Behind the Scenes: Straw Dogs (Peckinpah, 1971) with Dustin Hoffman and Susan George

Behind The Scenes
14 followers
218 Video Views·Mar 19, 2026
This house behind me here is Trenchard's Farm. It's the temporary home of an American professor,
David Sumner, and his wife, Amy. They've come over to Britain and come to Cornwall,
where they find themselves faced with the perhaps justifiable hostility that Cornish people always
accredited to have towards foreigners. At least, that's the story of this. They try to interfere
with what the local Cornish regard as their affair. Well, the local Cornish people take
the law into their own hands, hence the title of the book, The Siege of Trenchard's Farm.
The Straw Dogs is based on the highly successful Peckinpah. Earlier today, I spoke to him and to
Susan George. First, Sam Peckinpah. The West Country people are portrayed as being very
insular and inward-looking and inbred. Is this how you find them? Well, I've found insular and
inbred people all over the world. I certainly wouldn't confine them to the West Country,
as you say. I certainly found them in the South, in the West, in Nevada, Arizona.
Some of my own family, I think, would fit very well in some of the characters here.
We're all a bit inbred. Gordon Williams, who wrote the book upon which this film is based,
has complained publicly that the film is nothing like the book. How do you answer,
as a director, criticisms like that? I think Mr. Williams has a penchant for his own work. I don't.
You haven't had exactly the best kind of weather, certainly not today. Would you come back to
Cornwall to take another picture? No, I intend to come back here to live. I leased a house here.
May we ask where? Just down the road about two and a half miles. Will you be living here very
much? I hope so. I like it here very much. Well, may we welcome you to the West Country, Mr. Peckinpah?
I really, I like it. I even like the weather. Thank you very much. Despite the fact that I
almost died of pneumonia here, I've become acclimated now, so you can't get rid of me.
Thank you very much. He's a Hollywood baby. Over, but even on location in Cornwall,
the star still gets a chair with his name on the back.
I mean, it's very rough here today. It's misty. It's cold.
Well, as far as it's, it's, it is cold. It's, it's a little warmer for me than I would be if
I were in New York now, because they're having the coldest winter they've ever had in a long
time. It's about zero degrees with a lot of snow, so I feel that this is a reprieve for me.
Are you waiting to shoot? Well, I'm sorry. Maybe we can talk to you in a little while. Thank you.
That's okay.
Okay, in our program, we had a young actress who maintained that in order to get on these days,
you just had to take your clothes off in films. Now, you, I think, have a very different view of
that. I don't think it's true. There are stipulations one makes all the time about
when and why, if there's a good reason, but I don't think one has to take their clothes off.
I think you have to be a good actress. Um, no, I'm not saying you have to be a good actress,
because I suppose people have done it without, but I don't think it's got anything to do with
taking your clothes off. I will not sign that bit of paper that says I won't do any films where I
don't have to take my clothes off. I mean, I don't like doing it. I don't like nude scenes.
I have only ever done one which was comparatively nude, and that was only a back shot of me,
and that was when I was 17. I feel I was much less inhibited then than I am now,
and so now it means more to me than it did then. I don't particularly like the idea,
but it depends where and when, as I say. Artificial mist, and yet you can't see more
than about 200 yards for the real thing. Still, I suppose that's show business. At least it's
here on this film at the moment. Perhaps the best known of them there in the centre,
Billy Cornelius, who received all those cuts and abrasions on his face a little while ago,
demonstrating just how easy it was to get knocked down by a car. Dustin Hoffman again for another
couple of moments. Uh, Dustin, you really epitomise the young actor of the 1970s. How
sort of sensitive are you to this? How obvious does this seem to you?
It seemed only obvious, I guess, after the graduate, because the part I played was of a
young man. Since then, it seems less obvious to me the more I work and the older I get. Right now,
I'm almost 34, so I don't feel that I represent the youth. You had your wife and children over
here. They're still here. How are they liking it? Fine, very much so. I just wish that we could put
we have a girl that's almost five and a baby that's four months. It would have been nice to
put the five-year-old in school, but we couldn't because of the short term. Into an English school?
