How Inflation Ruined the Roman Economy

Artifact Archives
9 followers
1 Video View·Mar 20, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Last year, the inflation rate in the U.S. rose to its highest level in decades.
Though nothing like the sort of hyperinflation that drove the value of the German mark
from 320 to 4.2 trillion to the dollar in the wake of World War I,
the recent price increases have foregrounded the fickleness of money in many American minds
and made ancient historians like yours truly think about the inflation
that destroyed the Roman currency in the third century A.D.
In modern America, the government issues money to serve as a medium of exchange
and value storage throughout the national economy.
The Roman Empire, by contrast, minted coins for one purpose and one purpose only
to pay its own expenses.
The emperors recognized that it was a good thing to have money circulating through the provinces,
at least because it made taxes easier to collect.
But the nature and the number of the coins they issued
were always determined by their financial obligations.
The emperors had many sources of income.
The most important was taxation, levied both directly, in the form of land and poll taxes,
and indirectly, through customs duties and taxes on inheritances, auctions,
and the many mission of slaves.
Tax revenue was supplemented by the income from properties owned directly by the imperial house,
which included everything from massive estates to marble quarries to tenements in Rome.
The revenues produced by taxation, the imperial estates, and the occasional war
were balanced, and sometimes dwarfed, by expenditures.
The emperors had to pay a small but elite bureaucracy.
They had to finance massive building projects.
They had to sponsor gladiatorial combats and beast hunts.
They had to subsidize the Egyptian grain barges that fed the city of Rome.
And above all, they had to pay the troops.
By ancient standards, the Roman army was enormous.
The almost half million men who were permanently under arms by the early 3rd century
represented a colossal investment and a gargantuan burden.
Soldiers were paid well, earning about as much each year as a skilled craftsman,
and officers were paid much better, to the point that their salaries alone
accounted for almost a quarter of the total payroll.
In addition to wages, the emperors had to meet the costs of provisioning the troops,
which could rise exponentially in times of war.
Although it's impossible to calculate the budget of the Roman Empire with anything like precision,
a few estimates have been made.
The most comprehensive of these suggests that, in the middle of the 2nd century,
the annual expenditures of the imperial government averaged around 1 billion sestertii.
Of this, something like 700 million sestertii, that is, about 70%, went to the army.
To pay the troops and meet their other obligations, the emperors minted coins.
The gold coin, the oreus, was used for high-value transactions and to store wealth.
But it was the silver coin, the denarius, that was the true core of the monetary system,
and the medium in which troops and officials were usually compensated.
For almost two and a half centuries, the Roman monetary system, anchored by the denarius,
was remarkably stable.
But even at the best of times, imperial expenditures tended to exceed tax revenue.
To make up the difference, the emperors relied on new gold and silver
from mines and successful wars.
When these supplies fell short, there were only two possible solutions.
Deferring payment, always dangerous since unpaid soldiers were mutinous soldiers,
or debasing the currency, making coins, in other words, that contained less gold and silver.
There were a few episodes of debasement in the early empire.
After the Great Fire of Rome, for example, Nero reduced the weight and fineness of the oreus.
The silver content of the denarius, likewise, fell slowly but steadily after the reign of Domitian.
But these changes were minor and caused no lasting economic problems.
It was only in the late second century, when the empire was afflicted by a series of disasters,
that things began to fall apart.
Before we discuss the crisis, however, a quick word about this video's sponsor.
Skillshare is an online learning community where thousands of creators and entrepreneurs
share their passions, their vision, and, yes, their skills.
For me, the resources on Skillshare have been a great way to learn tips and tricks
for promoting Tolton Stone on social media.
I found this batch of videos, which outline strategies for making visually appealing thumbnails,
especially helpful.
Of course, there's much more to Skillshare than optimizing thumbnails.
Whether you'd like to start the new year with a new hobby, a new job, or a new outlook on life,
you'll find content on Skillshare to guide and inspire.
The first thousand people to use the link in the description will get a free one-month trial
of Skillshare Premium.
And now, back to the Romans, whom we left on the brink of disaster.
Early in the reign of Marcus Aurelius, a terrible plague, probably smallpox, swept the empire,
killing, by some estimates, a tenth of the population in a few years.
At almost the same time, the frontier provinces along the Danube were ravaged by a coalition
of German tribes, forcing the emperor to mount a series of long and expensive northern campaigns.
Marcus managed to repel the barbarians, but only by emptying the imperial treasury.
Much worse was to come.
During the 3rd century, a seemingly endless series of crises brought the empire to the brink of collapse.
Every frontier was breached, and cities from London to Antioch were raided and sacked.
Whole provinces were abandoned in the face of the onslaught.
And, within the shattered frontiers, a parade of pretenders and usurpers battled for the throne.
The Roman economy splintered and shrank, slashing tax revenues at a time when the emperors
desperately needed gold and silver to pay the troops.
The supply of precious metal was further diminished by the practice of buying off aggressive enemies
with stipends, and by the slow decay of the mines on which the emperors had relied for centuries.
As the supply of precious metals dwindled, military expenses soared.
