see Christ giving the last communion to Saint-Denis while he's in prison.
So you see this little architectural structure with an oval window that has bars on it, and
Saint-Denis, who is a bishop, so he has his bishop's tiara on his head, is leaning over
as Christ offers him the host, and then there's a little angel kneeling.
And then on the other side, we see the martyrdom of Saint-Denis and two of his fellows, one
who has already been decapitated, and the other who is waiting for his turn to be a
martyr.
There's a wonderful story about Saint-Denis, that after his head was cut off, he picked
up his head and walked off with it to the site of the church of Saint-Denis in Paris.
It's a neat legend.
Okay, who is Henri Bellacolse?
Well, we don't have exact dates.
We find him in records from about 1414 to 1440, so we say he's active at that time.
And then there's a reference that he's dead, so he had died by January of 1445.
Like many of these artists, he's from the Netherlands, from the South Netherlands.
This would be the area that we would think of perhaps as Belgium today.
And he became the court painter to John the Fearless, that's the Duke of Burgundy, after
the death of Jean Malo.
There is a record saying that he was paid for pigments to perfect the painting of Saint-Denis,
perhaps to complete it, of May of 1415.
Now there's two ideas about who painted this painting.
One is that Malo began it and Bellacolse finished it.
There's no record saying that Bellacolse was paid for the gold that adorns this, so it
was believed that Malo had already begun the drawing and had applied the gold when he died
in 1415.
The other theory is that Bellacolse painted the entire altarpiece.
So here we see, close up, this section of the painting showing the last communion of
Saint-Denis, and it's a miraculous communion.
Christ has come down from heaven and he's extending the wafer to the imprisoned Saint-Denis.
You might notice that Christ is wearing this golden garment with a beautiful cape that
has golden fleur-de-lis against a blue ground.
So Christ is now being associated with the nobility of France, of whom the fleur-de-lis
is a symbol.
Now the building looks a little awkward to our eyes.
It's kind of made out of different parts, a little brick above and a stone below, and
we're looking at different angles.
Sometimes we're looking up at it, sometimes we're looking from a side, sometimes we're
looking down.
However, this was a way of showing depth, and you'll think of the manuscript pictures
that we saw, where the thrones or the tiles on the floor were a bit skewed, exaggerated,
trying to show you depth.
In the center, we have the Trinity.
We have the large crucifix, Christ hanging on the cross, with God as though he is offering
his Son.
This is the throne of grace.
In other words, God is giving his Son for the salvation of mankind.
And it is similar to the seal of the Chartreuse de Champlain, which was dedicated to the Holy
Trinity.
So this increases the likelihood, and I say the very great likelihood, that this painting
was painted for the Chartreuse de Champlain.
And then we see the execution, or the martyrdom, of Saint-Denis.
His companions are Saint Rusticus and Eleutherius, and one of them has already been decapitated,
and his severed head with a gold disc halo is lying near his body.
Saint-Denis, you can identify him, he's wearing the mitre of the bishop, and he has his head
on the block, and the executioner has this huge cleaver that he's going to let fall and
decapitate the saint.
And then his other companion is waiting for his turn at martyrdom.
And here we see some details here, you can see that the executioner has already let fall
the axe, but that Saint-Denis is still suffering, that his head is not yet completely severed.
And here you can see close up these very decorative fleur-de-lis, and of course they are a symbol
of France, and this would also apply to the Duke of Burgundy.
The retable of Champmal is an elaborate altarpiece, and a retable means an altarpiece, and since
retable is talking about something that means back, it's the altarpiece that sits on the
back of an altar.
Philip the Bold, the Duke of Burgundy before John the Fearless, Philip the Bold commissioned
two Flemish artists to create the high altarpiece for the Chartreuse du Champmal, and this was
finished in 1399, so almost 1400, it's easier to remember that date.
One was the woodcarver, Jacques de Bazet, and he carved the interior, which we'll take
a look at in a moment.
And the other was Melchior Brodelon, who was the painter.
