EPISODE 7: ALBERUNI AND MARCO POLO IN INDIA In the early second millennium, two famous travellers visited India: Alberuni and Marco Polo, who’ve left behind vivid impressions of social life. Alberuni, a great scientist and scholar of the Persian ‘Golden Age’, was in north India between 1017–30, when Mahmud of Ghazni was raiding temples. Led by his own curiosity, Alberuni spent thirteen years studying Indian thought and society. He learned Sanskrit, studied the works of Brahminism, and sought out learned men to clarify his doubts. In 1030, he published his magnum opus, Alberuni’s India, containing sharp insights into Brahminical religion, scriptures, caste, marital norms, festivals, inheritance, taxes, crime and punishment, etc. He also assessed the quality of the ‘Hindu sciences’. Alberuni’s portrait of India is so perceptive that he deserves to be called the ‘first Indologist’.
A thousand years ago, Al-Biruni wrote,
Most Brahmins recite the Veda without understanding its meaning.
Marco Polo also wrote that dark skin was preferred by Indians.
Al-Biruni was surprised by the mediocre state of Indian science.
The scientific theorems of the Hindus, he wrote,
are in a state of utter confusion and mixed up with religious dogmas.
Al-Biruni's account shows that on the eve of the Turko-Persian invasions,
Brahminical society was not exactly a picture of intellectual and moral health
that many now fondly imagine it to have been.
Hello and welcome to Indians, I'm Namit Arora.
In the previous episode, we looked at the Chandela kingdom at Khajuraho
and how its erotic temple art was shaped by tantric religiosity.
We examined the hedonistic culture of its elites
and why it started declining long before the Turko-Persian invasions of North India.
Let's now look at two famous travellers who visited India
and their impressions of social life in the early second millennium.
The first is Al-Biruni, who frequented North India between 1017 and 1030
when Mahmud of Ghazni was raiding temples in India.
The second is Marco Polo, who visited South India in 1292,
just a few decades before the rise of the Vijayanagara Empire.
Their accounts add colour and depth to our understanding of medieval India,
with rich insights into how much has or hasn't changed.
Al-Biruni was one of the greatest scholars and scientists of the medieval age.
Not much is known about his early life,
but he was a product of what's often called the Golden Age of Islam,
a period of scientific, economic and cultural flourishing
during the Abbasid Caliphate, centred in Baghdad.
Its creative spirit was more Persian than Arabic.
Its elites were studying ancient Greek classics,
mathematics, astronomy, optics, medicine,
shipbuilding, poetry, literature and philosophy.
The folk tales of the Arabian Nights were compiled at this time.
This was the age of luminaries like Abyssinia,
Al-Farabi, Umar Khayyam, Al-Hazn and Firdawsi.
Some of these men were contemporaries of Al-Biruni.
Al-Biruni was likely born in the city of Kiva in Uzbekistan.
Fluent in five languages, he was a gifted polymath.
He excelled in mathematics, physics, geography,
pharmacology, mineralogy, philosophy, history and other disciplines.
When he was 60, he compiled a list of 146 books he had already written,
only 22 of which have survived.
In his writings, Al-Biruni rarely spoke about himself,
but he comes across as a mildly devout Muslim,
likely Shia, with some fondness for the Persian culture of Islam.
He was tolerant, open-minded and a big believer in science, reason and evidence.
At its peak, the Abbasid Caliphate had highly disciplined armies
whose eastern flanks were peopled by ethnic Turks
who had been converting to Islam from Buddhism
and their native animistic faith called Tengrism.
By the end of the millennium, some of the caliphate's Turkish generals
had broken away and built independent kingdoms
retaining only a ceremonial attachment to the caliph in Baghdad.
One such kingdom in modern Afghanistan was led by the Ghaznavids,
whose second king was the infamous Mahmud of Ghazni.
He is quite justifiably viewed by many Indians as a fanatic warrior,
a destroyer of temples and plunderer of their wealth.
From the year 1001, Mahmud had started raiding India's richest temples
in places like Mathura, Thanesar, Kannauj and Somnath.
He raided 17 times over the next 25 years.
Whether his primary motivation was material gain or religious fanaticism
is now a contentious topic.
What we do know is that Mahmud was bad news
not just for Hindus in Indian temple towns.
