Behind The Scenes: Reds (Beatty, 1981) With Warren Beatty And Diane Keaton

Behind The Scenes
14 followers
218 Video Views·Apr 14, 2026
At the beginning of Reds, the very beginning of Reds, I thought I cannot do this movie unless I
get Walter Lippmann, who was the greatest liberal columnist in American journalism history. And my
friend Arthur Schlesinger set up an interview, and he looked at me with the sourest of expressions
and basically saying, what is it that you want? And I just said that to you, what is it that you want?
What could you say that war is about, Jack Reed? Profits. Organize all the workers together.
One big union. Now what the hell do you want to waste your time with a lot of red propaganda
nobody's ever going to print? It's the truth. Does that mean anything around here? What I do know,
and what I did know then, was that no one had tackled the development of the American left
between 1915, 1920, which is what this period deals with, and that there was a gigantic fear
of communism. Am I being tried for witchcraft? Miss Bryant, tell me, are there no decent,
God-fearing Christians among the Bolsheviks? And I went to Moscow. I wanted to go to look around,
which I was able to finagle my way into, and found that in Moscow, the hero was John Reed.
He was buried in the Kremlin wall, and there's a lot to be said for that. But I was interested
in Insurgent Mexico, his book about traveling with Pancho Villa, and of course, Ten Days That
Shook the World, which is considered to be the great masterpiece. And I was particularly
interested in that group of people that included Max Eastman and Eugene O'Neill and those people
in New York and in Provincetown, Massachusetts, and painters and writers, and these people who
really thought that something else would be possible in American politics.
If capitalists can take this country into war, anytime they damn well please. The only impact
you can make is in the street. But the idea of this woman, Louise Bryant, who was an
admirably industrious person of aspirations that were high-minded, and then the relationship they
had, and then of course, the brevity of his life itself, I thought was dramatic.
I had written the original treatment of the movie, and that took years. So I had that treatment,
and then I finally realized that I had to do it with contemporary people. So I decided to
collaborate with the British playwright Trevor Griffiths, who was a very strict Marxist,
who I felt would keep me or John Reed in line with the dogmatism of it.
You're editorializing here.
I never editorialize.
At the end.
You're right.
Reds, of course, the subject of Reds, if you're going to go into the political,
the polemical, and the dialectical aspects of the picture, who would finance a movie like this?
So I made a picture called Heaven Can Wait first, which was more accessible to the finance.
And then I came around to finally doing this picture. It was very much motivated by my own
political activism at that time, probably had a lot to do with what I thought was a mistaken
American paranoia about communism, and most particularly in Vietnam. So finally,
I thought, if I don't do this, it won't be done. And there were a couple of studios who would have
done pretty much whatever picture I wanted to do at that time. But I felt an allegiance to Paramount,
to Barry Diller and Charlie Bluedorn, particularly, and they'd been very supportive on the
Heaven Can Wait, and they were smart.
I certainly knew that it was not a high concept popular subject,
but the word commercial to me is a horrid word and should be abolished from a lot of filmmakers'
decisioning. All you can do is really say, am I interested in this? And if that's so, then
that's all you really can do. And it was so much a project, not only of the mind, but of the heart.
I wanted the decision to be made as a group because I thought it would jeopardize whoever
decided to say yes to a three-and-a-half-hour movie about a communist who dies. And I thought
that's not going to sound hugely entertaining.
So I asked Charlie Bluedorn, whom I liked very much, that I would like to meet with the group
of them. There was Barry Diller, Michael Eisner, and Charlie Bluedorn in a meeting at Paramount.
If I remember correctly, I went to the office and I said, I'll sit outside. I don't want other
people to read this script. And Charlie read the script, and Barry Diller, and I believe Michael
Eisner also read the script. And they were in a meeting. I came back into the room. They seemed
to be looking mostly at their shoes. And Charlie said to me, what is this picture going to cost?
I said, I don't really, I don't know. That's the honest answer. But I said, Charlie, I know
somebody who will make this picture. But my loyalty is to Paramount. You've done well by me.
I've done well by you. So let's make the movie if you want to make it. So I went out of the room
again and sat as if I were at the dentist. And they talked for a while. I came back in again.
They talked a little more. They sent me out of the room again. I sat there for a while.
