Early Christian persecution and pagan persecution by Christians a historical analysis Part 1

Hellenic Legacy
8 followers
5 Video Views·Mar 20, 2026
Why did the early Christian persecution happen? How extensive was it and could one argue that it's over-exaggerated?
In this two-part series we will cover the history of the early Christian persecution in Rome. This will include why the roman pagans decided to persecute Christians, how extensive the persecution was as well as the often less talked about persecution of pagans by Christian emperors in late antiquity.
This video will cover the early Christian persecution with part two covering the later pagan persecution by Christians.
Did the early christian persecution really happen? If so, to what extent and how severe
was it, and could one argue that the later pagan persecution by christians was worse?
I'm Koloink History and in this two part series we will cover the history of the early christian
persecution, together with the christian persecution of pagans in late antiquity,
as well as put both persecutions in the greater religious and political context of the roman
empire in antiquity, and through that way, gain a better understanding of the nature
of the persecutions, as well as their extent. Stay tuned!
In the first and second century AD, christianity spread from having started as a small sect in
to eventually grow into a religious movement encompassing up to two to three million people
by year 300, to even become the majority religion within the empire a century later.
However, despite this remarkable growth, the empire's transition from paganism was by no
means smooth, and up to the conversion of emperor Constantine in 312 AD, christians
encountered firm and sometimes intense opposition from their pagan counterparts.
It should be noted that up to the mid third century, most persecution of christians that
were carried out were local and isolated. There were no laws passed against christians,
and to the extent that christians were considered troublemakers, local roman officials had the
The first detailed account of early christian persecution was carried out by Pliny the Younger,
whom in a letter of correspondence to emperor Trian around year 110 AD asked what to do with
christians being brought before him. The suspects were charged with refusing to worship the
traditional roman gods, which in ancient Rome was seen as a matter of great importance.
In pagan society, the goodwill of the gods were considered crucial to the survival of society,
and if members of the society refused to revere them through participating in religious practices
like cult sacrifice, the gods could get angry and remove their divine protection,
which could lead to communal disaster. The way Pliny decided to prosecute the accused suspects
was by bringing a cult statue, order the suspect to make an offering to the gods
and curse the name of christ. If the suspects complied, they were acquitted of all charges,
whereas if they refused, they were faced with execution. Later officials acted in similar ways,
executing or harshly punishing christians who refused to recant, due to ironically
being guilty of a crime without a law. It needs to be stressed that this attitude by Pliny was
by no means the norm for pagan officials, and while some christians were locally persecuted
in some places in the empire, many lived peacefully besides their pagan neighbors in others.
However, as the christian population increased, it eventually started to get the attention of
roman emperors. The first emperor to issue an empire-wide legislation that had a profound effect
on the early christians was Decius in 249 AD. In the middle of the 3rd century, the roman empire
was facing a stream of continuous political upheaval, economical crisis, as well as many
barbarian invasions that pushed the empire to the brink of collapse. Because of this,
proper worship of the gods was called for more than ever. Shortly after assuming power,
Decius made a universal decree requiring that all citizens perform a sacrifice to the gods,
and feared that they had always done so in front of an imperial official. While the decree was not
necessarily directed against christians, it had a profound effect on both christians as well as
the religious state of the empire in general. Up to that point, religious worship in the empire
had been a local affair, and by issuing the edict, an official type of religion was now pushed for
the entire empire. As a result, the persecution of christians were now becoming more common
and centralized. A few years later in 257 AD, emperor Valerian made a new decree, which this
time was directed specifically at christians, ordering the executions of all christian bishops
in Rome, as well as stripping all christian senators and equestrians of their property.
Later in year 303, the harshest and most intense persecution of christians were issued by emperor
Diocletian, which lasted until emperor Constantine declared the edict of Milan in year 312.
Diocletian's edict declared all christian meetings to be illegal, christian places of worship to be
destroyed, as well as christian scriptures to be confiscated, and all people within the empire
being required to perform a sacrifice or face imprisonment, torture or execution. One important
thing to have in mind, which we will come back to in the second video, is that there is one thing to
issuing a decree, while there is another to enforce it. No imperial police force existed to carry out
the requirements of Diocletian's decree, which meant that the task fell on regional governors
or on municipalities. This in turn meant that the enforcing of the decree varied between different
parts of the empire, even though the persecution in the places where the decree was enforced could
be very brutal. Some christians managed to escape the enforcement by bribing their forties,
some apostatized and others ardently refused to give up their faith and suffered harsh punishments
with the death toll likely being a couple thousands. However, in the end Diocletian abdicated
and following the conversion by emperor Constantine in year 312, the persecution of christians ceased,
with christianity eventually becoming the majority religion within the empire.
As we will see were the christian emperors of late antiquity no more hesitant to persecute their
pagan subjects than the pagan emperors that had preceded them, which will be covered and compared
in the next video. Today I hope you learned something new about the early christian persecution
in Rome, as well as about ancient history in general, and don't forget that if you liked
this video, smash that subscribe button as well as the bell icon so you don't miss anything!