In other regions, he also plundered those he considered the wrong kinds of Muslims
such as Ismailis and Shias and even desecrated their mosques.
Mahmud also kept a division of loyal mercenary Hindus in his army
who lived in a Hindu quarter in Ghazni
and one of whose commanders was named Tilak,
a detail that ought to inform our assessments of Mahmud and his motivations.
Mahmud's temple raids helped fund his central Asian wars
and turned Ghazni into a fine city with palaces,
gardens, a huge library, a university and a grand mosque.
From his central Asian raids,
Mahmud brought to his court the greatest scholars and writers of the age.
One of them was Al-Biruni,
who Mahmud had brought as a prisoner of war from Khiwa in Uzbekistan.
Another captive was the great poet Firdausi,
author of the Persian epic Shahnama.
Firdausi managed to escape after some time
but this was how Mahmud tried to be a patron of the arts and science
and that's largely how he is still remembered in Afghanistan.
Curiously, our knowledge of Mahmud's raids
is based entirely on Turko-Persian court chronicles.
Hindu sources are silent about even the most infamous of his raids
on Somnath temple in 1025.
Nor do the Hindu sources suggest a sense of social trauma.
12 years later,
the account of a Goan king's pilgrimage to Somnath temple
mentioned neither any damage nor the raid.
In time, the local Gujarati and Turko-Persian merchants
even began a thriving trade.
Scholars have puzzled over why Hindu chroniclers
failed to record Mahmud's attack on Somnath temple
and why his raid was apparently forgotten.
One theory is that the damage wasn't great
and the locals simply rebuilt and moved on,
much as their ancestors had done
when rival Indian kings raided and pillaged their temples.
Somnath itself was a relatively new Shiva temple at the time,
likely built over a Buddhist chaitya,
a fate that many Buddhist sites suffered in the late 1st millennium.
What's really interesting is that it was only in the 19th century
that British scholars discovered Mahmud's raids
in dusty Turko-Persian archives.
The British cited these raids
to present their own colonial project as more enlightened
and to divide and rule Indians.
The Hindu revivalists of this period
used this discovery for their own partisan ends,
inventing the trope of the thousand years of memory
and its lingering social trauma.
This would soon become a foundational mythos
of modern Hindu nationalism.
Al-Biruni was a decent man.
He hated Mahmud
and after Mahmud's death in 1030 CE
denounced his raids on Hindu temples.
In some of those raiding years,
Al-Biruni had travelled in North India
and noticed the damage caused by Mahmud.
Led by his own curiosity,
he spent 13 years studying Indian thought and society.
He learned Sanskrit and studied the major works of Brahmanism.
He felt overwhelmed at first by the sheer volume of material
but he kept going.
He sought out learned Brahmins to clarify his doubts.
He even translated Sanskrit texts into Arabic,
for instance, of Samkhya and Patanjali.
In 1030, at age 57,
he published his magnum opus titled
Verifying all that the Indians recount,
the reasonable and the unreasonable.
Its 19th century English translation
is simply called Al-Biruni's India.
Al-Biruni's native informants were Brahmins
since they dominated scholastic learning in India.
He never came across Buddhism
because as we saw earlier in this series,
Buddhism's demise from much of India
predated Mahmud of Ghazni.
So Al-Biruni mainly documented the customs
and practices of Brahminical society.
The focus of his book, as he says himself,
is that which the Brahmins think and believe.
He introduced their major religious texts
and highlighted parts of the Vedic corpus,
the Bhagavad Gita,
the Puranas,
Patanjali
and stories from the two epics.
He reviewed Indian scientific and astronomical texts.
He compared Brahminical thought
with the Greco-Roman thought of Socrates,
Pythagoras,
Plato,
Aristotle,
Galen
and also with Sufi thought.
Al-Biruni admired many things in India,
from its mathematics
to the architecture of step wells.
He describes how Indians made books
from the bark of birch trees.
Such a book was called Puthi
from which we get Pustak.
He saw a festival called Diwali
for which people dressed up,
exchanged presents,
visited temples
and gave alms.
At night,
they lit a great number of lamps in every place.
This celebration had nothing to do
with Rama liberating Sita
but with a different story
of Lakshmi liberating Bali
who was a prisoner in the seventh earth.
The cult of Rama was apparently still small
and yet to be linked
to the festival of lights in North India.