And finally, I came in. They all seemed sort of depressed. And they said,
okay, we're going to make the movie. And here you had a company, Gulf and Western,
which owned Paramount, which was the most competitive, the most capitalistic. And you
had this company put up the financing for a film about John Reed, a great figure in the history of
socialism and the U.S., communism, etc. And do it with a happy face. You can't really tell an actor
what to do. I don't believe in that. You get the best actor and then you try to create a situation
in which he or she will function well. And then you do it as many times as they would like to do
it. I like to do a lot of takes because it's a new experience each time you do it.
Alma, this is Louise Trollinger. Alma Boyle. This is Ned Boyle. Jack Reed. Jack Louise is quite a
progressive in her own right. Mr. Partlow. How do you do, Mr. Reed? When I prepare a movie,
I pretty much know who's going to be in it. And if I don't know, it's a problem for me.
It makes it much, much harder. You know, technically, you cannot act and direct at the
same time. Ideally, it can't be done because if you're really acting at the top of your game,
you're somewhat out of control. And it is the director's job to be in control.
And it is the actor's job somewhat to be in control of being out of control. So if you're
directing and acting and you're in control of being out of control of being in control and
on down the line, what comes out is insanity. So I like to give the other actors the feeling that
they are co-directing with me. Don't stand behind the moon. Can you step back a little bit?
This is the moon. This is the moon here. Of course, the fascism of it all in the long run is
they're not. I make the decision. But as you can see, I have to have very, very good actors.
I have promised to love you, a Negro sailor. Casting is destiny in so far as the character
goes. And character is plot. Because in order to hold Reds together, those two people had to be
pitted against each other somewhat. They could not be two idealists riding off into the sunset
on the back of a tractor. Jack, I can speak for myself. So can you work? Taxi's waiting, Jack.
No, taxi's waiting, Jack. What was this tension all about? It was, I think, the competition between
the two of them. That competition is what holds this story from one hour to two hours to three
hours together. I want to be responsible for my own time and my own actions. I want to be referred
to as Miss Bryant, not Mrs. Reed. And I want to keep an account of every cent we spend so that I
can pay you back. Now, I assume you know that I'm not going to sleep with you. So just don't confuse
the issue by bringing it up. Keaton, to me, is funny in a way that other people are not funny.
And Keaton is very quick. Her responses are very quick. Mr. Wiggum, are you saying you need Jack's
permission to make a pass at me? She goes through an interesting process. She'll do one take,
a second take, and a third take maybe. And then she's rather peeved with you for continuing. And
by the time she gets to the sixth or the seventh or the eighth take, she's really pissed off.
And then she'll go to a dark level that will give you something totally different.
And then if she goes on past that, you don't know what's going to happen. And that can be
really interesting. You're a wounding son of a bitch. And whatever I've done to you,
you've made me pay for it. We had a good, you know, working relationship. And she's one of
the most fun people to work with. There's no, no drag, you know, it's all bing and ready. And,
you know, she learns everybody's line and she's ready to roll. And very unpredictable,
which means you can be alive and moment to moment with her. Well, what are you working on, Gene?
At the moment, scotch. You know, she would find probably a lot to find fault with in this
particular approach to making a documentary and getting poopsy about the period or too much in
this. You made a movie, blah. This is sort of the way she is. I just want us to be friends, Gene.
Oh, how genteel. That would be a good role for you, wouldn't it? There's Louise with Jack and
Gene. He's crazy about her, but Jack doesn't know. Poor Jack. Poor Gene. What a heartbreaker
she is. I had to get Eugene O'Neill. So whenever I have a casting thing, I like to talk to actors.
Actors know actors. And so I called Jack, who was a friend. And I said, who do I get to play
this guy? He says, well, what kind of a thing is it? I said, well, as you know, it's Eugene O'Neill.
I said, Warren, you know, I can act anything, but I can't act thin. You know, the only thing
America knows about O'Neill is this very gaunt guy leaning against the mast of a sailboat on the
paperback cover of A Long Day's Journey Into Night. And he said, look, let me just say one
thing. He says, after you would play O'Neill, they'll think O'Neill looks like you rather than
vice versa because of this preponderance of the images, which I thought was a pretty smart answer.
