COUNTERING FOREIGN INTERFERENCE AND ECONOMIC COERCION: THE EXPERIENCE OF THE INDO-PACIFIC

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
2 Video Views·Mar 19, 2026
28th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Philippines🇵🇭- February 3-4, 2025
-Hon. Erik Bethel
Distinguished Fellow, Chamber of Digital Commerce
Former U.S. Representative to the World Bank
AI Generated·May contain errors
former U.S. Representative to the World Bank.
He is also well-versed in Mandarin, Spanish, and Portuguese.
A great friend who will lead us, a very bright guy,
in this discussion and the following two panels.
Thank you.
All right, so we're reaching the tail end of our day.
And when we're talking about malign influence,
and we can get into the details,
but I'd rather sort of take a step a bit higher,
to the meta level, and understand what we're dealing with.
So, by way of background, as the Congressman mentioned,
I was asked to be the U.S. Director of the World Bank.
I was then asked to be the Ambassador to Panama.
But before that, I spent more than a decade living and working in China.
And before that, another decade living and working in Latin America.
When I arrived in China, I was, perhaps like many of you,
shocked at the lack of transparency or governance.
I was shocked at how business was conducted.
And I tried to dissect and understand,
why? Why am I getting cheated?
All the time, everywhere, always, right?
And to understand what we're dealing with,
it's important to understand culture.
All of us in this room, largely all of us,
come from a background of shared values.
Our values are based on the Abrahamic religions.
We think that lying is bad.
We think that cheating is bad.
We think that coveting is bad, etc.
But maybe other cultures don't do that.
So, I'd like to highlight some of the...
Who here has heard of seven habits of highly effective people?
Okay, a few people, alright.
So, in China, for the last 2,000 years,
you've had Sun Tzu, The Art of War,
but you also had Sanshuo Liuji.
Sanshuo Liuji is the 36 stratagems.
You may or may not have heard of them.
But these are basically principles
that have been employed over the millennia
that teach you how to win in different things.
And let me go through a few of them
that are very relevant.
Stratagem number six,
Shendong Jishi, which is Clamor in the East,
Attack in the West.
What does that mean?
It means create a distraction over there
while doing something over here.
Are we not seeing that?
So, create a distraction in one part of the world
and then do Belt and Road in Africa.
Or create a COVID problem
and then, you know, figure out a way to buy assets on the cheap.
I'll go through a couple more of these
because these are phenomenal.
Stratagem number 14,
Jidao Shanran, which means Kill with a Borrowed Knife.
So, instead of direct action,
you can hide behind intermediaries.
So, I spent a number of years at the World Bank.
China has infiltrated the World Bank
as it has many other institutions,
the United Nations and so forth.
So, if you can push United Front people
into these organizations to do your bidding,
you don't look bad.
So, again, I bring some of these up
because understanding, you know,
some of these 36 stratagems are very interesting.
Here's another one.
Stratagem number 19,
Fu Di Qiu Xin, which means
Remove the Firewood from Under the Pot.
Meaning, you can undercut the U.S. and its allied influence
by buying out critical industries
like manufacturing, batteries.
And so, everyone depends on you.
You remove manufacturing from the United States
and now we are beholden to China.
So, my point is,
I think it's important for all of us
to understand what we're dealing with.
We're dealing with a very, very different
cultural paradigm
and we're also dealing with
the Chinese Communist Party,
which has lived through the Great Leap Forward
and the Cultural Revolution.
And when you are untethered from a sense of
what we would call, you know, traditional values
and all they care about is winning,
we should not be surprised
when we find ourselves in situations like we're in.
So, we shouldn't be naive.
So, what I encountered at the World Bank,
and I'll finish with this to sort of leave it open for questions.
What I encountered at the World Bank was the following.
Gosh, where to begin?
I was astonished, at least when I was there,
that China was the largest recipient of World Bank loans.
And I said, why?
That doesn't make any sense.
China is the world's second largest country, economy.
It's sending, you know, it has quantum satellites.
They're doing quantum communication.
They've got the largest venture,
second largest venture capital pool in the world.
Why are they getting loans from the World Bank?
Note, the World Bank is there to help people
impoverished countries get out of poverty.
So, why?
Well, the answer is very simple.
If you get a loan from the World Bank,
you're a developing country.
And if you're a developing country,
then at the World Trade Organization,
you get favorable benefits.
Probably no one here has ever heard of the Universal Postage Union,
but it's one of the siblings of the United Nations.
And it is the global body that determines freight around the world.
Well, if you're a developing country, you get paid, right?
And so, if you are a developed country, you pay in.
Meaning, packages from Shanghai to Miami, Florida
are cheaper than, you know, packages from, you know,
Washington, D.C. to Miami.
So, these are the kinds of things that I saw.
I also saw that of the tens of billions of dollars
that the World Bank deploys in loans around the world
for infrastructure and so forth,
the Chinese were winning, I don't know, 40% of them.
And we were winning less than 1%.
I noticed that when I opened my Lenovo computer,
that it was a Chinese Lenovo computer,
which was obviously not what I expected.
And I learned that the then CTO of the World Bank was from China.
So, I started calling attention to this early on in the Trump administration.
And a group of us, including our mutual friend Matt Pottinger and others,
started developing a group of informed people
who had lived in China, who understood China,
to start moving policy in a different direction.
In my case at the World Bank,
in Matt's case at the National Security Council,
and then there were others.
But I'll stop and say, and I'll go back to how I started,
to understand what we're dealing with, we need to understand culture
and understanding how other people think
can help us make better decisions.
So, thank you very much.
Thank you.