Al-Biruni's social observations
are perhaps the most interesting.
Caste made a deep impression on him.
It really bothered him
that learned Hindus
did not mingle with foreigners
or malach like him,
as in sitting, eating
and drinking with them
for fear of being polluted.
Nor did they mingle with members
of other varnas.
Many outcaste groups
who performed essential services
were forced to live outside
the walls of towns and villages.
Al-Biruni despised social institutions
that, he wrote,
cannot be broken through
by the special merits of any individual
and yet such institutions
abound among the Hindus, he wrote.
He called this the main difference
between Hindus and his own people.
We Muslims, he noted with some pride,
consider all men as equal
except in piety.
He seems to concede
that Muslims can be more fanatical
than Hindus about theological matters
but he thought that the Brahmins
just expressed their fanaticism differently.
It showed up in their obsessions
with purity and their treatment
of fellow humans
as innately impure and inferior.
A thousand years ago,
Al-Biruni wrote,
Most Brahmins recite the Veda
without understanding its meaning.
They teach it to the Kshatriyas
but the Vaishyas, Shudras
and other outcastes
are not allowed to hear it
much less to pronounce and recite it.
If such a thing can be proved
against one of them,
the Brahmins drag him
before the magistrate
and he is punished
by having his tongue cut off.
This punishment was apparently rare
but the threat is indicative
of the era's social realities.
According to Al-Biruni,
child marriages were the norm.
A Hindu man could marry
up to four women
depending on his place
in the Varna hierarchy.
Brahmins were allowed four wives,
Kshatriyas three,
Vaishyas two
and the Shudras one.
Al-Biruni wrote that
a husband and wife
can only be separated by death
as the Hindus have no divorce.
If a wife died,
the husband could marry
another woman
but the reverse wasn't allowed.
A widow inherited nothing
from her husband's wealth
so her choices were to
either remain a widow
dependent on the kindness
of her male relatives
or burn herself
on the husband's funeral pyre,
an event that was fortunately rare
outside the Kshatriya class.
Al-Biruni described taxation,
inheritance,
cremation rites,
crime and punishment.
The common people he wrote
lied about their property
in order to lower their taxes,
a custom we have tenaciously held on to.
Female prostitution was legal
which included the temple devdasis.
Al-Biruni's morality
and sexual conservatism
did not approve of this practice.
He faulted the kings
for making prostitutes
an attraction for their cities,
a bait of pleasure for their subjects
for only financial reasons.
It seems the taxes they paid
offset the state's military expenses.
The Brahmins however
were exempt from all taxes.
Even the law of the land
treated them leniently.
They literally got away with murder,
asked only to atone for it
by fasting,
prayers and almsgiving.
Members of other castes
faced harsher penalties
for the same crime.
Interestingly,
the Brahmins were punished
more for flouting the caste order.
Al-Biruni wrote,
if a Brahmin eats
in the house of a shudra
for sundry days,
he is expelled from his caste
and can never regain it.
Al-Biruni was surprised
by the mediocre state
of Indian science.
The scientific theorems
of the Hindus, he wrote,
are in a state of utter confusion
and mixed up with religious dogmas.
The Hindus, he added,
do not raise themselves
to the methods
of a strictly scientific deduction.
His views reflect the fact
that a thousand years ago,
science in the Persianate world
was more advanced
than in India and Europe.
Indian astronomy
had actually regressed
in the 500 years since Aryabhat.
Its leading astronomers
now believed
that the earth
does not rotate on its axis
but is at rest.
So Al-Biruni showed them
how to construct an astrolabe
to understand the rotation
of the earth.
As we saw in a previous episode,
Indian medicine too
had long stagnated,
partly because Brahminical healers
who monopolized formal education
avoided working
with the polluting fluids
of the body.
Such is the state
of things in India,
Al-Biruni lamented
that Brahmins attempt
to combine ideas of purity
with the pursuit of science.
No resemblance at all
to our own age.
But none of this,
according to Al-Biruni,
prevented the elites
from having an inflated opinion
of themselves.
In a fit of annoyance,
he wrote,
the Hindus believe
that no other people
besides them
have any knowledge
or science whatsoever.
Their haughtiness is such
that if you tell them
of any science or scholar
in Khorasan and Persis,
they will think you to be
both an ignoramus
and a liar.