Yes. Would you really like that? She likes children. It's best for her if she's with
other children. Dustin, you are a family man. How much of an interruption is it coming out on
occasion like this to normal family life? Well, it's been our biggest problem in marriage and
my family's come with me every film I've done. Unfortunately, today, it's not like in the old
days where you did everything on the set in the studio. Today, location is location. You go where
the film takes place, and we've been gypsies. We haven't solved that problem at all.
Hoffman, up the set, please, and Susan, George, urgently. Lights going. Need them. Over.
My company, Town Associates, we'd acquired the book Seeds of Trenches Farm,
and what I loved about it was the premise and the last sequence, the idea of people without
martial arts skills defending their home and tariff against the hooligans. I had worked with
before on some television specials that I had done and asked him if he would ... I called and
I said, would you like to direct this, adapt and direct it? He wasn't available for adaptation.
But I said, would you like to direct it? And he said, I'd love to, but I should tell you that
I'm blacklisted. You may not want to use me. And I said, it's all the more reason I do want to use
you. I had asked David Z. Goodman, who I'd worked with before to do the adaptation, and then he and
Sam did the final shooting polish together with a big contribution from Dustin. And it kind of,
I guess it took a while for me to get it set up because the sine qua non was getting a known
actor and Dustin had only done one or two pictures before then. The first picture was The Graduate,
which made him an overnight star. And it took me a long time. Sam and I met with him
in New York where I was living at the time, then Sam had to go back to California.
And I had countless meetings with Dustin because he's very careful about what he does. And finally,
he was persuaded and we just set off, did a long prep in England, during which time we
went crazy finding the right locations. As a matter of fact, Sam and I divided the UK and I
went to one part of the country and he went to the other. Actually, he went as far as Scotland
and he found a location there that he loved. And I flew down to it, but it wasn't practical. And I
meanwhile came across St. Ives, which I thought was this marvelous small English fishing village
and quaint beyond the word quaint until I wandered in it the first day, turned a corner,
and there was Hepworth sculpture. It turned out there were major international known artists
were living there. But anyway, we scouted it, Sam came down, we found the specific locations,
but then actually shot in a little village outside St. Ives called St. Burians,
which consisted of one street and a few pubs. And that was it. We never had a title we'd liked.
We know we didn't like Caesar Trench's Farm because nobody knew what Trench's Farm meant,
it was. And as anytime you have to change a title or find a title, it's always horrendous.
And finally, I organized a contest among the cast and the crew and anybody who, you know,
the waiters in the hotel say anybody who can come up with a title, we had some kind of prize for.
And actually, it was one of the crew, one of Sam's old friends who came up with the title,
which is a quote from Lao Tse. And it has no particular meaning, but it just sounded,
it's so ambiguous that you don't read anything into it. And it also gave us a real key for
the artwork and everything else. And so it's hard to remember that a picture was ever called
anything but Straw Dogs. The idea, it was at a time where the dilemma of the lead character
played by Dustin Hoffman of David confronting the violence in America after Martin Luther
King's assassination and Bobby Kennedy's, it was a time where we all felt so strongly
about violence. And it was the opportunity to, while providing excitement and entertainment,
to make a statement about, you know, be able to make an anti-violence vehicle was particularly
interesting to all of us, particularly to me. It was always a problem in Sam's later years,
even when I'd worked with him earlier. And he always vowed that he was, stopped drinking and
he was only drinking wine and he was not going to drink anything by the shoot. And he did,
he did go on shooting. And at one point I remember drinking rather during the shooting.
And I remember one point saying to him, I would have to replace him if he kept on drinking.