During the 2nd century, visionary pay had been stable at 0.012 a year.
It rose dramatically under Septimius Severus and Caracalla,
to the point of inflating the imperial budget by something like 70% in a few decades.
And, thanks to further raises and additions over the following years,
soldiers at the end of the 3rd century were being paid about 8 times what they had received 100 years before.
With more debts to pay, and less gold and silver to pay them,
the emperors did the only thing they could.
They debased the currency.
The aureus, whose size and quality had been stable for two and a half centuries,
was reduced from a pure gold coin weighing a little over 7 grams
to an alloyed fragment that sometimes weighed less than 1 gram.
At the same time, the silver coinage was debased into oblivion.
To illustrate the changes, the Classical Numismatics channel here on YouTube
kindly agreed to make this short clip.
During the 3rd century, we will see unprecedented manipulation of the silver content on Roman coins,
as well as some tricks on the imperial administration's part
to squeeze more purchasing power out of available silver.
This is a coin of Emperor Caracalla.
By his reign, silver coinage was already down to about 50% purity,
but this does not seem to have been enough to pay for his expenses and the raises he gave to his soldiers,
because on 215 AD, he instituted a new denomination, the Double Denarius, or Antoninianus.
This coin was tariffed at 2 denarii, but only had the silver content of around 1.5-1.6 denarii,
allowing the emperor to mint more coins with less silver without having to reduce the silver purity.
This new denomination would slowly drive the denarius out of circulation,
as people preferred to spend the coin with less fine silver content per denarius.
Obviously, this led to inflation.
As political instability worsened, the following emperors would continue to reduce silver content on the coins
as they tried to pay for their troops and their personal bids for power.
This next coin was minted under Emperor Decius, between 249 and 251 AD.
Now, silver purity was just below 40%.
Notice, however, that the coin has a pretty good appearance.
Romans were very good metallurgists, and they knew how to leach the copper from the surface of the coins,
leaving a superficial layer of good silver that gave the impression of a high purity coin.
If we were able to cut this coin in half, we would see a reddish, coppery alloy, revealing the trick.
By the reign of Claudius Gothicus, between 268 and 270, this is what we're left with,
a pathetic lump of bronze covered in a thin silvering layer.
At around 2% silver content, and after decades of civil wars and rampant inflation,
you would need a bag full of these to get the same silver content of a denarius from the beginning of the century.
The imperial monetary standard, originally instituted by Augustus, was dead,
and it would need a series of very important reforms to re-monetize Roman society.
The debasement of Rome's silver coinage in the 3rd century was accompanied by inflation.
Debasement and inflation, it should be said, were not automatically correlated.
Though the Romans knew and cared how much precious metal their currency contained,
it was only when trust in the government failed, as it did in the 3rd century,
that coins came to be valued purely by bullion content.
Inflation had existed in the early empire, most notably after Augustus' annexation of Egypt
and Trajan's conquest of Dacia, when the economy struggled to absorb huge influxes of gold and silver.
Less dramatically, there are signs of a slow rise in prices.
At Ephesus, for example, the price of bread seems to have risen from 2 to 5 ovals over the course of the 2nd century.
The smallest Roman denominations, the quadrans and semis, were no longer struck after the mid-2nd century,
which suggests that rising prices had made them obsolete.
Inflation accelerated in the 3rd century, as both the quality of the coinage and faith in its value plummeted.
As prices rose, the Cistertius fell out of production, followed by the Denarius itself.
With gold marginalized and bronze increasingly worthless,
almost the only coin left in circulation was the 2-Denarius piece, the so-called Antoninianus.
As their silver content fell, Antoniniani were increasingly unlikely to be accepted at face value.
To compensate, the emperors minted more and more, sometimes producing over a million coins each day.
This, of course, drove prices even higher.
By the year 268, both the empire and its economy were on the brink of disintegration.
The empire had broken into three parts.
A German tribe was ravaging northern Italy.
Gothic marauders and ships were plundering the cities of Greece.
And a huge barbarian army was massing along the Danube.
Emperor Claudius Gothicus, a skilled general, beat back the invaders, but died after a short reign.
It was left to his successor, a cavalry commander of peasant origins named Aurelian, to save the empire.
Against all odds, he did.
After reunifying the empire and crushing the latest round of invaders,
Aurelian decided to end the economic chaos that had plagued the Romans for decades with a full-scale reform of the currency.
Among other things, he replaced the Antoninianus with a heavier coin that had its silver content, 5%, printed on the reverse.
Aurelian's reforms didn't last long.
It would be another half-century before Diocletian and Constantine finally stabilized the currency.
And even then, inflation remained a problem.
So much of a problem that Diocletian issued an edict of maximum prices,
which decreed the death penalty for any merchant who charged too much.
But the edict was unenforceable.
Prices continued to rise, and the economy limped on.
I'd like to thank Classical Numismatics for their contribution.
See the video description for a link to their channel.
If you enjoyed this video, please consider supporting Toledon Stone on Patreon.
You might also enjoy my book, Naked Statues, Fat Gladiators, and War Elephants.
Thanks for watching.