And the other thing was why he wanted me to play the part. I said, well,
you know, why do you want me to play this particular part? You know, I mean,
I understand some reasons, Irish, so forth and so on. He said, because the audience has to believe
that it's someone who could take my girl away from me. So I called Barry and I said, guess what? I
said, Jack wants to play O'Neill. Rather you went up in flames than put out your cigarette in the
middle of a monologue about birth. I'm sorry, you're absolutely right. It just makes me want
to cancel the whole production. I won't do it again. Excuse me. I'm sorry. Jack is unendingly
fresh from take to take the glass. I'll take the bottle. And I like Jack as a very romantic figure.
Jack is a real intelligence. I found O'Neill's life absolutely fascinating. You know, so many
things about him that I didn't know. You know, I mean, there are quite a few books written on
O'Neill. I found a lot of things, you know, that I actually used in the movie. One of the more
fascinating research jobs I ever had to do on something. But don't you think, Emma,
that if Debs gets a lot of votes, it'll strengthen that image? No, I don't. I think voting is the
opium of the masses in this country. Every four years you're dead in the pain. Maureen Stapleton,
she's a great actress. There's never been a greater actress than Maureen Stapleton. Maureen
is funny. She's deep. She's true. She's energetic. Thank you, Jack. Everyone else brought me hats.
I don't think I'm being indiscreet by saying that she has sometimes some feelings of claustrophobia.
So Maureen doesn't like to go into elevators, doesn't like to sit in the middle of a theater.
She just likes to sit in the back and she doesn't fly. I had tremendous difficulty in getting Maureen
to say yes to this movie. And I wanted Maureen from the very beginning. And we finally got her
to come to do the movie on a Polish freighter that sadly ran out of gas in the middle of the
Atlantic Ocean. So when she got to England to shoot this part, she was pretty frazzled.
The acting profession always has people that they look at as saintly, wild things.
And Maureen was always one of those people, you know, very serious, very funny. You know, Maureen
was funny. I never knew why, but she used to call me on the phone in the middle of the night a lot.
You know, we'd talk, what have you seen? What are you doing? It's very nice, you know,
spirit. Hello, are you lost? No, I'm not lost. I'm here to tell my friends that the newly formed
Communist Party of America is meeting at the Russian Federation on Blue Island Avenue.
Sorvino has always been one of my favorite actors. I saw him originally in that championship season
on Broadway. I thought he was just a terrific actor. And we've worked, he did Dick Tracy with
me, also Bullworth. My idea of revolution is not a revolution in my own party. And my idea of a
socialist party is not a debate in society. It is a party of action. Bye.
Warren called me. I was on vacation in Florida. It was a free vacation because a friend of ours
had a place in Florida that we could go to. And I hadn't worked in a year and a half,
and I really felt like I was out of the business. It was a bad time for me.
And I get this call from a nervous sounding voice. He said, this is Warren Beatty. I feel
very nervous to speak to you. And he then went on to say that he was doing this movie
and that he really wanted me in it. And I was stunned, you know, because
I didn't expect that. And that kind of put me back in the movie business.
As Kazan said, this is a business of comebacks. And I've had about 20.
Well, took my notes, every goddamn note I have for my book. Can they do that?
Welcome home.
There's a something about Ed Herman that is period less.
It's been a long time since I thought about Max Eastman. I studied him a good deal. And in a way,
they were all passionate intellectuals about what was going on and changing society.
But it was all linked up with shifting alliances. And they were discovering
the joys of sleeping with one another's girlfriends and wives and things.
And Max was very much part of that. But he was a very smart guy,
and very sincere about his desire to change things. And he was a sincere socialist.
I see you eat the peel with the lemon. Fight the scurvy, so does the onion.
Together, they fight better.
Kozinski is a very interesting
example of someone who had to suffer through communist totalitarianism.
Jerzy was considered really one of the better writers around. He had received numerous awards,
among them the National Book Award for Steps, his second novel. Had also taught at the time
at Yale, Princeton, and Wesleyan. So very much on the American literary scene.
Jerzy Kozinski is one of the quickest wits I've ever known. In a room, he could stand
up with Robin Williams or Jonathan Winters or anybody of that nature. He was hilarious.
I don't know.
Kozinski, I think, had some reluctance to get involved with a movie on this subject.
He didn't say yes that quickly to who was Zinoviev. He said to Warren, are you crazy?