And he said, you wouldn't do that. You're my friend. And I said, it's because I'm my friend,
your friend, I would do it. And at one point he got sick, not from drinking, he got
some kind of upper respiratory infection and we had to put him in the hospital for a couple of
days. So there was a rumor that we had to be hospitalized because of drinking, but he had
some form of walking pneumonia. But he always had a thermos of coffee, you know, next to him as he
was shooting. And every time I walked by, he would offer me coffee and make me have a drink
with him because I knew that as soon as I walked away, there was a switched, a thermos and there's
a little brandy probably in his coffee, but we didn't lose any time because of it. There was
some agitation, probably as I would think as I reconstructed from the distributor and the
insurance company, the film bonding company, because once he was sick, there was nobody knew
how, you know, how long it would take to get better. So there was an agitation. And Peter
Yates' name came up because he was a terribly talented guy whose work we all knew. Actually,
there was one other thing that I did, which was, I'm not proud of, was somewhat manipulative.
As we lost a couple of days, there was a director in London who was not a terribly admired man, but
somebody that the film bonding company would use if they ever had to take over a picture.
And at one point, as we lost a couple of days and I knew I had to fend off the authorities,
the people putting up the money, I hired an actor who's not recognizable to come down and
stand on the set. And Sam a couple of times said, who's that fellow? Don't worry about it.
And by the third time when he said, Sam, at the end of the day, I said, Joe,
I guess I have to tell you, there's a real worry about our going over. And this is a director
that they'll hire to replace us. And suddenly we picked up speed. He discussed things only generally
and then waited to see on film what he wanted. And, you know, within the parameters of his
intelligence, that's where I felt he did provoke a performance. And there was not a lot of
intellectualization, but Sam doesn't do that, didn't do that with actors. Although we indulged
ourselves more. I think Sam was always a little bit embarrassed at how intelligent he was.
It was really quite, quite intelligent, very intelligent and very well educated. But I think
the myth of Sam is the last man with guts and integrity in the film business. And the last man
with the pure American Western ethic was something that he kind of got caught up in. Actually, he
came from a long family of judges and was very, very well educated. Dustin Hoffman is an enormously
creative and internal actor. And the contributions were, you know, all through the film,
less in the actual writing than in moments, moments of dynamic playing.
And also very often there was the moments in dialogue that any good actor makes his own,
you know, that's a state in his own vernacular. And Dustin was particularly creative and inventive.
We had difficulty working with Dustin, I've had difficulty working with Sam because
Dustin is one of the great internal so-called method actors and everything must have a
rationale and there must be real reason for every piece of behavior. And Sam works very intuitively
and is less articulate. And I always felt that Sam, as his directing technique,
rather than verbally eliciting a performance, would provoke a performance. And so it took
Dustin a while to get used to that way of working because he was used to discussing
everything at length. But finally, everybody found a way to accommodate each other.
He was so right for it that I frankly don't know where I would have gone as an alternative.
Perhaps Al Pacino because of a quality of honesty and his size, frankly. But Dustin was somebody who
I admired so and was so anxious to work with that it was the only real choice. What had happened,
and I don't know that it was ever planned, because we shot in continuity,
the film was shot as the story unfolded really and that's not very usual. But in the very beginning,
Dustin and Susan George bonded very, very well. They really liked each other very,
very much. And as the film went on, and I don't know that it was conscious,
I don't know that Sam provoked it, but I know that as their relationship as husband and wife
deteriorated in the story, Dustin started relating to Susan George and Sam started relating to her
as the husband was relating to the wife. And at one point, I just thought it was so mean
that I had, I remember going and seeing Sam, taking him aside and saying,
you can't do this. This is inhuman. And I think in his most poetic sense, he told me to piss off.
He's getting the performance he wants. But I felt very badly that Susan, I think was victimized
by it, although I think it probably contributed to a wonderful performance.
I remember the very first memory I have of Sam Peckinpah was blue eyes, piercing blue eyes and
very, very confrontational. That's the very first thing I remember about him. He was direct.
There was a kindness to him that I thought was instantly recognizable. But there was also
an aura around him, whether that was something I'd been told or something I felt. I don't know.
But it was a pressure meeting him. I remember that. It was quite terrifying. And he was lovely to me.