If they traveled
and mixed with other nations,
they would soon
change their mind,
for their ancestors
were not as narrow-minded
as the present generation is.
According to a modern scholar
of this period,
the smugly insular stance
of Sanskrit scientific literature
remained for centuries
willfully ignorant
of its competitors.
This situation
improved somewhat
after Persianate
and Sanskritic cultures
began mingling in India.
Al-Biruni's account
shows that on the eve
of the Turko-Persian invasions,
Brahminical society
was not exactly
a picture of intellectual
and moral health
that many now fondly
imagined it to have been.
Barring exceptions like
Abhinav Gupta of Kashmir,
India's urban
intellectual culture
seems to have declined
in preceding centuries.
It had fallen behind in science.
Its Brahminical elites
had grown insular,
insecure,
superstitious,
caste-bound,
lacking in creativity.
By the late first millennium,
growing Brahminical orthodoxy
and bhakti devotionalism
had been crowding out
the rational and liberal
strains of Indian spirituality.
Al-Biruni's portrait
of North India
is so perceptive
that he deserves to be called
the first Indologist.
Marco Polo was a very
different kind of man
than Al-Biruni.
A Venetian merchant
and adventurer,
Marco Polo had travelled
the Silk Road
from Europe to China.
There he ended up
serving as the
foreign emissary
of the Mongol Emperor
Kublai Khan
for 17 years,
which took him
all over Asia.
He was 38 years old
in 1292
when he stopped in
South India
on his way home
from China.
His ship landed
near modern Thanjavur
in Tamil Nadu,
in the kingdom
of the Pandyas.
He spent a few months
going around the
Indian coast,
finally sailing out
of Gujarat.
Like Al-Biruni,
Marco Polo was curious,
open-minded and tolerant.
He had a cosmopolitan spirit
and a merchant's
pragmatic eye,
but he had none of the
scholarly temper
of Al-Biruni.
He was superstitious,
gullible
and prone to exaggeration.
He believed hearsay
about giant birds
that lifted elephants,
men who looked like dogs,
and other such
fabulous tales.
Fortunately,
his account also contains
fine social observations,
and it's usually
not hard to separate the two.
For instance,
who would doubt
his observation
that Indians
reserved their left hand
for unclean necessities
like wiping the nostrils,
anus and such like?
Or that Indians
did not put their lips
on flasks,
preferring to hold it above
and pour the fluid
into their mouths?
Or that Indians
chewed a leaf
called tambur,
sometimes mixing it
with camphor,
spices and lime,
and went about
spitting it freely?
The hot climate
of South India
meant that all men
and women wore
nothing but a loincloth,
including the kings
and queens,
except theirs
were studded
with rubies,
sapphires,
emeralds
and other gems.
Boys and girls
went naked
till seven years.
Marco Polo
called the Pandya kingdom
the richest
and most splendid
province in the world,
which together
with Ceylon
produced most of
the pearls
and gems of the world.
The people
consulted astrologers,
he wrote,
and had enchanters
called Brahmins,
who read mantras
to protect
the oyster divers
against predatory fish.
For this service,
the Brahmins
received one in twenty pearls
the divers
extracted from the sea.
Not a bad gig.
Marco Polo
noticed the practice
of sati
among certain groups.
People venerated
the cow
and docked
their houses
with cow dung.
They did not eat beef,
except for a group
with low social status,
whose members
were not admitted
inside holy places,
and who ate cattle
that died a natural death.
Marco Polo
observed that
people looked down
on sailors
and seafaring.
This likely came
from the Brahminical
taboo of
Kala Pani,
in which
seafaring caused
ritual pollution
and loss of caste.
Many Hindus
still sailed,
but this might
help explain
why the shipping
lanes at the time
were dominated
not by Hindus,
but by Indian Muslims,
Arabs,
and the Chinese.
Marco Polo
wrote about
Devadasis
who sang
and danced
in temples
and traded
sexual favours
for money.
It seemed to him
that Indians
did not regard
any form of
sexual indulgence
as a sin,
a remark
best understood
in light of
his strong
Christian morality.
Marco Polo
also wrote that
dark skin
was preferred
by Indians,
when a child
is born,
he wrote,
they rub an oil
on her skin
to make her
grow darker,
because darker
people
were more
highly esteemed
than the
lighter-skinned ones.