Now Melchior Brodelon was the Valet de Chambreau to the Duke, which is a title that is given
to the servants of the Duke, later on we'll hear that Jan van Eyck was the Valet de Chambreau
to the Duke of Burgundy, in that case it's Philip the Good, who is the grandson of Philip
the Bold, and Brodelon was called upon to paint the exterior of the wings, and we have
both of these so we'll see this.
The retable, or the altarpiece, is a carved wooden altarpiece.
In German they call them schnitzalters, which means carved is schnitz, or cut is schnitz,
so a cut altarpiece, or a carved altarpiece, and as you can see it's a form of a triptych,
a three panel altarpiece, which it has a large central area, and then two side panels, also
known as wings from the German flugel, or as, sometimes they'll call them shutters,
but side panels is quite accurate, and these are hinged, and they shut over the center,
and so you can see that they are shaped to fit exactly over the center panel.
Now on the side we have rows of saints with this Gothic architecture above, and in the
center we have, right in the center, the scene of the crucifixion, or a calvary scene.
On either side there is the adoration of the magi on our left, and the entombment of Christ
on our right, as we look at it.
Let's take a look at the crucifixion in the center.
You see all sorts of details here, you have Christ on the cross hanging between the two
thieves, with angels up above, you can see the sun and the moon.
Down below you have probably, the figure with the arm raised was probably Longinus, he's
on a horse, and he's saying, you know, truly this was the son of God.
There is a story that the centurion who makes this statement was named Longinus, and that
he was blind, and he was cured by the blood of Christ dripping into his eyes.
I don't know how a person could serve as a centurion in the Roman army when they're blind,
but this is one of the legends that grows up.
But at any rate, he recognizes Christ, he's one of the people who came to execute Christ,
and then he recognizes his divinity.
The figure on the other side, you see him holding up this lance with the sponge on the
top.
Christ says, I thirst, and they give him a sponge soaked in vinegar, and sometimes he's
given the name Stephaton.
The name, of course, is not biblical, neither is Longinus, but we have given names to the
figures in the Bible.
You see at the foot of the cross, the soldiers throwing the dice for Christ's garment.
You see a ladder reaching up, presumably Christ has died and they're going to take him down
from the cross.
And then in the lower left, that's as we are looking at it, you see Mary, John, the holy
women.
Mary is standing, but it looks like she's ready to collapse.
She's being held up by John and one of the holy women.
Now, you have to think about how this would be seen.
Probably it would be closed during the week, or during Lent, and then on Sunday, the time
of Mass, it would be opened.
It would be opened during Masses.
And so this is on the altar, and that ties it directly to the Eucharist, the sacrament
of the bread and wine.
It is believed that the sacrament of the bread and wine, it goes by many names, the Eucharist,
Holy Communion, the Mass.
It's believed that that transformation of the bread and the wine into the body and blood
of Christ re-enacts the sacrifice of the crucifixion and is efficacious.
Now, efficacious means it's effective.
It works.
And it is believed that it works to make merits for the souls of mankind, just as the crucifixion
of Christ did.
So in a bloodless fashion, the sacrifice of the crucifixion is being re-enacted in the
sacrament on the altar.
And here I have a little detail from a painting by Roger van der Weyden, his Altarpiece of
the Seven Sacraments.
And you can see that there is a carved wooden altarpiece with the priest standing in front
of it, and he's holding up the host.
The host is raised at the consecration, and that's the moment when it becomes no longer
just bread, but becomes the body of Christ.
It was in the 14th century that they changed the way that the priest said Mass, as far
as his position.
Previously, the priest had stood behind the altar, and they have now restored that to
many churches today.
The priest will stand behind the altar in many Catholic churches.
And the priest would face the congregation.
But during the 14th century, they changed that so that the priest would be standing
in front of the altar with his back to the congregation.
And so this makes it, what, more secret, more of a mystery.
It also allowed them to place altarpieces on the back of the altar.
And so that the people could see that the consecration had happened.
