CHANGING SECURITY, CHANGING POLICY TOOLS: MEETING THE CHALLENGE OF CHINESE AUTHORITARIAN MERCA(...)

Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
3 followers
Mar 19, 2026
28th Parliamentary Intelligence-Security Forum
Philippines🇵🇭- February 3-4, 2025
Topic: CHANGING SECURITY, CHANGING POLICY TOOLS: MEETING THE CHALLENGE OF CHINESE
AUTHORITARIAN MERCANTILISM
-Mr. Carl Timonthy Delfeld
Chairperson, Hay Seward Economic Security Council
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
We have 15 minutes on a very interesting topic, so maybe I'll take four or five just to give
you my perspective on mercantilism, which is a term that a lot of people hear about,
but many don't really think too much about what it really means.
So let me start with kind of my interpretation.
To me, to understand mercantilism, you have to kind of start with the opposite, which
is classic free market, sort of Adam Smith market economics.
In other words, the free flow of capital, trade, information, even people.
Now, you don't really find this in the real world.
So it's a spectrum.
So on one side, you have this classic free trade, free markets, and on the other side,
you have a very closed, very controlled, government-controlled society and economy, and you don't really find
that very often.
So most countries are along the spectrum.
The Philippines is along there, the United States, every country.
Now, mercantilism is really nothing more than a government sort of top-down strategy,
economic strategy, aimed at increasing a country's wealth and power.
And hopefully, in the calculus is what's best for the people of that country, but not always,
not always.
So how do you execute a mercantilist strategy?
Usually you pick strategic sectors you want to dominate, either for power reasons or to
national security reasons.
And so, for example, you pick a sector, for example, some of the key sectors that countries
focus on are autos, electronics, commodities, textiles, shipbuilding, and all these are
very important strategic sectors that if you can master them and dominate them, it
gives you power, wealth, and the idea is to move up the food chain to more advanced levels
and more advanced levels.
Some of the tools countries use is, of course, to keep out competitors from other countries,
government regulations, subsidies, protections of domestic companies.
You want to import technology or steal technology.
You want to attract foreign investment into your country so that your economy can get
stronger.
You restrict imports and subsidize exports to earn foreign exchange, gold, to give you
more security, more economic security and flexibility.
And in the classic sense, and mercantilism goes way back, maybe the heyday was the 15th
to 18th century in Europe, the whole idea was to accumulate gold.
And that was a source of power at that time.
So briefly, let's just move to the more modern era, the post-World War II era.
There's a lot of countries that practiced mercantilism and a few examples I studied
in Japan.
So Japan was a mercantilist country, or at least what people call a neo-mercantilist
country.
Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, all the so-called Asian tigers, they all focused on exports
to earn foreign exchange, to develop their countries, protect certain markets, and dominate
other markets.
Now this brings us to a country which is probably on everybody's mind, and that's China.
Now China basically followed the same strategy.
But what made China different?
The main reason that we're dealing with the issues we're dealing with today is that first
of all, China's a lot bigger than those countries.
I mean, it's 13, 14 times bigger than Japan.
So Japan, in other words, the United States could endure and tolerate these practices
for different reasons.
We'll get to that in a second.
But with China, because of the size, the scale, the speed, and their focus on these sectors
and all their mercantilist practices, they basically got away with it.
And I would say, why would a country such as America or the world in general put up
with a country practicing mercantilist strategies year after year after year?
I think there's three.
Number one, complacency, not thinking that it will last.
Second would be lack of power to push back, lack of power to push back.
And then the third reason is, in the United States' case, I'm convinced that they really
sometimes they want the country to get stronger.
For example, all those countries I mentioned, Japan, Taiwan, South Korea, Singapore, they
were allies of America in the Cold War.
And so we actually put up with it because we wanted them to be stronger.
As they got stronger, the alliance got stronger.
And then the last point I'll make about the US, and I'm curious to see what Eric will
say about this, is something I mentioned yesterday.
So as China got stronger and stronger over the last three or four decades, American and
other foreign companies basically moved their manufacturing there, put up with restrictions
and technology theft and all that, because each individual company and the executives
of that company gained.
They gained because they lowered their costs, raised their profits, their stock price went
up, and they personally gained.
So in other words, when Johnson Controls moved their manufacturing capacity to China, they
weren't thinking about what's best for America.
They were thinking what's best for my company, what's best for me, and what's best for my
share price.
So I'll stop there and turn it over to Eric.
Thank you.