To have Kozinski, who was a very entertaining man, to participate in the Zinoviev character,
for whom he had nothing really but contempt. I had more sympathy for Zinoviev,
because I saw it more from a distance.
You can always go back to your private responsibilities. So can I.
You can never, never come back to this moment in history.
It was an enormously important time in history. It was a revolution, and it was the first time
that Americans volunteered to become involved, to help in a cause that they thought was very
worthwhile. Despite what happened afterwards, the concept for it was brilliant. Jerzy truly
appreciated what John Reed is, which was probably the motivating force with Warren.
It was Gene Ackman originally. It was just in the pub scene, basically.
It was shot in a pub, but it looked like a restaurant. Wonderful scene. He was not well,
Gene. He was ready to come and do anything. He was feeling absolutely dreadful when he
did that. There's no sense of it when you see the scene. It's incredible.
I'll drink to that. I don't drink to anything. Well, that's right, too.
We talked about it, but these were Warren's choices. I was in this area, his cheerleader.
I mean, I thought that the picture was so wondrously cast. Just wonderful. Every piece
cast. It was Henry Ford who said,
history is bunk. There was something I liked about that, the music of that, because we all
rewrite our history and the history of the things around us in ways that make it more bearable,
I think, for us. I think he felt quite correctly that one of the big problems in doing any kind
of historical film, particularly a historical epic like this was intended to be, was the
deathly undramatic and unrealistic nature of historical exposition. You don't want to have
a character saying, well, Bob, now that we're in World War I and the Germans are on the other side
and the English are our allies, that's the death of realism in any kind of film. I think he had a
brilliant idea. He said, well, face it head on. We'll just have talking heads come right in and
say, this was World War I. Imagine 65 million go to war, right? Ten million die. Ten million
become orphans. Twenty million become maimed, crippled or wounded. And so that the dialogue
and the dramatic action doesn't have to carry the weight of that exposition. And basically what we
did was we took out ads in newspapers all over the country, queries. Warren Beatty would like
to meet anyone who knew John Reader or Louise Bryan. And we got thousands of letters. And so
my first job was to go through them all. And once I'd spoken to everyone and knew who we wanted,
then I traveled around the country, pre-interviewing, meeting every single
person that we considered plausible. You know, I feel like one of our witness in Reds.
I remember the time that I was having this camera, a big camera like a Mitchell.
Everything was black around, just one light. And I have those people
remember the time they were knewing that John Reed and Louise Bryant.
Jack Reed was in the class, several classes ahead of me. As you know, I never graduated.
I saved my money and took third year work. Can you tell me what the First World War was all about?
Well, the first, as far as we were concerned. Anybody and us. I feel terribly disappointed
at something I've said, but I don't know. I'm not disappointed at all. You're probably deceived by
my silence is it because I don't want to hear the sound of my own voice on the sound track.
The process was really to try to engage the person in a comfortable dialogue
and to shut up when they were talking so that it wouldn't go over their track.
And at the same time, try to lure them into using the proper name or the place or the identity that
would supply the exposition that I needed that would then save me from having to write a three
minute scene to bring up an issue in the movie. Well, no, wait a minute. That's very good because
I'd like to bring John Reed into that. It was like fishing, you know, you just hope that,
oh, and they said the word. Now let's bring it in. And I remember George Jessel saying,
who was it? Emma, Emma, Emma, Emma, Emma. I think it was Emma Goldfarb. Emma Goldfarb,
Emma Goldfarb. And it was a priceless moment. That was her name, Goldman, not Goldfarb, Goldberg.
We went all over. We had problems sometimes keeping the lefties from the righties, you know,
the ones who we would make an appointment if we were in a hotel, say, in New York or something
like this, we would have to make sure that they didn't cross. And then we had that wonderful
experience where we did Dora Russell. I had a great time with Rebecca West and Lady Dora Russell
because they came in the studio at the same time and they hadn't seen each other for 40 years.
And at lunch, Warren kind of flicked his eye to Vittorio and he caught on right away and he
ran back and he set it up for two and he invited the two of them to come together. And that was
one of the most charming of the interviews because, you know, you remember the days when,
and oh yes, all those wonderful things that came out. Did you begin to say something,
Dame Rebecca, about? No. About what? Rebecca West. The more I talked to her,
the more beautiful she became. And when I would talk to these people, it seemed like every 10
minutes they'd get five years younger. And then finally they were my age. Then some of them got
younger than I was, you know. And the more accessible the period of 1915, 1920 became.