They would hold up the host, just as you see it in this picture.
So imagine that that retable that's shown in the picture is the Champmal retable, or
altarpiece, and that right in front of the priest is an image of the crucifixion.
And so he's holding up the body of Christ right before the body of Christ, the Corpus
Christi, in the altarpiece.
As the mass is reenacting it, there is the image on the altar, and of course it ties
it in, and the meaning of the altarpiece is enriched by its use in connection with the
Eucharist.
Okay, a little closer looks at some of the carvings, and you might notice that these
are gilded and painted, which makes them richer.
So most of the carved wooden altarpieces we have from the Northern Renaissance are painted
and gilded.
It makes it more lifelike.
And here you can see they've used a large amount of gilding, that's gold leaf that has
been applied.
Now on one side we have the Adoration of the Magi, on the other we have the Entombment
of Christ's body being laid in the tomb.
And you might say, okay, well I understand the Entombment, we have the crucifixion in
the center, and then he's laid in the tomb.
But why the Adoration of the Magi?
Well actually the Adoration of the Magi is connected to the Eucharist in several ways.
Mary is considered to be the Ara Dei, the altar of God.
She's also called the Aracole, the altar of heaven.
These are names, titles, that are given to Mary.
And so the Christ child is seated on her lap as the host is placed on the altar.
So Mary becomes the altar, the symbolic altar, if you will.
And Christ child is on her lap as a sacrificial offering.
And then the Magi, who have come from the East, journey to the Christ child.
And as you can see, the Eldest Magus is kneeling as the other Magi approach.
And their journey is considered to be a kind of exemplar of the worshipers who are in the
church and they're coming to the altar, either to receive the Corpus Christi, the consecrated
bread of the Mass, or perhaps if the Corpus, the host, and the word host comes from the
word for victim, the sacrificial victim in Latin.
So the host or the bread, which has been consecrated to become the body of Christ, is often placed
either in a tabernacle, the sacrament, or in a monstrous.
A monstrous is a very elaborate structure, usually with glass and pinnacles, and you
can see the Corpus, you can see the host within it.
And they could be placed on the altar or near the altar and people would come to venerate
the consecrated bread, which is now the body of Christ.
And so just as the worshiper would come to venerate the Corpus Christi, or to receive
the body of Christ, so the Magi journeyed.
And so they talk about the pilgrimage to the altar, and they talk about the Magi's pilgrimage
to Christ.
So they're seen as sort of parallel events.
And I should also mention that when someone goes to the Catholic Church and receives the
bread, the consecrated bread, the priest says, Corpus Christi, the body of Christ.
Now, the Three Kings, and remember we talked about the idea that the Magi were not just
wise men, astrologers, but they were identified with different verses in the Bible and were
called the Three Kings.
And so many of the aristocratic families, including the Dukes of Burgundy, identified
themselves with the Three Kings.
And not just aristocrats.
You may know that the Medici, who became the rulers of Florence, started out as upper middle
class.
In other words, they were not landed aristocrats from the beginning.
And in the 15th century, Botticelli paints them as the Three Kings with portraits of
various members of the Medici family as what I call sacred impersonations, embodying the
Three Kings.
I don't know that that's what they're doing here.
I don't think so.
They look much more like generic faces.
But certainly that association was possible.
At the Adoration of the Magi, Christ is said to reveal himself to the Gentiles, who are
the Magi.
St. Augustine says that when the Magi, who represent the Gentile world, and he says from
which come the church, that Christ is manifest in the flesh to the Gentile world at the Feast
of the Adoration of the Magi, at the time when the Magi come to adore him.
And he says that the Gentiles make up the universal church.
And here we see a detail of the side where you have these arches, this very elaborate
architectural structure, with the carved saints beneath each arch.
This is the exterior.
And as you can see, it is two panel paintings.
And they would be the outside of the shallow box that houses the figures that we just looked
at, the Rose of Saints.
And so when this is closed, and of course just take the sides and you can close them,
they're on hinges, this is what people would see.