That's why
their gods
were all black,
and their devils
white as snow.
It's possible
that the
higher value
for lighter skin
that had emerged
with the spread
of Indo-Aryan culture
hadn't yet
penetrated
folk culture
this far south.
Cultural standards
of beauty
have of course
changed
dramatically
since then.
Marco Polo's
account is
also full of
spicy
gossipy tales,
like the story
of a king
who kept
500 wives
and concubines.
Whenever he
set eyes
on a beautiful
woman or damsel,
he took her
for himself.
Yet he coveted
the wife
of his brother,
who was
also a king
of a nearby region.
He even
managed to
steal her away.
A war
between the brothers
was prevented
only by their
mother's
emotional blackmail,
when she
threatened
to cut off
her breast
with a knife.
This is
the story
he tells.
We have
no way
of verifying
if it's true.
In another story,
Marco Polo
met
holy men
who went
stark naked
and led
austere lives.
They believed
that all creatures
had a soul
and took pains
to avoid
hurting
even the
tiniest of them.
When asked
why they
did not cover
their private parts,
they said,
We go
naked
because we
want nothing
of this world,
for we
came into
this world
naked
and unclothed.
It's
because
you employ
this member
in sin
and lechery
that you
cover it
and are ashamed
of it,
but we
are no more
ashamed of it
than of
our fingers.
Another
vignette
comes from
the Thanjavur
region of
Tamil Nadu,
where,
according to
custom,
the king
and his
barons
and everyone
else
all sit
on the
earth.
He asked
them
why they
do not
seat
themselves
more honorably.
The king
replied,
To sit
on the
earth
is
honorable
enough
because
we were
made
from the
earth
and to the
earth
we must
return.
I think
we could
certainly
use a few
similarly
grounded
politicians
today.
Marco Polo
also visited
the tomb
of Saint
Thomas
the Apostle
near
Chennai,
a place
of pilgrimage
for local
Christians
and Muslims.
He wrote
that
Indians
imported
over
2000
horses
from
Aden
every
year.
But
most of
them
died
because
Indians
didn't
know
how
to
care
for
them.
He
mentioned
a
kingdom
ruled
by
a
queen,
a
very
wise
woman.
Historians
think
this
was
Rudrama
Devi
of
the
Kakathia
dynasty
of
Warangal.
He
praised
the
fine
cotton
textiles
of
South
India.
He
admired
wine
made
out
of
dates
in
Kerala.
He
noticed
leather
workshops,
pepper
and
indigo
plantations,
and was
visibly
thrilled
by the
beautiful
birds
and animals
of
South
India.
Other
travellers
after
Marco Polo
have
given us
additional
insights
into
South
India.
These
include
Ibn
Batuta,
who
visited
in
the
1340s.
He
described
huge
Chinese
ships
in the
Calicut
harbour,
some
with
four
decks,
cabins
with
toilets,
and
a
thousand
people
on board.
Batuta
called
the
Chinese
the
wealthiest
people
in the
world,
who
dominated
the
shipping
industry
around
the
13th
to
15th
centuries.
Calicut
had
a
large
resident
community
of
Malayali
speaking
Muslims
called
Mapilas,
dating
from
at least
the
9th
century.
They
and
others
in
the
region
had
matrilineal
societies.
Some
groups
even
practised
polyandry.
Clearly,
Indian
social
norms
were a
lot
more
diverse
in
Batuta's
time
than
our
narrowly
patriarchal
norms
today.
In
the
13th
century,
parts
of
South
India
saw
much
political
churn
and
military
violence.
Some
of it
was
driven
by the
expansionary
Delhi
Sultanate,
whose
Turko-Afghan
warriors
possessed
a
culture of
greater
military
discipline,
battlefield
innovations,
and
meritocracy.
When
the
dust
settled
in
the
early
1300s,
the
Delhi
Sultanate
ruled
in
the
North,
and
two
new
entities
had
appeared
in
South
India,
the
Bhamani
Sultanate
and
the
Vijayanagar
Empire.
In
the
next
episode,
I'll
look at
the
rise
and fall
of the
Vijayanagar
Empire,
and
the
secrets
of
its
wealth,
military
power,
and
cosmopolitan
culture
that many
foreign
travellers
wrote about.
See
you
next
time.