You know something that I think that there was just as much going on then as now.
Remember that I had no sleep. I was completely exhausted. I sat down with Henry Miller and he
was as candid as anyone I've ever spoken to. What I am curious about is if you could explain to me
what the hell the First World War was all about. Oh my God, I was going to ask you that.
He was totally alive and alert and funny. And he said to me, you know, he said, when I didn't
really want to do this, he said, I thought you were going to turn out to be a stuffed shite.
He said, but you're not a bad guy. And then he's telling me all of these stories,
which some of them were shocking. I remember my first adventure into that world was with a whore
right near the Herald Square theater on 31st street. We had this thing back and forth in
which he would reach over and slap me on my leg. And I, and I, at some point I reached over and I
slapped him on his leg and it was, it felt like a toothpick. Adler Roger St. John was
nothing if not lively. Yeah. He said, look, I'm too big. I can't go walking around the streets
when England is in trouble. And she was the person who wrote the Nixon checkers speech,
you know, when he talked about his dog and sort of turned things around for him when things were.
We have to talk about the menace of communism, which I've already done.
They are so powerful that they can destroy us now. And we have to get busy and strengthen our
simple as that. Hamilton Fish was of course, very right-wing and, uh, and his memory of things,
of course, didn't coincide with, uh, anything that I knew about, but, uh, I loved him.
Were you very aware of Reed's work in Mexico? No, I wasn't. You see, I didn't, I lost track of
myself, but I had to concentrate on that. Uh, and then the war came shortly afterwards
and, uh, I didn't really know much about him. And now that I'm 80, I begin understanding exactly
how memory works. And it's, uh, it's really remarkable and fun to realize the idiosyncrasies
of becoming a little older and the things you remember and the things you forget,
and then they flash back at you. Sometimes I have lapses like that.
So whenever I look at the beginning of that movie and that whole opening about age,
it means so much more to me now because I understand it fully.
I might sort of scratch my memory, but not at the moment.
So since war, if it can be, firstly, if it's black, everyone will be concentrated on the face.
There's no, any, any, any distraction around. Second, probably would be great while they are
telling the story like can happen right now on my face through this black, maybe you can start to
see the image that he's talking about, about the movie. That's why they were shot against black.
It wasn't because it was going to be beautiful. It was going to be so that it would be a neutral
background that their heads could be placed inside the shot of the action. Um, and I guess when they
got time to actually doing it, they thought it would be nicer to cut away from the action and
have them against black because they did look so beautiful against black.
Reed said, uh, this is a war for democracy. Where is the God damn democracy?
When this thing came along and I knew for quite a while, of course, that he was going to be
directing it. I went up to his house actually to say, look, Warren, I know how hard you've
worked on this, but don't direct, you know, direct something else. Don't direct this picture
because they'll discount your performance. And I went up with this in the back of my mind and he
said, I want to show you something. And he then showed me the footage of all of the witnesses.
And it was such startling footage, you know, the lives of those people of that time and the
tremendous social upheaval was going on all over the world that I just forgot that part of it. I
said, I've changed my mind. This is simply too big a contribution to a film to just pass on to
someone else. You know, you have to get the credit for this and all that he did and all that he
continued to do on this, on this movie. When Warren made that decision not to put the names
of the witnesses on the screen, and I saw that for the first time, because he didn't, I don't
recall him discussing it with me. I think the first time I realized it was when I saw it on
the film. I felt it was absolutely the right decision. It's my feeling was to put the names
on it would pull the film towards documentary. Jack reads like, short as it was, happened at a
time. And all of us, after all, are the victims of our time and place. This is a historical drama.
It is not a documentary. And this is an element that we're using in the drama. And to put the
names in would say, this is now a different kind of movie that we're sticking into this movie.
Now isn't that something? So I thought it was absolutely the right decision. When I asked
Warren about it, he told me he felt the reason was that it would place more importance on what
famous people said than not famous. And I thought that was also an excellent reason not to do it.
It's good to have witnesses. And, and it's sad to lose them.
But there wasn't a moment that I didn't really have a lot of fun with those people.