Now we have a pretty good date for this because they have records that he was paid to install
the outer wings.
So we know that the painting had to be finished by 1399, and then he would have been working
on it probably for some years before that.
So Melchior Brodalom, the Duke's painter, painted the outer wings of the retible of
Champamont.
And you can see how they are shaped like the structure within.
Now when these panels are closed, the subject matter are scenes from what we call the infancy
cycle or the infancy of Christ, in other words when Christ was a baby.
It starts out with the Annunciation, followed by the Visitation on the left panel, and on
the right we see the presentation of Christ in the temple and the flight into Egypt.
So there are four scenes here from the infancy of Christ.
So let's look at these a little closer.
We've already talked about the Annunciation.
It is a very frequent theme in Renaissance art, and it also is very often placed on the
outside of a painting because this essentially begins the era under grace, the era of salvation,
the moment of Christ's first sacrifice when he takes on human flesh.
So the Annunciation is when the angel Gabriel announces to Mary that she will bear the Christ
child, the Savior of the world.
And Mary replies, Behold the handmaid of the Lord, and at that moment Christ enters Mary's
womb and takes on human flesh.
So it is at the event of the Annunciation that the incarnation takes place, God taking
on the flesh of man.
Now note up in that upper left corner, the little pointed section, you have a picture
of God the Father.
And so here's our detail of God the Father.
He's gray-bearded, he's holding a three-part tiara like a pope, a papal tiara, the three
parts would represent the Trinity.
And he's surrounded with angels, in this case red angels, and you'll see blue angels a little
further out.
And there are rays of light which are in gold.
So these are golden rays which are coming out of his mouth.
Well, there was a lot of speculation about how did the Virgin Mary conceive a child?
And the theologians had decided that it was by the breath of God.
So this is quite literally, you know, the rays are coming out of God's mouth and going
down to Mary.
You can quite literally see that idea of conception by the breath of God.
So inside and outside.
Outside we see the incarnation.
We see the first sacrifice when God becomes man.
And then inside we see the fulfillment of that sacrifice, the ultimate sacrifice, which
according to Christian church, they said that he shed his blood to atone for all human sin.
Now stylistically, what do we see here?
We see, well, we see some elements that, now stylistically, what do we see here?
We see some stylistic elements that relate both to the international style, which is
of course going on now, and to the new naturalism.
And this is true of things like the Limbourg Brothers as well.
Particularly this interesting setting.
Melchior Brodalom is trying to show you a spatial representation.
Trying to show you that the building goes back into space, that there's a kind of panoramic
landscape that goes, you know, down to distant mountains.
So he's showing you both an interior setting and an exterior setting, a landscape.
And that's the way he's used to separate these two scenes, by having both an interior and
exterior setting.
Now when we look close at it, we see these beautiful curving forms, just graceful drapery
that sort of swings in arcs.
And of course, this is part of the courtly nature of the international style.
We see all the rich decorative patterns as well.
And then we see how he has tried to set up the illusion of space.
He uses walls that recede into depth.
He has the little cell in which Mary is seated, and the little room behind her, where the
doors are sort of tipped up so we can look down on them and see the beautiful designs
in the tile.
And he also uses light and shadow.
You can see light shining in on the opening of the Virgin's room, shining on the windowsill,
and then down below it's darker.
We see the same thing, the room that you're looking into, that's sort of behind the Virgin's
room.
You have the shadows on one wall, and other areas are picked up with light, and you can
see this on the towers and the buildings that we're looking from the exterior at.
There was a tradition that the Annunciation occurred when Mary was reading her Bible.
And what was she reading?
She was reading the verse in Isaiah that says, a virgin shall conceive and bear a child.
Now we can't see what she's reading in this.
The reason we say that is we can read those words in a number of other paintings, and
sometimes sculpture that had the verses painted in it.
So there are many examples of that.
As we're looking at it, she's being very devout, she's reading, and the angel appears, in this
case on the outside of her little room, which almost looks like a kind of antechamber to
the rest of the building.