But as I say, very confrontational. And we seemed to get on very well.
International stars were not something that you met on an everyday basis or knew or came to know.
So I didn't really know very much about Dustin Hoffman, apart from the fact that I had seen
The Graduate, which I thought he was absolutely sensational in. And I thought he was incredibly
sexy and a gorgeous guy. And so I really look forward to meeting him. I remember initially,
my initial gut feeling as I met him was that he was tiny. I couldn't get over how small he was.
I thought he was some sort of huge hunk, but he was quite petite. I was terrified when meeting him,
but he was a really sweet man with a huge sense of humor that was evident immediately.
Sparkle, twinkle in his eyes, completely, you know, disarming, slightly disarming.
Loved that. He loved that. He loved to be disarming and he knew he was.
He would take you on and his intention was to make you feel disarmed and he did it very well.
And I loved it. I responded to that and I enjoyed it. And it was the same thing all the way through
the movie. We had a fantastic relationship within the movie, the same thing from emotional turmoil
and sometimes huge sparks and incredible chemistry, which is what it needed to make this film work,
to mammoth laughter of huge proportions that went on for days, which he instigated and I responded
to. Three grown men, Dan Melnick, Sam Peckinpah and Dustin Hoffman, I realized is what it was,
all having a heated discussion. So I hovered in the doorway. They paid no attention to me
whatsoever and they continued with this bout. I stood there for a few seconds and I thought,
they don't know I'm here. And then I, in my head, I went, they don't, they don't know I'm here.
So I went back out the door and as I did, I dropped my eyeline. And as I dropped my eyeline,
I realized that these three men were standing with their trousers around their ankles,
absolutely naked trousers around their ankles. And I looked down and I thought, oh God,
and I looked up again and these three men burst into extraordinary laughter and looked at me and
said, welcome Amy. Dustin and I had very, had a very different work ethic. That was painfully
obvious from the moment that we started working together, but it was fantastic. And that was,
that was part of the extreme, the extreme different way that we worked was part of the
magical chemistry, I think, that came together and ignited and made this fantastic energy between
these two individuals because he was most certainly a method actor. He always had been,
he told everyone, he still is, you know, that's the way he works. He's a method actor.
I respect that a thousand percent. It's wonderful, but I am not, I'm instinctive. Everything I do
is natural, is the first thing I think of. It just is, it's an, I'm instinctive, he's method.
Two totally, totally extreme different ways of working. And that was a major
confrontation to begin with, with he and I, but a wonderful one, as I say, that worked in the
chemistry of the film and made, I think, such an energy between the two of us and made the
sparks fly and made from hilarity to tears to emotion, you know, the extremeness of the way
we worked came out in our almost realistic lifestyles with each other on camera, which was
great for the film. And I think Peckinpah knew that. He was so smart. He was a genius in his
own time. And I think he was so smart that he absolutely would have known that these two
different human beings would have been such an interesting mesh. And Peckinpah then,
after the weeks of rehearsal, when we were really working well together, he then made another major
decision, which at the time, at 20 years of age, I found a little personal, a little encroaching
into my personal space, because I had a boyfriend who loved me very dearly, and I did him too,
and we were about to get engaged. And suddenly Peckinpah announced that he wanted me to leave
by train for Cornwall with Dustin and the writer, David Z. Goodman. And he wanted me to spend the
two weeks in Cornwall apart from my boyfriend and to live with Dustin, not in the same bed
or the same bedroom, but to live in the same hotel, to spend every hour with him that I had.
And it was so clever, because it was this relationship in Straw Dog at the beginning
of the movie starts with a marriage that's on the rocks, about to disintegrate. And without
the pre-knowledge of how these people had got on in their existing lives together,
if we didn't know how this fallout became, how uncomfortable they had become with one another,
if we never knew how comfortable they once were, if that makes sense, there was nothing to build
on this relationship. So we had to form a really fantastic relationship, Dustin and I,
and then we had to break it down before the film started.
Chief Censor was a lovely gentleman named Sir John Trevelyan, I believe.