There are also some items that can be seen as symbols of Mary's purity, or her virginity.
And you'll see these in many different paintings.
For example, you can see where the angel is, and there's a little crenellated wall, and
behind that you can see plants that are growing.
This is the enclosed garden, or the hortus conclusus.
And our source for this as a symbol of purity is from the Song of Songs, in which the bride
is compared to an enclosed garden, which shows her chastity.
The Song of Songs had long been interpreted not just as a beautiful, erotic love poem,
but as a metaphor, as symbolic.
First it was God's love for the Hebrew people, and then when the Christians were interpreted
it was God's love for the human soul, and God's love for the Christian church.
The bride then would be associated with the church, the bridegroom with Christ.
And then, starting in the 12th century, with Rupert of Deutz and Honorius of Aten, and
Aten is in Burgundy, Deutz is in the Netherlands, so we're having our Netherlandish and Burgundian
connections as far back as about the 12th century.
They both wrote commentaries on the Song of Songs, in which they went one step further.
Because Mary was seen as an embodiment of the church, they interpret this as the love
of Christ for Mary.
And so all of the symbols that could be associated with the bride of the Song of Songs, or the
Song of Solomon, can be applied to Mary.
And so we're seeing the little enclosed garden, you'll see that in many other paintings.
We're also seeing the lilies, which are growing out of this vase, and the lilies are sometimes
seen as symbols of Christ, but also seen as symbols of the purity of the Virgin.
And then, if you look close to that window that's right behind Mary, and remember we
saw the rays coming out of God's mouth, well that's where they end up.
Those rays come out, they go through the glass window, they shine directly on the Virgin
Mary.
There you see a close-up where you can see those rays.
And light is considered to be a metaphor for the Virgin conception and the Virgin birth.
As light passes through the glass window, but it doesn't break the glass, the glass
is still intact.
So they see that as a kind of analogy to Christ entering the Virgin's womb without destroying
her virginity.
And also, we'll hear about this later, people like St. Bridget of Sweden had visions of
the birth of Mary, and it was a miraculous birth.
The child did not pass down through the birth canal, it was one moment he's inside, another
moment he's outside.
So he does not break the hymen, essentially, and Mary remains the intact virgin.
This idea was widespread enough that it is part of a medieval hymn, and of course this
is translation, and they had to change a few things to make it rhyme, but as the sunbeam
through the glass passes but not stains, so the virgin as she was, a virgin, still remains.
So here we see Mary visiting her cousin Elizabeth, and the visitation is taking place in this
rocky landscape.
We see Mary pregnant with the Christ child, visiting her cousin Elizabeth, who is also
pregnant with John the Baptist.
So John the Baptist is the cousin of the Christ child, traditionally he was conceived about
six months before, he's about six months older.
And the story goes, this is in the Bible, that when they meet, the child John leaps
in his mother's womb, and that's interpreted as even in his mother's womb, he is acknowledging
Christ as Savior.
The right wing shows the presentation of the flight into Egypt, and once again we see this
interest in setting and the separation of an interior setting and then this landscape
that just, you know, goes up to fill up the space and back into space, as it were.
You can see that the Temple of Jerusalem is represented as a polygonal building, and it
has these tiny little columns, so we can clearly see what's going on inside.
We'll look a little closer at that.
And then we see the flight into Egypt with this landscape with all of these craggy mountains
and winding road that takes the Holy Family to Egypt.
So here we're looking at detail of the presentation of the Christ child in the Temple.
The Gospel of St. Luke conflates two ceremonies.
One is the presentation of the firstborn son in the Temple.
And the other is the purification rituals, the purification of the virgin, we call that.
After giving birth, women had to be purified.
But what we're emphasizing right here is a prophecy that is made about Christ.
You can see we've got Mary passing the baby Jesus to this older man.
And he also has a halo, indicating he's a holy man.
He is Simeon, and Simeon was supposed to have lived in the Temple, praying, and had received
a kind of revelation from God that he would not die until he had seen the Savior.