And when we had gotten the print close to our release print, I remember going back and
standing over the movieola, the film equipment, with Sir John and a man named Stephen Murphy,
who was an associate of his, running the rape scene, those few moments of one sequence,
to convince him that what we were looking at, what he was looking at and worried about
in the rape scene was rear entry and not sodomy. One is acceptable, sodomy is not.
And so that was a very ludicrous scene. And finally, we did get released initially in London
and caused enormous controversy. And then I think the film was pulled after that.
It's a really long story as to whether I walked off the movie or I didn't. I did,
most definitely. Sam would not discuss the specifics with me. He kept skirting around
it all the time. And I kept asking Dan Melnick all the time, somebody has to, at some point,
tell me exactly what is required of me so that I can at least have time to go home and think about
it and think about what I'm able to do. And if indeed there's anything that I'm not able to do,
so that I can discuss with the makers of this movie how to get round anything that I think
is too uncomfortable for me. I could never get that answer. Nobody wanted to answer that question
until the day the rape scene was literally, excuse the pun, on top of this.
And I asked these questions of Sam. And the answer was that he wasn't prepared to give me
definition of what he required. I would just have to wing it all on the day.
And which I said I'm not prepared to do. I need to know. Because I was frightened.
I was obviously frightened. Yes, I'd committed to do this film. I'd read the script through and
through and through. I'd gone to all these auditions. I knew what was required in terms of
a rape scene. But that's really all it said. It never went into the specifics on paper.
So I needed to know what was required of me, as anybody would. And they were not prepared.
He was not prepared to give me that. And it did come to blows. And I did walk out,
and I did say if he wasn't prepared to tell me what I was going to shoot. He actually gave me
some rough notion on that day. And the rough notion was extremely rough. And I didn't like
what I heard at all. And I wouldn't have been prepared to do what he asked me to do. So I said,
on the basis of what you've just asked, find yourself another Amy. And I walked out.
That caused huge upheaval, as you can imagine. And to cut a very, very long story short,
there came a time when he had to come back to the table and discuss with me legitimately
what he was intending to do and how we could, you know, it was just a grown-up
meeting. How are we going to do this? We together, Sam and I, and Del Henney. How are we going to
make it work? How are we going to make it, you know? And one thing he did say to me was he wanted
it to be the best rape scene that had ever been shot. And the one thing that I said to him in
return is, I would like to achieve that for you, and I will endeavor to do so. But on my terms.
People have commented and asked about Sam's violence and have accused it of being almost
pornographic. I would disagree, and I would probably say that pornography is in the eye
of the beholder. I think to the degree that it's so powerful, so viscerally affecting,
people have made that comment. But I think it's balderdash. Whatever balderdash is.
I think it's nonsense. The one thing other than the title that hadn't been resolved before we
actually started shooting were the very last moments in the film. And it was, in retrospect,
quite wonderful and stimulating, because whenever there was any downtime, Sam and I,
and then Sam and Dustin, and I and Sam and David Goodman, the writer and I would discuss
alternative endings, not changing the substance, but really the very last moment. And actually,
it came, I'd love to say that we all had a creative flash, but it was actually, while
Sam was shooting the last moments of the film, where Dustin Hoffman drives off with Susan George
and David Warner in the car, and David Warner said, and it was to be originally the last line
in the film, I don't know my way home, and Dustin ad-libbed, neither do I. And the moment we all
heard it, we knew that we had a powerful last beat. Well, I think the reason people have asked
why it is still so powerful, and I think it is because its intensity is so honest, and it's so
easy to identify with the principal actor, with Dustin's character. Because when you first see
him, and you see him reacting, come to this little village, because of the violence in America,
the death of Martin King and the death of Robert Kennedy, you feel when you first see him
interreacting with the town locals, the bullies in the town, that he may be a coward.
Or first you think really that he's a pacifist. And then as he continues to be provoked,
you feel maybe he's a coward. And then by the end of the picture, you realize
that what he fears the most is the violence within himself.