And when Mary comes in with the Christ child, he says, or he sings, what is known as the
Nunc Dimitas, which are the first words in Latin of his hymn of praise.
And this is one of the canticles of the Church.
And Simeon receives the Christ child, and among the things he says, he says,
My eyes have seen thy salvation.
Now let thy servant depart in peace according to thy word.
My eyes have seen thy salvation, a light to the revelation of the Gentiles, and a glory
to thy people Israel.
The woman who is standing behind Joseph could be one of two people.
She looks like she's probably the maidservant, because she looks like she's younger, and
it may be that she's holding the offering of the doves.
And they often will put a servant in.
The Bible doesn't say that Mary and Joseph had servants.
It seems quite unlikely for a carpenter's family.
But they often show her with attendants.
And the other person, who I don't think it is in this case, was an old woman, the prophetess
Anna, who also recognized the child.
Now I wanted to show you this really interesting detail from the flight into Egypt.
And if your eyes follow the winding road, you see on the far right of the panel, there's
a pedestal.
And on top of this is an idol, which is falling down and breaking apart.
This comes from one of the apocryphal gospels.
And the story was that when the Christ child entered Egypt, all the idols fell from their
pedestals.
They just could not stand in the presence of the Christ child.
You'll notice that it doesn't look like an ancient Egyptian god.
It doesn't look like Anubis or Osiris or any of the other often human-animal hybrid gods.
It looks a little more like maybe an armored figure, maybe a little more classical.
It could be almost a statue of Mars falling off the pedestal.
In the Middle Ages, they did not make a distinction between what we would call archaeology.
They didn't have it.
They probably never saw or heard of or even saw drawings of the Egyptian deities.
So the idols they know about would be, what, classical antiquity.
So that's how it's represented.
There's also the story of the miraculous spring from which the holy family are able to find
water.
And this is a little amusing, almost.
You see Joseph, who here is a kind of fat, maybe workman class, well, he was a carpenter.
And he's drinking deep from his canteen.
And then you see the love of the Virgin Mary and the Christ child.
He's a swaddled child.
He's holding him close.
And a charming little donkey.
So here we can see close-up Joseph drinking.
He's so thirsty.
Such a long trip.
And so you see this naturalism in the details.
How would someone behave when they've been on this trip and they've found the miraculous
spring?
He's filled his canteen and he's drinking.
There's also, of course, some stylistic elements that tell us this is the time of the international
style.
And if you look at those lovely hems of the cloth that's behind Joseph, they're just beautiful
clarabasks, beautiful curving forms.
You might even note that the tie in his belt just has a very graceful curve to it.
And this is just one last manuscript that I think is quite interesting.
It's the Hours of Mary of Gelders.
And we're seeing an annunciation, but there's some things that just don't seem to fit with
the annunciation of the Virgin Mary.
I mean, she's in an enclosed garden.
She has angels to attend her.
And she's reading a book.
But she's dressed as a court lady of the early 15th century, about 1415.
She doesn't look like what we would expect the Virgin Mary to be, and she's not down
on her knees.
This actually is believed to be a representation of Mary of Gelders, the patron for this book
of hours, in the guise of the Virgin Mary.
And I know you can't see it, but on the banderol, instead of saying Ave Maria, it says Mildi
Maria, mild Mary or gentle Mary, which certainly could apply to the Virgin Mary, but it's not
the angelic salutation.
And Mary of Gelders shares her name with the Virgin Mary.
She's probably named for the Virgin Mary.
And it has been suggested that this may be painted in hopes that Mary would have children.
She desperately needed to have children to maintain her position, and she did not.
But the Virgin Mary could conceive even as a virgin.
And so in a sense, I suppose you could call it sympathetic magic.
I don't know that that's exactly how they'd have thought of it.
But by taking on the guise of the Virgin Mary, she's essentially showing that she has the
devotion of Mary, you know, she's imitating Mary, and she hopes that she will, like the
Virgin Mary, conceive and bear a child.
